4 ms·
> The point of a union should not be to collu[d]e to raise prices. The point of a union should be to pool market power and resources These are just different w
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> The point of a union should not be to collu[d]e to raise prices. The point of a union should be to pool market power and resources
These are just different words for the same thing.
- gruez 6y agoYou can have cooperation without price-fixing.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoWhat would you be cooperating to do?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- alteriority 6y agocan't speak for gruez, but a couple off the top of my head: -set standards that all members abide by, potentially bypassing "tragedy of the commons'-style coordination problems -share information which, in a more cutthroat environment, would be considered "trade secrets". Not sure how these would apply to the dairy industry specifically; it just seems overly broad to say that price fixing is the only plausible form of cooperation.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoLook into the effects of your ideas, and you'll see them wind up in rising prices. Your first example, excluding industry members who don't meet a particular standard, is one of the most typical forms of "colluding to raise prices" you could possibly think of, often expressed in the form of professional certification. The only things an economic organization can do are raise prices and lower costs. For a labor union, costs are labor; from the consumer end the workers' "lower costs" mean less work is being done, which shows up as higher prices for consumers.
- elmomle 6y agoSetting standards and price fixing are different things. You can have fair competition within a marketplace with rules and standards. Price fixing is when all sellers agree to not sell below a certain price, which is a problem pretty much regardless of a marketplace's rules.
- rightbyte 6y agoStandards might be a way to prevent a race to the bottom in quality. I think that is the most important thing.
- jschwartzi 6y agoBy arguing from the standpoint of raising or lowering prices you're being very reductive. Doctors form trade associations too, and yes the prices for a certified doctor are much higher, but the quality of care is also standardized and usually higher to match. OP wasn't making the point that industry associations don't raise prices. OP was pointing out that most industry associations are formed to try to make things better. And that might result in increased prices, but that's a side-effect and not the goal.
- duxup 6y agoUltimately the problem is the price...
- jerome-jh 6y agoThe problem is that cooperatives turned into monopolies, becoming inefficient. So it is both a price and organizational problem.
- reedjosh 6y agoI'm seeing a resurgence of competition on quality too. I personally purchase organic grass fed glass bottled milk from local farms. Sounds snobby and onerous, but it's available at any Whole Foods. Quality food is truly worth it. Milk should not be a commodity. I know it's a bit more expensive, but I promise eating quality reduces the need for quantity. Our bodies are starving on this poorly made junk commodity food.
- katbyte 6y ago> Milk should not be a commodity neither should food, water, or shelter but here we are
- maxerickson 6y agoCommodity literally means cheap and of consistent quality. All of those things should be commodities, even if we choose to pay for them as a society rather than organizing the flow of goods using markets. Put simply, if you are willing to buy it without sampling it, you think it's a commodity.
- reedjosh 6y agoI think you mean if you are willing to buy it regularly without sampling. We bought a few brands prior to our current buying pattern. I am not willing to buy milk without sampling. Currently we have two that we like. Basically, one has extra fat added, but the other comes in a reusable (literally return for reuse) glass bottle. If only I could get both.