7 ms·
Considering how entrenched Docker has been in global tech infrastructure for so many years, I automatically assumed that the company was worth billions already,
by paxys 6y ago
Considering how entrenched Docker has been in global tech infrastructure for so many years, I automatically assumed that the company was worth billions already, but guess not. I wonder why they haven't been bought out by Microsoft or Google, if nothing else then just for the talent.
- systemvoltage 6y agoIt is obvious. This is a common pattern: 1. Offer open-source 100% free product that's absolutely ground breaking, unlike anything else. 2. Get a shitload of users and free PR machine gets rolling. Network effects kick in. 3. Go to investors with your active user count in excess of millions. 4. Investors go bonkers and their eyes swell up with all the ways they can exploit these addicted-to-free user base. 5. Company has trouble monetizing the users. Users are pissed. 6. We all wonder why they couldn't make billions. It just happened to Elastic search a couple of months ago when Amazon swiped the rug from under them. Good. This should be a lesson to all the companies that want to follow this pattern. Without Step 1, Docker would have had a much more difficult time to get traction and would have to compete on a level ground. So, they short circuit this competition by going full 100% free product route. I have zero empathy for these companies and their investors.
- zapita 6y agoExcept Docker had already raised $10M before launching. So they do not match your pattern.
- systemvoltage 6y agoDoesn't matter. $10M initial round to offer free product to get users aboard. The key point is to get users addicted to free. Uber did this by undercutting the entire taxi industry at a loss. Ever wondered why your rides were so cheap!? Jio did the same in India, offer free unlimited internet on their phone service and wipe out the competition.
- koolba 6y agoWho cares? Why not just milk their VCs for the free handouts and then move on like we do with every other VC funded unsustainable service.
- evanelias 6y agoTheir initial product was a platform-as-a-service (dotCloud), which wasn't free, aside from the early beta. Docker was essentially a pivot. I see no evidence that the company was founded as a nefarious scheme to get users addicted to a free product.
- systemvoltage 6y agoYou just made my point. The reason why I’ve never heard of dotCloud and literally everyone knows Docker. Docker is popular because it’s free. A lot of people would be upset if they take down their free hosting repositories. As a user, I want to pay for stuff to sustain companies. They can still be open source.
- evanelias 6y agoIf enough users had wanted to pay for dotCloud, they wouldn't have needed to pivot in the first place. My understanding (as a complete outsider) is that they raised a $10+ million series A for their PaaS. The PaaS then presumably wasn't successful enough to raise a subsequent round, but one of their technologies (Docker) was, despite the monetization path for it not being clear yet. So they pivoted to focus on that. I'm not sure what other outcome could plausibly happen in this scenario. If they stuck with the PaaS as their main focus, they would have gone out of business many years ago.
- Yajirobe 6y ago> I have zero empathy for these companies and their investors. Wow, imagine being so hateful towards amazing open-source tools
- systemvoltage 6y agoOpen source tools were developed by the community and they're being harrassed now for monetization. How is that being hateful? I am looking out for the community in this sense.
- botswana99 6y agoThey are not developed by a 'community'. The developers who build it are paid for by investors. Those investors want a huge return. It's not open source, it's bait and wait
- cutemonster 6y agoBait and wait and ... But what's step 3? Doesn't seem to work super well, hmm
- cheriot 6y agoMySQL was acquired for 1B. Elastic is currently worth 10B. Redhat was acquired for 34B. What's not working well?
- cutemonster 6y agoGood points. So step 3 can be to do an exit, when the software is really popular. I wonder what's next for Elastic. And mongodb etc. And all their users and customers
- yagizdegirmenci 6y agoExactly, when you take a look at the mainstream "open-source" projects, you 'll see that those projects are all developed and maintained by some people who gets paid to do that. (e.g. Kubernetes, Firecracker, Gvisor, Bottlerocket, Podman)
- mvzvm 6y ago> when Amazon swiped the rug from under them. Good. > I have zero empathy for these companies and their investors. Are you trolling? Or do you want to see all amazing open source tech move behind closed doors and payed walled gardens?
- Spivak 6y agoYou're presenting a false dichotomy. I think the parent would have preferred these projects be successful and sustainable without the sleazy tactic of baiting users with free stuff, taking a mountain of VC cash, and then desperately trying to find ways of "monetizing" those users. Bleh. F/OSS software works best when it's not a revenue source of the business that develops it. "Hey, I ran into $problem at $work and created $project to fix it! I'm giving it away so that it might solve your problem too! Hit me up on $mailing_list if you want to contribute." Red Hat is pretty much the poster child of this model. They make $0 on all the FOSS software they develop and release to the world but they dogfood it into their own products to collect dividends.
- fergie 6y agoElastic has a market cap of over $10billion. It is literally one of the most successful tech companies ever.
- chuckSu 6y agoUh. Sure
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> absolutely ground breaking, unlike anything else Containers existed for decades as a concept and for years on Linux (using lxc or VirtSquare and later nspawn)
- johannes1234321 6y agoIt is true that the technologies existed for a while. I played with (Free)BSD jails and Solaris Zones long before Docker. Docker however made things "trivial" with the integration from container building, to public registry and docker-compose, which can make developer lives (depending on domain) much nicer. With jails and zones it was never as convenient.
- seniorThrowaway 6y agoThat was docker's real value add, making it easy and developer centric. Previous containerization technologies were heavily ops-centric. I come from an ops background and I remember thinking at the time that Docker was in some ways a developer workaround to barriers that ops set up to limit what they could do and protect them from themselves.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrkeen 6y ago> 5. Company has trouble monetizing the users. Users are pissed. Are we pissed? Docker hasn't started showing me ads or spewing MOTDs asking for donations. I haven't run into limitations that would have me purchase an upgrade. It hasn't been bought by a proprietary company that would make me start worrying about its licencing. It's a solid workhorse that's been at all my previous jobs and will be at all my future jobs for the foreseeable future. Most criticisms of it boil down to "there are other container technologies".
- amelius 6y ago> Docker was estimated to be valued at over $1 billion, making it what is called a "unicorn company", after a $95 million fundraising round in April 2015. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Docker,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Docker,_Inc.
- paxys 6y agoThe fact that they had a $95 million round in 2015 and then a $23 million round in 2021 leads me to believe their valuation is a lot lower now.
- dpkrjb 6y agoI’d imagine that some of their valuation was based on the future success of docker swarm and what they would monetise around it
- LeSaucy 6y agoWas there ever a technical reason why swarm never won out in the market? I've still got a couple of multi-node swarms that work great and are WAY easier to configure than k8s. I never really understood why it didn't take off.
- KronisLV 6y agoI'd also like to know more about this, since for smaller to medium sized deployments (think 1-100 nodes, maybe running between 1-1000 containers) Docker Swarm does seem like a pretty reasonable solution, especially with tools like Portainer ( https://www.portainer.io/ https://www.portainer.io/ ) for a web based UI to manage it. I guess some of the reasons for the popularity of Kubernetes could be: - Kubernetes had Google as a big name behind it, so there was a lot of development resources put into it and eventually, lots of learning resources available, in addition to overall publicity; for example, i don't think anything like this exists for Docker Swarm https://www.katacoda.com/courses/kubernetes - in addition to the marketing and PR, it got picked up as a solution for many managed offerings by cloud hosts (managed Docker Swarm has almost none), a bit like what happened with serverless and AWS Lambda - Kubernetes allows for CRDs, has a pretty good API and has a large ecosystem built around it, to help manage its complexity (even distros like K3s and MicroK8s could be mentioned), as well as many to implement additional functionality (Istio + Kiali come to mind) - this further snowballed into turn-key offerings like Rancher and OpenShift that had financial incentives behind them, the idea of building a new distro that vendor locks clients into a particular company's offering, resources, support etc. - almost everyone (oftentimes incorrectly) believes that they need to be able to scale a lot and therefore chased the hype - FOMO further motivated a whole bunch of developers to use Kubernetes for their projects, instead of looking at the alternatives like Docker Swarm or Nomad - however, knowing Kubernetes can help to be more easily onboarded and to work with deployments in many different companies (except for when it isn't), the skills carry over nicely Of course, some of these may be my subjective views and not at all accurate. Personally, i think something between Docker Swarm, Nomad and K3s would be the sweet spot for containerized app deployments and orchestration, but personally i just like the Docker Compose manifests more than i do Kubernetes' and it feels like the popularity of Helm (or Kustomize) supports this line of reasoning. Ideally we wouldn't even need containers and something like FreeBSD jails with a user friendly API around it would be sufficient. But the popularity that Docker gained seems to highlight that perhaps something was missing from those older technologies.
- tw04 6y ago>I wonder why they haven't been bought out by Microsoft or Google, if nothing else then just for the talent. Because they received an insane valuation years ago and probably aren't even worth break-even on their funding rounds. Google already has far more K8s knowledge internally than anyone at docker, so what would be their gain? MS did try to buy them back in 2016 but Docker pulled an Jerry* Yang and said no [1]. I don't see why MS would bother at this point, they are also headed down the k8s path, and anything they needed from an expertise perspective they likely already received through their partnership agreement [2]. [1] https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/news/sources-microsoft-tried-to-buy-docker-for-4b/2016/06/ https://www.sdxcentral.com/articles/news/sources-microsoft-t... [2] https://www.docker.com/blog/docker-microsoft-partnership/ https://www.docker.com/blog/docker-microsoft-partnership/ *I incorrectly said Andrew Yang initially, my apologies for my bad memory and any confusion it may have caused. Thank you Hexcles for the correction.
- swyx 6y agoi'm not up on my political references; what does "pull an Andrew Yang" mean?
- tw04 6y agoIt has absolutely nothing to do with politics. Microsoft offered to acquire Yahoo for $44.6 billion dollars in 2008 [1]. Jerry* Yang turned them down claiming the offer "substantially undervalued" the company. 8 years later they sold to Verizon for $5 billion [2]. [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/yahoo-rejects-microsofts-bid/ https://www.cnet.com/news/yahoo-rejects-microsofts-bid/ [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/briansolomon/2016/07/25/yahoo-sells-to-verizon-for-5-billion-marissa-mayer/?sh=1c5795e0450f https://www.forbes.com/sites/briansolomon/2016/07/25/yahoo-s... *I incorrectly said Andrew Yang initially, my apologies for my bad memory and any confusion it may have caused. Thank you Hexcles for the correction.
- Hexcles 6y agoI think that's Jerry Yang.
- raiyu 6y agoThis is the challenge with taking venture dollars, your interests aren't aligned. As a founder post Series B you probably have at least 10% of the business, that's a nice $400MM payout coming your way. But if the VC invested at a $1B price, picks up 10% and 80% of their return goes to their LPs they are personally pocketing much less. So it is advantageous for them to continue to shoot for the stars rather than sell short. Plus they have multiple bets going on at the same time while the founders only have one. So a $4B acquisition nets the founder $400MM, but and the VC firm is picking up $300MM of which 80% is going back to LPs, leaving $60MM for the partnership, perhaps split 3-7 ways, with maybe a kicker for the partner that sourced and led the investment. So let's say that's roughly $10MM going to the VC partner. Well you got one person staring at $400MM and another staring at $10MM. The interests aren't quite aligned. Also survivorship bias has us focused on companies that turned down acquisition offers and made it big, like Facebook, Google, Netflix, Snapchat, and so forth, but we don't really hear about the companies that turn down the offer and then fail to meet that acquisition price later, because that story just doesn't sell as well and the company fades into irrelevance so it isn't a piece that is picked up often. Certainly at the time it could have been a good decision given how new the market was and the potential upside, but obviously hindsight is 20/20.
- goatinaboat 6y agoConsidering how entrenched Docker has been in global tech infrastructure for so many years It is not entrenched at all, that's their problem. You can literally drop in Podman as a replacement and alias the command it it will "just work" - and Podman has some significant advantages in many environments/use cases. Docker, the company or the product, has no concrete barriers to entry to protect itself.
- caminocorner 6y agoMy best guess is they slowly become less valuable until IBM buys them for the name recognition