12 ms·
Someone is hacking the hackers
- sunstone 6y agoTraditionally the message on the hacked homepage should be: All your base are belong to us.
- majkinetor 6y agoDamn be those hacker hackers for breaking such a great tradition.
- 1f60c 6y agoWhat you say!!
- RedShift1 6y agoYou have no chance to survive make your time!
- smoldesu 6y agoYeah, today's hackers lack class. The Cyberpunk codebase hack would be pretty funny if someone awk'd the subtitle files to say "Can I haz cheeseburger?", but I guess today's crowd is more interested in editing HTML and CSS.
- hnick 6y agoThey've lost their passion, they're just doing it for a paycheck :(
- gigatexal 6y agoThe data that was harvested was leaked to other “dark web” locations. The gangster move to take out your hacker competitors is to “out” these hackers on something more social like a github dump or to pastebin.
- doniphon 6y agoStrike Back - XXI season teaser
- YarickR2 6y agoBrain drain, infosec edition. Pandemic struck, and suddenly relocation is all the rage. I know a few infosec guys moving from Russia to various places outside of reach of local law enforcement (and "law enforcement") agencies . Next steps are usually easy to guess - infosec guys are doing what they were doing before, but for new management, and with new targets (ex-allies) in sight. Just a wild guess, of course.
- cosmodisk 6y agoThe problem with infosec,even during good times, is that it's a low paid job. I don't mean it's 10$/h or something, however taking into consideration what's at risk and usually the knowledge required, majority get paid peanuts. No surprise more lucrative deals of questionble sort pop up and attract the more talented ones.
- tyingq 6y agoI'm curious what forum software Maza, Verified, and Exploit use. If they all use the same one, that might explain the quick succession.
- wyxuan 6y agoI'm guessing xenforo? Most forums use it - even the illicit ones. The issue probably stems from an insecure plugin - this was how OGUsers was hacked.
- ryanlol 6y agoNone of these hacks were related to the forum software. Maza and VF run ancient vb, but nobody has found vulns in that for ages. Exploit frontend proxy was compromised by someone, most likely the hoster. The forum software doesn’t run on the frontend proxy. VF was hacked with a MITM attack that intercepted admin credentials, you can check CT logs to verify this.
- tyingq 6y agoI'm surprised even ancient vbulletin doesn't have new vulnerabilities arise. Last I looked at it, it was a horrible kluge. For example a fair amount of the actual PHP than runs was in database tables.
- jart 6y agoThat makes it unpleasant which does not necessarily mean insecure. In fact, having an unpleasant codebase can be an advantage from a security standpoint. If the code is so ugly and complicated that no one wants to add new features, then that means less churn, and less churn means fewer weaknesses. Imagine if the Sudo codebase, which has had over 9,000 changes, had been written that way. I think Donald Knuth got it right with his marvelous tex.web monstrosity that some software should arch towards immutability. https://mirrors.concertpass.com/tex-archive/systems/knuth/dist/tex/tex.web https://mirrors.concertpass.com/tex-archive/systems/knuth/di...
- 6y ago
- sigmaprimus 6y agoIm surprised there was no mention of Jokers Stash, it seems reasonable to me that after it shut down it left a power vacuum of sorts with several actors looking for new places to ply their trade. Not to mention the real possibility that some "peepls" have an axe to grind because they got burned when J$ closed up shop.
- ryanlol 6y agoNobody got burned when joker quit, everyone got paid.
- sigmaprimus 6y agoI didn't say they didn't get paid. There a plenty of other ways to lose out from having the rug pulled out suddenly...but now that You made the argument, unless I missed it, the only evidence that everyone got paid was the promise made within the announcement which is no evidence at all.
- ryanlol 6y agoThere’s lots of evidence if you read VF and similar forums. Joker manually processed withdrawals for those who requested them, even small amounts. All the sellers got paid.
- ivanech 6y ago[deleted]
- dang 6y ago"Please don't complain about website formatting, back-button breakage, and similar annoyances. They're too common to be interesting. Exception: when the author is present. Then friendly feedback might be helpful." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ivanech 6y agoWhoops, sorry!
- dang 6y agoAppreciated! These things genuinely are super annoying, which is why we need the rule. It's about foregoing a local optimum (justified but repetitive criticism of flaws in web pages and software) for a global one (more interesting, less predictable conversation).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cyberlab 6y ago> spurring fears among criminals that their identities might be exposed I imagine there is very little to gain from the leaked credentials. I mean we are talking about cyber-criminals, who always like to mess with their real IP with Tor or VPNs. And who would be stupid enough to use their legal name on a darkweb carding forum?
- ryanlol 6y agoPeople have lost hundreds of thousands because they reused their forum logins on jabber... Lots (most?) of the people on these forums aren’t hackers, but banking experts moving tens of millions of stolen money around the world.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoHow did they lose the money, impersonation? Are they running some informal banking/laundering system via jabber chats?
- ryanlol 6y agoHey, here’s my new bitcoin address for payments: Hey, here’s the new bank account info to send stolen money to: Hey bro, can you borrow me 100k for a few days?
- nullCommand 6y agoWe simply ask the user to install an App to iOS or Android that gives us two factor codes. This is done with the user contest. At least, that's how I do these things.
- nullCommand 6y agoWhat's stolen? The user gave contest to us. We are simply acting to that contest. The US GOV need to focus more on Tether not us because Tether steals billions of dollars directly from economy. Everybody know who is Merlin!
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago
- goatinaboat 6y agoI just love the arrogance of these fuckers. “No one but state level law enforcement could take us down!” What a crock of shit. More likely just an ex member with an axe to grind. Yep, everyone always says they were the victim of a sophisticated hack by advanced state-sponsored level hackers, whereas maybe their password was <company name>123.
- mannykannot 6y agoIndeed; it seems unlikely that a state-level actor would announce to the targets that they have been compromised.
- derefr 6y agoIs it just me, or has the number of large hacks on “things you’d expect to be at least somewhat secure” picked up since the pandemic started? It seems like every week now there’s a source-code leak for some high-profile project. My own assumption so far is that credentials that were previously being passed along through (essentially) in-person key-exchange parties, have now been forced to be passed along over channels like email/Slack/etc., making the ability to spin “mail/chat server admin creds” into “general system-level elevated creds” a lot more frequent.
- aboringusername 6y agoI think the pandemic has a role to play in this for sure. I imagine may were required to use computers/tech as they've not done before. Often times those who are uneducated have to be accounted for so concessions are made. For example, Sam needs to use a corporate network, doesn't really understand "apps" or what a "TOTP" is, so they optimize (weaken security) to allow them in.
- luckman212 6y agoCan we change this to "dumber than average" Sue? I guarantee when I'm 60 I'll still be able to safely operate a computer and understand what an "app" is, FFS. Ageism is really out of control these days.
- jstanley 6y agoSure, but when you're 60 you might not be so hot on technology that you first encountered in your 50s. I'm sure today's 60-year-olds are still perfectly good at the kind of things they've been doing since they were 20.
- ineedasername 6y agoThe implication that someone couldn't keep up with a relatively new things-- in your case vague example something they even encountered a few years earlier-- is pretty much the definition of ageism. Anyone who decides to keep their professional skills current will do just fine whether they're 5 years out of school or 40 years out of school. If someone doesn't keep current & is 5 years out of date on their skills, there's not a lot of difference between a 30 year old and a 60 year old that are equally 5 years out of date. Though the 60 year old might have decades more of experience working in their advantage, so maybe the two aren't equal.
- praptak 6y agoIt would be out of character for a government agency to act like that. Shutdown and a threatening message? Maybe. Dumping the data on darknet? I'm not even sure if they can legally do that. Besides, which agency wouldn't use that to gain even more possibly useful information?
- osipov 6y agoIt would not be out of character for a government contractor...
- temp485850 6y agoYou've clearly never heard of intelligence laundering before.
- libraryatnight 6y agoAm I the only person, when thinking of governments, that has removed "legality" as a barrier to any potential action?
- srswtf123 6y agoYou most certainly are not the only person. At this point, I presume governments are breaking every law on the books. Who is going to stop them?
- cosmodisk 6y agoNowadays you just call it the fight against terrorism and greenlight whatever you want.
- juanani 6y agoThe government, in a time of war, will pull all sorts of nasty shenanigans. Thankfully, we've been at war for a while so.. dont be traitors now.
- williesleg 6y agoAbout fucking time those commie chinese bastards get their shit stolen. Hopefully now I won't get those shit calls about my car warranty. Assholes.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoI'll bet money this is a private corporation that sells 0days taking out their competition. State-sponsored entities and research groups don't take down forums, for the same reason you don't arrest all the low-level perps on the street. You need to watch them to trail them to the bigger crimes. And blackhats don't take out forums of other blackhats.
- ryanlol 6y ago> I'll bet money this is a private corporation that sells 0days taking out their competition How much? :)
- naebother 6y ago> Whoever hacked Maza netted thousands of data points about the site’s users, including usernames, email addresses, and hashed passwords, a new report from intelligence firm Flashpoint shows. Two warning messages were then scrawled across the forum’s home page: “Your data has been leaked” and “This forum has been hacked.” Oh no. Not my username, email address and hashed password. I'm shaking right now. But then again there's always some idiot who doesn't try to anonymize.
- lstamour 6y agoAll it takes is one hit traced to a misconfigured VPN or browser, for example, to learn an IP address and thus real user, at least from a law enforcement perspective… though I suppose the same is true for any honeypot links. Same goes for checking your “anonymous” email, unless the provider is only accessible to check email on Tor, for example. Anonymity, like security, is hard to do 24/7 if someone is actively interested in you…
- varjag 6y agoNo honor among thieves.
- beny23 6y agoWas it due to an intern?
- bmsleight_ 6y agodang - can we change the source to https://krebsonsecurity.c https://krebsonsecurity.c om/2021/03/three-top-russian-cybercrime-forums-hacked/ please ?
- tacker2000 6y agoYes please, Gizmodo is cancer. Whats with that sticky video container??
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- meowface 6y agoYes, please. This is far better than the linked article.
- 1cvmask 6y agoI posted the original two days ago here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26362141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26362141
- mrkramer 6y ago"Criminal hackers have been known to hack each other, but is that what is happening here?" After years of researching computer security and cybercrime I think this is most likely the case with this one. "KrebsOnSecurity reports that the intruder subsequently dumped the stolen data on the dark web." If Law Enforcement people are after them they wouldn't do this they would simply seize the website and put notification on website's front page so it seems like rival group hacked them or simply whitehat hackers. Some of this cybercrime forums are running for more than a decade so no wonder they have attention and problems with Law and cyber criminals alike.
- hollander 6y agoIt could very well be law enforcement doing this, just to encite a war between different groups. Didn't they do this with drug gangs in Colombia?
- mrkramer 6y agoThey don't do it when they prosecute cyber criminals. You don't dump data and information you seize in investigation because you can use it in further operations or because you will need to use it in court.
- meowface 6y agoBut this wouldn't be a typical law enforcement action. (If it is actually a government that's responsible, here. I think it's unlikely, but we can just assume it for the sake of argument.) The likely culprits would be FIVEEYES law enforcement and/or intelligence. But the main people of interest on these forums likely all reside in Russia and perhaps some neighboring countries. An indictment against any of them is purely symbolic; these people know never to travel to a Western country and risk arrest. So, if you're FBI/CIA/NSA or similar, and you want to mitigate and disrupt all this fraud and theft and malware and PII harvesting from semi-organized Eastern European cybercrime, you're going to have to use some unconventional tactics. If I were a US "cyber commander" I think I'd consider trying to breach and expose their infrastructure and account info, and perhaps also plant some false flags so they think a rival was responsible. All of that helps encourage confusion, infighting, and decreased trade and communication. Keep doing it over and over and soon enough certain types of activities might become less lucrative, since more things have to be pushed even deeper underground and are less able to depend on semi-public advertisements for vending illicit goods and services. I could also imagine the US government considering it "fair game" from a geopolitical perspective. The current administration probably would be more likely to feel that way compared to the previous one, at least. Especially since there's evidence the Russia security services do sometimes team up with cybercriminals for certain things and turn a blind eye to them as long as they aren't targeting other Russian citizens.
- marshmallow_12 6y agohmm. seems the US government hasn't been twiddling their thumbs doing nothing about Russian Hackers after all...
- chiefalchemist 6y ago> This hack comes shortly after similar attacks on two other Russian cybercrime forums, I don't understand so I have to ask: What allows these sites to be designated as Russian? Is it simply the location of the server(s)? Is it a geographic designation, or more of a political one? Or both?
- luplex 6y agoI don't know the sites in question, but maybe the language?
- theMuckPot 6y agoAccording to this article: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2019/11/why-were-the-russians-so-set-against-this-hacker-being-extradited/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2019/11/why-were-the-russians-so... Since their inception in the mid-aughts, both of these forums (Mazafaka and DirectConnection) have been among the most difficult to join — admitting only native Russian speakers and requiring each applicant to furnish a non-refundable cash deposit and “vouches” or guarantees from at least three existing members. In addition, their administration is exclusively Russian nationals, and all forum posts and communications are done in Russian.
- imwillofficial 6y agoWhat is the route somebody takes to join forums like this? I’ve always found it fascinating. Even when I was a teenager.
- imhoguy 6y agoword of mouth or challenges like Cicada 3301 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cicada_3301 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cicada_3301
- cheeze 6y agoI've read that the biggest thing is referrals. Gotta be in the know or 'trusted' by someone else in the scene
- hutzlibu 6y agoLike with anything underground/dark. If there is a open and clear way to it, it is no longer underground/dark web. I bet they are a very paranoid circle, though.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoWord of mouth and sometime challenges. I remember, there used to be a Greek forum, pwnb0x (which appears to have vanished from all search engines), that allowed members with referrals or by solving puzzles.
- Strongylodon 6y agoPeople still post about crime on the internet? A LOT of anti social people seem to act badly thinking no one is going to even look at what logs exist due to existing policy, let alone illegal sources of info that are used in parallel construction. https://www.npr.org/2021/03/04/973696073/a-former-police-chief-in-md-was-a-serial-arsonist-authorities-say https://www.npr.org/2021/03/04/973696073/a-former-police-chi...
- ChuckMcM 6y agoPersonally I would expect to see more of this than we have. After all, with crypto cash exploding in value it seems like there are assets to be seized. But the cynic in me suspects that its really just an escalation of the world wide cyber war that has been going on for years now and is getting more resources as it hits more sensitive spots.
- lpriv 6y agoI suck cocks.
- lpriv 6y agoHjj
- lpriv 6y agoGjj
- joe_the_user 6y agoEveryone's excuse is "state actors" now and maybe they're right; Only intelligence services or people who know where the servers are located can pull off things like that,” mused one mainstay of Exploit. “Three forums in one month is just weird. I don’t think those were regular hackers. Someone is purposefully ruining forums. The thing with the state actor stuff is; once a actor state creates some tooling and methodologies, what could possibly prevent this from getting into private hands? (I mean, serious question) States have huge computing power for cracking passwords or whatever, state have "patience" but still, computing power can be stolen (via botnets or however), any process can be automated, etc.
- meowface 6y agoThe tooling, while sometimes containing extremely valuable weapons (see: ETERNALBLUE and Shadow Brokers), generally isn't as as much of a public risk as you might think. With the very important exception of leaked zero-days, the leaks of what are probably a significant portion of NSA's and CIA's secret toolkits weren't really a big deal for anyone besides NSA and CIA. Zero-days and backdoor access points are like turn-key WMDs and the rest are analogous to small pistols and oddly shaped special-purpose wrenches. As long as the zero-days and backdoors stay private, I think there isn't that much concern. If they don't stay private, then, yeah, it's a severe risk to the world. But those aren't exactly tools; more like privileged knowledge. You're unlikely to find some super secret intelligence agency hash cracker or DDoS tool that's 100x better than all existing free and paid tools, or something like that. And I think you're probably not going to find a leak that gives you access to a gargantuan government botnet, as you suggest. Even if they're incompetent enough to somehow have that become exposed and accessible by some random internet person, they'd almost certainly shut it down within minutes. Also, odds are such a person could rent a larger botnet through a number of much simple means, anyway.
- joe_the_user 6y agoI don't think this addresses my question, which whether there's anything that inherently makes "state actors" effective hackers than criminals or amateurs.
- thrownaway69 6y agoWhat does elders of HN do recommend if you find serious bug in security company's system? They don't have security.txt or bug bounty. First time I've had to go thru data I've obtained and email multiple times to get thing patched. They were ass about it. p.s. The company is affiliated with three letter agencies and basically offer them device decryption.
- killjoywashere 6y agoIn addition to law enforcement, keep in mind intel, counter-intel, and private-yet-national (e.g. Mandiant, Kaspersky, Sophos, et al)
- nullCommand 6y agoI'm a member of Mazafaka. This attack was conducted by US Cyber Command. Dear Maj Sheryl, I request you to consider raising salaries of your solders or next time they will be ours. Just few days ago, I had a chat with a solider, he don't have money to raise a family or buy a house.
- nullCommand 6y agoIt is incorrect to say that we are hackers. We are entrepreneurs like the Valley people. I personally have offices in Moscow with people. Our work is legal in accordance with Russian law. Holmes was the tip of the iceberg. The people at Valley are just like us, except they use complex manipulations and legal loopholes. We are transparent and open in what we do. Most Valley people don't care about building. They care more about going through an IPO or Acquisition. We create real value. I have a force of 100 men in the US Cyber Command. Just remember this!
- frEdmbx 6y agoWhenever I hear about something like this, it reminds me of things that were advantageous to, and allowed by, an old guard that the new guard isn't going along with. There isn't much going on that some "authorities" aren't capable of putting an end to if they so chose.