18 ms·
Israel's autonomous 'robo-snipers' and suicide drones raise ethical dilemma
- ryanmarsh 6y agoThey need open borders the same as us.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scrollaway 6y agoSlaughterbots come to anyone's mind? For those that haven't seen it, it's on youtube. Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slaughterbots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slaughterbots Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CO6M2HsoIA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9CO6M2HsoIA
- baybal2 6y agoProtein based slaughterbots cost USD $4k a month to hire, and $2k to arm, house, and feed. And they've been on battlefields for much longer.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThey have an intermittent tendency to have human emotions like "I should not commit a war crime", though.
- baybal2 6y agoIntermittent at most
- nkrisc 6y agoYou can find many without that particular constraint, if history is any evidence.
- ceejayoz 6y agoMy use of the word "intermittent" was intentional, yes. My point: you're not going to find many drones like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov in the foreseeable future.
- scrollaway 6y agoYou're talking about the ones that can't fly and can't be manufactured by the millions by anyone with the right amount of money?
- heavyset_go 6y agoThey're in luck, because as long as there are people who aren't born into means there will be a steady supply of people who choose to join the military over other pursuits.
- imtringued 6y agoYou can't manufacture military drones by the millions. It's also failing to actually realize military objectives. The problem isn't delivering bullets or explosives to the target, it's finding the target in the first place. Drone surveillance is a much bigger threat than killer drones. You are more likely to be thrown into prison because of drone technology than being killed.
- cryptica 6y agoThis could be a positive. It will create a disincentive for people to pursue political power or to get any kind of public attention. Anyone who draws attention to themselves could become a target. Control over the bot armies is likely to change hands frequently until they become fully autonomous and wipe us all out.
- a_f 6y agoPhillip K Dick's Second Variety came to my mind (or the film Screamers 1995)
- lambda_obrien 6y agoI think researching this stuff today is pretty immoral. If you're creating shit like this, you're inventing the next land mine. Stop it.
- seneca 6y agoWhile I understand the sentiment, the problem is that abstaining from weapons research due to moral qualms leads to the least moral being the most well armed.
- lupire 6y agoInvest in defensive research. "War is symmetric" is a fallacy. You often can't shoot back at who is shooting at you, but you can shoot at others.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- inglor_cz 6y agoThere is a remorseless logic in a race to the bottom, though. Anyone who eschews development of such military system risks becoming a toy of those who went all in. The Armenians just lost a lot of territory in Nagorno Karabakh they considered their own - to an enemy who had suicide drones. Their country wasn't exactly big even before that loss. Fifty other nations in potentially similar position looked at that war and its outcome. I doubt that their decisions were "let us stay moral and possibly be next on the chopping block".
- LegitShady 6y ago>The Armenians just lost a lot of territory in Nagorno Karabakh they considered their own - to an enemy who had suicide drones. IMHO while it's true their enemy had 'suicide drones' (which are actually loitering munitions, but 'suicide' makes it sound so much more evil) that wasn't a deciding factor - they also had Turkish drones that didn't require self detonation to work. Azerbaijan put a lot of videos on youtube showing them bombing and pursuing groups of Armenian soldiers with those drones, not the suicide drones. The suicide drones were anti material weapons against mobile air defense and other harder targets. The azeris even used old (trash) AN-2's turned into drones to get a response from Armenian air defense systems so that loitering munitions like the herop could identity air defense systems with minimal danger. We are already in this race. Everyone is, even if they won't acknowledge it. Without anti air/anti drone technology no ground force is safe. This isn't new or unique to drones - it's the truth of every war where air dominance occurs. In the Six Day War Israel destroyed most of Egypt's air force on the ground in its opening strike, and when Egypt tried to retreat from the Sinai they used their air force to bomb the retreating units with impunity. The remnants of Egypt's air force couldn't fight against an intact air force so they flew support sorties but were overall ineffective. No drones required. It's just gotten cheaper to do.
- xwdv 6y agoA more humane version may be to set up turrets with auto-aim lasers that can instantly blind targets rather than outright kill them.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThat'd be an explicit war crime. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_Certain_Conventional_Weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_Certain_Conventi... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_on_Blinding_Laser_Weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_on_Blinding_Laser_Wea...
- foota 6y agoRight, better shoot them instead. Maybe we just need a new convention on AI weaponry.
- badRNG 6y agoYou can use this line of thinking to justify any war crime that doesn't involve killing the adversary. "Well, we could've just killed them, better we dragged them to a black site to be tortured instead." A scenario where Palestinians are permanently blinded for approaching the prison fences in Gaza or elsewhere is honestly horrifying.
- marshmallow_12 6y agoi take your point, but they're not prison fences. Lets be clear about that.
- pessimizer 6y agoBut is not improved by shooting Palestinians who approach the prison fences in Gaza.
- skinkestek 6y agoRemember: the border used to be more open and I guess it will be in the future as soon as attacks decrease.
- Judgmentality 6y agoIt seems pretty obvious to me this is a slippery slope, and humans won't be in the loop forever. When you're already using weapons to kill your enemies, it's pretty easy to justify killing them easier when your goal is just to kill them already. It even gives them plausible deniability over individual deaths (not that it should, but it will).
- SavantIdiot 6y agoThere's a funny Asimov short story about improving technology for guided missiles. The solution: put a pilot in each guided missle. The entire story is tongue-in-cheek, but characterizes the ebb and flow between ethics and military technology.
- owyn 6y agoBack in WW2 the US worked on pigeon guided bombs but it never got very far. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Pigeon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Pigeon
- beaconstudios 6y agoAnd the Japanese had torpedoes with actual pilots https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaiten https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaiten
- holbue 6y agoI didn't know about the story yet, but the reality was already very close to that terrible scenario: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bachem_Ba_349 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bachem_Ba_349 (One of the launch sites is quite close to where I live)
- ceejayoz 6y agoThat looks like the pilot was intended to survive. A better comparison would be the Japanese approach. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamikaze https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kamikaze
- birdyrooster 6y agoHow is it more dignified to have another human decide to kill you? It seems just as undignified to have a human with agency disregard your well being in a way which is indistinguishable from an automated killing.
- xjabskns 6y agoBecause I can kill you back. It is said that Al Saladin, upon learning that Richard Lionheart’s horse had died in battle had the best horse in his own stalls sent to his opponent as a gift. It would appear that Saladin held King Richard in high esteem (he was brutal to those he did not) Compare that behavior with our drones and F-16 raining death from the safety of miles of distance, and you see how pusillanimous we’ve become. Im sure NPR will wax poetically about drone operator’s PTSD, but it’s not PTSD what they suffer from for there was no trauma. It’s shame, guilt and disgust. In the Christian West we held Saladin in the highest esteem for the way he conducted himself in war. We sought to emulate him, added his behavior to our codes of chivalry. Now, there is no doubt in my mind that future generations will spit on the memory of our generals loosing wars from the safety of telework.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> it’s not PTSD what they suffer from for there was no trauma. It’s shame, guilt and disgust. Given PTSD manifests in people who have never killed and is not restricted to soldiers (e.g. victims of sexual assault and traffic accidents [1]), this claim is unsubstantiated. > we held Saladin in the highest esteem for the way he conducted himself in war You’re transporting values from a zero-growth world, where war was practically the only route to advancement, to a positive-growth one. War was honourable when it was necessary. It is no longer necessary. The era of celebrating our enemies has long passed. (That is why everything is now framed in terms of defense.) [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-traumatic_stress_disorder https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-traumatic_stress_disord...
- xjabskns 6y ago“ Given PTSD manifests in people who have never killed and is not restricted to soldiers” PTSD is the last of a long list of euphemisms used to describe shell shock. To make war more palpable. Eventually the shrinks added all the bad life experiences as causes of PTSD. To dilute the unique horror of war.[1] Therefore, today a guy who sees his best friend blow up next to him from landmine, or a solder who witnesses one of our “friend and ally” rape a boy [2] has the same diagnosis as someone who got into a car accident. Even the fact that PTSD is not a word but an acronym oozes with our degeneracy and America’s military bureaucracy in particular. “You’re transporting values from a zero-growth world, where war was practically the only route to advancement, to a positive-growth one.” Or maybe our forefathers weren’t as obsessed with careerism and advancement as we are today? Never mind that those who waged war were born into the highest class so there was little to advance (King Richard Lionheart was King!) Anyway, we get to pass on higher values because we’re rich? So values are ephemeral not universal? If values are not universal I’ll take the gallantry of the crusaders who mourned their valiant enemies over the moral emptiness of our generals. (And what do these generals have to show for their moral laxity? A long string of defeat. These generals are, as Trump pointed out, losers) Nor does it appear to be true that we became dishonorable when we became a growth society. There are a great many examples of men acting with honor in the world wars, and we certainly were a growth obsessed industrialized society then! [3] And the whole argument that war was necessary then, it isn’t now is just not true. War was as necessary then as it is today. Which is to say not much. Read the old philosophers, Church fathers, the Bhagavad Gita etc, the Chinese sages, and the futility of war is expressed unambiguously. How many ancient texts throughout all Eurasian cultures caution the ruler against war? No, it is us that are dishonorable, not the age we live in. The Persians returned Leonidas’ body for burial [4]. Obama dumped Bin Laden’s body overboard and lied that he gave him a Muslim burial. By not treating our brothers in arms with dignity and honor we have become degenerates. [1] War is uniquely horrible because, when conducted dishonorably it embraces all other horrors. [2] Afghanistan [3] my favorite story is of a German pilot in WW2 who didn’t finish off a plane that he had crippled. Instead he escorted it back to the channel. The two pilots eventually met after the war and the German said that that action had saved his humanity. [4] Xerxes was known for his anger and he uncharacteristically (for the Persians) kept the body to deny it burial. 40 years later, the Persians restored their honor and returned it.
- strulovich 6y ago> The turrets feature heavy duty 7.62 calibre machine guns tied into a network spanning the entire border. If any turret detects human movement, the entire chain of guns can train their sights and concentrate firepower on the interloper. Some turrets are also able to fire explosive rockets. > With such overlapping fields of fire, even heavily armored vehicles would be quickly eliminated. The effect on a human body would be overwhelming, disproportionately violent, and would leave little in the way of human remains. You can tell this is not written by a person with any military knowledge or with an agenda against weapons. Non peaceful borders have been manned with such weapons operated by humans for more than a century (in the case of machine guns). And generally, if you can shoot one bullet and kill someone, you don’t use keep shoot hundreds of bullets, and if you can stop a threat with bullets, you don’t launch a rocket at it. Israel doesn’t launch rockets at people next to the border. And tries to avoid killing unarmed people (for example by aiming for the legs). I assume every sane military does the same. Killing unarmed people, besides obviously being immoral, is bad strategically as well. (This comment deals with a specific paragraph, and not the actual interesting issue raised by this article, which is not unique to Israel I presume, and is practiced by all military industries capable of building such weapons today) EDIT: well, I had it coming. I didn’t mean for it to become the classic Israel vs Palestinians flame war - just wanted to point out the realities of borders, wars and weapons which I suspect most HN readers are not exposed to. But again, I should have seen this coming. :(
- Nullabillity 6y agoOh no, who will be brave enough to take a stand against the all-powerful anti-murder lobby!
- strulovich 6y agoIs your viewpoint that you see any person killed in an armed conflict as a murder?
- Nullabillity 6y agoLet's see.. 1. Did a human die? Yes. 2. Was it caused by another human, directly or indirectly? Yes. 3. Did the perpetrator intend for a human to die? Yes. Yeah, I'd call that murder.
- gizmo 6y agoThere is no ethical dilemma here at all, because these automated killing machines aren't necessary. Borders are defended all over the world by conventional means. Execution by robot is another step towards dystopia, and we should absolutely reject the notion that this is some morally complicated issue.
- flyinglizard 6y agoIsrael has three hostile borders with a close to an active war going on (Lebanon, Syria, Gaza).
- marshmallow_12 6y ago>Borders are defended all over the world by conventional means. I think you are wrong. most countries do a terrible job of efficiently- or even effectively- defending borders. I'm not making a political statement, but just look how many illegal immigrants get into US, EU, etc. Even Israel, which is relatively small, has to invest vast resources into maintaining their fences. Please note, i don't want to be dragged into a political discussion, i'm simply explaining why i think your are wrong.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> I'm not making a political statement, but just look how many illegal immigrants get into US, EU, etc. That's not inefficient/ineffective, the system is just optimized for different things. It ensures a cheap and compliant labor force for things like agriculture.
- maxlybbert 6y agoPlenty of borders around the world are peaceful, and there isn’t much “defending” going on. Those are maintained without much trouble. If we narrow the discussion to borders that aren’t very peaceful, there aren’t many successful solutions. It looks like “nothing gets through” works, but “only approved traffic gets through” doesn’t work.
- marshmallow_12 6y ago
- rossdavidh 6y agoSo, I realize that lots of apocalyptic projections get made about AI that have a habit of not coming true, but this seems like an awful idea. Also, an awfully hard one to resist. If your opponent has fast-as-a-computer-can-pull-the-trigger firepower, it's going to be pretty hard to resist the urge to get your own. Once you have two sides with automated offensive capability, we are one bug away from the kind of mistakes that, during the Cold War, were intercepted by humans in the loop. I'm not sure how this can NOT end badly.
- Waterluvian 6y agoI have a feeling that humans will remain overwhelmingly responsible for most of the wartime mistakes. I think this will further reduce conflict between advanced nations (robots killing robots just becomes a stalemate) and will intensely escalate any asymmetric conflicts where one advanced nation can crush whoever without having to pay the price of deploying humans (think CIA drone strikes).
- gizmo 6y ago"wartime mistakes" is a nice euphemism. And I'm sure that people will continue be held to account. For instance when somebody whoopsies and dronestrikes a wedding party in Jemen.
- wizzwizz4 6y ago> I have a feeling that humans will remain overwhelmingly responsible for most of the wartime mistakes. Of course we will. It's not as though they're programming themselves. Somebody has to tell the computer what to do.
- Waterluvian 6y agoHah. Good point. But I meant like self driving: we suuuuuuuck. Let's not fool ourselves acting like it's critical that there's a human touch to things.
- 6y ago
- ufoolme 6y agoI would have thought that the main reason people ‘shoot to kill’ is in self protection, if more autonomy is introduced then surely lethal force would be required in less situations.
- realistan 6y agoMost of the persons crossing the border between Gaza and Israel do so for nefarious purposes, ie attacking civilians in nearby Israeli villages and cities. So yeah, it's self protection. It wasn't always like this, Gaza had an airport, free travel to Israel and Egypt, etc. But the majority in Gaza has voted for Hamas, an extremist party which calls for the annihilation of Israel, so for now all Israel can do is watch the border closely and thwart attacks.
- skinkestek 6y agoAgree. It is also telling that Egypt allows no traffic over the border while Israel typically allow tens of semi trailers a day of food an humanitarian aid as long as they can ensure weapons aren't smuggled in.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThat's on Israel's insistence, so they can control the flow of goods. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rafah_Border_Crossing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rafah_Border_Crossing > The Palestinians agreed that all imports of goods are diverted to the Kerem Shalom border crossing, because Israel threatened to exclude Gaza from the customs union out of concern about the implementation of the Paris Protocol.
- realistan 6y agoIsrael restricts flow of dual-use goods [1]. There's nothing wrong with that. If you had a bad neighbor, which has intentions to build bombs in his basement, you'd damn sure try to restrict what goes into his basement. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-use_technology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual-use_technology
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Lucasoato 6y agoNext warfares will be much deadlier for civilians... These automated systems can scale in a devastating way, imagine million of people deciding between dying of hunger at home or getting shot automatically in the streets. Imagine if the military forces of Myanmar had this kind of robots and decided to deploy them during civil protests...
- amitport 6y agokilling civilians is easy, it's not something newly enabled by modern "robot" technology... I image they could just as well use bombs and bullets
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> killing civilians is easy, it's not something newly enabled by modern "robot" technology It’s easier to kill civilians and blame it on a bug than to admit that someone ordered the attack.
- ruined 6y agomodern warfare is already extremely deadly to civilians. you don't need a robot to kill innocent people when soldiers of all stripes are apparently perfectly willing.
- imtringued 6y agoThat makes no sense. It's just another nuke at that point.
- Google234 6y agoUn, Myanmar could just deploy soldiers with machine guns or shoot rockets and achieve the same thing? How is that different?
- monkey_monkey 6y agoThe only way drones and other devices like robo-snipers could be thought of ethical is if the conflicts are drone vs drone and robot vs robot. Basically, this seems like a terrible idea, and will enable futher distancing between crime/action and responsibility.
- ta8645 6y agoThat's way too simplistic. If one of these drones could have killed Hitler and saved millions of innocent people, would you still say it's not ethical? The reason to dislike these machines is because of the practical problem of making sure they only target bad-guys. That said... their continued development and deployment is essentially inevitable anyway.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> If one of these drones could have killed Hitler and saved millions of innocent people, would you still say it's not ethical? I don't think a hypothetical requiring time travel to obtain 20/20 hindsight is a very reasonable basis for discussion here.
- ta8645 6y agoCome on, that's not a charitable interpretation of my argument. It's meant to highlight the idea that there are targets _today_ that would make the world a better place if we could kill them. And it doesn't matter what tool we use to do so, it's still an ethical action. I don't like the idea of these devices very much, I see the problem with controlling them. But there's no way to stop them from being created. The required technologies are too pervasive and reproducible.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> It's meant to highlight the idea that there are targets _today_ that would make the world a better place if we could kill them. We think it would. We thought that about knocking off Saddam Hussein, but the resulting power vacuum killed a lot more than he ever did and gave rise to ISIS. It turns out predicting "if we kill this guy, it's good" can be far more difficult than you're making it out to be. Hell, we don't even know if killing Hitler would've been good; it might've given rise to someone far more competent.
- heavyset_go 6y agoIronic how the Gestapo and SS would have salivated over the technology and policy that's applied at the Palestinian border.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- leetcrew 6y agothis is affirming the consequent. "liking bad things -> you are bad" might be true, but it does not imply "bad person liking thing -> thing is bad".
- heavyset_go 6y agoWeird, I didn't make a value judgment, I had only pointed out the biting irony of the situation at hand. Any assumption you've made from my post is just that: an assumption.
- leetcrew 6y agothe irony kinda depends on the value judgment though, at least under my reading. if the israelis invented a delicious new candy, would it be ironic that nazis would have enjoyed it? or slightly less ridiculous: the nazis would certainly have loved to have a rifle like the galil. is that ironic?
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoThe irony is that the Nazis are famous as sadistic torturers and deniers of human liberty and these days it is Israel which is famous in the world as one of these along with some other shameful nations (i.e. North Korea)
- fishmaster 6y ago> but it does not imply "bad person liking thing -> thing is bad". It does imply this if it's in the exact context of the Gestapo and Stasi and surveillance technology.
- somehumanbeing 6y ago“ Take the Israeli Border Control Sentry-Tech turret currently deployed along Gaza’s border. They were designed to prevent Palestinians from leaving the Gaza strip and entering Israeli territory. Automated ‘Robo-Snipers’ set up along the Gaza border, designed to create “automated kill-zones” at least 1.5 km deep. But they aren’t merely robotic guns. The turrets feature heavy duty 7.62 calibre machine guns tied into a network spanning the entire border. If any turret detects human movement, the entire chain of guns can train their sights and concentrate firepower on the interloper. Some turrets are also able to fire explosive rockets.” Literally created to destroy a population they already control at will. If this were China people would be up in arms, but because it’s Israel I have to make a private account to post comfortably.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIt's really important that actual humans are sent to war and die because it's the o ly think that makes us hesitate to go to war. Otherwise your in Ray Bradbury's distopia where wars are just rich countries slaughtering people in poor ones with no sense of hesitation. That's what drones represent: not skynet but man's inhumanity to man. Imagine wars being like action movies, watch the assassination live, tonight at 9!
- Invictus0 6y agoPlaying devils advocate here: arguably our hesitation for war has contributed to horrible atrocities, such as the Rwandan genocide.
- LatteLazy 6y agoYeah, that's fair. I would hope the aim is always reducing bloodshed (by intervention in genocides and not in stable countries). I'm not sure how to actually achieve that...
- vidarh 6y agoThe philosopher Arne Næss once argued that cannibalism practiced by eating the fallen would be a moral good because it would serve as a strong incentive to limit war. The idea is the same - war should not be sanitized, because it removes pressure to constrain them. It's important that the cost of war is visceral to both sides.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSomeone once suggested that the nuclear launch codes should be implanted in a living human volunteer. If the president wanted to launch the missiles, he would have to killed the person in front of him before he could kill millions 10,000km away...
- naringas 6y agoI guess so did machine guns and all ways to kill more people for cheaper and with more effectiveness (rockets, etc..). then again, it doesn't matter; they're here to stay, cat's out of the bag.
- mrtksn 6y agoThere's a brilliant short film on the subject of autonomous weapons, "slautherbots": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fa9lVwHHqg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9fa9lVwHHqg
- matheusmoreira 6y agoScience fiction really does predict reality. Sometimes I feel like I'm living in a video game world.
- andrewflnr 6y ago> More critically, it’s nearly impossible to externally distinguish between a kill made with human oversight or machine autonomy, blurring the lines of accountability on the battlefield. This seems like the real threat to me. The ethics of outright autonomous weapons have a straightforward solution, at least in theory: giving the order to deploy them is precisely morally equivalent to pulling the trigger yourself. A flying bullet is a simpler system than an autonomous network of machine guns, but you still set it in motion and are responsible for its path. No, the tricky part is when you can't tell who set it in motion.
- tomc1985 6y agoKind of amazed at all the suprised pikachu faces here when videogames have been giving us experience dealing with autonomously-operated turrets for decades Also the joystick control is kind of LOL. Give her a mouse and keyboard!
- Apocryphon 6y agoNot to mention the sentry gun from Aliens. https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/UA_571-C_Automated_Sentry_Gun https://avp.fandom.com/wiki/UA_571-C_Automated_Sentry_Gun
- oyebenny 6y agoIt's really only a matter of time where we will see the mods that we put into War Zone controllers actually exist in real life.
- amitport 6y agoa) Those weapons are not autonomous, they are remote controlled. Just fancy more accurate guided missiles. They are alternative for blind bombing. Like any weapon, it depends what you do with them and what your enemy is doing. b) This type of weapons exists in many military industries and is bought by many countries (any country that can afford them). Making this specifically "ethical" in connection to Israel is appallingly biased.
- cochne 6y ago“Euphemistically described as a ‘fire-and-forget’ weapon, the Israeli Aerospace Industries’ Harop autonomously attacks any target meeting previously identified criteria, but includes a ‘man-in-the-loop’ feature that allows a human to technically prevent an attack from taking place.” Are you saying it is not autonomous just because there is a person in loop? Seems pretty clear that it would be easy to remove that person, making it fully autonomous, unlike a remote controlled device.
- amitport 6y agoIt's less autonomous than anti-radar missiles, heat-seeking missiles, etc., ... Not to mention "dumb" munition like mortar shells. I any case, even if there was some 'autonomous' weapon (which is not the case here), what is the point of talking about autonomicity of weapons as though they are not being deployed and launched by humans.
- throwitaway12 6y agoThey are always using weapons for offense, never defense. Just give back the land already.
- germinalphrase 6y ago“ Demand for autonomous ‘suicide drones’ is at an all-time high after the Azerbaijan-Armenia conflict of 2020, which established a benchmark for the effective use of kamikaze drones against conventional military forces.” I have read many statements similar to this in recent months, but I haven’t come across a good analysis of how offensive drones were used/defended against (if they were) in that conflict. Anyone have a good resource?
- sn_master 6y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/nagorno-karabkah-drones-azerbaijan-aremenia/2020/11/11/441bcbd2-193d-11eb-8bda-814ca56e138b_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/nagorno-karabkah... You'll also find countless combat footage from the azeri drones destroying Armenian positions. Some are even on YouTube, most on the azeri defense ministry. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xme_NTpVauU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xme_NTpVauU Israel been supplying the azeris with drones for a while, and were even accused of "test firing" it on real Armenian troops themselves to impress the azeris into buying them. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israeli-company-charged-live-testing-drone-armenian-soldiers https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/israeli-company-charged-l...
- Justsignedup 6y agoJust curious... Suicide drones... how is that different from missiles?
- jxcole 6y agoI think it's mostly psychological...since missiles move so quickly you might not be able to see them people think of them as more like bullets, regardless of the complex technology involved. People see these slow moving AI powered drones and they think it's a suicidal robot.
- amitport 6y agoThey have bigger wings... This article is just anti-Israeli propaganda I find it disappointing to read how it's being received on HN --- EDIT: Why is this being down-voted? Are those drones different from missiles in a meaningful way? No, certainly not in any "ethical" way Is there a reason to single-out Israel here? No Explain if you disagree and actually have some knowledge and experience with this international industry.
- skinkestek 6y agoHN is slightly anti-jewish. It is just a matter of fact. A good thing however is it seems to changing slowly towards a more nuanced perspective. Here's a true story which kind of describes a very similar situation but with a different outcome than what we've seen (yet). For years I was bullied at school, and anytime I took revenge teachers arrived swiftly, telling me that even if the others started I wasn't allowed to respond. I still did though but it was obvious that I got more trouble for it than them. Then I came to a new school. Pattern continues. I complained, nobody did anything. Then one day I gave another bloke a real beating, and for a change my teacher stepped up and told the other teachers that if they couldn't ensure skinkestek was left alone they better not interfere when I gave the bullies a beating. That was the last fight. Once they realized they wouldn't get any sympathy anymore it stopped. My siblings also stopped being harassed. Generally everything got quieter because I was top dog now - and I didn't want to fight. I feel this is the same in middle east. Israel is strongest but want peace. The international community keeps this conflict going like my teachers used to do by verbally abusing the strong but peaceful one. My guess is the moment Hamas realizes there is no more sympathy to be gained by doing insane attacks that only serve to anger the neighbor then we'll get peace.
- Animats 6y ago"Automated ‘Robo-Snipers’ set up along the Gaza border, designed to create “automated kill-zones” at least 1.5 km deep. But they aren’t merely robotic guns. The turrets feature heavy duty 7.62 calibre machine guns tied into a network spanning the entire border. If any turret detects human movement, the entire chain of guns can train their sights and concentrate firepower on the interloper. Some turrets are also able to fire explosive rockets." It's surprising that wasn't proposed for the US-Mexico border wall.
- mrtesthah 6y ago>It's surprising that wasn't proposed for the US-Mexico border wall. With enough scapegoating and propaganda, anything is possible.
- Rule35 6y agoDo you use that to adjust your opinion of Trump and of what you're told he said, or do you just assume that he wanted auto-cannons but couldn't ask for them? Lol, I'll take that as a strong 'No'.
- itstruetho 6y agoThe people funding Israel to the tune of billions would have been outraged at this white supremacist proposal.
- christkv 6y agoReally feels like we are moving quickly towards ghost in the shell as a future. I guess cyberpunk was much more of future vision than anyone ever would have imagined.
- cwkoss 6y agoI'd really love if the US stopped sending foreign aid to apartheid states
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- skinkestek 6y agoThen they should start with Israels neighbors. Arabs in Israel have good lives and prefer living in Israel strongly to living in neighboring countries. Contrast that to trying to live as a jew in a neighboring country.
- cwkoss 6y agoTwo opposing groups can both commit atrocities: the world is not black and white
- imtringued 6y agoForeign aid is just an indirect military subsidy in most cases. Give someone money so they can buy your guns. It would be more effective to just build schools, roads and invest into agriculture.
- Rule35 6y agoDon't the people of those countries deserve a way to defend the infrastructure they build? And no, investing in things like that for a country rarely helps. Instead either buy or sell products to them, that necessitates a road but now market forces determine where it should go. Pay your employees enough and let them build a school that teaches what they want.
- TruthWillHurt 6y agoThese are not autonomous weapons. They are all remote controlled by a human operator.
- throwaway31338 6y agoIt doesn't feel like it will be long until we're getting CAPTCHAs like: "Click the pictures of humans brandishing firearms."
- fishmaster 6y ago"Tag the insurgents"
- vmception 6y agoAs long as I get to look at cat photos afterwards I'm good
- vijayr02 6y agoI highly recommend Ronen Bergman's account of the Israeli covert assasination programme: Rise and Kill First [0]. It's a very nuanced book, grappling with the moral issues of a single death now to avoid multiple deaths later, and the unintended consequences of these decisions. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rise_and_Kill_First https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rise_and_Kill_First
- kjrose 6y agoI don't make the apocalyptic predictions about AI that everyone else seems to. But there is a simple fact that anyone in IT has run into. Google (as an example) has a massive amount of money and spends it extensively to try and prevent fraud and issues with their various services. In the process, there is story after story of someone losing their entire Google history, being blocked from Google Ads, Mail, etc. all because some automated system kicked in and decided they were a problem. Since Google doesn't have any reasonable appeals process this usually turns into a kafkaesque hell for people who experience it. Now imagine you put that exact same computer system in control of sniper rifles and drones that can kill someone. Yeah. It's not an ethical dilemma, it's a hellish reality. Let's wait until Google (or someone with essentially an unlimited supply of money) can figure out how to make it so that they can run their own services without randomly killing people digitally before we start to kill people in real life with those same tools.
- onion2k 6y agoAutonomous weapons don't decide whether or not to kill someone based on subjective moral criteria. They're dumb. They don't discriminate. They're essentially just working on a model that looks like "kill any human within this virtual fence". Building in features that try to be clever is unnecessary and complicated. You just need a sign that says "Don't go in here."
- kjrose 6y agoUntil the day that it messes up and thinks that a certain area outside the fence is within the fence.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe warnings/fences should be placed past its range limits anyway if done properly given overpenetration and missed shots. Of course friendly fire also should not happen.
- oconnore 6y agoThis feature is ready to ship, our data shows that over 99.2% of hikers correctly interpret our fence boundaries!
- aaron695 6y agoIt's good to see the comments bike-shedding on the ethics don't even understand the technology. I think that sums up ethics well, 'Those who can, do; those who can't, ethic.' Although Google has shown people employed in the field are also genuinely awful people. How have we got to a stage where the worst humans of society are employed doing ethics? Here's a loitering munitions meme if you don't know why the Harop is different to missiles - https://twitter.com/MENA_Conflict/status/1371106931109167105/photo/1 https://twitter.com/MENA_Conflict/status/1371106931109167105... At least one of the 'autonomous'robo-snipers photos linked is photo-shopped, but here's a very dystopian real photo that at first I thought was a Bansky https://akhbaar24.argaam.com/article/detail/171579 https://akhbaar24.argaam.com/article/detail/171579 (last photo)
- einpoklum 6y agoThey raise the dilemma of how to topple the oppressive Israeli regime. I live there (well, "here" for me), and it's already intolerable if you're a Palestinian; for Hebrews/Jews there's a process of gradual decline in democratic freedoms and a slide into religious obscurantism couple with jingoism. Not that this didn't exist before, or that the government had not fostered that before, but it looks like it's gradually "letting loose". (This is mostly, but not entirely, independent of the governing PM, Netanyahu.)
- Huwyt_Nashi031 6y agoOpen borders for thee, robo-snipers defending the border for me. If Southern European countries set these up on the shores to defend against vessels arriving from North Africa, the Jewish media in the West would go mental. The only consolation here is that, from the videos I've seen, an automated gun that indiscriminately kills Palestinian children anywhere near the border is only different from Israeli snipers in that it won't laugh and upload the footage afterwards.
- kumarvvr 6y agoAs inevitable as these things are going to become, a good strategy would be to develop systems and technology to build these robots with as minimal inputs of skills and material in a completely de-centralized manner. Can anyone win a war with a country that has these factories spread out throughout its land. It will be incredibly difficult to win against it. If these things can be made modular, with AI and control tech being firmware that can be downloaded over the air, and the hardware being manufactured anywhere, it could lead to end of all wars. Why would you want to fight a war with a country when you know you will never win it.
- wilsonfiifi 6y agoIf anyone is wondering what the Israeli-Palestinian situation would have been like today had prime minister Rabin not been assassinated, here's an article that touches on that point. [0] [0] https://foreignpolicy.com/2015/11/03/what-would-have-happened-if-yitzhak-rabin-had-lived-israel-palestine-peace/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2015/11/03/what-would-have-happene...
- betwixthewires 6y agoI'm not sure what the common sentiment on this sort of technology is on this site, but I for one view autonomous military technology as a positive development. Warfare is the failure of all other conflict resolution mechanisms. The goal of warfare is to end the capability of an enemy to continue to wage that war, so as to put them in a position where they have to acquiesce in the disagreement that could not otherwise be resolved. This means targeting strategic military and economic assets of an enemy. Historically these assets have been human beings. Until very recently, even after the industrial revolution, manpower was the prime driver of an economy. It still is in most places in the world. As production becomes increasingly automated, the targets that will involve more loss of life will be military targets, unless military operations are automated as well. Automating military operations ensures less loss of life. Automated weapons designed for defense, such as defense of a border or perimeter, are equally as morally defensible as manual defense using lethal force. The morality of the action in both circumstances is predicated on the right of the defender to occupy that territory. If a transgressor is warned that passing a point may end in loss of life and they choose to take the risk anyway, neither scenario is more or less morally defensible. Where do we get this idea that it is morally superior to have a guy do the killing?
- cdmckay 6y agoPeople don’t like to kill, and if they do, there’s a cost. The person doing the killing has to decide to kill someone and live with that. If a robot does the killing, it just becomes a figure, and human life is cheapened further. These kill walls will be deployed more and more and I can guarantee the people being shredded by them won’t be people from Western countries.
- betwixthewires 6y agoSome people do like to kill. I think taking this absolutist assertion that having humans involved in the killing will mean less killing is incorrect. Some people like to and some don't. Every person that has died in every war ever was killed by someone else. There are and were entire cultures dedicated to waging warfare. Lots of killers sleep better at night for having done it, some might not even be bad people.