9 ms·
Dogs orient and move in synchrony with family members
- hackeraccount 6y agoRead the article for the line, "[cats]blow everything out of the water in terms of being socially responsive to their owners’ behavior" i.e. You do your thing human and I'll do mine. See you later if I think you're nice and there's nothing better to do.
- say_it_as_it_is 6y agoYour cat won't even notice or care if you're gone
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoOh they do, it's just that they pretend not to when you're there. It's all on their terms.
- PeterisP 6y agoI seem to recall brain scanning research that showed that, unlike how it might seem from their behavior, cats recognize being called by name as good or better as dogs, they just often chose to ignore it.
- blonde_ocean 6y agoAnecdotally, my cat definitely responds to his name being called. Often around feeding time
- worik 6y agoMy dog does that. Easy to train, but not obedient.
- buu700 6y agoCats are tsundere: https://soranews24.com/2019/08/17/japanese-people-love-cats-because-theyre-tsundere-psychologist-says https://soranews24.com/2019/08/17/japanese-people-love-cats-...
- noir_lord 6y agoExcept that is simply not true of some cats. I have two - one is remote, aloof and probably wouldn't notice I was gone. The other is affectionate, cuddly, always wants to sit on my knee and cries on a night when they get locked in the living room. Personality wise complete opposite ends of the spectrum.
- dmos62 6y agoTangential, but I wonder how does it affect the cats having nearby another cat that's different personality-wise. I've a guinea pig that's kind of insecure, and planning to get another that's probably more outgoing. Can security be learned by osmosis?
- whalesalad 6y agoCan't speak to cats but with dogs generally the answer is no. These are engrained personality traits.
- dominotw 6y ago> I wonder how does it affect the cats having nearby another cat that's different personality-wise I've had cats all my life. I would say it all depends on the cat. For some cats there is nothing worse that having another cat in their territory but some are more social. I've had older aloof cats come to life, perk up and become more social when there is new social cat in the house.
- clairity 6y agoin my experience, there's a limited amount of osmosis. i adopted my current (female) cat as a kitten when my prior (male) cat was declining toward death, in the hopes that she would provide some youthful companionship after his sister had passed away a few months before (they were littermates, got them as kittens). surprisingly, he became solemnly composed and accepting of her almost immediately, despite spending his whole life trying to dominate his sister (out of both competitiveness and territoriality, i imagine). i picked her from the kitten rescue specifically for her mild temper, knowing how dominating and insecure he could be. she was playful but respectful, and i'd like to think he was a little less lonely in those last few months with his sister already gone. fast forward a couple years, and i have an accidental (male) foster kitten who's a crazy ball of energy next to my mild-mannered, now-adult cat. otherwise pretty lazy, she's learning how to play more energetically and socialize with the little devil (as i socialize him as well--his first-time cat owner didn't seem to know if or how to do this). so yes, there's some osmosis going on, as cats learn from each other and the social structure shifts, but it's limited. no wholesale changes in my experience.
- staticman2 6y agoYou sound like someone with no experience with cats.
- pessimizer 6y agoCats can like you. The difference is that dogs think of you as a big upright dog, and cats think of you as something other than a cat. Dogs think of you as a peer, cats think of you as a pet or a fancy piece of furniture.
- worik 6y agoYou cannot read their minds.
- hackeraccount 6y agoI've always thought the difference between a cat and a dog is that for a dog being with you is like a job. You might have a great job. You may love your co-workers. You might have a crap job. Your co-worker may occasionally kick you in the side. But, you know, what are you going do? It's a J O B. It makes a dog a great companion. Loyal even to those who have done nothing to deserve it. Even an untrained dog will do it's canine best to be a good dog - though it will generally have no idea what we expect that to be. The problem with that from my point of view is that when you meet a good dog. Well, they're all good dogs aren't they? Who's a good dog? This dog right here! Anyhow - the problem is that I don't trust them. Because they're punching a clock. Do they really like me? Or am I just a co-worker they landed? A cat on the other hand is different. A cat is like that dude who lived with you and 3 other guys when you were all going to school. I think he was enrolled? Honestly I wonder; it seemed like all he did was sit around, smoke pot and try to fight off all the women running after him with that stupid guitar he played. Classical of course. Anyhow. If you had kicked him he might have kicked back if he thought he could but maybe he wouldn't if he thought he'd get hurt. What he would have done though is move out the first chance he'd get. If for some reason he couldn't he'd avoid you. Here's the thing though. When you come home and your cat rambles over and jumps up on your lap. When you scratch him behind the ears or rub a warm belly. It's a genuine thing. It's not much really but it's an unnatural act of empathy. People say cats view us a kittens. Or as mother cats. Or something. I'm not sure that's the case. I think it's possible at least that they know us to be something alien and strange to them. That they're living their life apart from us but they can choose to try and relate to us - and they do that in the ways that they know.
- moosebear847 6y agoIf you raise a cat from kitten so it doesn't experience negative memories/associations with humans, consistently and empathetically analyze what it wants, and earn it's trust, they will be unbelievably affectionate and attached. If they meow at you or otherwise try to get your attention, they are trying to communicate something. I used to think they were just being cats doing random useless things like sniffing, pawing or meowing, but nearly every single time there was some scent I needed to deal with, a desire to poop/eat/move or something real that they were trying to communicate. If you consistently ignore their attempts at communication, they will stop trying after a few times (wouldn't you?) unless they're like starving. But if they know you pay attention and respond, they will communicate their wants to you pretty clearly. Nothing they do is random, there is always a reason for it.
- leetcrew 6y agoI agree cats are much more intentional in their communication than people appreciate, but sometimes you can't just give the cat what it wants. my cat mainly meows for two reasons. he either wants food or he wants to go in the kitchen. unfortunately he can't be free fed because he will quickly become overweight. he's not allowed in the kitchen because he eats plants and jumps up on the stove, sometimes right next to an open flame. serious question: how would you handle this situation?
- Alupis 6y agoA properly fed cat, with an established routine, should only start going crazy around it's normal feeding time. Most cats and dogs crave a routine. Unfortunately, sometimes a routine is difficult to establish if your work hours don't permit, or other activities get in the way. That was the original intention behind the free-feeders, however as you noted that can lead to obesity in your pet (not all pets, some regulate their intake well on their own). So, if you're one that is establishing a feeding time, make sure you stick to exactly the same time every day (like clockwork, seriously). You may even consider providing "breakfast" and "dinner" to your cat (again on a fixed schedule), dividing the daily intake into two meals. Your cat wants into the Kitchen because they are curious creatures, and you've made the Kitchen some fun forbidden zone. Ideally you're in the Kitchen when the stove is on, so you can prevent burns. You could also try training them into a negative association with the stove by squirting them with a squirt gun (low pressure) every time they walk on it... same with nibbling the plants.
- echelon 6y agoWhat's a paywall technique that works now? I tried googling the article title, but that failed.
- ct0 6y agoPaying
- dsnr 6y agoSure, let me get my credit card real quick to pay for the article about how dogs move in synchrony with their family members. I‘m sure most of the readers here have subscriptions for nytimes and 100+ other publications.
- ct0 6y agoThey asked for a paywall technique that works. Paying always works.
- anoncow 6y agoNytimes and a few other subscriptions, yes.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoSounds like you're not interested enough to pay for it, which is fine. You're not required to read it, you're not entitled to read it, and you can move on from FOMO. It's fine to miss out. It's fine to not read content. It's fine to not want to pay for a publication if you're fine with not accessing it.
- Etheryte 6y ago> People who take up dancing together, for instance, often express greater closeness and cohesion afterward. Moving in tandem seems to generate intangible, intimate bonds. As a dancer in my youth, it's a bit funny reading someone writing this as research. Dancing is physically close, intimate, other-person-way-closer-than-your-regular-comfort-zone by nature. Add to that that eye contact, again inherently intimate, is crucial for coordinating any nuanced moves and you'd be hard pressed to find anything other than the above result. There is no way to put in the hours of rote practice, sweat, awkward mishaps and more without becoming intimate with your dance partner. I'm not saying it's bad there's research into this, I'm more so surprised this is something that was only strictly established by research in 2015.
- germinalphrase 6y agoI feel similarly about wrestling. The culture can be extremely macho (often to its detriment) - but the physical contact and trust involved similarly builds bonds.
- TrispusAttucks 6y agoWrestled from an early age. Totally agree. Takes a lot of trust to let someone shoot in trip and slam you. Knowing that it's your turn next. You truly know someone's strength and skill and all the social tough guy posturing means nothing when it's just two people on the mat.
- leetcrew 6y ago> You truly know someone's strength and skill and all the social tough guy posturing means nothing when it's just two people on the mat. I ultimately decided wrestling wasn't for me, but I did appreciate this part of it. there were quite a few matches in highschool where some scrawny kid got matched against one of the "athletic" types. often turned out to be quite the upset if the scrawny guy had actually been paying attention to the coaches.
- notsureaboutpg 6y ago
- phonebucket 6y agoMy dog moves when my two-year old does and is generally still otherwise. But I attribute this to my dog's survival instinct rather than an emotional bonding.
- INTPenis 6y agoYes exactly, also small children tend to leak food.
- elliekelly 6y agoA few years ago I was in the Galapagos and met a German evolutionary biologist who pointed out some fur seals sleeping on the beach. It was a hot day but they were arranged in a neat line to sleep so they were touching. He explained it was a group evolutionary advantage - if one of them wakes up because of a predator attack, for example, they’d all be woken up and hopefully most of them would manage to get away. I specifically remember him mentioning that dogs and puppies still have a slight preference for sleeping the same way. I haven’t for the life of me been able to remember the word (or phrase?) he used to describe the behavior and every so often I Google in vain for more information. I can’t even recall whether the term he used was in english or german. Perhaps someone here can point me in the right direction?
- nappy-doo 6y agoI can't help you with the term you're looking for, but as far as seals are concerned, they're genetically very close to dogs. I'd expect similar behaviors.
- lostlogin 6y agoA friend who works in a conservation role was telling me about the time he took a seal to the beach to get it off the road in a small town. The window was open, and like a dog it was happiest with its nose in the breeze.
- munificent 6y ago
- lelanthran 6y agoIn other news, water is wet? Seriously, dog owners know all this already. They know that me puting my hat on means I'm going outside, if I grab my keys they know I'm leaving the yard, when I pick up a ball to throw, they know to look at my face (facial cues) to determine which direction I am going to throw it in.
- dan-robertson 6y agoI think I’m ok with studies determining that things we think are obviously true are true. 1. Sometimes they turn out not to be true so it is good to do the study 2. It would be bad to do the study looking for a surprise, find no surprise, and then not publish the results. Probably some university PR department is trying to come up with something to say.
- corpMaverick 6y agoAlso. Somethings are obvious but they are difficult to test. These experiments help us make progress on how to design experiments.
- rakoo 6y agoBut people who don't own dogs might not. This research might be interesting for everyone else
- amelius 6y agoA scientist has even found that dogs know when their owner is coming home [1] Rupert Sheldrake had a Google Talk about this in 2008 [2] [1] https://www.sheldrake.org/books-by-rupert-sheldrake/dogs-that-know-when-their-owners-are-coming-home https://www.sheldrake.org/books-by-rupert-sheldrake/dogs-tha... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hic18Xyk9is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hic18Xyk9is
- worik 6y agoAs a child my dog was always at the top of the drive when I came home from school.
- ambivalents 6y agoThis is obvious if you have a dog, but cool to see it studied. My dog is a velcro dog, he follows me everywhere. If I change direction he will too. If I start to run he will too. One amusing thing on our walks is he will walk confidently, determinedly in one direction, as if he is rushing to a destination. Then if I change direction, he immediately does too, as if forgetting about his original destination in the first place. Anthropomorphizing a bit I know. This article suggests all dogs are like this, mine just might do it to a stronger degree.
- noodlenotes 6y agoDogs also spend a lot of time on leashes where they'll get yanked around if they don't pay attention to their human's movements. And many families specifically train and reward dogs to move in sync with them (heeling, agility). It seems obvious that synchrony is something that humans both train and selectively breed dogs for. I guess the point of this study is that synchrony is another way to measure social connection between dogs and humans and that this connection extends to children.
- lordgroff 6y agoIncidentally, my dog behaves and is far more synchronized off than on leash, so much so that I'm trying to train her to be leash free. She listens a lot better like that for some reason.
- slacka 6y agoAs someone who grew up in a family of pet owners, the joke is anytime there is a story with "study" and "dog", that any dog owner could have told them that. This study is what we refer to as the "invisible leash" that dogs have with with their masters. The article also touches on mirroring behavior, which is also well known and even has a whole class of dog training based around it called "Do as I Do"[1] I trained my dog this way as a pup. AMA. Dogs spend their lives trying to figure out what we want and the meaning of our words. Science has year to catch up to learn just how much they understand and how in-tune they are with their adopted pack. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oC3OqbjlxkM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oC3OqbjlxkM
- ska 6y agoThere is a tendency to feel this way when anything in day to day experience (pet ownership, parenthood, career experience, etc.) overlaps with scientific study. It's tempting to say "well, obviously" but it's a slippery slope. Beyond the obvious potential for confirmation bias, etc., when you do the science carefully, sometimes you find out what people "knew" was just wrong. This happens often enough to make it worth the effort.
- postalrat 6y agoIn the case of dogs you will probably find more things that is common knowledge with dog owners that science got wrong vs. things where science showed that owners were wrong.
- jonmc12 6y agoPBS NOVA's "Dog Tales" (2020) is a good watch and explains this behavior. https://www.pbs.org/video/dog-tales-vskr2y/ https://www.pbs.org/video/dog-tales-vskr2y/ They demonstrate that a wolf can be domesticated, but will still keep its distance and act independently from the domesticating humans. Surprisingly, domesticated wolves test higher than dogs on intelligence tests. The show attributes dog behavior to a genetic mutation from their wolf ancestry. A similar mutation occurs in humans at 1:10k frequency called Williams Syndrome. One feature in this mutation is a form of learning disability; another is friendliness.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nicbou 6y ago> One feature in this mutation is a form of learning disability; another is friendliness. I really don't want a certain kind of people to ever hear this fact
- yencabulator 6y agoI've seen a canine behavioral study that said wolves were better problem solvers because, given the same task of opening a box, dogs gave up and switched tactics to asking for help from a human.
- npsimons 6y agoAnyone else think of "A Fire Upon the Deep" by Vinge?
- lalabert 6y agoCats don’t!
- nicklecompte 6y ago“Humans orient and move in synchrony with their cat owners” (I certainly do! The cats run the show here.)
- whalesalad 6y agoDepends on the cat. Ever met a dog-cat?
- nicwolff 6y agoFrom the last paragraph of the article: > She and her colleagues also are interested in studying the bonding and interwoven movements of people and other types of pets, particularly cats. “We’ve done a little work with cats and, so far, they blow everything out of the water in terms of being socially responsive to their owners’ behavior,” she says.
- astrange 6y agoDon't they? I think the problem is we don't know how to read them and every cat has a different language because they don't learn it from each other. https://www.gwern.net/Cat-Sense https://www.gwern.net/Cat-Sense
- notJim 6y agoThe lab this is from has a nice page with some of their publications here: https://thehumananimalbond.com/publication-media/ https://thehumananimalbond.com/publication-media/
- aaron695 6y agoI'd like to hope they address the issues of the fake news research around "Google Earth shows that cow and deer herds align like compass needles" and "Do Dogs Have Their Own Poop Compass" I see the difference between the controversial ideas around magnetoreception in many mammals and what I'd see as un-controversial, animals have some level of herding with humans and it will be different with children for various reasons. But clearly people are misusing the difficulty of measuring alignments on animals to get exciting research. Can't see the paper online for free - https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-020-01454-4 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-020-01454-4
- dmurray 6y agoEverything in the study can be completely explained with a mechanism no more powerful than "dogs tend to follow their owners". Plus a little bit of quantifying whether they are more loyal at following adult owners/shelter workers/children. "Move in synchrony" is a very clickbaity way to suggest that there's something magical or insufficiently understood here (like magnetoreception). That seems to be editorializing from the NYT, rather than the authors of the study.
- staticman2 6y agoSynchrony is the term from the scientific study: your beef isn't with the NYT on that term.
- yostrovs 6y agoWhy have the New York Times when you can read the study yourself with all the scientific jargon included? I thought their purpose in covering science is to make it easier to understand for a layman. What is synchrony? Do you think an average person actually knows? I'm educated in the sciences and I'm not sure of what it really means.
- dreen 6y agoCows dont tend to align NS? This isn't new and I never heard of this being debunked