6 ms·
> Opponents of the bill say DST makes it hard on school children and parents who have to wait at the bus stop in dark hours of the morning. Here's an idea - le
by paxys 6y ago
> Opponents of the bill say DST makes it hard on school children and parents who have to wait at the bus stop in dark hours of the morning.
Here's an idea - let students (and parents) sleep for an additional hour rather than make them wake up before the crack of dawn for no reason.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> Opponents of the bill say DST makes it hard on school children and parents who have to wait at the bus stop in dark hours of the morning. Probably easier to just give them all flashlights, than to have everyone shift their clocks to accommodate this use case.
- croes 6y agoHow about standard time instead of DST especially in winter
- garmaine 6y agoOr here’s an idea: we can do DST in the summer, and standard time in the winter. Best of both worlds!
- croes 6y agoThe problem is the switch, so it's better to get rid of it and then Standard Time is the better choice
- garmaine 6y agoThis argument makes less and less sense with each passing year. I'm old enough to remember when we had to change all the clocks by hand, and some people had no idea how to change the clocks in microwaves and VCRs or their car, so it'd be off by an hour for half the year. Somehow we managed fine. These days all clocks change automatically, and there are standard and constantly improving datetime libraries to help applications manage these human factors in a standard way. Your morning alarm is automatically updated, you calendar events automatically reflect the timezone they are defined in. The only curveball is when when the government arbitrarily changes the rules, like then did not too long ago in extending DST. And which DST advocates are advocating for doing _again_.
- croes 6y agoIt is not about the process of changing the clock, but about the fact that the body should be able to perform one hour earlier from one day to the next. Especially when changing from standard time to DST, this is stressful for the body. https://www.businessinsider.com/daylight-saving-time-is-deadly-2018-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/daylight-saving-time-is-dead...
- garmaine 6y agoThe transition is over the weekend, so really one ought to be able to adjust 20min a day--again, something which could be automated. But honestly I believe this reporting is overblown. The body is able to adjust rather quickly to such a small difference in time, as many of us who (used to) travel quite frequently know.
- croes 6y agoDepends on how early your day starts. If you normally start at 05:00 o'clock standard time then to get up at 04:00 o'clock standard time is pretty stressful.
- exabrial 6y agoYep. Or just close the schools permanently, sell the assets, commit to at-home learning or micro-schools.
- tony101 6y agoHow about we do it the other way: Eliminate daylight saving time and make standard time permanent?
- ISL 6y agoThat way noon has the sun at zenith, which makes sense.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoThat's my preference too, but making DST permanent is better than continuing to change twice a year. When confronted with three choices and none of the three have majority support, society usually chooses the "status quo" option. Even when a proper ranked choice vote would end up with one of the other two options. So I guess I need to keep quiet to ensure that we end up with our second choice rather than our third choice.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoLet's split the difference: Spring ahead 1/2 an hour and then keep the clocks there.
- saalweachter 6y agoSo the big problem is springing ahead. No one likes it. On the other hand, everyone loves falling back. I'd like to propose making the day approximately 9.86 seconds longer, so that each year we accumulate 1 hour of extra time. Then, each fall, we set the clocks back one hour. You get the benefits of DST (more sunlight later in the day in the summer) without the jarring "spring ahead" each year.
- _-david-_ 6y agoIt would be quite annoying to have your clock off a minute every week. The first couple weeks wouldn't be too big of an issue, but when you start getting 10 minutes off you would need to fix your clock.
- jimbob45 6y agoI don’t think it ultimately matters. Shifting the schedule forward or backwards doesn’t change the fact that the students will only have so many hours in the day. The only way to give more time to students is to cut school shorter. That’s to say nothing for the students who would feel compelled to immediately fill that time with another extra-curricular. IMHO what would help is colleges putting a stop to the resume-padding they implicitly encourage students to do to gain an edge on their peers for acceptance.
- sokoloff 6y agoWhen elite colleges get 15-20 applicants for every student they admit, how would you propose they implement this? Roll a d20, score a critical hit, get into Harvard?
- jimbob45 6y agoJust cap the criteria they consider for entry and lottery the qualifying applicants on in. That’s basically how it works now anyway.
- PLenz 6y agoYes, that's EXACTLY how it should work. Lottery
- sokoloff 6y agoPrediction if Harvard did that: Within two years, Harvard gets 100+ applicants for every spot. 10 years later: Harvard is no longer considered elite (or Harvard after Class of 2030 is no longer considered elite). That outcome might be aligned with your goals; it's probably not aligned with Harvard's goals nor that of their alumni.
- jimbob45 6y agoWhat does elite mean anymore? What makes Harvard elite?
- heavyset_go 6y ago> Here's an idea - let students (and parents) sleep for an additional hour rather than make them wake up before the crack of dawn for no reason. Turns out that that doing just this has quantifiable benefits[1]. [1] "Teens get more sleep, show improved grades and attendance with later school start time, researchers find": https://www.washington.edu/news/2018/12/12/high-school-start-times-study/ https://www.washington.edu/news/2018/12/12/high-school-start...
- xeonoex 6y agoI think it's mostly the teachers and the administrators who advocate for the earlier times. Well, that and parents who drop off their kids before work. A later start would be great for students.
- aksss 6y agoWork schedules would have to change. Schools are basically a child care service with varying qualities of value-add education thrown in. Maybe after a year of WFH being normalized, companies will be more accepting of flexible schedules.
- dimitrios1 6y agoWork schedules would not need to change if one salary would be all you need to support a family. This world we've raised for ourselves was underpinned by a primary wage earner, and a primary homemaker. We even used to subsidize homemaking. We've gone backwards all in the name of progress.
- vmception 6y agoIn my area this was actually a logistical thing. Other schools in the area bussed children at different hours. I don't think people are considering this reality in this debate. I am not advocating for anything.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> Other schools in the area bussed children at different hours. Do you mean other schools in your school district or schools in other districts?
- vmception 6y agoother schools in my school district. it was just a crowded and large area. a single high school even put 9th graders in a totally different building and location. It was basically middle middle school. All the levels of school had different start and end times to accommodate, and there were many schools at each level with overlapping bussing.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoAny changes made would be district wide. We probably got here (counterproductive start times) by making budgets the first consideration - with literally everything else following it. It also explains why we segment kids by age.
- Retric 6y agoAdding more buss drivers is relatively cheap. Bussing is ~3% of the total cost of primary school.
- garmaine 6y agoOne bus can’t be in two places at once, no matter how many drivers you have.
- 6y ago
- baron816 6y agoYeah, what’s stopping schools from having their own “DST/Standard Time” switch. Schools should set their hours according to what makes sense for students. We don’t need the whole country to set its clock around students.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf elementary schools changed schedules by an hour, some parents of elementary school kids would need to change their schedule by an hour as well. When the whole society does this all at once, the individual parents/coworkers/bosses don’t have to negotiate or coordinate anything; it “just happens”.
- Spartan-S63 6y agoExactly. We, the people, need to exert back pressure on a deeply flawed system to force it to happen. Such a change wouldn't be nearly as problematic if union membership, for example, was widespread.
- sokoloff 6y agoHow does union membership help align a work team that needs two members for a team job (for task-related or safety-related reasons) and exactly one of the two needs to change schedules because their kid's school changed schedule by an hour?
- sjg007 6y agoA lot of elementary schools have before and after school programs so it'll be a mixed bag.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoIf we switch to permanent DST, and the whole of society compensates by setting schedules back an hour, all we’ve done is create de-facto permanent standard time. That’s the best-case scenario. I have a better idea. Let’s just actually switch to permanent standard time, so we don’t have to hope that society shakes itself out.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> makes it hard on school children and parents who have to wait at the bus stop in dark hours of the morning I can't even understand what is 'hard' about it?
- belltaco 6y agoPossibility of crimes in dark hours in crime-prone regions? It's hard to imagine if you don't experience it where you live.
- leetcrew 6y agois the one time of the day when every child and parent on the street is standing outside together really the best time to commit a crime, dark or otherwise?
- Ensorceled 6y agoIt's a bizarre "con": Pros: better health, less accidents fewer deaths during the switch, etc. Cons: it's "hard" on some kids and parents to wait for the bus in the dark which they already do anyway, just now it's for a few more weeks. Seems a no brainer.
- croes 6y agoCon: more accidents in winter time because it's harder to become awake if it's still dark than stay awake if ut becomes dark. More accidents of children if they have to walk to school or the bus. The pros refer only to the elimination of the switch but not to the permanent implementation of the DST. Standard Time would be the better choice.
- cafard 6y agoMontgomery County, Maryland, is quite prosperous, but wishes its school buses to make more than two runs per day. So the high school students are out at the curb early in the morning, since nobody wants the elementary school students out in half-light. The high school students--who would prefer to sleep in--are groggy from lack of sleep, the elementary school students--who wake early--have an extra hour at home to do nothing in particular. I don't know what the story is with the middle school kids. I commuted to college long ago one winter with DST. I did not enjoy it. I'm not sure I'd have enjoyed it even living on campus.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago> let students (and parents) sleep for an additional hour To complete the sensible set, elementary schools open first, high schools last. In brutal southern climates, end the school year on Halloween when kids can play outside w/o heat stroke - with kids inside air conditioning during worthless summer months.
- sjg007 6y agoSome places have year round schooling.
- guyzero 6y agoAmerican high schools have to be out around 3 PM to allow for enough time for sports teams to practice. Other schools end up synchronizing to this schedule. A non-trivial reason is that high school teachers with young children need to have them synced with their own work schedules and teachers have some level of control over how school days are scheduled. Anyway, like everything in the US, blame the obsession with high school athletics.
- pbronez 6y agoI have no great love for high school sports, but at least it's a mechanism to get kids moving. Given the obesity epidemic, a solid physical education option seems useful. Definitely has grown into something way beyond that though.
- marshray 6y agoPE class is one thing, building the whole school schedule around the football team's needs is another.
- JDulin 6y agoIt's not for "no reason" - Public education's primary purpose in the United States, other than indoctrination, is daycare for the workforce. So school must start early enough parents can get children to school before heading to their jobs.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoBefore school programs exist. Daycare exists. School does not need to start early enough for parents to get children off to school first. Folks working retail, in factories, and in health care deal with this all the time.
- eMSF 6y agoJust so I understand what you're saying: we should first move the clocks an hour ahead (permanently), then delay our schedules an hour, then ???, and then, I guess, profit? How exactly does this differ from not moving the clocks an hour ahead permanently and not delaying our schedule for the day for an hour?
- paxys 6y agoThis problem (if it even is a problem) affects a small number of students in a handful of regions in the country. Individual schools/school districts are free to come up with their own personalized solutions. There is no reason to involve the other 95% of the population in this game.
- ncallaway 6y agoSeriously. If schools want to start at 8am instead of 7am in the winter, then they should just do that.
- warkdarrior 6y agoThere are 70+ million children in US, so at least 70+ million parents affected by this "game". That would be half of the working population of 150MM.
- mattnewton 6y agoIs changing the definition of the hours the best way to solve this problem though? It seems tangentially related at best.
- paxys 6y agoNot all children are of school going age. Not all parents work strict 8am-5pm office jobs. Some schools/school districts already start late. A large chunk of the country doesn't have problems with daylight because of location. My overall point is - the equations of labor, electricity, fuel, school, daycare, geographical times and more are complex enough in this country today that it is okay to let individual schools/offices etc. pick what timings best work for them rather than artificially trying to fit everyone in the same mold.
- nabilhat 6y agoNorth of about 45 degrees latitude, the winter time change centers daylight perfectly so that for part of the year students leave home in the dark, go home in the dark, and sit in class through all of the daylight. When the days finally start getting long enough to see a little sunlight at each end, it's time to move the clocks forward and they're back to going to school in the dark. It's brutal. Way back when I was in school there were a couple that had 10 hour days, to better accomodate parent's schedules. Drop junior off when it fits your morning schedule best, same for pickup in the afternoon. Teachers worked on the early end, late end, took a long lunch, worked four 10 hour days, whatever suited the needs of their students and their own lives. The pickup and dropoff zones didn't get gridlocked with every single parent showing up at the same exact time. My point is, there are far better options available than fooling around with time itself.
- flowerlad 6y ago> Here's an idea - let students (and parents) sleep for an additional hour rather than make them wake up before the crack of dawn for no reason. When exactly is the "crack of dawn"? Unless you live near the equator the "crack of dawn" changes every day. If "additional hour" is relative to the clock then you can always start things an hour late relative to the clock, regardless of where the clock is relative to daylight hours.