17 ms·
Myanmar's satellite held by Japan on space station due to spying concern
- codezero 6y agoThe politics around a decision like this are fascinating. I assume they've already paid in part or in full for the launch, and regardless, they did R&D on a satellite which is itself an asset that is now difficult to return to the owner!
- jaywalk 6y agoAlso, "the contract with MAEU did not specify that the satellite cannot be used for military purposes." I completely understand why they're doing this, but it's tough to see how it's legal.
- WJW 6y agoConcepts like legality have much less meaning between countries. It's not like there is a court where Myanmar can sue if it wants their satellite back. At this level, the ultimate recourse is declaring war and reclaiming it by force but we all know how that would turn out.
- TameAntelope 6y agoDiplomacy is a critical function of any government due to what you're saying, and IMO this could be a consequence of Myanmar neglecting that reality (for a myriad of valid and invalid reasons, I don't know enough about the current situation to speak with any intelligence about it).
- celtain 6y agoNot all international disagreements are disagreements between sovereign nations themselves. It's possible that MAEU could sue JAXA or Hokkaido University in a Japanese court if they think they're violating Japanese law. If that's not the case, or if the Diet passes a new law that protects their countrymen in this dispute, then yeah it becomes the type of conflict you describe.
- adinb 6y agoIsn’t that what the World Trade Organization (WTO) is for?
- freeflight 6y agoThe WTO has been effectively out of order these past years as the US has blocked the appointment of new judges to the appeals court. It's supposed to have seven judges, a minimum of three judges are required to issue rulings, but since 2019 there are only two judges left [0] So any ruling the WTO main body makes, like for example declaring US tariffs on China illegal [1], only needs to be appealed to be stuck in procedural limbo, which is exactly what ended up happening with the WTO ruling on US tariffs [2] [0] https://www.dw.com/en/wto-judge-blockage-could-prove-the-beginning-of-the-end/a-51613082# https://www.dw.com/en/wto-judge-blockage-could-prove-the-beg... [1] https://apnews.com/article/global-trade-china-archive-donald-trump-58a89252300408e255ed3a9a26004091 https://apnews.com/article/global-trade-china-archive-donald... [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-26/u-s-appeals-wto-ruling-that-trump-s-china-tariffs-were-illegal https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-10-26/u-s-appea...
- adinb 6y agoThanks!
- bilbo0s 6y agoDon't they say that the great secret of international law, is that there is no international law? This situation is an example of what they mean by that.
- ramphastidae 6y agoAccording to what law? Tried in which court? And enforced by who? International law is basically: “Don’t like it? Well what ya gonna do about it?”
- DigiDigiorno 6y agoImagine you were contracted to release a satellite and then you realize you might be providing military equipment to a hostile nation. Would you really think to yourself "Well the contract doesn't say I can't do this"?...
- tkgally 6y agoAlso, the Japanese government and individual national universities, including Hokkaido University [1, in Japanese], have regulations on the export of technology that can be used for military purposes. I work at another national university in Japan, and there has been a lot of internal debate, with political overtones, about how strictly those regulations should be enforced and how to deal with technology that has both military and civilian applications. I can easily imagine the researchers at Hokkaido University deciding that the military coup in Myanmar meant that deploying the satellite would run the risk of violating the rules of either their own university or the Japanese government. [1] https://www.hokudai.ac.jp/research/export-control/ https://www.hokudai.ac.jp/research/export-control/
- slg 6y agoYou used "they" a couple times in that comment and it is important to question who "they" is given the political environment in Myanmar. Is the "they" that paid for the satellite and did the R&D the same "they" that who would be controlling the satellite? If not, would the new "they" use the capabilities of this satellite in a nefarious way?
- seniorgarcia 6y agoIn context of this satellite, they is the MAEU (Myanmar Aerospace Engineering University) and the reason the satellite is being held is because apparently JAXA (Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency) can't reach the rector of the MAEU to make sure what the satellite would be used for. The reason why they can't reach the rector of the MAEU is because he might have been arrested or is in hiding (https://www.myanmar-now.org/en/news/soldiers-raid-aerospace-university-in-meiktila https://www.myanmar-now.org/en/news/soldiers-raid-aerospace-...). So, all in all, Japan is being careful and the situation in Myanmar is "undetermined". I think it is questionable where the "spying concern" is coming from, aside from being clickbait. >Officials at JAXA could not be reached for comment. MAEU did not respond to calls seeking comment, nor did a spokesman for Myanmar’s junta. It could be used for spying, because it's a satellite with cameras. If it has the capabilities to be used for spying is unclear, all the data would go through Japan anyway. Japan does not want to comment on it, persons responsible at MAEU are in prison or in hiding and the junta would probably lie anyway.
- rantwasp 6y agokeep the satellite. shipping back is gonna be more than what we payed for it
- drak0n1c 6y agoSomething similar happened with the US and Iran. The Shah paid for military fighter jets, but then the Islamist theocracy took over. So the US froze the money and obviously wasn't going to deliver the jets to a USSR supported regime. The question of property legitimacy after a revolution is a recurring one throughout history. https://time.com/4441046/400-million-iran-hostage-history/ https://time.com/4441046/400-million-iran-hostage-history/
- selimthegrim 6y agoSince when was Khomeini USSR supported? Tudeh and MeK got their butts handed to them pretty early on.
- drak0n1c 6y agoIn the beginnings and first few years the revolution was supported, but relations cooled by 1984. https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/the-soviet-union-and-the-iranian-revolution/ https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/the-soviet-union-and-t...
- downrightmike 6y agoOppsie! We dropped it and it burned up. Sorry lol
- rusanu 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENS_Gamal_Abdel_Nasser https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ENS_Gamal_Abdel_Nasser Mistral class helicopter carrier, payed by Russia, built in France, delivered to Egypt instead due to the War in Donbass. France had to compensate Russia.
- liquidify 6y agoI'm curious about laws in this case. Is there 'jurisdiction' in space? Or is it just whoever is there can decide what they want to do.
- mjevans 6y agoI am not a lawyer; but the saying is something like... "possession is nine tenths of the law". This is much easier right now since currently JAXA possesses the un-deployed satellite.
- jandrese 6y agoIt's a diplomatic situation. The countries will have to negotiate the use of the equipment. I can completely understand the Japanese University not wanting the equipment to be used to further a genocide.
- filereaper 6y agoI don't want to minimize the geopolitical issue here but wanted to ask about microsatellites and the ISS. How do you put the satellite onto its intended orbit, like are only satellites intended with a polar orbit capable of this approach? Do you need booster rockets to get in the right orbit? Can we go the other way and use the ISS as like an orbital garage to capture and fix satellites? This is the first I've heard if the ISS holding onto satellites, I thought satellites are deployed by the launch rocket and just put into orbit.
- mcountryman 6y agoI had to picture someone opening a window and throwing it into orbit haha
- genera1 6y agoIt's not that far off from the truth
- Steltek 6y agoIt's actually pretty cool. They have a space torpedo launcher: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanoracks_CubeSat_Deployer#/media/File:NanoRacksCubeSatLaunch_ISS038-E-056389.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanoracks_CubeSat_Deployer#/me... What I haven't figured out is how they get the sats far enough away from the ISS orbit with only one push.
- genera1 6y agoThere are even manual deployments https://youtu.be/-hutA7In7GA https://youtu.be/-hutA7In7GA
- bagels 6y agoIf you give it a few cm/s velocity, the separation distance grows over time.
- dylan604 6y agoRelativity. At the moments before launch, the ISS and satellite are moving at the same speed. The launch gives extra velocity (positive delta-v??) which ever so slightly due to mass differences gives a tiny push against the ISS. So the satellite continues to pull away with its increase in velocity. See Newton's first law of motion. However, after launch, the small satellite usually has no ability to course correct, and its orbit slowly decays to friction with the thin atmosphere. Meanwhile, ISS continues to course correct.
- 99_00 6y agoWhich is the government that committed the genocide? The one that sized power or the one that was thrown out, or some other one?
- gostsamo 6y agoIt is complicated. Long decades Myanmar was a military dictatorship. A few years back the dictatorship allowed democratic elections under the condition that it will conserve key positions in the government and there was this brief period when the country was semi-democratic. The military part of the government initiated the genocide, but the democratic part was accused for not opposing in any visible way. After the last elections, the military were supposed to loose some more of their positions and hence the coup.
- vmception 6y agoand from my understanding, the military's unilateral action is also in line with their constitution, at least according to the military. so where does that leave us to form an opinion and activism about it? just because we have a democracy-boner doesn't mean we can ignore a country's constitution, even if it is flawed, does it? and if our democracy fervor is really so strong for us to actually do something about it, then its hypocritical because we don't do anything meaningful about it in country's that are more relevant, and it makes us picking on the little country.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoI think there could at least be some geopolitical reprecussions. The US is so willing to proscribe various Iranian government officials as terrorists and to sanction Iran so far as to deny them medicine and food from other countries, and they have not done anything close to resembling what Myanmar has done (genocide). Democracy doesn't have to be the answer but there should be pressure on the state of Myanmar to change in case of genocide. We don't have to go forcing other countries to accept our values (democracy, socially liberal policies / conservatively fiscal policies, etc.) But we should at least draw the line at genocide.
- 99_00 6y agoWhich is the government that committed genocide? The one that lost power, the one that sized power, or some other one?
- elmomle 6y agoIt would seem from the language of Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rohingya_genocide, pp2) that the military (current group in power) bears chief responsibility--one thing I do know is that the military long existed as an independent power structure in the country. So it seems like they would only have driven the genocide its leaders had wanted to (given that this has been a deliberate, years-long operation). Perhaps someone with deeper knowledge could say more.
- flavius29663 6y agoon the first page of your link: The Burmese government dismissed these as "exaggerations" It doesn't look like the government cared too much about the well-being of the genocided population. This is a hallmark in most genocides in history. The government doesn't have to order a massacre, most of the times it's just doing nothing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SirSavary 6y agoSomeone once described Myanmar to me as a "military with a country" instead of a "country guarded by a military".
- naringas 6y ago"we can spy, but you can't" --"1st world" western powers There must be a more modern term than "1st world", I just don't know it.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoFVEY. The Five Eyes. Five English-speaking countries that share military strength and intelligence. Somehow the world simply tolerates all the blatant espionage they perpetrate with zero diplomatic repercussions. The USA alone probably has more espionage satellites in space than every other nation combined.
- jsty 6y ago> Somehow the world simply tolerates all the blatant espionage they perpetrate with zero diplomatic repercussions Because pretty much every other country with a security service is either pursuing similar operations or wants to be. Sure when something becomes public a fuss gets made, but oddly enough no concrete repercussions ever follow.
- xxpor 6y agoBecause other European countries know they're screwed without the US's backing. In return, those countries don't have to spend nearly as much on defense as they would otherwise. You can see why this would be politically advantageous for the Europeans. Outside of that, who could do anything diplomatically to the US that wouldn't just be laughed off?
- modo_mario 6y agoYou do realize the EU has a mutual protection clause similar to Nato. Russia can't exactly invade. It's economy is smaller than Italy's. I don't think the EU depends as much on US defence as some Americans would have one believe.
- colinmhayes 6y agoRussia already invaded Ukraine.
- T3RMINATED 6y agoI dare Japan to hold USAs satellite. They spy on them DAILY.
- st3ve445678 6y agoBegun, the space wars have.
- jtdev 6y agoMaybe a "Spaceforce" is actually a good idea?
- __john 6y agoI think it will be the thing he is most remembered for.
- yabones 6y agoNope, still not a good idea. The name alone suggests militarization of space which is a horrible idea. The only thing that kept us alive through the 20th century was mutually assured destruction, and more importantly, the capability to detect ICBM launches and retaliate within the 30 minutes before your continent is glassed. Space launched nukes don't give you any warning, you get at most 30 seconds to detect the shock heating in the high atmosphere before it's game over. It's an actual slippery slope, the very first payload containing weapons in orbit is a direct path towards space launched nuclear weapons.
- thevardanian 6y agoThe militarization of space is unfortunately inevitable.
- drusepth 6y ago>Space launched nukes don't give you any warning Unless you have your own space-launched nukes and satellites?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoWhile dangerous, it's not necessarily MAD-breaking. MAD stands on nuclear-armed submarines these days. Now, if someone figured out how to reliably detect submerged submarines from orbit, that would be truly MAD-breaking.
- 627467 6y agoAs interesting as this situation is it also looks inconsequential. No one from burmese side has voiced anything (yet). Considering the political situation on the ground and how japan can't contact the burmese liaison it seems like this is just an (expensive) limbo situation.
- aritmo 6y agoIt looks like it is more about causing pain to Myanmar than actual spying concerns. Xiaomi, the Chinese consumer electronics company, which definitely does only consumer products, is restricted from buying microchips. The excuse was an award that was granted by the CCP to the chairman of Xiaomi, a type of award that is given away to 100 people EVERY year.
- lmilcin 6y agoThere is, almost by definition, no way to have business in China without cooperating with government. The award is inconsequential.
- jessaustin 6y agoEvery American consumer buys multiple products manufactured in China every week of her life. If this is the standard, we'll all be suspect. Perhaps that's the point...
- patagurbon 6y agoThat seems... High? Does every, or even most people in the US buy non-grocery items every week? AFAIK most food is domestic, and I imagine most if not all the packaging for that is domestic as well. Sure if you buy semi-durable items: clothes, shoes, electronics, etc.
- dnautics 6y agoClothes and shoes don't even really come from china, either.
- shostack 6y agoThere is a substantial difference between buying a product from a company and running one in terms of the relationships the individuals have with government involvement and the impact on directing the company to support said governments agenda.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- optimalsolver 6y agoNot your satellite platform, not your satellite.
- eunos 6y agoShould have just went with Russia and Chinese then.
- aaron695 6y ago> monitor agriculture and fisheries. Lol, are we going to bomb their corn fields next. Exactly how could it be used by the military? I don't know, but I feel like a satellite worth only $15 million and released from the space station wouldn't do much, but I might be pleasantly surprised tech has advanced enough. I don't get how on such a low orbit if would be useful to one country? I think it's called the MMSATS-1 (Lawkanat-1) https://www.global.hokudai.ac.jp/blog/collaborative-development-of-micro-satellite-by-myanmar-and-japan-started/ https://www.global.hokudai.ac.jp/blog/collaborative-developm...
- simonh 6y agoCubes at imaging is really decent nowadays, this article shows images of a refugee camp. https://www.ft.com/content/c7e00344-111a-11e8-940e-08320fc2a277 https://www.ft.com/content/c7e00344-111a-11e8-940e-08320fc2a... The concern is probably that satellite images could be used to identify and keep track of Rohingya and other ethnic minority settlements in jungle areas, and target them for attacks like the ones the military have been carrying out since 2017.
- aaron695 6y agoI think it's a stretch the possible cameras are good enough to use by the military. Here's photo's from Diwata-1 and Diwata-2 which is the same Japanese team and the Philippians. Similar costs, same project. https://www.goodnewspilipinas.com/diwata-1-2-view-from-space-photos-of-philippines-9-countries-released-to-mark-earth-day/ https://www.goodnewspilipinas.com/diwata-1-2-view-from-space... Diwata-1/Diwata-2 have a High Precision Telescope (HPT) which I see no mention of on the MMSATS-1, only a super multi-color imager (SMI). But I can't see the exact specs. If you can find a photo of the underside of the MMSATS-1 you could see if it has a HTP by comparing it to this - https://directory.eoportal.org/web/eoportal/satellite-missions/pag-filter/-/article/diwata-1 https://directory.eoportal.org/web/eoportal/satellite-missio...
- simonh 6y agoOne of the express purposes of the satellite is to track agricultural activity, which by definition means it must be able to identify remote agricultural communities through e.g. forest clearance. That could be used to target ethnic minority settlements.
- inetsee 6y agoCan anybody tell me the resolution of the cameras on this satellite? Would it be better than the resolution of the images available from Google Maps? How much resolution is needed "to monitor agriculture and fisheries"?
- gattilorenz 6y agoNo idea, but it's not necessarily "regular" cameras. For monitoring agriculture, infrared imagery is often used due to the difference reflective properties of vegetation (and other stuff) at different wavelengths; having multiple type of pictures, at different wavelengths, is useful to get better estimates of what you're looking at than what you would achieve with just visible light.
- williesleg 6y agoIts to monitor the environment, trust them.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoIs there any general picture related to these and others. Old days most concern with geo sync etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_orbits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_orbits Not hundreds of floating around ... I only concern in the past how it affects by astro photo. But if it goes back to this low orbit floating how these ideas come around and how to choose one from others. More important how it work across national boundary.
- tjpnz 6y agoWith Soichi Noguchi up there now this headline can be read literally.
- elliotec 6y agoWhat? Can it not be read literally anyway? What's the context?
- known 6y agohttps://www.speedcheck.org/wiki/bssid/ https://www.speedcheck.org/wiki/bssid/ can be used to track your location
- supernova87a 6y agoWell, what's the point of holding on to one satellite if anyone can basically buy imagery from a dozen satellite companies right now? Are any of those players restricting anyone from buying imagery of Myanmar? If no, then this is pretty much a pointless thought exercise for them to engage in?
- waheoo 6y agoYou can stop those companies should you need to. Good luck taking out their satellite after the fact.
- MartinWill 6y agobreak a contract in a short time, or maybe many lives. it's an easy choice.