5 ms·
First step: figure out if you are a covered entity or a business associate, or neither. If not, the law doesn't apply to you. However, you may still want to f
by dekhn 6y ago
First step: figure out if you are a covered entity or a business associate, or neither. If not, the law doesn't apply to you. However, you may still want to follow its guidelines.
it's an onerous law and many people now cite it when they don't want to provide information, even if the law doesn't apply to them.
- noodlesUK 6y agoThis unfortunately seems to also be the case with GDPR in Europe. People use it as a scary sounding excuse for various nonsense, even when it clearly doesn’t apply. I recently heard a university claim that GDPR prevented them from recording lectures amongst other things. I’ve also heard numerous individuals complain that GDPR prevented them from doing one thing or another, when GDPR doesn’t apply to things individuals do in most cases. Well-publicised laws generally get this treatment, where people invoke their name as some sort of magic incantation to justify their action (or more often inaction), and know little to nothing about the law itself.
- zamadatix 6y agoI'd be curious why University recordings weren't subject to GDPR myself. Consent could be had and managed but I could see this as enough trouble to just not do recordings as a result, especially since it can be withdrawn later.
- smnrchrds 6y agoI don't know anything about GDPR, but I guess at most it will protect students. If they only record professors while giving lectures, that can't be illegal, can it? And I'm sure the professor cannot withdraw consent for sharing the video anymore than an actor can withdraw consent from appearing in a film he had played in 10 years ago.
- anticensor 6y agoNot GDPR, but school regulations and other privacy regulations may prevent such recording by students.
- PeterisP 6y agoAt least pre-Covid, I presume that the general contract for professors does not include an agreement to be recorded, their job duties include giving lectures to students but not (without specific amendments) preparing recordings for public distribution. IMHO it might be the case that if a particular professor really wants to, they can refuse to be recorded (or refuse to allow arbitrary redistribution of the record beyond the students to which the lecture was given) without any legal ability for the university to push them to agree to that - while in this site most of GDPR discussion refers to its application for websites, in reality most of GDPR enforcement has been in the non-web world and especially for the employer-employee relations, including things like surveillance cameras in workspaces and the validity of nonnegotiated clauses in employment contracts regarding employee privacy rights; so the employer pushing a contract change "agree to be recorded or stop working for us" might not be legal. The specific details matter, of course. Some examples of actual GDPR enforcement cases for mishandling of employee information: https://www.complianceweek.com/regulatory-enforcement/german-laptop-retailer-fined-127m-under-gdpr-for-employee-surveillance/29911.article https://www.complianceweek.com/regulatory-enforcement/german... - general video surveillance of employees; https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/hm-fined-352m-for-gdpr-violations/ https://www.infosecurity-magazine.com/news/hm-fined-352m-for... - one of the biggest GDPR fines, for tracking various (IMHO clearly unreasonable) private data of employees; https://dataprivacymanager.net/725000e-gdpr-fine-by-dutch-dpa-for-collecting-employees-fingerprints/ https://dataprivacymanager.net/725000e-gdpr-fine-by-dutch-dp... - collecting employee fingerprints in an inappropriate manner. https://inplp.com/latest-news/article/EUR-150000-gdpr-fine-imposed-on-pwc-by-greek-data-protection-authority-for-being-not-accountable/ https://inplp.com/latest-news/article/EUR-150000-gdpr-fine-i... - employer asserting that a "consent" form that they forced all employees to sign counts as actual consent. I'm not saying that this necessarily prevents recording of lectures, but it also doesn't seem to be the case that you can "just do it" without properly accessing the legal aspect.
- noodlesUK 6y agoThey are subject to the GDPR in so far as they might record students, who might then need to give consent, which could then be withdrawn. In so far as the lecturers are concerned, the lawful basis is likely not to be consent, but rather a contractual obligation, where different rules apply. If for instance, paid actors in films could arbitrarily exercise their right to be forgotten, that would not be a tenable situation. The solution is clearly to not record students in any identifiable way, but there’s no need to avoid recording the lecture altogether. In fact, if the student were not identifiable, I expect it would be perfectly legitimate to record them without any explicit consent. Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer, this isn’t legal advice
- bigiain 6y ago> First step: figure out if you are a covered entity or a business associate, or neither. If not, the law doesn't apply to you. If you are a "covered entity" try and work out if you can stop being one. If you can avoid collecting HIPAA relevant data and still make your business model work, that's likely to be a significantly easier path to take than ensuring ongoing compliance. (Same as PCI compliance - outsource all that brain damage to Stripe or Square or whoever, and be able to look a judge in the eye and say "We never even see credit card data.")
- rsj_hn 6y agoWise words. Information should be treated as toxic effluvia and HIPAA compliance (as well as GDPR and related laws) should be considered as superfund cleanup procedures. They are expensive, complex, and fraught with legal risk. Don't collect information, don't store it, unless absolutely necessary and you can't find an expert certified third party to handle it for you.
- sokoloff 6y agoWe had a PCI QSA who argued that pages that linked out to payment processors were in full scope for PCI, because if compromised, they could be changed to point to a compromised payment entry site. Which logically means that pages which point to those pages are also in scope, all the way up the stack and suddenly everything is in full PCI scope. Absolutely use a PSP to minimize your wasted effort on compliance activities, but also choose a sane QSA.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoNote this is explicitly covered in the PCI self-assessment questionnaire levels. SAQ A-EP is specifically for websites where you own the website, but link out to something like Stripe for the payment processing. Here's a good overview I found googling for "SAQ A-EP vs SAQ A": https://epayments-support.ingenico.com/en/direct/faq/comparison-of-the-saq-a-vs-saq-a-ep https://epayments-support.ingenico.com/en/direct/faq/compari...
- Fomite 6y agoI'd say the first step is "Is this data even the kind where HIPAA compliance might be required?" The number of people I know who conflate "human subjects data" and "HIPAA data" is staggering.
- jollofricepeas 6y agoThe idea that you should inspect your systems for risk and then mitigate that risk should not be considered onerous. The idea that you should protect your Grandma’s healthcare data and encrypt it should not be considered onerous. If software development was actually “real” engineering, we’d have no need for HIPAA and something as obvious as its risk management statute. HIPAA is what happens when the tech industry acts irresponsibly and fails to police itself. We continue to choose features over security/maintenance.
- Centigonal 6y agoThis is how every discipline evolves. Do you think building codes and fire codes were thought up out of thin air? Do you think the FDA came into existence just because? The SEC was created in 1933, as direct result of the Great Depression. Dodd-Frank and CFPB were a direct result of the 2008 financial crisis. Every discipline starts out without regulation, until it inflicts some injury upon society that motivates the creation of regulation, which then often calcifies the industry and creates barriers for new entrants. The difference with data is just that we happen to be alive to see that transformation taking place.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoYup, people should follow the "rules" even if they don't actually apply to them. Confidential personal information should be kept confidential short of a legal compulsion to divulge it. Over my decades in IT I've seen plenty of things by accident (and once, not-accident. A guy was getting a lot of gay "spam" and wanted me to stop it. I went along with the cover story, knowing perfectly well it was message digests from a forum he had to have signed up for.) None of it gets repeated other than anonymized.