8 ms·
Facebook has 10k engineers working on AR/VR
- astlouis44 6y agoThat's like 10x more than Apple's reported 1000 engineers working on Mixed Reality.
- ecmascript 6y agoI wonder if it's profitable right now or that they see a future were it's so important to the loss is worth it.
- HHC-Hunter 6y agoI really doubt it's profitable right now. As for the future - There's no doubt, VR is it.
- perilunar 6y agoVR has been 'the future' since at least the 90s.
- numlock86 6y agoSo were electric vehicles but we are getting there now.
- perilunar 6y agoNo, electric vehicles were 'the past'. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26422912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26422912 Hydrogen fuel-cell powered cars were 'the future'.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThat's almost like someone in the 18th century saying steam engines were the past, because Hero of Alexandria built them in 1AD [0]. Nothing new to see here, Mr. Watt. Much like with steam engines in ancient Rome, the technological and economical context at the turn of 20th century wasn't right for the mass adoption of electric cars. Technological environment stayed wrong until the turn of 21th century, and the economical environment stayed wrong until Tesla single-handedly dragged the market, kicking and screaming, into accepting electric cars as a viable product. Similarly, we had VR since at least the 90s, but the technological environment was bad then. It's right now, and it's the Oculus Quest line that made a pivotal change in the market acceptance. -- [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile
- numlock86 6y ago> No, electric vehicles were 'the past'. Meh, by that same argument you could say VR is the past. The point of the discussion is that VR is now at a point were it will most likely get adopted, instead of just being a feat. Hence the comparison with electric vehicles. And no, hydrogen fuel-cell for mobility won't be the future. A niche in some sectors for sure, but that's it. The efficiency is just as bad (~40%) as with combustion engines. And that's not even taking production and transport into account. Sure, it's cleaner, but the whole "hydrogen is the future for everyday use" is lobbyism from people who want to keep their current infrastructure (especially transport and production) running ...
- neartheplain 6y agoAs someone who's followed VR for decades, and was underwhelmed by every Oculus headset from the DK1 to the Rift CV1: VR is here, now. The Quest is it. It's the real deal. The combination of standalone wireless play, precise inside-out environment sensing and hand tracking, heightened graphics quality, a substantial software library, and an attractive price point have finally hit the sweet spot. It's a shame that Facebook is the sole proprietor of this revolutionary device, but the device IS revolutionary. I've demoed VR for three non-technical friends in the last month who all promptly ran out and bought Quests of their own. I'm very excited for the future, and present, of this medium.
- perilunar 6y agoSo now VR is 'here, now'. Cool. Can we stop calling it 'the future' then?
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago"Kids these days" don't care about video games in that way. For them it's a fact of life, and not a glamorous one either; only a quick, addictive and not very healthy way to waste an hour or two (or four). Similar to cigarettes or beer in that respect, though we allow kids access to video games. Most of them play online mobile games because that gets the rush quicker and easier. Trying to sell an overly complex, bulky, expensive and high-investment video game system to the coming generations will be a very uphill battle. (We saw this with TV; for the boomer generation TV was high technology, and getting on TV was the highest aspiration in life. Who even watches broadcast TV now?)
- neartheplain 6y agoKids love novelty, sensory stimuli, and attention. The Quest provides these in spades. Half my random squadmates in Population One (the big VR battle royale shooter) are kids. There are so many kids in VR right now that huge threads on r/virtualreality are dedicated to this problem, VR’s own Eternal September: https://www.reddit.com/r/virtualreality/comments/m2t7jl/children_in_vr_suck_and_something_needs_to_be/ https://www.reddit.com/r/virtualreality/comments/m2t7jl/chil...
- baby 6y agoSounds like someone who doesn’t have a Quest.
- ma2rten 6y agoWhy?
- siekmanj 6y agoI was always very unimpressed with VR until I borrowed a headset to play Half Life Alyx. That game convinced me VR is the inevitable future of gaming. The rest of the industry may not be there yet, but it is an obviously superior experience.
- hervature 6y ago“The future” != “future of gaming”
- psychiatrist24 6y agoActually, it may be.
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoOne of the problems is that competitive fps gaming probably not going to move away from the mouse/keyboard inputs in the short term. And sitting down looking forward in a vr goggle, and turning your character around with a mouse induces wild nausea for a number* of people. *I’m unfamiliar with the exact ratio.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoThe future of gaming is already here; it's called "pay to win mobile multiplayer shooter". Video games are only a way to get a quick dopanine rush, and that's the local optimum that gets you your rush quickest and easiest. VR is not needed.
- JKCalhoun 6y ago> I was always very unimpressed with VR until I borrowed a headset to play Half Life Alyx. The word "borrowed" stands out for me: I also tried a cutting edge VR headset loaned from a co-worker but did not then rush out and buy one. Because the experience felt like more of a "novelty", not a day-to-day thing that I would switch over to.
- Tepix 6y ago"Most of what Facebook does today, he [Zuck] said, is "building on top of other people’s platforms."
- zizee 6y agoIndeed. What would happen to FB if for some reason both Apple and Google simultaneously removed their apps from their respective apps stores? I'm not sure it would destroy FB, but it would be a huge blow.
- herbst 6y agoAt this point it should be fragil enough to probably just die.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAn expensive lawsuit, probably. Push comes to shove, I guess Facebook could launch their own mobile platform too? They already have their own Android phone - it's buried inside the Quest headset. But they probably don't need to, unless Apple/Google disallows the use of Facebook SDK by all the other apps in their app stores. Until then, the sweet sweet surveillance data will keep flowing.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoAt a certain scale, hiring people to do nothing starts to make sense as an investment for an IT company. Microsoft Research is a classic example - some of the smartest people in the world are being paid big salaries to do nothing much of anything at all. But then imagine what those same people could do had they worked at a startup or doing open source...
- coolspot 6y agoConsidering what Quest 1 has achievied on the 10nm process and Quest 2 has achieved on the 7nm process, I can see how this quick escalation of compute power will enable extensivly immersive experiences that are going to be very accessible and user-friendly. 5nm is already shipping (Apple M1) and 3nm is planned for the next year. Facebook is betting on being the leader and the sole owner of the new class of human-computer interaction.
- random5634 6y agoI’d buy except for forced Facebook login - the brand is a bit damaged
- mattnewton 6y agoSame, my next upgrade from the Oculus v1 will probably be a valve index for this reason.
- Tepix 6y agoI'm holding out for XR2 based Quest competitors. But they will be more expensive for sure.
- dgellow 6y agoExactly this.
- nicbou 6y agoInstead of a Samsung or Google account?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoFrom a practical POV: logging in with Samsung account would be OK. Logging in with Google account wouldn't, for the same reason Facebook isn't. It's because ToS violations tend to be executed against the whole cloud account. Do something stupid in a Samsung VR game? The hypothetical Samsung headset is now a paperweight, but at least that's all that happened. Nobody uses their Samsung account for anything anyway. Do the same on Quest, and you lose your Facebook account. Or, post something on Facebook that their automoderation doesn't like, and you lose your Quest. Same stuff happens with Google all the time. My favorite example is how a lot of people lost their whole digital lives because they commented with emojis on a YouTube livestream[0], and got their Google accounts banned immediately by YouTube's spam detector. That means GMail, Google Docs, calendar, all gone. That's the pragmatic POV. A little more future-oriented POV is to say hard no to all such cloud logins, because as implemented today, they're a stupid and exploitative idea. With the importance of digital SaaS to daily lives and businesses of so many people, we're allowing companies to create what's essentially a parallel system of legislation and national (fiefdom?) IDs. -- [0] - https://old.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/dtyxn7/whats_going_on_with_youtube_and_banning_peoples/ https://old.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/dtyxn7/whats_... - TL;DR: a popular YouTuber asked the audience of his livestream to vote on some stuff live, using color emojis to distinguish between options.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoAs Facebook is one of the worst companies in existence today, I really hope they will not succeed in that new market.
- Shared404 6y agoYep. I hope the best for VR/AR, and the worst for Facebook.
- goatinaboat 6y agoI hope the best for VR/AR, and the worst for Facebook It's funny, Tron was one of the most memorable movies of my childhood. Later I watched Star Trek with the Holodeck, read Neuromancer and Snow Crash, dabbled with VRML, played with the SGI CAVE at university. I ought to be hugely excited by the progress in VR. But... I'm just not. Because Facebook and friends are not doing it because it's cool or because it will be useful to humanity, to them it's just another siphon to hoover up and monetise your personal data by steering you into purchasing and voting decisions that benefit them, not you. After literally decades of anticipation, I doubt I will bother to participate in VR.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYour story also describes my personal disillusionment with technology more generally. Not with just VR, but with technology in general. All the time, I see ideas and technologies that have huge unrealized potential - they could be so much more - but they aren't, because they're being purposefully crippled by the companies who develop them, patent the shit out of them[0], and proceed to milk people for all they're worth using that tech. Everything is exploitative. And what about all that potential? Companies see it, alright - they wax about it in their marketing materials. Then they make sure it doesn't happen. -- [0] - While intended to protect from other alike competitors, this has a side effect of shutting off anyone who would like to develop technologies up to their potential.
- Shared404 6y ago
- Tepix 6y agoThe Oculus Quest 2 is the most interesting standalone VR headset available. Unfortunately, it requires a Facebook login. There was a competition to jailbreak the device to enable its use without handing your data to FB and it seems like there were several successful jailbreaks, but none of them were released to the public. With a working jailbreak i would be very tempted to take advantage of the subsidized pricing of this device.
- supernova87a 6y agoWhy in the world would we link to the crapfest that is the website makeuseof.com instead of the actual source article?
- tpmx 6y agoThere's a $39/month paywall on theinformation.com.
- OptionX 6y agoWith 10k engineers you would think they could task a couple of guys the remove the forced Facebook account use to use the Oculus products. /s
- neartheplain 6y agoFrom Facebook's perspective, why would they? They've got the VR market by the short hairs, no competitor comes close. I really hope Valve works on a mobile VR headset of their own. The Index is fantastic for PC VR, but mobile (with PC VR optional, via Virtual Desktop or USB cable) is clearly where the users are. Facebook's already sold millions of Quest headsets: https://www.roadtovr.com/facebook-rec-room-2-3m-oculus-quest-2-sold/ https://www.roadtovr.com/facebook-rec-room-2-3m-oculus-quest...
- viklove 6y agoValve isn't trying to probe your asshole to extract every last bit of value from you at your expense. They just want to make games. And from that perspective, a non-desktop VR headset doesn't seem profitable.
- stevula 6y agoUnpopular though it may be, I’m pretty sure it’s an intended feature not a bug.
- m12k 6y agoTheir job isn't to kickstart the VR revolution, their job is to ensure Facebook owns it.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoThey could have done that without the login. Instagram and WhatsApp manage to exist and farm data without the login. Still think it was a dumb move by some exec who is being judged by “FB platform interactions” or something equally dumb. It made no sense doing it this early.
- samspenc 6y agoNumbers seem to be a bit off here because author is conflating total headcount with number of engineers. If we go by ratio at similarly large FAANG companies, say 1/3 or 1/5 of the company's employees are engineers. > At the start of 2021, according to Statista, the social network employed 58,604 people (a huge increase from the 18,000 people that Facebook employed back in 2017). OK, so maybe 12,000 to 18,000 engineers max at the whole company? > And of that number, according to a new report from The Information, about 10,000 engineers have been tasked with significant AR and VR development work. "10,000 engineers" would indicate more than half its engineering workforce is working on AR/VR, not 20%! Something seems a bit off here, let's go to the original story from The Information to have a look. Luckily it's linked from the article: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/the-people-with-power-at-facebook-as-its-hardware-commerce-ambitions-expand https://www.theinformation.com/articles/the-people-with-powe... > The seriousness of its ambitions is reflected in its headcount: Nearly 10,000 people are working in its group developing augmented and virtual reality devices, or nearly one-fifth of Facebook’s total global workforce. Ok, phew, that's better! The Information says 10,000 people are working in it's group. Doesn't mean they're all engineers. And the ratio is closer to 1/6 or 16.66% assuming Facebook's latest headcount. And if we go by the same FAANG engineer-to-workforce ratio, that would mean something like 2,000 to 3,000 engineers in Facebook at working on AR/VR. It's not a small number, but seems more realistic.
- objclxt 6y agoIt’s also a little misleading because Facebook includes Portal (its smart home devices) as part of AR/VR. Plus you have all the other HW and OS teams that other companies like Google and Apple would account for elsewhere, since Facebook has no other consumer hardware development teams.
- globular-toast 6y agoWhat do you think the other 4/5 of people are doing for AR/VR?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoMy guess: the same as with all other big tech companies, which also tend to have similarly skewed split between engineering and non-engineering. I.e. mostly sales, marketing, legal, and management. Software engineering scales up well, all that other stuff doesn't.
- saos 6y agoNice. I will be using competitor products.
- hyko 6y agoObviously VR is miles away from mainstream adoption–it’s the fusion power of computer science–but FB are mad keen on not having gatekeepers like Apple moderate their power. Btw, anyone who lets FB that close to their eyeballs is a stone cold moron at this point. They couldn’t be trusted to run an online photo album, giving them the ability to actually control your sense of reality is nightmarishly awful.
- m12k 6y agoYeah, the Quest 2 looks like a great piece of hardware, but I'm getting one if and only if a jailbreak comes out.
- pantalaimon 6y agoWhy do you need a jailbreak? You can already install third party APKs and there is a huge SideQuest community.
- herbst 6y agoSome of us avoid devices that depend on (forever changing) hacks for normal usage.
- nomel 6y agoI don't think I would consider side loading with a developer account as a hack, and I don't think there's much evidence that this will change.
- ngokevin 6y agoI think they're looking to kill it in favor of a sideloading channel they can control. They announced it but I forgot its name.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoYup. They knee-capped Quest in a really dumb way. I'm not upgrading my Quest 1 until I can buy something equivalent without forced cloud login bullshit. If I can't, I guess I'll just stay out of VR. From what I see, this is not just nerds being nerds, a lot of Quest's current user base feels the same. I'm also hoping general population is slowly discovering the flip side of shared cloud logins for unrelated services. Connecting Facebook to your Quest doesn't just mean you can VR-chat with your Facebook friends now. It also means that if Facebook automoderator doesn't like you, your Quest will turn into an expensive paperweight. Or if you break Quest ToS, you may lose your whole Facebook account with it. (What is sometimes called "digital feudalism" really does start feeling like one.)
- zmmmmm 6y agoIt's kind of terrifying to think how Facebook expects to make that money back. If I believed they were making a platform play I would not feel so uncomfortable about it, but they seem intent on locking onto turning it into a social media device. There's just no way to pay for that scale of investment on a subsidised device without some seriously invasive / and or creepy practices. Please Facebook, prove me wrong (fastest way: make the FB login optional ...).
- neartheplain 6y agoThey're already doubling-down on the forced integration. They replaced the Oculus profile-based "Friends" button on the Quest home with a "Chat" button that opens Facebook Messenger in VR. In my friend circle, nobody wants this. It gets in the way of starting party chats and sending game invites to Oculus friends, who (for me anyway) are largely a separate network from my Facebook friends. Facebook is assuming that users want their gaming social networks and IRL social networks to be the same. This is lunacy. My Steam friends and my Facebook friends have been largely-disjoint graphs for decades, and for good reason. Imagine friending someone in a VR game, and immediately getting blasted with their political posts/family photos on Facebook. Imagine friending someone in a VR game, and suddenly they know who you are IRL (forever). Via people-finder sites like Spokeo or YellowPages, it's trivial to connect this info to your home address, telephone number, employer, and so on. What happens when Internet stranger who knows where you live gets mad that you won the rare drop and they didn't? Forced integration of Facebook and Oculus is a safety issue.
- Tarsul 6y agothis has always been (my) issue with facebook: They assume you want to share everything with everyone of your friends. But most people don't want to do that, they want to share relevant stuff with the people for whom it's relevant. Only narcissists don't care about who they're talking to when they make a speech.
- mustardo 6y agoThe one thing Google plus got right with "circles" IMHO
- mola 6y agoToo bad. Humanity will probably suffer. Imagine every street and every particle of air owned by a single business corporation. Are you its customer or vassal?
- djohnston 6y agoCustomer. You are purchasing its product voluntarily.
- hackerfromthefu 6y agoIf you have no other reasonable option, its a strange form of voluntary. e.g. you can volunteer to be without a smartphone from apple/google, but its not a truly reasonable option in the modern world.
- mhh__ 6y agoWith all this talk of Facebook let's not forget that valve want to read your mind too!
- ericbarrett 6y agoI have always been a VR skeptic. I interned at NASA Ames in the 90s. My sponsor was working on VR. They had two devices, a (very expensive) commercial headset with 256x256 stereo resolution, and a homemade augmented reality (AR) device using 50% silvered lenses and wireframe. The system was driven by an SGI Onyx, and before that a Skywriter, using custom serial port drivers[0]. The goal was to research people's ability to complete VR tasks under differing circumstances: latency, frame rate, and so forth. One of the most common tasks was a VR variant of the buzz ring game[1]. It was exciting, and the wonders of VR when it's working and you're not sick really can't be overstated. Even that old primitive system had magic, and I always enjoyed imagining the games of the future. We had a bunch of people in and out of the lab to be experiment subjects. And as lab techs, we were always "volunteered" as well. What I observed from watching this for a few years was that some people just can't use VR. There was one person, I think a grad student, who had poor balance and underperformed at most tasks relative to the mean. Nobody cared, as it was only data collection, and he was still a data point. Until one day he came in with a cold and congested sinuses. I'll never forget: the moment he put on the VR headset, he toppled backward like a chopped tree. First slowly, then all at once. No reflex or anything! He just started leaning over at the heels. He would have come crashing down onto thinly-carpeted concrete at full speed had my (neither young nor large) boss jumped up and caught him. That was his last time in the helmet. We had a few more subjects through who performed similarly poorly. My guess—empirical, but still a guess— would be 15-20% of the population lacks some kind of proprioception that makes them vulnerable to falls and injury using VR. Obviously VR is fun, and extremely engaging. I'm sure it won't be going away as the tech gets smaller and cheaper. But I don't think it will ever become a primary interface; how can it when 1/5 of the population can't use it safely? [0] The custom drivers, used for the positioning sensors, reduced input latency by 40ms to 10. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KZgD053xXI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KZgD053xXI
- paperwasp42 6y agoI fall into that 15-20%. I'm quite tech savvy and spend a lot of time in front of screens, so it's odd that I react so poorly to VR. But I simply can't balance while using a VR headset. Interestingly, I have a neuromuscular disease. I would guess this is part of the issue, even though I don't experience dizziness/lack of balance as a day-to-day issue. A friend of mine has similar issues. She has chronic sinusitis, so I wonder if that is the cause. Anyway, I have to agree with you here. It's going to be a bit difficult for VR to catch on if 1/5 of your friend group can't play/participate without injuring themselves. The question is, how common is this really? And if it is common, would growing up with VR make the next generation less likely to have these issues? Or is it an immutable problem for people with certain brain structures or health issues?