17 ms·
Mobile touch screens aren't really the issue here - the problem is mouse users on laptops, where they don't get to touch the screen to discover elements and the
by simonw 6y ago
Mobile touch screens aren't really the issue here - the problem is mouse users on laptops, where they don't get to touch the screen to discover elements and they need to be able to interact with a visible scrollbar in order to scroll.
I'm not a mouse user so this issue caught me completely off guard!
- zozbot234 6y agoI don't exactly like invisible scrollbars either (and it sucks that Gtk+3/Adwaita has adopted thin/invisible scrollbars in Linux) but modern mice have dedicated scroll wheels.
- neolog 6y ago> I'm not a mouse user I'm curious about what tools you use to manage mouseless workflow?
- simonw 6y agoMac laptop trackpad - where double finger scrolling feels so natural to me I forgot that it could be harder with a mouse.
- mercurysmessage 6y agoSo you don't use a monitor either?
- mercurysmessage 6y agoThis site is way too fickle
- andylynch 6y agoProbably a trackpad? They are ok with his kind of scrolling but mice are tricky, especially for horizontal movement
- martyvis 6y agoI love my new Logitech MX Master 3 mouse with its thumb wheel
- smoe 6y agoNot GP, but I pretty much only ever use the mouse/trackpad for testing from a user perspective or in some apps that don’t have good keyboard support. For the browser I use the Vimium plugin to navigate and only need to use the mouse in the case the site is badly made and e.g. a button is not a button but some styled div element with an event listener attached. Most of the other daily needs like functions of the tiling window manager (AwesomeWM), Editors (IDEA, VS Code, emacs), terminals, etc. come out of the box with good keyboard control support.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoThere's nothing stopping the mouse from dragging exactly like with the finger: click, move, release. In addition to that, most mice have a scroll wheel. I don't think I understand the issue you're referring to.
- simonw 6y agoI've had two separate users tell me that they use a mouse and they can't my scroll tables horizontally without first scrolling to the bottom of the page.
- wongarsu 6y agoI can scroll horizontally on my touchpad, but on a mouse it doesn't work. Horizontal scroll wheels are rare (the Logitech Master series has them, but that's about it). Most apps allow you to hold ctrl while using the scroll wheel to scroll horizontally. Some implement some kind of drag-mechanic, but that feels incredibly awkward with a mouse and is unusable with a touchpad.
- pseudalopex 6y agoDon't most scroll wheels tilt horizontally? The Windows and macOS apps I tried zoomed or scrolled vertically with Ctrl.
- wongarsu 6y ago> Don't most scroll wheels tilt horizontally? On some mice they do, and it's a really useful feature. But it's fairly niche and mostly on the more expensive mice. I would feel pretty confident betting that over 99% of Windows users don't have a tiltable scroll wheel.
- fomine3 6y agoEven though I have trackball with tilt wheel (MX Ergo), I noticed that I never use them. When I should scroll vertically, I just middle click and move cursor, or grab scrollbar and drag. Maybe because tilting wheel isn't comfortable way to scroll.
- Kranar 6y agoNeed to is pretty strong. My company did UX testing on scroll bars and the overwhelming majority of our users on laptop scroll using the keyboard or the scroll wheel (which on laptop is done using two finger dragging). I forget the exact number but it was less than 10% of users actually interact with the scrollbar.
- simonw 6y agoIt's that 10% I'm worried about!
- The_rationalist 6y agoI am not interacting with the scrollbar but I regularly semi-incousoucly look at it as it give me crucial feedback of where I am.
- bombcar 6y agoNot interacting with it doesn't mean you don't use it - I glance at it to see if there is more content and where in it I am, even though I use the scroll wheel to move.
- Kranar 6y agoYes, the solution we went with, which Apple also uses, is to display the scrollbar while scrolling.
- eptcyka 6y agoFor us, it was vocal Windows and Linux users that were asking for the scrollbars to be visible 100% of the time.
- naikrovek 6y agoI would be one of those users. Hiding relevant information from the user is a bad idea. The computer is a tool that the user employs to accomplish a task. Do not hide tools from people who need to use the tools. A computer is a tool. It's not a design statement. It is not a canvas on which you paint. It is a toolbox full of tools a user needs to do work. Treat it as such, please.
- brundolf 6y agoI enable persistent scrollbars on any machine where I'm doing front-end web dev, so that I can better see what (some of) my users will see (not doing this has bitten me when it affected layout). But on my personal laptop I leave the scrollbars off. I virtually never drag them with the mouse these days and they just clutter my visual landscape; I'm glad the option is there to hide them (and dear god would they get in the way on the already-limited real estate of a phone screen).
- epriest 6y agoI think mouse users don't generally suffer from this problem: by default, MacOS always shows a scrollbar in all contexts if you have a mouse plugged in to your computer.
- thebean11 6y agoI don't think so? I remember having to enable that feature
- breakfastduck 6y agoOnly if it's a third party mouse
- chrisseaton 6y ago> by default, MacOS always shows a scrollbar in all contexts if you have a mouse plugged in to your computer No it doesn't - and why would it? Any reasonable modern mouse has a scroll-wheel or touch area so you don't need to click the scrollbar.
- banana_giraffe 6y agohttps://imgur.com/a/Z97cDc9 https://imgur.com/a/Z97cDc9 Not only does it not show the scroll bar by default, but (not sure if this is a Chrome or Mac issue), when it does show up during a scroll operation, you have to have great reflexes to grab it with a click if you want to.
- pmontra 6y agoA customer of mine was surprised to see some extra VMs in vSphere a few days ago. He never tried to scroll a list somewhere in the app and always missed the extra content because his Mac doesn't display the scrollbar. He has a laptop, so no mouse. I tweaked my Gnome desktop to always display a transparent scrollbar (only the outline is visible) so I could see that the list had extra elements. By the way, vSphere is part of the problem. It's one of those web applications that try very hard to look like a desktop application. It doesn't use the standard HTML behavior of building a page that scrolls. It clips everything at the borders of the screen. Ironically that reduced functionality probably cost them a lot of developer time.
- pilif 6y agoHas macOS changed the default setting for scroll bars? In the past, whenever a mouse was connected, it would switch to always showing scroll bars. At least on Catalina, the default (System Preferences > General) is still set to “automatically based on mouse or trackpad”
- antihero 6y agoMouse users on macOS have scrollbars visible by default.