8 ms·
What Happens When Our Faces Are Tracked Everywhere We Go?
- blakesterz 6y agoThese are good questions that EVERYONE needs to ask. What Happens When MY Face Is Tracked Everywhere I Go? I think it's really important that as many people as possible understand what is happening with Clearview, and everything else. It's important that as many people as possible take some time and understand how all types of tracking work, both on and offline now. If "we" as a society learn what's going on and shrug, then oh well, Clearview wins I guess. I hope that if everyone knows what's going on "we" will push back with... well I don't know what. Better laws/regulations? As someone who talks privacy/security quite often, I am still surprised at just how little most people know/care about privacy. Most people, even after they learn a bit about what's going on, just don't care. They'll read this story and come away with "They caught a pedophile, this is a good thing! I have nothing to hide, bring it on." It feels like "we" privacy/security folks are just fighting a losing battle.
- rvanmil 6y agoI feel the same and it has led me to conclude that this is a situation where things have to get (a lot) worse before they can get better, and only through legislation. I've been thinking about how it seems like we're living in the 50s of smoking except this time it's privacy and social media. Perhaps we can learn something from the tobacco control playbook...
- indymike 6y agoTobacco control has been a big fail, all that has really happened is that government and tobacco became co-dependent. People are still dying from tobacco related disease (I've lost close family members to this), and the product is sold everywhere. I would hope we do not model anything on "tobacco control".
- throwaways885 6y agoIdk, the younger generation see it as filthy and don't go near it for the most part. Seems to have finally paid off.
- bongoman37 6y agoThe younger generation is rapidly cozying up to smoking marijuana.
- dathos 6y agoDo you have some data for that? And I wonder if and how this affects the big problem we have with alcohol abuse at any age.
- MonkeyClub 6y agoFinding data for this is a walk in the park (ha ha).
- gruez 6y ago>Tobacco control has been a big fail Can you elaborate on this? Short of treating tobacco like heroin, what other measures should the government have taken to curb tobacco use?
- throwaway210222 6y ago"what other measures should the government have taken to curb tobacco use? " Make people with traces of nicotine in their blood ineligible for free health care. Including emergency care. Focus their minds.
- altcognito 6y agoWhile I don't think we would disagree that cigarettes are still sold and there are still smokers, the problem is a fraction of what it was. That's not fail at all.
- Ajedi32 6y agoUnfortunately I suspect this is somewhat of a Pandora's box situation. There's only so much legislation can do once this technology becomes commonplace. Even in a hypothetical extreme scenario where facial recognition technology were completely banned the software would still exist and there'd still be databases of people's faces floating around the web. All legislation would do is create a situation where it's "illegal" to use software to identify people from a picture of their face even though just about everybody knows how to do so trivially and secretly.
- dimitrios1 6y agoHarsh penalty and strict enforcement should do quite well. If you want to be a database of private information, the burden is on you to comply with privacy laws. If I assert you have collected my face and stored it illegally in a database (i.e. without my consent), a regulator should be able to quickly follow up for compliance, and if found to be out of compliance, penalty is imposed. TCPA works really well for call centers, and CAN-SPAM works really well for email marketing platforms. There's no reason a similar piece of legislation for facial recognition could not be passed.
- Ajedi32 6y agoSure, you can stop legitimate US companies from using your face that way. But what happens when the database isn't hosted in the US, or is distributed anonymously by a peer-to-peer network. TCPA and CAN-SPAM are hardly what I'd call effective. I still get tons of spam calls and emails. I'm not saying legislation is a bad idea; just that it's not going to be able to put the genie back in the bottle.
- michaelt 6y agoUnlike spam (which can trivially be sent across jurisdictional borders) you can't point a new camera at a San Francisco resident without being in California.
- da_big_ghey 6y ago
- rapjr9 6y agoOne thing that might motivate lawmakers is if someone starts tracking THEM (with license plate readers, face trackers, camera based heart+breath monitors, Bluetooth/WiFi/Cellular trackers, etc.) and makes the data public. It's currently legal for anyone to do this in the USA as far as I know. Perhaps some cities have laws limiting their police but I don't think they limit the public or corporations. Do talk to a lawyer before making the data public though. You could do this on a personal level also, use your phones camera and start telling people their heart rate, breathing rate, radio emissions, etc., to raise awareness. Start saying "Hi" to them before they are within site range of you when you detect their phones transmissions. People may start to think you're a creep, but they'll certainly start to recognize that they are at the mercy of creeps. A likely outcome would be a ban on remote sensing during workplace meetings or at the workplace in general which could lead to a nationwide ban eventually. I don't think anyone's boss would like their employees monitoring their heart rate or stress level during meetings or using that to get an advantage over other employees. Or maybe everyone will love it, you could automatically terminate meetings if everyone's stress level gets too high and people may become more forgiving if they find out what raises other peoples stress levels. You can get heart rate from cameras and variability in heart rate is strongly correlated with stress.
- amelius 6y agoCan't these Clearview folks find some other interesting thing to work on? It's not like there is a shortage of technical challenges. Sheesh. Not every market gap needs to be filled.
- zentiggr 6y agoYou seem to be ignoring the large number of people who seem to be interested in a large exit, who will look for ANYTHING a target audience will pay for and do it to scale, because. And the other group of people who will assist those in power to maintain it, because trickle down. You can open your original sentence out to "Can't these <insert any potentially harmful project> folks find some other interesting thing to work on?" As long as there is some sort of incentive on the other end, someone will be interested.
- amelius 6y agoIn today's economy, engineers can literally choose what they work on. For a decent income, there is no need to work on unethical things. There simply is no excuse.
- Sleepytime 6y agoNot necessarily directed at the parent comment (who seems more at a loss than thinking it's a solution), but calling for laws and regulations to restrain a state that regularly ignores laws and regulations already on the books feels very lazy (slacktivism?) to me, and is all too common a trope on HN. Call me pessimistic but I really don't think that the kind of elites that will use illegal metadata to drone strike their own citizens and their children (among numerous other atrocities) will suddenly behave if we just put a few more of 'The Right Laws and Regulations'™ in this time. The only answer to the privacy and security question is to be principled enough to do what you can to opt out even if it's difficult. Yes I get it, you don't want to alienate some percentage of your social circle/users/customers. But that attitude contributed to how we got here in the first place. You may be pleasantly surprised how many people will be willing to follow along if you ask them directly and are willing to help them do it. I thanked a friend for getting set up on matrix after I deleted all my other services and he told me "even though I still use whatsapp you have a good reason not to and you know more about this stuff than I do so I'm happy to use element to chat with you". I haven't had a friend that I made a personal appeal to turn me down yet. "I'll create your user on my server. It's nobody's but ours and it runs from my living room" goes a long way, apparently. My personal roadmap (ymmv): - Use tech that makes your adversaries job harder. For me this is things like no JavaScript (plain pages in general), FOSS/OSHW, walled gardens, cash/cryptonumismatics, mirror things on RSS/yggdrasil/gemini/alternate dns roots/ipfs. Self host. You get the idea. - Help others do the same. Cultivate a community. Make topical group chats/forums/pages. Mirror the content of things you would like to see. - Make your employers do the same, and be willing to say no to things that are counter productive to that goal. - Regularly make your friends/coworkers/boss confront the idea that they do have something to hide. Ask them to hand you their phone and tell you their password, ask for naked pictures of them/their family, ask them to install a parental control app that gives you their location/microphone/browsing history/etc, ask if you can put some cameras in their house/bedroom/bathroom (bonus points if you bring a camera over). - Obviously tailor the above to the situation and remind them that they do in fact want privacy. Don't ask a co-worker for naked pictures what is wrong with you? - People are wrongfully arrested on a regular basis based on minimal evidence. Amplify their stories. - Rotate usernames regularly. Anyway that's what I do. It hasn't been nearly as rough of an experience as I thought it would be. Thanks for hearing me out. Welcome to the panopticon, friends.
- dfxm12 6y agoIf "we" as a society learn what's going on and shrug, then oh well, Clearview wins I guess. It doesn't matter if we shrug or not. Big business always wins. One of our best shots at a material change is to elect more people like Ed Markey, Jeff Merkley and Bernie Sanders to congress.
- prepend 6y agoSo now a practical goal of social media is to not post enough pictures that allow training an accurate representation. Anyone know that if Google/Apple/other private photo storers train on my private photos if they can sell the model to other facial recognition without my specific identity? I suppose a model could accurately identify a photo of prepend without actually saying that who prepend is. So that would allow the selling of data as “de-identified.”
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Anyone know that if Google/Apple/other private photo storers train on my private photos if they can sell the model to other facial recognition without my specific identity? The better question is probable "who sells facial recognition identities/services and also has users uploading pictures?" Even if Google, FB, whoever, aren't having the photo's department handing their stuff over to the facial recognition department, they're only a minor shift of priorities or management personalities away from that happening.
- prepend 6y agoI’m not a machine learning programmer, but trained models don’t really have identifying information right? So they wouldn’t even need to hand over any photos or PII, only a trained model that now better identifies specific individuals. What’s really interesting is that any healthcare images can be used without requiring patient permission since training models can be used on a completely HIPAA de-identified image (stripping out any burned in characters, etc).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ArnoVW 6y agoArguably, if the model can identify me from a picture, then the model IS "indentifying information" (in the most literal sense). In France, and I believe now in the whole of Europe (GRPD) anyone can ask to remove or correct "identifying information". I wonder if this angle has already been used by someone.
- api 6y agoLeaving aside the really obvious political dangers of this, one answer is that we get inundated by creepily well-targeted advertising and propaganda.
- luxuryballs 6y agoThen some of the most polarized political views suddenly swap stances with one another on mask wearing policies like poles switching on a magnet.
- Nihilartikel 6y agoMy slightly-less-than-half-joking prediction is that COVID era hygenic mask wearing will transition into a privacy mask culture as facial recognition becomes ubiquitous.
- Ninjinka 6y agoUnfortunately facial recognition is not stopped by a mask that covers half your face. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-55573802 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-55573802
- Dylovell 6y agoAfter learning that someone can get your cardiograph with a laser from 100 ft away, I believe the adversarial fight with privacy won't help us nearly as much as fighting for legislation. Although I do think, as an american, we should rework the second amendment to include things like encryption. And change the 3rd amendment to privacy protection. I'm a little more worried about the people in my devices, than I am housing enemy soldiers at the moment.
- Ninjinka 6y agoYou sacrifice too much even if you could attain privacy through your own effort (which I very much doubt). Without laws to protect citizens, privacy is a pipe-dream simply because people aren't willing to give up what comes with giving up their privacy.
- nonameiguess 6y agoThe problem is this isn't even about privacy. Courts have always held that you have no right to privacy as soon as you step outside and that is never going to change. News broadcasts and most film making would become impossible if they needed the consent of all people who might incidentally make their way into a frame by walking in front of a camera. And if you go into someone else's business, there's usually a sign right out front telling you that by stepping inside you consent to them monitoring and recording everything you do. The only reason this never used to scare people is there was no practical and scalable way to collate all of these sources of public data into a usable profile that could identify and locate an arbitrary person. Well, now there is. How do you fight it? I don't think you can. The obvious answer is don't commit crimes and nobody is going to care enough to try and find you. Unfortunately, law enforcement has never proven particularly trustworthy about only going after actual criminals, so that answer doesn't generalize, but the vast majority of people are very unlikely to ever find themselves the victim of political persecution. What do we do for those who are? Right to encryption and constitutional amendments for privacy are great and all, but that still means absolutely nothing for a case like this. This technology relied entirely on public data. You're never going to have the right to not be photographed when you go out in public. The paparazzi literally killed a member of the royal family doing this and suffered no consequences for it.
- sleepysysadmin 6y agoyou start wearing Mandalorian helmets everywhere you go.
- o_m 6y agohttps://xkcd.com/1105/ https://xkcd.com/1105/
- INTPenis 6y agoRemember to sign the reclaim your face petition if you're a european citizen: https://reclaimyourface.eu/ https://reclaimyourface.eu/
- haspoken 6y agohttp://archive.is/mdTgQ http://archive.is/mdTgQ
- known 6y agoHow Elites/Law makers are exempted?
- You-Are-Right 6y agoWhat are you pussies afraid of? Dictatorship and authoritarian regimes are for real men! Woke culture is weakness - we need strong old white leaders with big police-state penis-power! Ride my horse naked or go to hell!
- bmeski 6y agoWhat's funny is that the "woke" companies are the ones doing this. The "woke" left is behind a lot of this.
- dang 6y agoWe've banned this account for posting unsubstantive comments. Please don't create accounts to break HN's guidelines with. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- JulianMorrison 6y agoLaw enforcement are untrustworthy, bigoted and violent. Some of them are also corrupt. Laws are written by bigots to oppress people. Corporations view you as a meat byproduct and your human rights as inconveniences. All of these problems are global, and IMO, they are the underlying issues of the privacy problem that nobody likes to mention. Because when you strip off the indirections, what people are fighting for is the right to break or ignore laws with impunity - because your line isn't tapped or your face isn't recognised. Why do we need havens from the law? Because the law is bad. I'm not arguing we should abandon privacy. But I'm arguing we need to refocus attention where it belongs, on bad law and bad law enforcement. Or otherwise we will be in a constant game of spy-vs-spy trying to outwit them as we carve out our little havens, and they kick the doors in.
- nonameiguess 6y agoThis needs to be signal boosted. The fact that we were able to apprehend a a guy raping 7 year-olds in his basement because he accidentally photo bombed a bodybuilding convention once is great. It's a very good thing that committing crime in the dark and staying hidden forever is the hardest it has ever been. The entire problem here is that we can't trust law enforcement to only use technology like this for good because we can't trust law enforcement. We can't put this genie back in the bottle. There is no way to conceivably stop the police from scraping completely public sources of information to find you. This service is just scaling and automating the anonymous tip. They're not even grabbing anything private. Facebook and Google sent them cease and desist letters when they found out what they were doing but those couldn't be enforced because you can't keep people from scraping publicly viewable photos. The only solution to this is trustworthy law enforcement. Which is unfortunately maybe not even a solvable problem, but I don't know what else we could even try to do.
- Buttons840 6y agoGovernment and law enforcement needs to be surveilled more than the public. This is the opposite of what seems to be happening.
- 6y ago
- bmeski 6y agoWhat happens when NYT journalists follow you around and tattle when you say naughty words?
- ExcavateGrandMa 6y agoRecords vs Tracking :) So Tracking implies by the definition that something is about you :) Records implies that there is a sex tape from your past copulation... :D
- wealthyyy 6y agoEveryone was afraid that someone was watching them, but they are missing the fact that it's is difficult to watch everyone. Even with algorithms, I don't think it's possible. Essentially, I believe the three letter agencies are pattern oriented when it comes to tracking.
- Spooky23 6y agoEn masse, probably not. But there are plenty of public accounts of how camera networks (or a combo of cameras + lpr) can track individual movements. If you drive from Miami to Montreal, US CBP or Homeland Security has breadcrumbs of your trip the whole way. Camera tracking is possible and is just a matter of funding.
- jtdev 6y agoAre you dismissing the potential for this to be abused because (we assume) the technology doesn't support mass biometric identification surveillance today? If so, you should know that technology has shown a propensity for rapid evolution.
- zentiggr 6y agoAnd that is even a worse problem than in=person surveillance. The more societal functions are automated, the more ways individuals can be effectively screwed and no one in authority can say anything except "well, you were flagged so you must be guilty". Until we push back against that as well, and then we run right back into the "They came for..." problem.
- reaperducer 6y agoit's is difficult to watch everyone. Even with algorithms, I don't think it's possible. It's already happening. The Chicago Police Department doesn't have to have 70,000 people watching its 70,000 cameras. It just has several dozen. The computer decides if something looks (or sounds — some have microphones) suspicious, then routes that video feed to a human to look at. The problem is that we train our computers with "AI" (a word we should stop using) that has biases.
- 6y ago
- reaperducer 6y agoI don't mind public facial recognition so much if it's very limited in scope, and absolutely not networked. I once lived in a very secure building. When you walked through the lobby, your face would be scanned and a picture of your face, plus your information (name; apartment number; birthday; messages, laundry, and packages waiting; etc.) was displayed on a screen for the doorman to then let you into the elevators. To me, this is OK. This was back before everything was networked, and every human being on the planet was sold and tabulated, so the information stayed with the doorman's station. When you became a new resident, the building manager took you to the doorman's station to get scanned, so evidently it wasn't even shared within the building. The problem is that these days once your face data is somewhere, it's everywhere, for people good and bad to use for things good and bad. There is no control.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- frandibar 6y agoHow ironic, the perpetrators name, Viola, means "to abuse" in spanish, and the guy is from spanish speaking Argentina.
- grey4228 6y agoReal-time car locations too. Recent HN thread: "Ulysses can provide our clients with the ability to remotely geolocate vehicles in nearly every country except for North Korea and Cuba on a near real time basis," the document, written by contractor The Ulysses Group, reads. "Currently, we can access over 15 billion vehicle locations around the world every month," the document adds. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26492322 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26492322