7 ms·
France grossly underestimated radioactive fallout from atom bomb tests, study
- youeseh 6y agoWhat was the incentive to adequately estimate the fallout vs. underestimate it?
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere's no real incentive to estimate accurately because it's in Algeria, which the French did not care much for.
- lostlogin 6y ago> because it's in Algeria Wasn’t it more in the south pacific? There was a need to underestimate radiation doses so as to undercut our opposition. When we made the fuss those in power in France took the time to send a military team to bomb a Greenpeace ship in Auckland, killing someone. They followed up with economic sanctions when we caught their amateur operatives, and later gave the soldiers medals for the murder they committed. Who needs enemies with friends like these?
- jshmrsn 6y agoI had not heard of this before, thanks for bringing it to my attention. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warrior https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warri...
- boudin 6y agoFrance did the first tests in Algeria but this is about the ones done at Mururoa, in the pacific indeed.
- Bayart 6y agoWhen were we ever « friends » with New-Zealand ? It's not even in NATO. The only relationship we ever had was being part of the so-called West I suppose, although that never prevented us from going to war with our neighbours.
- lostlogin 6y agoI do think you could call the countries friendly toward each other. Plenty of New Zealanders have died fighting in France (though at the bidding of our colonial overlords) and the countries have largely got on outside of this dark period.
- EdwardDiego 6y ago> When were we ever « friends » with New-Zealand Usually when the Germans invaded. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Rue+de+la+Nouvelle+Z%C3%A9lande,+59530+Le+Quesnoy,+France/@50.2476498,3.6341267,17z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x47c28b807dbc75a9:0xa65e8c7962f38ccd https://www.google.com/maps/place/Rue+de+la+Nouvelle+Z%C3%A9... > It's not even in NATO Article 6 of the North Atlantic treaty kinda prevents Southern Hemisphere countries in the Pacific from joining. No doubt NZ would have joined in the 60s, 70s, around the same time we had a penchant for getting involved in other people's post colonial wars.
- a0-prw 6y agoNato is a tool of the five eyes and the five eyes are a tool of a program of permanent domination and exploitation of the world by Anglo-American "capitalists".
- mytailorisrich 6y agoWhen Algeria was French performing nuclear tests there in the Sahara was not much different from the US performing nuclear tests in Nevada/New Mexico. The British performed tests in Australia for the same reason. It was not a question of 'caring' but simply that it was sufficiently big and empty while still being accessible to be deemed an acceptable option taking into account that having nukes was a top strategic priority for national security. As it happens nuclear tests continued in the Sahara even after Algerian independence under an agreement with the new independent Algerian government (so clearly they did not not 'care much' either) before they were transferred to the next possible location... French Polynesia. It should also be noted that the British and the Americans had already carried out nuclear tests in the Pacific when the French moved theirs there as well.
- sudosysgen 6y agoUnlike Nevada and New Mexico, there were actually people living in those deserts. Surprising, I know, and yes there aren't that many. The biggest issue is that the Algerian people did not support the tests. As for the agreement with the Algerian government, it was signed during wartime. Allowing the tests was a condition without which France would have killed more people.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThere are people living in Nevada and New Mexico, even within range of the test facilities: tests were carried out 65 miles from Las Vegas. Arguably the Sahara is better suited. It's fair to criticise the way nuclear tests were carried out and perhaps whether they were needed at all, but this is a general criticism: My comparison with the US and the UK is to illustrate that the French did not do anything different or worse.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere were people living literally there, living exactly where the tests took place. And no, it's not normal to do nuclear tests in a territory which is currently fighting for independence.
- onion2k 6y agoIf you need to use your bombs on a country that invaded you a few decades ago you want to make sure you don't accidently irradiate your own country.
- mhh__ 6y agoBack in those days whatever the answer was the decision would he the same e.g. the people in charge of windscale probably knew it wasn't safe but if you don't have a bomb you are a complete nobody.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAll countries underestimate the health and environmental impacts of their military actions and experiments. There is a part of secret because they are military operations and they are not keen on realising information (that's very true in France). Another aspect is to avoid political and public backlash against military actions and experiments. And, of course, the last aspect is financial because acknowledging the impact and its scale might be very costly in compensation. Apart from underestimating another tactic is not to look into alleged issues at all. If there are no data there is no need to underestimate anything! A good example of that is the so-called 'Gulf War Syndrome'.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 1cvmask 6y agoThe fallout of the French bombs was on non-whites. This would have been a huge story in Western media of genocide if it was done by say the Chinese (or insert any other non-white nation).
- markdown 6y agoDo you know what makes the ocean glow Do you know what makes the ocean glow When unwelcome guests, are making nuclear tests Are making nuclear tests, are making nuclear tests Are making nuclear tests ... Let me be more specific, get out of the pacific Ki te la pacific, get out of the pacific Ki te la pacific https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZD8dA678ss https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hZD8dA678ss It's long past the time for the French to GTFO out of the Pacific. Decolonise and free the Tahitians and Kanaks.
- bpodgursky 6y agoYou know these territories regularly vote on independence, right? https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/375335/tahiti-calls-for-independence-vote https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/375335/tahi... And the answer is usually "no", because most of these islands are poor and get net funding and support from France (or whatever other country holds sovereignty).
- boudin 6y agoIf you're talking about New Caledonia it's as really biased view. It was a special agreement following a stron crisis with the Kanak independance mouvement that allowed to agree on 3 independance votes. There's a big difference in votes between the people from metropolitan France and a much stronger support for independance in the Kanak population. We'll see next year what's the result is going to be, but the last one was quite close. Other territories do not have the opportunity to vote on their independance.
- orwin 6y agoKanak and new Caledonia is a very hard problem to solve, for France but especially for residents. The issue is more about identity and origin than independance at that point (but freedom is nice to have in any case). The past referendum results mean nothing, they were not rejected because people did not want to be free, but because they don't know who they are. And an independence vote won't be like Brexit, France actually agreed to let new Caledonia resident keep their french passport and rights if they chose to go independent, the effective change will by that social services, police, healthcare will be run by New Caledonia people, but it won't change private rights until next generation. Its a hard question anyway. I've stayed a year in French polynesia small islands (and ocean, mostly ocean...), i'm pretty sure the only islands that want to leave are the ones with the international airports (and i'm not sure about Bora Bora, never went there). Those with offshore ressources especially don't seem to trust the independence party for whatever reason (it might have changed since then).
- dr_faustus 6y ago1 mSv is a pretty low threshold. It's actually a bit more than 10x the radiation of a thorax x-ray done with modern equipment. But its 1/10 of a thorax ct. It's also less than the yearly difference between the exposure of people living in regions with low and high natural radiation here in Germany (which, as has far as could be determined, has no impact on the cancer rate).
- lostlogin 6y agoCould you expand on this? I didn’t understand the problem to be the threshold, but the convenient underestimation of dose by a factor of 2-20x.
- dr_faustus 6y agoIt's not my place to evaluate which method of calculating the exposure was correct. Just pointing out, that 1 mSv is a rather small amount of radiation. The smallest amount of radiation where one sees some indications of an increase in cancer risk is at 50-100 mSv [1]. I'm not arguing either way whether this should have an impact on any payments. Putting the threshold for compensation at 1 mSv is very conservative and will lead to the payment of compensation for many cancers that weren't caused by radiation. Which, again, is fine by me because I do believe that very little interest was paid to the protection of the neighboring populations. [1] Pretty good summary: https://www.pnas.org/content/100/24/13761 https://www.pnas.org/content/100/24/13761
- Retric 6y agoThe issue here is both the linear no threshold and threshold model are indistinguishable with our current data. The problem is cancer is really quite common and has many sources so it’s hard to say what if any level is actually safe to expose X million people to. At least with medical X rays there is some benefit to offset risk, but without that it’s much harder to justify.
- sjg007 6y agoMost people don't get 10x thorax xrays done in their life. If you have a reason to get those xrays fine... But in general there's a cancer risk so just multiply it out. I don't get dental xrays every year and I wait 3-5 years to actually have one. And I never have had a problem. You should only get an xray after the dental exam indicates a problem and you trust your dentist. I learnt this the hard way after seeing several pushy dentists over the course of a few years who in retrospect focused on the money. One of the dentists I saw was busted by the FBI for insurance fraud.
- Mkm1800 6y ago87
- marcelpro 6y agoFrance is unique in the West as one of the few countries that unapologetically holds on to its colonies which it still regards as French territory. It continues to actively permit white settlers to migrate to New Caledonia and French Guiana, subtly ensuring the autonomy referendums are defeated and indigenous populations continue to be suppressed. It will come as no surprise that the French military are also actively involved in these overseas 'training' bases. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_France , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_military_bases_of_France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Overseas_military_bases_of_Fra...
- omginternets 6y agoYou should at least make the effort of detailing the enormous educational, medical, infrastructural resources (not to mention subsidies) that mainland France directs to these places. You’re not telling the whole truth, here.
- FuckButtons 6y agoNo one ever said that colonial empires didn’t invest in their colonies. But the real question is how do the people who live their feel about the way their country is governed.
- omginternets 6y agoAgreed. The opinion among these populations tends to be quite split, believe it or not. It’s a complicated question, contrary to what the top-level comment would have us believe.
- ralusek 6y agoWhich is obviously pretty complicated. Take Hong Kong, for example. They much preferred the colony of the British to the Chinese.
- FooBarWidget 6y ago
- Lichtverschwend 6y agoSaw an interview a couple of days ago here on French television with the journalist who published a book about it recently. Lying to the public was baked into the test explosion right from the beginning. That is as much part of the trade as firing guns.
- lm28469 6y agoFrance also did a lot of tests in Algeria, French docu: https://youtu.be/s0SUtQPgi9U https://youtu.be/s0SUtQPgi9U The US pioneered this in the marshal Islands, from 8 to 40 minutes here: https://youtu.be/vAfeYMONj9E https://youtu.be/vAfeYMONj9E Not the brightest moments of human history...