9 ms·
Please support Web Monetization if you want less ads on the web
- sneak 6y agoI was really keen on building something like this quite some time ago, but the way I understand the US regulation surrounding money transmission made all of the good and fast ways I could think to do it illegal without full KYC and a money transmitter license which is approximately $1M USD per state in which you wish to operate. Being a US person, I gave up on the idea, although it still deeply saddens me that there is so much red tape around micropayments that the (fairly technologically simple and readily achievable) systems that we could quickly use are basically illegal in the US. We have all of the infrastructure to do micropayments; from browser extensions and http status codes to the lightning network. It's just against the law.
- sofixa 6y agoWell Uphold ( the wallet i personally use) seems to require some documents before withdrawing money, probably to satisfy KYC requirements, so it seems legally possible. Not to mention, the sums involved are rather small, so maybe there are some thresholds ?
- gpvos 6y agoKYC = Know Your Customer, a kind of law applying to financial services; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_your_customer
- loloquwowndueo 6y agoWell no, thanks - my ad blocker works just fine. Instead of begging for support of a broken business model and/or trying to come up with technical solutions to what is a problem in economics, find a new one that works. That’s how real businesses operate, you know?
- thaeli 6y agoPlus, if this gets widespread, it's more fuel for the link farms and typo scam sites. Why monetize your dark patterns with ads when you can directly suck money out of your users? I'm sure the payment providers will claim to police this, but we know how impossible that is at scale.
- sofixa 6y agoYou're aware that we're not talking about business, right? It's for regular people who post random stuff on the Internet that would like to get something out of it and maybe one day turn it into a career. I don't mind posting whatever i've written for free, even if it has taken me tens of hours to research and write, but i also wouldn't mind being rewarded for that. There's plenty of crap on the Internet, but there's also plenty of good content. Do you think none of it deserves to get any income for the time spent and whatever costs incurred? Because the fact that a lot run ads or use medium or similar, would imply that at least a decent part of content creators would in fact prefer to gain at least some income.
- winphone1974 6y agoIt's fine for you to spend 20 hours producing content and for me to value it at zero. Saying it looks like people prefer any money to no money is not a new or unique observation
- abhinav22 6y agoThis is the main thing. To make money as a business (and running a personal website is a business in that sense if you want to make money from it), you have to give something that others value. It’s not just personal websites that face this issue, everyone who wants to make money from their interests does. That’s why the world has business people and employees - both have different strengths and weaknesses
- adam12 6y agoThis means that we get less innovation, though.
- corty 6y agoWhat guarantee is there that this will reduce ads in any way? If cable TV taught us anything it is that you can charge outrageous amounts of money and still force your customers to watch ads. Paper newspapers are also full of ads, even the ones the reader pays for. I can not think of any reason why the web should be different. Ads will stay, monetization will just be income on-top.
- sofixa 6y ago> What guarantee is there that this will reduce ads in any way? None, of course. It's possible to disable ads for users with Web Monetization, but it's also possible to be greedy and use both at the same time. But remember, we're not talking about big companies or anything of the sort, it's more for small scale personal blogs, or, as i pointed out, institutions like the Internet Archive or Wikipedia, so greed is IMHO unlikely and will probably be rare. In any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should, the ads don't impact you.
- paulryanrogers 6y ago> In any case, if you use an ad blocker, which you absolutely should... Why should everyone block the lowest friction way to pay creators? Besides the security argument which speaks more to JS, IMO.
- sofixa 6y agoBecause ads are obnoxious and privacy nightmares, and also security risks. You can just disable JS and third-party cookies, but that might break some websites ( and that number will only increase due to the proliferation of SPAs and fancy frontend frameworks). IMHO setting up ads on your website is higher friction that web monetization is.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- c22 6y ago
- NotEvil 6y agoIsn't this is what brave awards is?
- sofixa 6y agoIt's still ads, in a way: > Brave Rewards locally picks which private ads to show you based on your browsing activity. Then, Brave uses an anonymous accounting process to confirm ad event activity, keep personal details private, and ensure people earn rewards for their attention Compared to Web Monetization, which is transparent to the user and proportional to time spent.
- 0-_-0 6y agoBrave Rewards and contributing to websites are different and independent systems in Brave, you can use one without the other.
- pmlnr 6y agoflattr.com wanted this over a dedcade ago. It didn't work. Honest question: how is this attempt different?
- Bancakes 6y agoIt's very hard to take ads seriously. I only know about and use ~10 websites. Everything else could shut down tomorrow and I wouldn't know. Sorry, ad agencies, it's a lost battle for you.
- sokoloff 6y agoWhat’s to suggest I will get the privacy benefits rather than being secretly tracked anyway, especially on sites where my data is worth several dollars per month? While I won’t miss $5/mo, I’m guessing it would be consumed in the first couple days of the month, possibly leading content creators to optimize to compete for that tiny window of time and switch to ads (or just track full time anyway). Related, when is the meter running? Every time a tab is open on a URL? Only when frontmost, only when being interacted with? I have come to the sad conclusion that ads are a pretty good match for content payment and any replacement will a hard sell. With ads, I’m paying with my time (and privacy on the web). But I’m already spending my time for the content anyway.
- sofixa 6y agoCheck out my other comment here [0] on abusing tracking and ads anyway, but basically, just run an ad blocker anyway :) As for when the payments happen, it's only when the page is open and active, and stops if you go idle. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376118 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26376118
- gpm 6y agoSpending money actually just guarantees you can be tracked, because now you're logging into the same account day after day, and worse you've tied that account to a credit card. The only way for the average person to browse the web privately is to not pay. Theoretically this might be solved with the right form of digital tokens, but you're going to need anonymous payments (not bitcoin, but monero), and some form of cryptography system that tells the website that you have paid without telling them which person you are that paid. Practically no one does the former, no one does the latter, and the latter would be really difficult to implement if you want to stop people from sharing their accounts with the world at large.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf the web standard was such that the site generated a token (a request for payment) and the browser sent the authorization to pay referencing that token to a centralized authority (that you trusted), then you’d only be being tracked via this method by the group that can already track you by disbursing your funds.
- moonbug 6y agofewer.
- sofixa 6y agoIndeed! Thanks, Stannis, but a bit too late to change now..
- projectileboy 6y agoIn the world I live in, content creators get gobbled up by monopolizers, for which I pay monthly subscription fees, and then they also show me ads. And they also gather my data and sell it at will. This idea of “be a good little consumer and then there will be companies that will behave” is utterly absurd.
- baybal2 6y agoThe author is very wrong. I believe the current deluge of ads unseen since early 200X is the biggest proof that that "Internet economy" does not work, and will not work. If somebody does not want to give you money, why would they? People will never pay for what people now derisively call "content" nowadays. The only suggestion I have for the type of one man blogger enterprise complaining about nobody giving them money is to change occupation, and get a normal source of income.
- pessimizer 6y ago> People will never pay for what people now derisively call "content" nowadays. I wish there were a button I could push to take away money from the publishers of 3/4 of the articles I read on the web. edit: to head off any objections like "but you still read articles on the web so you must be getting some value," I have to state the obvious: I don't get to read articles before I read them. 3/4 of articles are the garbage I have to dig through to find something that meets the standard of mediocre. If it weren't for them, I could spend 3/4 less time reading articles, and 3/4 less bandwidth (so they're environmentally destructive, like bitcoin.)
- TeMPOraL 6y agoAnd, that's assuming you got positive value on the remaining 1/4. Which is not always a given. In case of news publishing, quite often that 1/4 has negative information value, in the sense that after reading it, your beliefs will be wronger than they were before.
- sircastor 6y agoIt took me a moment to understand that you didn’t mean that the money you take away wouldn’t necessarily be going to you. Sounds like we need a universal content rating system I compliment our initial payment system.
- lupire 6y agoYou can take away future money by choosing better sites to access and building a list of good and bad sites to remember, or by adblocking and unblocking and paying on good sites.
- enko123 6y agoThe worst is when you pay for an online newspaper and they still have ads!
- cyberlab 6y ago> without ads or any friction Initially there will be friction. After all the hype has dissipated from the early adopters, then regular users of the web will need to adopt it en masse. It's not going to be smooth sailing from the outset.
- justapassenger 6y agoBusinesses maximize profits, and people showed across many mediums, that they’re ok with ads in content, paid or not (press and cable are great examples - you pay for both, and they’re full of ads). Getting more paid content will not meaningfully reduce amount of ads, as they can provide extra income for companies, with overall little negative impact.
- Razengan 6y agoIdea: Let people donate the processing power of their billions upon billions of personal devices out there, like the SETI/Folding@Home projects but for general distributed computing, give them some kind of e-currency for that, and establish an economy on based that currency. You can run whatever you want (up to the storage/electricity limits I allow) on my computer/phone when I'm sleeping, give me eBling, and charge me eBling for web searches etc. Make it so that donating 12 hours of a mid-range phone's CPU would pay for 24 hours of web searches, or something like that.
- freebuju 6y agoSounds like a utility service built on top of other already existing utility services.
- techtom 6y agoWhy don't we focus on better quality adds to encourage people to not use ad blocker? Speaking of ad blocker, is there not an ad blocker which instead of 'blocks all ads' and have to whitelist. Can't we 'block no ads' and have to blacklist?
- maxwelldone 6y agoI've been thinking about this. How can we get good ads without extensive tracking? I've been blocking ads as long as I could remember, mostly because it's annoying and/or irrelevant. However, I'd be down to see ads if they're, say, relevant (things I'm actually interested in) 90% of the time. I thought about having a system where I could voluntarily say what I'd like to see in ads (obviously stuff I'm comfortable letting others know eg: sw, t-shirts, etc) - sort of like subscribing to RSS feed. Maybe advertisers could have a button on their site that I could click to let them know I'm interested in promotions, new releases etc. I imagine those advertisers could be part of an ad network I'd whitelist. I could see this as a win-win, though I don't want to think I'm the only one to think of this. Maybe those in the industry feel status quo is the best at scale.
- mnd999 6y agoAds are okay, and as others have pointed out this will not make them go away. Ad networks that track you, and slurp as much personal data as they can get are a problem. Invasive ads that make noise or take over the whole page are a problem. Ad companies that claim to be search engines but produced results based on who’s paying the most instead of what’s relevant to your search are a problem. Basic advertising I’m okay with.
- techtom 6y agoWhy don't we focus on better quality ads to encourage people to not use ad blocker? Speaking of ad blocker, is there not an ad blocker which instead of 'blocks all ads' and you have to whitelist ourselves. Can't we just have ads on all websites unless we make the choice to blacklist it?
- spark3k 6y agoThis is so important. It's much less to do about ads and more about quality information and content created by people who have invested in it being able to circulate in our society rather than information and content which is free but created by hacks and incentivised by some other motive or has an alternative agenda. We're seeing the ramifications of that every day. This needs to be brought into the web standards asap IMO.
- CodesInChaos 6y agoMy biggest issue with ads is the tracking. It sounds like this system will make tracking easier, and leak information about your browsing habits to the wallet provider. IMO the technology most suited for anonymous micro payments are blind signatures, like Chaum's Ecash or GNU Taler. This still has centralized issuers and some implementations require the payment receiver to be identified, but it neither the issuer not the payee can tell how you spend your money.
- sofixa 6y agoSorry, but i specifically address this in the article: > Anonymity and privacy are provided by the way things work - that wallets are randomly generated IDs, Coil transfer the money, the wallet provider knows who the recipient is, the content creators knows how much they’ve received, but nobody knows everything. Here’s a post[0] by Coil’s co-founder and CTO Ben Sharafian discussing wallet-side and sender-site (based on PrivacyPassp[1]) privacy techniques they and the wallet providers use to ensure everyone’s privacy is respected. 0 - https://coil.com/p/sharafian/Doubling-Down-on-Privacy/cD_ZiwT2J https://coil.com/p/sharafian/Doubling-Down-on-Privacy/cD_Ziw... 1 - https://privacypass.github.io/ https://privacypass.github.io/
- CodesInChaos 6y agoI based my statement on that paragraph, since the mechanisms the article describes are clearly insufficient to ensure privacy when the participants collude. However the part only mentioned by name, PrivacyPass, uses blind signatures and thus might actually work.
- raspyberr 6y agoYeah.... no. Companies want you to think and act like digital "products" are like physical products. Yet in the real world we don't get clothes or cars for "free" just beceause of advertising. "Monetizing" the web will just mean you'll pay for ads. I do however wish there was a micropayments system on the internet that wasn't directly linked to a bank or company. GNU Taler or Monero are the only things that really come close.
- blfr 6y agoFrankly, I want less commercial content. I want to read and watch stuff put out by hobbyists, people who are excited by what they're doing, who would do it without compensation anyway. I see very little upside to professionalisation of sports, sex, writing, even reporting. Anything worth doing is worth doing badly. Some things are just better when done by amateurs or done instead of watched. Journalism is best (worst) example. We are being deceived by dilettantes with slick production values and almost universally an agenda or served straight-up propaganda. I'd rather delve into less polished material from people who actually know things because they have a deep drive towards understanding them.
- sofixa 6y ago> Frankly, I want less commercial content. I want to read and watch stuff put out by hobbyists, people who are excited by what they're doing, who would do it without compensation anyway. The fact that someone would do it without compensation doesn't mean that if they do get compensation they wouldn't spend more time on it. It's precisely for hobbyist-level stuff where web monetization can really shine.
- pdimitar 6y agoDisagreed. When the money starts rolling in, your thinking changes. Not saying there are no people who resist it but most don't, and I've seen good YouTube and Twitch channels get completely ruined after their creator went past the $3000 donations/subs mark per month.
- Noos 6y agoI too would like people to work to provide content for me for free, which is what you are asking. I'd love it if you enjoyed programming so much that you'd code a database for me, please. I mean, i see little to no upside of the professionalization of computer engineering. Some things are just better done by amateurs, who do it for pure love of programming and for free. On a more serious note, eventually amateurs stop loving it and get burned out, because it's a lot of work to make high quality content on top of a day job you hate. Just because they are amateur doesn't mean what they do is effortless. And I'm not even going into the people who want amateurs to work for free so they can middleman and make money off of aggregated content, which is what techbros love to do.
- ibn_khaldun 6y agoIn all seriousness how similar (or different) is this to Ted Nelson's Xanadu franchises? The discussion around this post confuses me. Because in practice it doesn't sound that bad, but the comments seem to be against it. A person pays a subscription to "consume content" [1] and the author is paid for it. But why do I need a wallet? What is this ledger business all about? What's the meta tag for? In reality how is this even better than Patreon or "Buy me a Coffee" or GitHub Sponsors. I'm beginning to understand the other comments now. As far as advertisements go, what's stopping people from just selling ad space themselves? Why do I need Google? You sell cast iron skillets, I'm a food blogger. You want some ad space. Email me and send me a check. [1] i.e. to read, watch and listen to things on the internet. "consuming content" sounds so impersonal, if that's the best word to describe it.
- jefftk 6y ago> You sell cast iron skillets, I'm a food blogger. You want some ad space. Email me and send me a check. This totally works, but does have some drawbacks: * High friction. The advertiser needs to seek out sites, send emails back-and-forth, agree on pricing, etc. * Cheating. How does the advertiser know that their ad is really being shown? How do they know that the publisher really has lots of visitors, and isn't just sending them back traffic? * Lower payments. Unless you're writing about something where people spend a lot of money (insurance bloggers, etc) you'll likely make more money if you use something that supports personalization. The way this works out is big publishers (all the brands you've heard of) make direct deals with big advertisers, but (a) they still make a substantial portion of their money by first checking whether there's a high bid from a network and (b) they integrate various vendors to verify the traffic is legitimate. (Disclosure: I work on ads at Google, speaking only for myself)
- ibn_khaldun 6y agoThank for the disclosure. 1. Are there legitimate safe spaces for people who like friction? Or are they only for people who LARP as Don Draper and Jordan Belfort? 2. How was/is cheating in this sense addressed in print advertisements? 3. This makes sense, but I think the alternative would call for more friction and ethical data collection/sharing on behalf of personalization. 4. The last sentence was the most helpful. Who is the "network" in question? (Now for my disclosure: If you can't tell I need to sit down and figure out how the online ad business actually works, I likely can count on my hands many times I've ever clicked an ad online and I've definitely purchased something in that manner far less if ever). Thank you!
- freebuju 6y agoRemove the ads bit out of the equation and push this a payment platform for content creators. Ads on the web are not going away for a long time to come.
- kemonocode 6y agoI remember when the web used to be (mostly) free, with no ads nor any expectation of payment from others. Sites were simpler then, sure, but costs were very manageable even if the barrier to entry was higher. People deserve to get paid, for sure, but I think many overestimate the value of what they put out, and I'd argue much of the web has negative value these days due to the flagrant violations of privacy that come with the raw tripe I have to sift through if I'm seeking to be informed in a particular topic.
- rdxm 6y agothe short answer is no, just no. it's time to move past the web v1 monetization model. perpetuating a model that has lead to the cancers on our culture and species that are FB, Twitter, Insta, etc, etc. is not the answer.
- peanut_worm 6y agoWorked great with Cable
- have_faith 6y agoI have no conception of how many ads should or shouldn't be on the web, I mostly just want to be left alone in my digital travels. I also don't think any monetisation model that hinges on users making micro donations and deciding how much is a fair donation themselves will be a sustainable model for most people except outliers. The situation is interesting because we have had simple monetisations channels for over a decade it's just that the majority of the content available on the web is low value and in the majority of consumers eyes not worth paying for. Hence if you put this content behind a paywall no one pays for it. I don't think micro-donations will solve this in any way. Not that they don't serve some use case in the bigger picture. There are certainly niches that have benefited. I just don't see it taking off beyond that. I believe the majority of people have no urge to compensate "content creators" (small businesses marketed differently) for giving away content for free. If a business wants to venture into a market in which there is evidence of there not being a demand above a price point of zero any work done to extract compensation for the effort feels counter productive. I see a lot of arguments about creators "deserving" to be compensated, because they've put in the graft and produced...something. I wish anyone luck with their chosen enterprise and don't want to see anyone's hard work dissipate in vein but people don't deserve to be compensated for pursuing a business idea. I think that's seen as common sense outside of the digital realm.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoLet's ask the more important questions, will this allow centralized control of information access and make deplatforming easier? Will creators and consumers in every part of the world have equal access to the monetization system?
- sofixa 6y agoHow would it?! Did you even read the article? If anything, on the contrary, it would allow decentralisation of content because it could make running your own blog somewhere financially viable compared to having to rely on Reddit or Medium.
- ampdepolymerase 6y agoBecause you still need to depend on the monetisation providers and they are subject to the same KYC laws. If it gains traction then PayPal will magically come up with their own monetisation provider and eat the rest. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss.
- africanboy 6y agoI think this is misleading. If people think content is not worth paying for, they won't pay for it anyway. If content creators think they can make enough money with ads they'll keep putting ads on their content, they won't give up on the income stream ads provide for a theoretical ROI based on subscriptions And even if they did, it's still more profitable to sell subscriptions and cry that you don't make enough money and have to put ads on your website, against your will
- johannes1234321 6y agoI don't have a problem with ads, given that * they are non intrusive, and * don't track me all over my live. For the first item: If a news article is a small thing between a huge ad it is not usable. There are ways to make ads not too dominant. For the second item: Match ads based on the content of the page, not based on the viewer. This would show me ads relevant to what I'm doing right now, not what an algorithm things I might need in general. This is what mad google rich. They look at my search terms and pick the matching items. Same if I read an article about some topic, related ads will have an impact without invading my privacy. Similar to the past, where advertisers picked machines/papers based on the target audience.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- knz_ 6y agoHow about no? I'm going to continue blocking ads and I will never pay to bypass a paywall around a video or blog post. I don't care how easy it's made, I have no interest in opening my wallet to yet another recurring expense in a world where wages are stagnant and cost of living raises by double digit percentages every year.
- spencerflem 6y agoThe thing that weirds me out about coil is: 1. I don't think I spend 13hrs a month on enabled content. I feel like coil is getting most of the $5 vs giving more directly via patreon 2. The time spent metric incentives mediocre content, I wish there was some way to support sites you love more / exclusively 3. When I bought / was using it, browsing the web feet subjectivly different, like I had to be conserved about how long I was spending on sites 4. Having to download coils browser for mobile :( With that said, ads suck and we do need a better monitization scheme. The APIs themselves seem very good even if coil's implementation isn't perfect
- Razengan 6y agoWait. Why the fuck haven't any of the smart Alecs at Google, Facebook etc. thought about letting people willingly divulge their interests and things they're likely to spend money on? I mean, instead of trying to guess who I am or what I like, why not just let me TELL you? Let me provide some criteria (“pixel art”, “chiptune music”) and feed you some examples (Fez, MegaMan) and try to show me similar games. Then I might actually spend some money on a purchase solely because of an ad for once. For all the BS about personalized ads and shit, I have yet to see an ad for a product that I loved and didn’t discover through chance or word of mouth. Meanwhile if I search for a coffin even once Amazon keeps recommending more to me. This shit ain't working, unless the actual objective is to just track people and build "profiles" anyway.
- sequoia 6y agoThanks for writing this, I plan to give it a try now. I use imgur regularly but their pitch “use coil and get something in imgur!” really didn’t make sense to me, this write up is better. Is there a way to pause or speed up/increase or whitelist sites with this tool/process? This will 100% cause scammers to find ways to abuse this system just like scammy ad-filled sites, and there seems little point of contributing if your money will go towards building a new scamming industry. Basically: how do you avoid abuse here? I don’t want to give a penny to sites that for example make it hard to access content to increase the $ they get from me.
- sofixa 6y ago> Is there a way to pause or speed up/increase or whitelist sites with this tool/process? This will 100% cause scammers to find ways to abuse this system just like scammy ad-filled sites, and there seems little point of contributing if your money will go towards building a new scamming industry. You can manually stop the extension on scammy websites, and it only works when the page is open and active, and stops when you go idle. For the money involved (subscriptions are $5 USD/month, and you get less than $0.46/ active hour of use), and the hassle ( to withdraw money from a wallet you need to prove your identity), i don't think abuse will be very profitable.
- sequoia 6y ago> i don't think abuse will be very profitable. I don’t find this argument convincing at all. The same could be said about ad impressions (pennies or fractions of pennies per view) but there are whole content farm industries built on this. I support the idea but abuse should be considered and addressed, not handwaved away.
- jordanpg 6y agoWhile I applaud the effort to come up with new business models for the internet because of my distaste for advertising, this still misses the crucial detail. Virtually of the free "content" out there is only ever consumed because it is free. It is fast food. It is like watching garbage on television. It's an easy choice between getting no free "content" and paying anything whatsoever for it. The author assumes that some "content" is valuable. This is probably true. (As an aside, I would say that if you're labeling it "content", it probably isn't valuable.). That value needs to be demonstrated somehow and then affirmatively compensated by the consumer. It's on the producer to figure out how to make this happen. But just hoping that people will pay for the privilege of browsing your "content" belies the reality that the "content" probably isn't all that valuable. Ugh, "content".
- chiefalchemist 6y agoBloated pages loads aside, it's not the ads that bother me per se. It's what goes on behind the curtain to target those ads that's a concerns. It's not paranoia. We are - click by click - living under the threat and stress of constant survelience. If we no longer have a right to privacy, the least we can have is the right to pay for that right if we choose.
- aboringusername 6y agoYou do not have that right and will not have that right ever again as a living human, in fact, you never had that right at all. Logging about you likely began before you were born. Your interactions within the world are logged, like it or not. Money is logged (legally, it's a requirement, KYC and all that). I'm pretty sure every financial transaction for at least a decade is logged and accessible in some form to those who'd need it. You cannot pay for privacy (since transacting money requires identification in some form).
- marcodiego 6y agoHow about "Do not support Web Monetization if you want less monetization on the web."?
- stickfigure 6y agoWhat are the thresholds? Do I have to approve payment? If not, what happens when I land on a low-quality site that gamed SEO/titles/etc to capture my click and waste my time? Can I revoke payments? In principle, I like this. But the devil is in the details. Patreon incentivizes pretty high quality content because creators need to convince patrons to jump through quite a few steps to contribute (perhaps too many). In the worst case scenario, Web Monetization could incentivize clickbait that steals focus and tries to cheat the `isActive()` algorithm as long as possible.
- sofixa 6y ago> What are the thresholds? Do I have to approve payment? If not, what happens when I land on a low-quality site that gamed SEO/titles/etc to capture my click and waste my time? Can I revoke payments? It's automatic, and kicks in ~10s after loading the page. The sums involved are small though ( i don't have a way to test, but it's $0.46 USD/hour, so i doubt <1 minute would be even a cent). The extension is active only on the currently active open tab, and doesn't work with background ones, even if they try to game the isActive() algorithm.
- crazygringo 6y agoReality check: a million people have had the idea of paying a monthly fee not to see ads on the internet, and tons of people have tried it, including Google [1]. And absolutely nobody has been able to make it work over the past 20-ish years. I'm not going to pretend I know the exact reason why it doesn't work, there are lots of reasons that can be debated. But the fact that it's been attempted by tons of really smart people at companies large and small and nobody's been able to pull it off, tells me that it's not going to happen. I'm not a pessimistic person at all, but the evidence here is overwhelming. The technology to make it happen is easy, but the human side isn't: whether it's an unsolvable economic, coordination, or simply consumer demand problem. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor
- hobofan 6y agoFor video ads, Patreon has absolutely made it work for a lot of creators. Quite some high quality content that previously had sponsors on every video is now able to work primarily off of community contributions.
- crazygringo 6y agoOh sure, it absolutely works for individual subscription sites, but that's a completely different thing. The proposal here is about applying that to the entire internet under a single subscription fee, or at least a sizable proportion of sites overall.
- somedude895 6y agoPatreon amazes me. I see channels that aren't huge (1-2m subs) that make a good living simply because some of their fans decide to make monthly donations. It's a phenomenon that I haven't been able to wrap my head around yet. People willing to pay for someone to be able to keep doing their job if they could just consume their content for free.
- MikeUt 6y agoBut monetization itself is what degrades content. Just compare app stores to linux package repositories.
- jonplackett 6y agoCould this be added to another browser as an extension?
- sofixa 6y agoHere's the list of all supported extensions: https://help.coil.com/docs/membership/coil-extension/index.html https://help.coil.com/docs/membership/coil-extension/index.h... And the code for all of them is FOSS, so adapting for another browser should be relatively easy.
- jonplackett 6y agoWould like to see Apple get on this as a viable alternative to ad tracking. They could even bake Apple Pay into their version if they have to
- rchaud 6y agoI'm in favour of some version of this. Let's say I start off with $20 worth of article reading credits that can be used across all websites. This would be the same as standing in front of the magazine section holding a $20. Some websites will offer content cheaply (say $0.50/article) with no option to get a bulk rate. Expensive sites like FT can offer a high per-article price, but lower subscription pricing. Besides being a market-oriented way of producing content (charge what you want, not what AdSense deems that you deserve), it would probably make users more mindful of content they consume. And that runs contrary to how our ad-based system persists. Of course at some point this system would be poisoned by digital middlemen like Yelp popping up to become gatekeepers of 'good' and 'bad' websites.
- sammorrowdrums 6y agoI recently wrote about trying this, it won't solve all the issues but I actually quite liked the experience so far https://sammorrowdrums.com/going-ad-free-with-micropayments https://sammorrowdrums.com/going-ad-free-with-micropayments
- ashneo76 6y agoHah. Greedy companies will be greedy. Example: hulu ads even on their most expensive plan.
- user8382 6y agoPaying doesn’t scale
- nvr219 6y agonah
- temptemptemp111 6y ago"Let us show you more ads and we will stop harassing you with last generation advertising tech so much..." -- No, I don't negotiate with terrorists.
- grawprog 6y agoWeb monetization seems like a great way to create a two tiered internet. A high quality one full of usefull information for the wealthy that can afford to pay multiple subscriptions to websites for content. Meanwhile, the poor plebs will be left with ad ridden useless garbage they can mindlessly consume. Even better...why not do it like the Phillipines? Facebook can provide a free service for the poor people where they don't have to pay a subscription for certain sites as long as they browse the web through facebook? This'll give access to sites partnered with facebook of course, but who needs the rest of that internet anyway? What a great way to keep poor and uneducated people poor and uneducated. How dare they be able to just hop on the internet and learn whatever they want for nothing more than seeing an ad? Everyone should pay for everything.
- sofixa 6y agoAre we talking about the same Web Monetization? Unless all sites decide to provide everything only as exclusive for WM-enabled browsers ( which IMHO would be trivial to circumvent), what you're saying is not at all on the cards.
- digitalsin 6y agoIt's "fewer", not "less"
- karmakaze 6y agoI'm not against ads in principle, only in implementation. If advertising (1) did not misuse my personal information, (2) weren't A/V noisy, (3) weren't a source of malware, (4) actually stuff I have a chance of being interested in more than the average person, I'm okay with them. As a content creator, I would also want to be able to constrain the ads that are presented with the content. What we have now is the bad side of ads, there could be a good like PSAs relevant to the content kind that haven't been explored.
- pdimitar 6y agoYep. I never did mind ads in the specialized magazines I was was buying some 15-20 years ago. They were relevant and were not following my eyes during my reading of the rest of the pages (like those awful moving banners). I am OK with the print ads and they can be very helpful. What we have right now though, nope. I am working on my PiHole and adblock rules regularly and I like it when my pages are clean.
- fxtentacle 6y agoNo! I'm still hoping that those companies that I despise and that fill the internet with mass-produced garbage (which they call news or content) will finally go bankrupt and stop. Plus, the way to optimize for higher conversion rates with paywalls and subscriptions is to have even more outrageous public claims, meaning even more click-bait-y headlines and even more addictive (they call it "engaging") time sinks. I predict that once Web Monetization works friction-less, we'll see insane amounts of GPT-generated nonsense articles behind paywalls. Because even if people approve the paywall only by mistake (e.g. 0.1% of visitors), it'll still be a solid revenue stream, if you mass-produce enough random "content" :( And if you believe that companies will stop shoving ads in your face, just because you paid them, read this: https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/success-stories/form/female-fashionista/ https://www.samsung.com/us/business/samsungads/resources/suc... It's a Samsung whitepaper on how using the "smart ads" in their $5000+ premium 8K TVs you can finally reach those people who avoid regular TV because they hate ads.
- pdimitar 6y agoAbsolutely not. A tiny list of reasons: - Zero guarantees that a new buyer of the website (or acqui-hirer of the content creator) won't pump it full of ads. - Zero guarantees for that the website will not be full of trackers, with or without paying. - Promotion of the "content creator" profession which has its place but I worry that it gets promoted as the default way of sharing content. Knowledge must be free or else no human race progress is possible. - ...It's actually quite OK to want to charge money for your knowledge in some cases, sure. I know I would support 3 particular channels on YouTube personally, if I had more need of their videos (currently it's just a casual and rarely exercised interest). Making a guy like me pay will just make him leave. Everybody loses. - The proposed ways of implementing this monetization are deeply flawed. There are huge forum threads where freelancers are happily describing how to deceive a time-tracker software (not 100% related but IMO pretty close). - Zero guarantees the content won't get edited or deleted for variety of reasons, dodgy DMCA requests included. Why must I pay for something that the government or rich lawyers can disappear at any time? --- As a programmer this general idea gets a hard "NOPE!" from me, mostly because its execution cannot be guaranteed to be consumer-friendly. We need a new generation of tech that's completely divorced from corporations' and governments' interests for the web monetization to have even a small chance of ever taking off. One example: machine-enforceable contracts. ZERO human intervention must be possible. If I accept contract X on my machine then I don't care if the creator changes their mind tomorrow; they must grand-father my terms and conditions until I end the contract from my side. As for the monetization model: people will just compare pros and cons and will bail out when they are asked to pay for one more streaming-like service. Did we learn nothing from the rise of piracy which comes as a response to content fragmentation? --- TL;DR: Why must I play a game of dice when the dice are loaded?
- websites2323 6y agoPatreon is the real innovation, not web monetization. I spend more than $300/month on patreon, and there is room in my budget for more.
- sofixa 6y agoBut you need to actually follow and really like the content creator. I spend ~$50/month on it, but i wouldn't do it for plenty of smaller-scale stuff that i occasionally enjoy. Giving them something is still better in my eyes.
- laylomo2 6y agoThere is no guarantee that supporting monetization is going to stop the ad cancer. I pay for a yearly membership to a typing game website which claims that if I pay them they will stop showing ads. However, they don't stop tracking my data, and I still have to enable uBlock on their website.
- Hani1337 6y agoWhy would I want less ads? It's created a great economy online and it helps promote people who put effort into learning to utilize the web better. It's driving the web forward. Fuck a paid model, I don't want my online activity tracked by bank informations and payments history. The current model is fine. We just need fairer money transactions instead of the giants taking too much of a cut.
- iujjkfjdkkdkf 6y agoI don't see this solving anything. Paid work involves a meeting of the minds between the buyer and the person doing the work. This is why e.g. busking is not work, it is dressed up begging, regardless of whether the performers consider themselves to be working. This will just turn parts of the internet into more begging "like and follow", not produce quality content.
- stakkur 6y agoNo. A thousand times no. Free the web.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoI don't think the model is going to work at all. You don't know the worth until after you pay, that's going to encourage a lot of deceptive stuff. Instead, how about a system more like the Kindle Unlimited stuff--you pay a fixed amount per month and it's distributed based on your usage. However, I would handle it differently--when you view any participating site upon leaving you get a pop-up asking you to rate it on a minus one to 10 scale. Rating^2 * pages = score. At the end of the month payments are distributed according to the scores you gave the sites you visited. Note the minus one--that's saying the site was deceptive, not merely worthless and it deducts a bit from what they collect elsewhere. (Kindle does something like this, it's distributed by pages read. Unfortunately, the system is easily gamed.)
- egberts 6y agoHence, the difference in ad-free movies (e.g. Netflix) and ad-infested websites (just about any). The pull attraction of Netflix has been demonstrated for its end-users. Just waiting for the ad-free websites to develop a similar following via same pull attraction (hello, Amazon) instead of a push.