4 ms·
> The M1 laptop at a quarter the price is faster than the maxed-out Intel-based iMac Pro. Even with the "not for everything" guard, this is still some seriousl
by izacus 6y ago
> The M1 laptop at a quarter the price is faster than the maxed-out Intel-based iMac Pro.
Even with the "not for everything" guard, this is still some seriously heavy BS.
iMac Pro wasn't used by people who ran Geekbench, but by people who benefitted with bespoke accelerator card, multiple display outputs (which M1 significantly restricted) and support for large amount of memory
Seriously, let's avoid this type of hyperbole and silly comparisons.
- graeme 6y agoI have an imac pro. I bought it so I could make live video recordings without fan noise, and export video quickly. I bought my assistant an M1 macbook air for editing. It is by definition quieter, and yet reliably beat my imac pro in renders! I would love a machine with ecc ram though. Way fewer random crashes since I got my imac pro. As for outputs, I’m certainly waiting for more, though the M1 mac mini isn’t terribly if you get one of those new hubs. It has ethernet, two usb c, two usb a and a dedicated power port. Yeah there’s are people using the imac pro for super crazy advanced things but many people just wanted a fast quiet computer with ports. (The imac pro is still super quiet for recordings. But the air is fanless)
- Applejinx 6y agoI literally have the 18 core Xeon iMac Pro, with 64 gigs of RAM. I bought the Macbook Pro (not the Air) with 16 gigs of RAM and 1T SSD. Not as concerned with video editing and renders. The iMac Pro can wreck the Macbook on specifically OBS software x264 encoding, while OBS is not Apple Silicon-native. Repeat, software encoding, not attempting to use the hardware chip (there can be issues streaming to YouTube using it). This is the one case I've found, of anything, where the iMac Pro wins. I tried Minecraft, as there's an M1-native version out there. My old intel Mini: 70 fps. The iMac Pro: 240 fps. The M1 Macbook: 270 fps. I'm gonna say it's rare that my M1 Macbook Pro does NOT beat my Xeon iMac Pro at four times the price, four times the RAM. Again, I literally own both. I've even found a purpose (software x264) where the M1 machine can't keep up. It's the only thing I've found so far, where the M1 isn't faster. Everything else about operating this machine is faster than the iMac Pro, which remains my primary desktop I use every day.
- spacedcowboy 6y agoI have both too. The M1 is fast, no doubt, but throw a big compilation project at it and it’s smoked by the iMac Pro. Parallelism trumps the M1’s smaller number of cores.
- Applejinx 6y agoThat's fair. I see that in software encoding to x264, in OBS (though admittedly the M1 is running under Rosetta still). The iMac Pro can reliably stream at 'slow' quality level, but the M1 can barely go above 'ultrafast' without choking. You've nailed it as far as the reason: if you can come up with a task that legitimately needs parallelism that heavy, that's where the Xeon comes into its own. Anything lighter, and the M1 starts to zip ahead.
- 1123581321 6y agoWhat type and size of compile, and what numbers do you see?
- spacedcowboy 6y agoGenerally something like Mail.app or Xcode.app or some internal frameworks that can get pretty huge. Not sure if I’m comfortable disclosing numbers, but the iMac Pro is a lot faster for me in that sort of situation.
- Terretta 6y agoWhat does “literally” indicate or emphasize in this context? You used it above, and here, in a way I can’t tell if the sentence is different without the word or if I should take some meaning from it.
- jiofih 6y agoProbably not the best word for it, but it’s clear he is emphasizing the fact he owns both machines, and is reporting first-hand experience and not just blurting out an “informed opinion”.
- techrat 6y agoYou had an iMac Pro. Filtering fan noise is trivial with that kind of processing power.
- graeme 6y agoI said > The imac pro is still super quiet for recordings. But the air is fanless I have no issue with the imac pro! Just to say the M1 does win on both counts.
- perardi 6y agoSo these benchmarks are a bit out of date, as at least some of the Adobe apps have gone M1-native, but the iMac Pro does wallop the MacBook Pro in several cases. https://barefeats.com/m1-versus-imac-pro.html https://barefeats.com/m1-versus-imac-pro.html - “…bespoke accelerator card…” Are you thinking of the Mac Pro here? I don’t think the iMac Pro had anything exotic for GPU compute.
- Applejinx 6y agoThing is, I don't play Warhammer :) My iMac Pro has the Radeon Pro Vega 56 8 GB. I'm given to understand the absolute top of the line had some kind of problems… still, that's as much in graphics card RAM as exists in the whole RAM of some of the M1s. I'm betting Warhammer makes heavy use of the graphics card and it's that which is walloping the M1-running-Rosetta-emulation. This probably means there will still be games where a previous version with a fancy enough graphics card will get higher framerates than what the M1 Macs can get. I don't anticipate Apple ever making those kinds of concessions to the gamer market, so that's where you're going to see the only holdouts (in terms of, M1 doing super poorly). And that, mostly with stuff that expects real gamer cards. I don't think the Radeon Pro Vega 56 is nearly top of the line for a gamer card but I can easily believe it's better than the on-board graphics for the initial M1 machines. Remember part of the selling point for the iMac Pros is that they could summon up graphics-card grunt for the purposes of 3d modeling. I should try some Blender experiments and see what's snappier, there's a possibility the iMac Pro will make a decent showing for itself for that reason :)
- izacus 6y ago> Are you thinking of the Mac Pro here? I don’t think the iMac Pro had anything exotic for GPU compute. Yup, my mistake. No idea why I was thinking of the Mac Pro.
- titzer 6y agoI don't think we've even remotely scratched the surface of what the Neural Engine can do. Also, the battery life is incredible and stays up to the hyperbole I've seen online. 10 hours of heavy work and takes it like a champ. I can't speak to the all-out performance comparison with a 18 core Xeon, but yeah, this chip is pretty great.
- benreesman 6y agoFWIW my daily driver has been a maxed out iMac Pro, albeit from 2018. I just got my hands on an M1 Mini and it demolishes the iMac on my use case as well.
- matwood 6y ago> I just got my hands on an M1 Mini and it demolishes the iMac on my use case as well. This is why the iMac Pro is going away, it's simply not needed. The upcoming Apple Silicon iMac should be able to span entry level up to iMac Pro level with just BTO options.
- djrogers 6y ago> iMac Pro wasn't used by people who ran Geekbench, but by people who benefitted with bespoke accelerator card, The iMac Pro never supported the afterburner card - that’s a Mac Pro exclusive. I think you’re getting your products mixed up here…
- izacus 6y agoUgh, I was thinking of the Mac Pro, not iMac Pro. Mistake -_-
- smoldesu 6y agoWhat I've found over the years is that Apple's marketing can often lead people to buy tools they don't necessarily need. For every consummate Macbook professional I've found, there's always another savant who prefers to spend their money on a 15 year old Thinkpad and a 2-year supply of Four Loko. It's a somewhat ironic equilibrium in my eyes, but I think that's part of the ultimate joy of programming. However, I mostly agree with you. I think Apple's marketing does a pretty poor job of communicating the difference in their products, and it's certainly intentional. One of my friends ended up buying the iMac Pro for development, and I can't understand for the life of me why. Similarly, he also derides me for not buying a Mac Mini already and ditching my Linux ecosystem for good. C'est va, I suppose.
- jamroom 6y agoThe iMac Pro with it's 5K screen would make an excellent development system I would think.
- philistine 6y agoMight I recommend you work on your French?
- smoldesu 6y agoPlease do, it's quite bad.
- alexfringes 6y agoReplaced a 10 core, 64 GB RAM iMac Pro with a maxed-out M1 MacBook Air and very happy with that choice. Kept the iMac for Windows and "just in case" the Air doesn't work out. But it's just sitting in a closet now. It isn't just whether or not the speed tests look certain ways, you're right. It's also the fact that the Air is just a really great laptop. It's so good at being a laptop that, after years of compromising via a dual machine setup, the Air has allowed me to return to all the great things laptops used to represent, while providing comparable-to-desktop speed in the same machine. It can easily balance in all sorts of couch potato positions, functions as my main input to a larger screen, and can sit on my lap without burning me or giving me "build anxiety" like other laptops, where I'd dread the fan noise and heat of building. I'm not looking forward to having to decide to even have a desktop again because of however much faster the Apple Silicon desktops will be. Because having this much power in the same setup that I can take everywhere is really enticing and differs from past laptop offerings in the aforementioned improvements (and others like battery life or even the maybe somewhat silly option to run the Dyson iPhone app to control my office fan). PS: I think you might be thinking of the Mac Pro re the accelerator card, no?