18 ms·
Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in US
- devops000 6y agoYou should estirpate the same impact for gold mining otherwise we cannot know if it’s high or not
- BTCOG 6y agoSo if Bitcoin uses 7-8% of the power of the global banking sector, how many people are being murdered by folks holding US dollars!? What an absolute joke. Who's funding these quack pseudoscientists, that's what needs to be determined.
- Bluestein 6y ago"Cryptocurrency mining uses significant amounts of energy as part of the proof-of-work time-stamping scheme to add new blocks to the chain. Expanding upon previously calculated energy use patterns for mining four prominent cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, and Monero), we estimate the per coin economic damages of air pollution emissions and associated human mortality and climate impacts of mining these cryptocurrencies in the US and China. Results indicate that in 2018, each $1 of Bitcoin value created was responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in the US and $0.37 in China. The similar value in China relative to the US occurs despite the extremely large disparity between the value of a statistical life estimate for the US relative to that of China. Further, with each cryptocurrency, the rising electricity requirements to produce a single coin can lead to an almost inevitable cliff of negative net social benefits, absent perpetual price increases. For example, in December 2018, our results illustrate a case (for Bitcoin) where the health and climate change 'cryptodamages' roughly match each $1 of coin value created. We close with discussion of policy implications."
- Bluestein 6y agoFind the non-paywalled, full-text article here: - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335993117_Cryptodamages_Monetary_value_estimates_of_the_air_pollution_and_human_health_impacts_of_cryptocurrency_mining https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335993117_Cryptodam...
- api 6y agoPoW is wasteful as hell, but I am always skeptical of these calculations. It seems like an awfully long chain of causality to quantify. The error bars have to be huge.
- meheleventyone 6y agoLook at it this way we know that PoW is wasteful as hell and because of that causes external issues on a huge scale. If we don't try to work out what those issues are and how big their impact is how would we ever deal with them? Putting our heads in the sand won't make them go away and the link details their methodology and results if you wish to quibble with them. Particularly as it addresses estimate accuracy directly. More generally the whole external cost of PoW is definitely a case of techno-utopianism meeting the real world and a lot of proponents wanting to put on blinkers even though this study shows that crypto-currency is currently a net social positive. Literally any indication that it has any negative outcomes elicits very strange responses.
- Leader2light 6y agoBTC is a financial virus on the human race. It appeals to greed and forever wealthy, while destroying the environment and consuming electricity. Government should have shut it down long ago.
- yetihehe 6y agoAnd every cent coin created in US and some other developed countries costs more than 1 cent and promotes harmful mining operations for copper and other metals. Also copper is harmful for environment. We should stop making money altogether. /s
- fennecfoxen 6y agoWe should, in fact, stop making the penny, and devise plans to retire the nickel as well. Dimes and quarters are perfectly fine. The $1 coin gets a certain amount of press by people touting it as a potential replacement to the bill, but it turns out the US $1 bill is remarkably cost-effective by paper currency standards, and should probably remain paper for the time being.
- robin_reala 6y agoWhataboutism isn’t a great standpoint for argument. It’s possible for both to have higher cost than value.
- amarant 6y agoYou say this sarcastically, but it's spot on! Look at Sweden: nearly completely cash-less and we sure don't do our grocery shopping with bitcoin either! It's not for environmental reasons either: cash is just inconvenient when you think about it.
- jlokier 6y agoPros and cons. It's also a new form of exclusion, haves vs have-nots. Try being an international. https://www.thelocal.se/20190624/the-locals-readers-how-swedens-cashless-society-affects-international-residents/ https://www.thelocal.se/20190624/the-locals-readers-how-swed... > Bob, a United Kingdom resident but frequent visitor to Sweden, said this system is difficult for non-residents. > “As a visitor I can't pay at places that only accept Swish because I don't have Swish. And without a Swedish bank account I can't get Swish. And without a Swedish residence, I can't get a bank account,” he explained. > Howard Drobner, who is a frequent business traveller to Sweden, also proposed a tweak. > “Some small vendors, like at flea markets and craft shows, only take Swish which I do not have and can not get due to the fact that I do not have a Swedish bank account or national number. I would therefore really like to have a Swish setup for frequent travellers to Sweden,” he said. Those are people with money, doing ok but inconvenienced. There are things they can't buy. Now imagine being homeless, or an "illegal" resident. People can't even help by giving you money any more. Friends have to buy food for you themselves instead of supporting you with cash. It gets harder and harder to obtain essentials. Human rights should transcend that, and the cashless systems falling into place in Sweden do not even attempt to be available for all persons.
- eigenvalue 6y agoThis is about the furthest thing from “science”. Just sensationalist propaganda. It’s so far from being even remotely plausible. Maybe 1 BTC is responsible for $0.49 of “damage” if you could ever actually quantify it. Most of this electricity comes from the cheapest source of power, which is hydro.
- ath92 6y agoEnergy is not an infinite resource. The energy used to mine bitcoin could have been used for something else instead.
- 627467 6y agoEnergy is not an infinite resource. If you use up that energy to <insert activity>, it could have been used for something else instead.
- Tenoke 6y agoNot fully necessarily given how local energy is. There's only so many things you can do in cheap-energy places, especially without much bigger and less potentially temporary investments.
- eigenvalue 6y agoThat’s not true at all. There is a huge amount of stranded power. Electricity is not fungible across large distances. Otherwise people in Texas wouldn’t be paying $9,000 per mwh during the storm— power certainly didn’t cost that much in other states then.
- ben_w 6y agoWRT Texas, that was a deliberate political choice rather than physics: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_power_transmission_grid https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_power_transmi...
- efficax 6y agolol yes it is, texas is huge btw, but also has no interconnects with the rest of the grid, hence the price rise at a time of zero supply and high demand
- cardy31 6y agoDoesn’t this speak mostly to the US not cleaning up their grid? Obviously the huge amount of wasted energy going into Bitcoin is insane, but it wouldn’t cause health issues if it was all nuclear, wind, solar, etc.
- rtkwe 6y agoThe US is actually a tiny portion of the hash rate in the BTC network. China makes up 70%+ of the hash rate of the network and they use a lot of coal power, ~62% of their power generation is handled by coal power. Basically no where is to the point we can just add power draws and say they have no health impact. Energy being fungible until an grid is to the point of having excess renewable power during the day and miners being spun up and down to absorb that excess any mining will have health impacts. I think the spin up and down is important too because it means over night miners aren't causing excess capacity to be built for storage. https://cbeci.org/mining_map https://cbeci.org/mining_map https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China
- sherlock_h 6y agoAll these Crypto posts are getting pretty tiring.
- diegoperini 6y agoWhat's special about today and increasing frequency of these posts?
- nemo44x 6y agoBTC has surged which leads to a general interest in the topic. People looking for clicks try and figure out new ways to talk about the subject using whichever lens suits their agenda/objective and their audiences interests/convictions.
- sherlock_h 6y agoNothing special - that’s the problem. I consider a good HN post one where I learn something from the post and the discussion underneath it. Crypto posts for me at least typically don’t bring me learning from either. Discussions tend to all be along pretty similar patterns - either you’re pro or against. If pro, you talk about decentralization and money transfer in developing countries, if con about energy usage and criminal activity. Not that interesting
- fenk85 6y agoThere seems to be some sort of smear campaign to smear cryptocurrencies as anti-green anti-environmental Which is a bit absurd as you can pick anything in modern world, literally anything such as computers/phones in front of us reading this and point that XYZ damage was caused to the planet by the shiny macbook in front of us or android phone, not to mention the huge network of datacenters around the world from which the information is stored/streamed. Until there is highly efficient zero loss superconductor long range networks of several orders of magnitude better energy storage then saying that energy "is wasted" on crypto is very misleading, that energy could be coming from a dam up in a mountain enjoying a sudden influx of rain or windmills/solar in middle of nowhere with no nearby large population centers to absorb this energy (lack of efficient long range transmission infrastructure and/or energy storage).
- _red 6y agoAs opposed to fiat, which funds war and enormous waste via unrestrained printing....
- nyolfen 6y agothe petrodollar system is built on US military hegemony, with that military being the largest fossil fuel consuming entity in the largest fossil fuel consuming nation -- "the largest single institutional consumer of hydrocarbons in the world"[1], towards the end of making sure people buy oil with dollars. in a very real sense the value of the dollar is maintained by the fact that people have to buy oil with it. crypto is at least agnostic about what kind of energy you convert into it, and literally incentivizes renewables. [1] https://sci-hub.st/10.1111/tran.12319 https://sci-hub.st/10.1111/tran.12319
- karpour 6y agoGreat whataboutism, 10/10
- jlokier 6y agoLol, if you think cryptocurrency doesn't fund war.
- _red 6y agoNot by printing...
- ricardobayes 6y agoAnd I'm especially angry at hypocrites like Elon Musk who are profiting from climate change and then proceeds invest those profits in bitcoin that accelerates climate change.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoIf you were sitting on billions and wanted to accelerate climate change then investing in BTC is probably the most inefficient way to do that. I doubt that idea ever even crossed his mind. It’s just about the profit.
- gitrog 6y agoIs this bait? Of course it's just about profit... the point is that he should be aware of its environmental impact and the hypocrisy of his investment therein.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThat may be your point, but it was not GP's point.
- gitrog 6y agoIf he did it on purpose, he's a supervillain, if he did it due to negligence, he's a hypocrite. No need to split hairs.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThe way I understood GP they were explicitly insinuating he was a supervillain, so I don't think it's hairsplitting.
- ricardobayes 6y agoI'm not saying Elon's a supervillain, more of a wasted talent (so far). The non-solutions he presents to non-problems are weird to say the least. Hand on heart, do we really need space tourism and luxury cars affordable by wealthy middle-aged men? How does this contribute to a better society? Returning to the point at hand, both EV's and blockchain are non-solutions to difficult (and valid) problems. In my view, centralized money and climate change can only be only effectively solved at the origin and not the consumer level. The solutions offered are annoyingly superficial, like taking away our drinking straws and fake internet money that has no use other than to make more centralized money.
- lai-yin 6y agoGreat now do the U.S. dollar
- teekert 6y agoAnd then $'s spend on armies!
- thendrill 6y agoIf you have an army you don't need bitcoin. You just need to know where the guy with bitcoins live
- pwinnski 6y agoBecause if the US adopted BTC, we wouldn't need an army at all? Is that the claim?
- teekert 6y agoThe US spends a lot of $ on waging war, $ that could have been spend on Healthcare, or funding initiatives that help combat climate change. I'm saying Healthcare and climate are hardly a priority for the US, so why is BTC the bad guy here?
- bingbong70 6y agoBitcoin takes away the power of central banks to fund wars willy nilly. All the corrupt forces that suck at the teat of free money will coalesce around the protection of this debasement racket and so we get these "think of the kids needing energy" articles...
- jf22 6y agoThis is such a meme'y reply that boils down to pure whatabouism.
- effie 6y ago
- HPsquared 6y agoWorth noting the figures are comparing the value created in a year (2018) by mining, compared to the damage done by said year's worth of mining. Not that the cumulative damages amount to the total market cap (though this could be calculated as well)
- engineer_22 6y agoIt would be interesting to know what value the authors place on the damages caused by a typical single family home's annual electricity usage.
- engineer_22 6y agoI did the math. Based on US Gov't estimate the average single family home uses 11 MWh per year. [1] And a 2018 snapshot of BTC according to the paper: price per coin: $8000 MWh per coin: 80 Damages per coin: $3,170 Damagers per MWh: $39.62 Therefore, the typical single family home produces $435 in health and environmental damage each year.... not outside the realm of possibility. [1] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/electricity-use-in-homes.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/use-of-energy/electricit...
- freeone3000 6y agoSo in that sense, Bitcoin generated a net gain of $0.40 of planetary wealth for every dollar mined. Obviously, we should put as many resources into cryptocurrency as possible - we'll finally raise the money to eliminate climate change!
- alephnan 6y agoIf Bitcoin is here to stay, would increasing the dollar value of Bitcoin improve this ratio / metric implying society is better off?
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoNo. Power usage is proportional to Bitcoin value. At $ 1 million, the network will consume as much power as the continental US. The willingness and ability of nations/humanity to allow such a state should probably factor more into investment decisions than it currently does.
- exo762 6y ago> Power usage is proportional to Bitcoin value Not precise enough. Power usage is proportional to block reward USD value, which is proportional to BTC value. But once in 4 years number of BTC awarded for mining a block is halved.
- cpcallen 6y agoThe difficulty is that the increasing dollar value of Bitcoin incentivises more mining activity (even though no additional coins will be produced as a result), so energy use is almost directly correlated with the price, at least in the medium term. Fortunately as the block mining reward continues to be halved approximately every four years, the incentive to mine will decrease as well (though not quite as much, because miners also receive transaction fees).
- elevenoh 6y agolol..
- HPsquared 6y agoThe rise of Bitcoin is a reflection of low trust in the existing currencies. Low trust leads to inefficiency.
- te_chris 6y agoOh please. It has almost no use as a currency, it's the rise of an asset bubble.
- Pungsnigel 6y agoStill has usage as a potential store of value and a means of cheap global transfers. My mother in law use it monthly to transfer money to her home (third world) country, which is crazy easy and cheap compared to traditional means.
- Kye 6y agoI can rent a moving truck to get groceries, but that doesn't mean it's a good idea. There might be narrow use cases, but that doesn't mean it's the best realistic way to solve every problem, and it doesn't mean it's worth the cost.
- fullstop 6y agoI hear what you're saying, but it's not nearly as "narrow" as you suggest. Remittances from the United States total hundreds of billions of US dollars each year [1]. Even with what I feel are bloated fees associated with Bitcoin, it is vastly cheaper than other services like Western Union. 1. https://www.pewresearch.org/global/interactives/remittance-flows-by-country/ https://www.pewresearch.org/global/interactives/remittance-f...
- Kye 6y agoThe concern here is power use vs. utility relative to other options, not price. By cost I meant the cost under discussion: environmental and health. How much energy do remittance services use to move an equivalent amount of money? What about the cost to health and the environment?
- slewis 6y agoThe article is paywalled. So people upvoting this, are you just upvoting for the abstract and headline alone?
- Bluestein 6y agoThanks for pointing that out ... Updated the original comment with a link to the freely available full text ... - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26342105 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26342105
- jasonlenik 6y agosci-hub
- BTCOG 6y agoYes, they are astroturfing and socially manipulating false narratives as per usual with this site towards Bitcoin sentiment. There's no true discourse, as you'll notice anything said freely or positively about Bitcoin instantly is downvoted away. Oh yay, but let's pedantically talk for months on end about the beauty of ReactJS and Node bullshit. YAY. And obviously the key take away from this statement I've made is that things get downvoted here for simply being in disagreement with folks who have the weight to downvote. They are not being downvoted due to in any way being against rules.
- jbverschoor 6y agoWhat about every USD$?
- sub7 6y agoI think Bitcoin is a worthless enabler of the worst humans around but this headline is total bullshit
- cblconfederate 6y agoWell if they 're so upset they can ban the mining of new bitcoins, the price of existing ones will go through the roof
- base698 6y agoMining validates the transactions as well. No mining would mean it was worthless over night.
- cblconfederate 6y agothey could still make money from transaction fees. Thats the plan for bitcoin after 2140
- base698 6y agoYeah but mining is what distributes those fees as well.
- Cypher 6y ago$1 of Global Plastic production is responsible for far more health and climate damage in the US than bitcoin.
- hashhar 6y agoThe whataboutism from cryptocurrency proponents every time the power use of mining is brought up is astonishing.
- qertoip 6y agoProtecting integrity of the most sound money human civilization ever had sounds like a worthy use of energy to me.
- douglaswlance 6y agoWhy are there so many articles attacking crypto across the web as of late?
- glial 6y agoPossibly because so far crypto is a net drain on society?
- tziki 6y agoAttack on bitcoin != attack on crypto. Gridcoin suffers much less from this problem since the computations are actually useful and would likely be done anyway.
- Bluestein 6y agoThey are on the rise, true that.- (I am hoping they lead to intelligent debate, and - thus - improvement of existing systems ...)
- matsemann 6y agoBecause it's worth scrutinizing?
- karpour 6y agoBecause people finally realize the massive impact on the environment that Bitcoin has? You can say "f** it, I don't care", but you can't deny just how much energy the Bitcoin network uses (or wastes, imho) Bitcoin and other proof-of-work crypto comes with a price. And the price is environmental.
- douglaswlance 6y agoNot all usage of energy is equivalent. It requires energy to run carbon scrubbers, yet we would probably agree that carbon scrubbers are worth the energy costs for environmental benefits. Can you prove that the energy bitcoin miners use would have been put to a more environmentally friendly use if they had not existed?
- 6y ago
- m00dy 6y agoWe have been interested in miners or mining farms which are fully powered by renewable energy. Canada and Sichuan is taking the lead and they have a lot of hydro power. If you know any miners/mining farms powered by renewable energy sources, please send me a line to eren@countingcarbons.co thank you.
- jc01480 6y agoI’m noticing some very interesting attacks on blockchain technology lately. I’m willing to bet the calculations are derived from the probability theories we so dearly represent as near certainties.
- williesleg 6y agoNot to mention China!
- naraga 6y agoIt is year 2021 and people still think Bitcoin is boiling the oceans. Bitcoin is the greenest think on this planet. Economic empowerment it brings to individual together with energy extraction innovations is just beyond imagination of most people in this forum.
- iagovar 6y agoThere are literally thousands of alternatives to Bitcoin, who bring the same "economic empowerment". I can get instant, zero comission transfers with Nano, without banks. I assume there are many other cryptos like this one. As skeptic I am about the survival of cryptos to regulators and big whales, I am actually using Nano to transfer money to people in LATAM, but as far as it becomes volatile or if it changed and had feeds, I'd just abandon it. What's the point of bitcoin now, seriously. POW, very slow, very high transactions fees... ¿What does Bitcoin bring to the table? "Adoption" one would say, but no one is using Bitcoin to pay for anything, so the crypto enthusiasts changed the narrative to "store of value". There are far better choices than bitcoin in and out of the crypto ecosystem for pretty much every use-case you can imagine. And the only reasons Bitcoin isn't in the ground it's because there's a lot of people invested with hope of selling for a profit.
- naraga 6y agoOvercoming censorship is not possible in a PoS system, as the censor has acquired majority stake and cannot be unseated. https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin-system/wiki/Proof-of-Stake-Fallacy https://github.com/libbitcoin/libbitcoin-system/wiki/Proof-o...
- qertoip 6y ago100%.
- karpour 6y agoAh yes, the greenest "think" on the planet, consuming 130TWh of energy per year and rising. Do you even think what you write? We don't need Bitcoin, global energy usage rises without Bitcoin as well. But sure, go live in your little bubble where Bitcoin is the currency that solves all of society's problems, will forever rise in value and save the planet!
- crumbshot 6y agoSci-Hub link to bypass Elsevier's paywall: https://sci-hub.se/10.1016/j.erss.2019.101281 https://sci-hub.se/10.1016/j.erss.2019.101281
- S_A_P 6y agoI just don’t see how this is true. Are similar assertions going to be made when we switch to electric cars as a significant percentage of the population? It’s at about 2-3% IIRC and increasing this by several orders of magnitude will have a similar impact on electricity usage.
- pwinnski 6y agoElectric cars increase electricity usage, but lower overall energy usage due to reduced gasoline demand. In operation, the benefits are vast. In production, less so, but still positive.
- bingbong70 6y agoIf $1 in BTC is responsible for ~$0.50 (I don't buy this claim)...imagine how much damage central banks cause by debasing currencies to fight endless wars, funding corruption through a class of useless cantillonaires, exacerbating inequality, etc.... Central bank corruption probably even indirectly funded the stupidity that allows articles like these to be branded as "science"...to the casual observer this might seem like a stretch but it really is not. "Debase the money, debase society..."
- BTCOG 6y agoAnd look at us being downvoted into oblivion. CensoredNews. I fail to see how the comment sections here are at all real when it's blatantly apparent it's constantly manipulated and censored. You can't leave honest commentary on HackerNews unless it agrees with the HackerNews Zeitgeist.
- bingbong70 6y agoI expect many of the people here are one or two-hops downstream of the corrupt cantillon class whether they realize it or not (who makes risk-free stock-buybacks possible? Central banks). Not surprised by their response to the potential decentralization of the monetary system using BTC...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aww_dang 6y agoThe military industrial complex, petrodollar system and endless wars seem more quantifiable than any "climate damages" measured in a dollar cost. You can simply observe the number of deaths. Even harder to measure the lost economic productivity created by price fixing. BTC's popularity among speculators is arguably due to artificially cheap credit and economic manipulation. If you accept that you can attribute these so called "climate costs" back to central banking. The entire premise has so many elite promotions baked in that it becomes hard to approach logically. For me the headline reads as pure nonsense. I'd hoped true believers of central planning and anthropogenic climate apocalypse would find some of these leaps a bit too far. The comments read as a false dichotomy between bitcoin absolutists and warmists. Cryptocurrencies can operate without the energy usage of bitcoin. Subjective value tells us that individuals will have different preferences for energy consumption. We don't have to agree that it is efficient or demand that everyone agree on a preference for efficiency as we define it. The other goalpost of the dichotomy is more like a high voltage line. Instead of electrocuting myself and opening a debate on climate change, I'd prefer to simply note that many disagree for a variety of philosophical or scientific reasons.
- thirtythree 6y agoFrom seeing this, I fear the HN I once knew and liked is gone. The article isn't accessible, doesn't make sense and is promoting poor discussion. fwiw, I realize this comment doesn't help much either.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rmorey 6y agosci dash hub dot st/10.1016/j.erss.2019.101281
- ihsw 6y agoIt's a cash-grab with social justice written all over it and pseudo-science justification sprinkled on top, of course it will shoot to the top of HN. They are distrustful of decentralized bottom-up economics and they see a flood of interest in BTC, and, in this case, the gravest of sins has been committed -- there is economic activity that cannot be interdicted for extraction of payment or imposition of equity. Of course it must be outlawed.
- effie 6y ago> fwiw, I realize this comment doesn't help much either. I like your comment, it cracked me up!
- maxharris 6y agoWhat is the energy cost of the entire USD-based financial system? At a minimum we need to total up what the US Mint, the Federal Reserve, Visa, Mastercard, Chase, Wells Fargo, Bank of America, JP Morgan, Citibank, Goldman Sachs and thousands of other companies and government entities do. It is obvious that amount of energy used to keep the USD going absolutely dwarfs Bitcoin.
- konjin 6y agoSmaller than the energy required to run Ireland, unlike bitcoin. An algorithm designed to be wasteful in energy wasting energy is not something we should be shocked at.
- FDSGSG 6y agoThe US military certainly consumes more energy than Ireland.
- anoonmoose 6y agoHmm, a cursory glance on the topic made me think it's certainly possible, but not a guarantee. According to this[0] Wikipedia article, the DoD used less than Denmark, which is smaller than Ireland, but that data is outdated... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_usage_of_the_United_States_military https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_usage_of_the_United_Sta...
- p_l 6y agoAnd that consumption does not go away with BTC
- karpour 6y agoNice whataboutism. 10/10. And yes, the U.S. military should massively downscale.
- ric2b 6y agoIsn't this entire discussion the definition of whataboutism? We're all focusing on Bitcoin as if killing it would stop global warming or something. There are dozens of different things we could be criticizing when it comes to pollution.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages red flag this article is steeped in pseudoscience. you could spend a lifetime trying to model and predict global weather patterns _with no outside intervention_. the idea that you could even make an attempt at attaching a number to this phenomena is laughable. what are the error bars here, 10,000%? lets pretend, for example, you tried to estimate the impact of tsunamis assuming that we think this weather event is standard deviations more likely due to BTC (this is non-obvious and probably not true, but for the sake of argument). dozens of tsunamis around the globe will kill people and decimate cities, but your estimate will be multiple orders of magnitude off in some places like fukushima - a cursory glance at wikipedia indicates a lower bound of 300 billion dollars. this is not to say that we shouldnt be concerned about rapid global climate system changes; on the contrary! junk science like this actively harms the cause. we dont have to sensationalize, reality and truth are scary enough.
- trident5000 6y agoYou could make up some fear mongering "study" about almost every energy using topic. AI and video rendering for instance which is often for some marginal purpose. Or heating pools, idle electronics, big homes with AC, leisure travel, all the useless crap bought and manufactured in China with dirty coal, etc.
- jf22 6y agoRight, and all those things are harmful to the planet.
- trident5000 6y agoMany I just listed use more energy than btc...so yes, they are.
- jf22 6y agoSo what are you saying, that because other things are also bad we can't have a discussion how bad one thing is?
- trident5000 6y agoAh yes, the daily Bitcoin attack astroturf.
- karpour 6y agoAh yes, the daily "I don't give a f** about the environmental impact of proof-of-work cryptocurrencies" comment. Not saying that this paper is great, but I'm honestly tired of people (who obviously invested in Bitcoin) conveniently ignoring the impact.
- johndoe42377 6y agoBullshit. Such correlation cannot be established by scientific method (reproducible experiments). It just abstract bullshitting we call models. Even if there is a correlation (there isn't one) the causation must be established separately by scientific evidence.
- joshgoldman 6y agoThis is not reddit, please stop with the conspiracy theories
- trident5000 6y agoCool. Lets do AI and video rendering next.
- mam2 6y agohaters gonna hate
- BenoitEssiambre 6y agoWhile this is sad, this is a self correcting problem. Miners and other people using bitcoins are going to get tired at some point of the loss from buying all this energy to keep their bitcoin assets going. The most scary part of cryptocoins is the deflationary cycle that makes these crypto asset potentially displace productive investment on an economy wide scale. This is not self correcting. This is Moloch, it's a prisoner's dilemma, a bad Nash equilibrium where the incentives are to keep the vicious cycle going as long as possible because the first to leave the cycle are disadvantaged. This is mostly a worry if many companies do like Tesla and jump on the band wagon. They may be tempted at an economy wide scale to reduce investment in production in order to hoard cryptocoins instead. This dynamic caused the great depression in the 1930s when businesses switched to hoarding gold tied currency instead of producing. Now I'm not sure that crypto coins without being jacked up by central banks (like gold was during the great depression) are a powerful enough force to cause the type of havoc that gold did. Then again, the potentially stronger network/memetic effects of cryptocoins, along with the amplification factor from markets being synchronized through instant global communications nowadays might make them dangerous to the economy even without central bank involvement. We saw how much people got hypnotized during the Gamestop episode. I don't think unsophisticated investors' hoarding is enough to cause problems but it is a bit unsettling that Tesla and other companies are starting to hoard. If enough businesses follow suit, you get into scary territory (It would also be worrisome if companies widely moved to add billions in gold to their balance sheet but the lesson has been learned in the 1930s with gold). In theory, if central banks stay stimulative enough through all this, you can maintain growth in both productive businesses and crypto. As long as these central banks don't flinch at the sight of what may look like crypto bubbles.
- Bluestein 6y ago> We saw how much people got hypnotized during the Gamestop episode. I particularly like your use of "hypnotized", here ...
- ric2b 6y agoGold already exists and has for millenia, what about crypto currencies doesn't apply to it as well? The existence of deflationary assets doesn't seem to crash the economy as predicted.
- rkachowski 6y agoI don't understand where all these "cryptocurrency vs the environment" posts are coming from recently. The core problem is energy use, no? Things using electricity - of which bitcoin is a huge one - are powered by environmentally damaging supplies. I don't care about BTC at all, but if it were to be wiped out of existence tomorrow it would prevent further damage to the environment in exactly the same way that getting rid of plastic straws stopped plastic polluting the ocean.
- kristo 6y agoHuh? It would reduce a statistically significant amount of wasted energy. About as much as Ireland uses every year. Seems like a good goal to pursue, unless you’re a nihilist I guess
- cdiddy2 6y agoIf the energy was previously excess energy being thrown out, is using it for bitcoin actually increasing the energy footprint? Not saying all bitcoin mining is this way, but a portion of it is.
- p_l 6y agoIt would change economical pressures to push for things like building necessary transfer capacity, meanwhile you have BTC miners rescuing coal mine and coal power plant with new power purchase contract.
- newsclues 6y agoThere is the resource cost of crypto but also an opportunity cost. Given all the smart minds and money devoted to crypto research, could humanity not benefit from other projects?
- rkachowski 6y agoThat's a valid point, but that's an argument for "crypto is an expensive distraction from more worthy goals" rather than the original "computers used for a certain purpose are dangerous to the environment"
- kristo 6y agoIt’s hilarious to see the coin bros attack this article. The point here isn’t the number, it’s the scale of waste, which is astronomical. I would rather protect the environment than someone’s ability to buy drugs online. What other legitimate purpose does btc serve right now other than illegal activities?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- effie 6y agoYou were misinformed. BTC isn't darknet. It isn't anonymous and isn't a safe haven for illegal activities. It is used as store of value and for speculations, like stocks or metals.
- pkfz 6y agoHow's mining BTC compared to energy spent on heating? I heard about using the heat excess from mining to heat houses. Could one say this is ecological? For sure better than an electrical heater which doesn't do any other work than throwing the energy into air.
- effie 6y agoThe question of benefits and costs of cryptocurrencies is interesting, so I read the paper. Unfortunately, poor readability, strange assumptions such as the dollar value of social benefits of cryptocurrencies (confusing with dollar value of mining) and strange desiderata such as dollar value of mining being higher than dollar value of costs. Clear bias towards regulating and policy targeting of cryptocurrencies. There is no mention of the fact that pollution is produced by power plants and directly controllable by their owners, not cryptocurrency miners. No mention of the fact cryptocurrencies are less than 1% of total world electric energy consumption. A proper analysis of costs/benefits would put cryptocurrencies' externalities in perspective to other comparable and bigger consumers (cryptocurrencies are a very small part). This disproportional targeting of cryptocurrencies as the most important climate destroyer that we see in the news seems to be unwarranted. Also, somehow the fact that pollution is generated by power plants, not consumers, is not so hot topic.
- qwertox 6y agoIt's hard to digest a title. It gives the impression of talking in percentages, where $1 == 100%, and of those, 49% are environmental damages which cause health problems. What do the remaining 51% consist of? Benefits to human health?
- ufo 6y agoThe definition they are using is the dollar value of the mined bitcoins. For each $1 of bitcoin that is mined in the USA, the mining process causes $0.49 in health and environmental damages.
- nathias 6y agoHas the author compared how much USD and CNY monetary systems are responsible for as a point of comparison?
- maxerickson 6y agoThe equivalent of bitcoin happens on small servers all over the place. Bitcoin doesn't replace the need for civil defense, it doesn't replace the need for contracts (if anything it makes them more important), it doesn't replace the need for a legal system, etc., etc., etc.
- nathias 6y agoas a money it has much less dependencies, and probably less costly dependencies, although a proper comparison would be interesting to see
- cslarson 6y agoBitcoin is not sustainable even for providing for it's own security let alone from an environmental perspective. Bitcoin also gives the world very little in exchange for these massive externalized costs. It will eventually fail and the ethical loop-jumping that proponents espouse will become clear. But other blockchain platforms are the mirror opposite. They can provide sustainable security, provided without environmental degradation, along with utility that will radically change most sectors of the economy in a similar if not even a greater degree than the internet did.
- dexen 6y agoEvery day we see a renewed attack on Bitcoin from the establishment media. Almost every day it is couched in the SV-friendly terms[1], even if - as pointed out by others here - the merit of the attack is thin. By now I ascribe ulterior motive to those attacks, and I encourage you to also take them with a large grain of salt at the least. The establishment media seems to treat any emerging[2] technology as its opponent, and feels morally excused in posting continuous attacks. -- [1] I half-jokingly expect a "Bitcoin deepens gender inequality" headline tomorrow [2] or perhaps any "unregulated" technology
- acd 6y agoSystem engineer here: An Issue I have with the whole economic system is that external cost to the environment is not priced correctly. I think that crypto currencies is a good thing but must move from proof of work so something which consumes less energy, I think the fix is that you price negative carbon in the atmosphere, carbon capacity and you pay for all carbon you emit. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax Its currently quite insane that cryptocurrency is using energy on the equivalent of the country Argentina and that as a gamer cannot get hold of a Geforce 30x0 series graphics card to use for playing games. source: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56012952 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56012952 I think the current capitalistic economic system is modeled on infinite environmental resources / capacity and exponential debt growth which is simply not true. That system held up in the early 1800/1900s but the flaws I think are emerging in the 2000s. Ie you do not pay for external cost of polluting, but you as an individual or company may benefit short term but the rest others pay an external cost long term which is not priced.
- Bluestein 6y ago> think that crypto currencies is a good thing but must move from proof of work [to] something which consumes less energy, My thoughts exactly.- (Less energy, and is better overall / more advanced / capable ...)
- engineer_22 6y agoAre you familiar with Charles A.S. Hall? and Biophysical Economics...
- planb 6y agoAnd this does not even include the horror future scenario in which rogue states burn their oil (which they cannot sell on the global market due to CO2 taxes and other regulations) to directly power miners...
- ngneer 6y agoAll money has cost. How does Bitcoin cost compare to the cost of the mint and keeping dollars in circulation?
- karpour 6y agoMassive. Just as an example, a Bitcoin transaction uses 12.000.000 times as much energy as a VISA transaction. I'm honestly getting tired of this argument. Just think about how much energy a Bitcoin transaction uses. Then scale that up to the entire U.S. worth of transactions. Go figure.
- effie 6y agoThe difference in capabilities is also massive. With VISA you need also a good standing with the Uncle. With bitcoin nobody can stop the transaction.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoArguments like this are evidence that many BTC enthusiasts are at least as delusional as people who insist the 2020 US election was massively rigged.
- abstractbarista 6y agoEven if true, I think it's worth it. It shouldn't be used for everything. But having a currency that respects how you want it to be spent is a fantastic thing.
- yona 6y agoOk, assuming for a moment this is true, I never hear anyone talk about how much energy bank branches and ATMs consume. Everything needs the Internet, servers, etc to function. That requires electricity. BTC or cryptos aren’t the problem. Focus on sustainability of energy production, renewables.
- p_l 6y agoThey do - by comparison, existing financial systems use much less energy, which is why a popular "argument" is to claim that you should count military expenditures into it (which honestly makes no sense unless you believe in some weird axioms...) Another issue is that BTC siphons off the build up in green energy by wasting it - without miners setting up shop close by to turn your green energy into heat, you have to ensure you have either someone else nearby to sell (lots of real world focus on hydrogen energy storage recently as way to capture such excess) or invest in transfer capacity to clients.
- throwawayyy1986 6y agoThe idea that you could sum up something so infinitely complex like the combined spheres of "health", climate and cryptocurrency into one number and then reduce it to 49 cents! Really?! Anyone even remotely sensible would say 50 cents cause there is no precision in what they're estimating.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- moolcool 6y agoDoes this factor in home heating as well? If your house uses electric heat, the power used by a mining rig would pretty much 1:1 offset the power used by an electric heater. There's even people who build miners specifically to serve as space heaters https://medium.com/swlh/heating-my-home-with-crypto-mining-137d2a29b62a https://medium.com/swlh/heating-my-home-with-crypto-mining-1...
- rglover 6y agoIf anything, this is a good sign that if you haven't, it's worth learning more about Bitcoin, familiarizing yourself with how to acquire and use it, and consider a long-term strategy around holding some. When the propaganda machine spins up and the smear campaigns start, it's being considered a valid threat by the established players.
- magikaram 6y agoI'm curious to see how Proof of Stake on Etherium will affect the PoW for BTC, and how this would affect the damage that crypto does to the environment.
- joshspankit 6y agoThere was an excellent discussion about this last night in CH. The takeaway was that because solar is now the cheapest source of electricity, miners are flocking to it. An estimated 30% of the BTC network is running on solar. It’s not perfect, but as long as the most ecologically friendly electricity is the cheapest, I feel like miners will drive straight for it at record speed.
- effie 6y agoThank you for a valuable contribution to this discussion. Could you explain what is "CH"? Can you link to it?
- joshspankit 6y agoThat’s nice of you to say. Thank you. For sure I can expand on “CH”. I’m referring to Clubhouse: https://www.joinclubhouse.com/ https://www.joinclubhouse.com/ It’s a realtime audio app for topic-based discussions.
- effie 6y agoThanks for the link. Unfortunately this seems very exclusionary. Do I have to have an iPhone to listen?
- joshspankit 6y agoYou are correct: you have to have both an iPhone (for now) and an invite.
- aww_dang 6y agoPlease, no more climate change articles. Everyone has already made up their minds. There's very little that can be said to someone with differing views on the matter without acrimony.
- moralsupply 6y agoI actually love how much the HN community is invested in demonizing Bitcoin for its energy consumption. It gives us, the ones who understand Bitcoin, more time to enter the market before it runs yet another full cycle. I truly wish for you bashing Bitcoin to keep all your wealth allocated in assets associated with fiat currencies. I also wish that you spend lots of time running political narratives in order to stop a decentralized piece of technology from growing. Good luck trying to reach out the Bitcoin CEO in order to ask him to shut down his "environmentally damaging operations". In 5 years time, however, once the US dollar has lost 50% of its purchase power, you'll be begging your employer to pay you in Bitcoin. By that time you'll conveniently forget the narrative about energy consumption. You'll even claim that Bitcoin is one of the most important technologies ever invented, and that you always believed in it. Screenshot this.
- pwinnski 6y ago50%? You don't mean 8%? Or 9%? Most recent five-year periods have seen inflation in the 8-9% range[0], but somehow we're going to spike to 50% in the next five years? Do you hear yourself? 0. https://www.usinflationcalculator.com https://www.usinflationcalculator.com
- moralsupply 6y agohttps://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL
- cannabis_sam 6y agoDoes anyone know of any similar calculations for switching most the web over to https?
- dang 6y agoThis submission broke the site guidelines, which ask: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait; don't editorialize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Cherry-picking a detail and making that the title instead is the primary form of editorializing, so please don't do that. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... Titles are by far the biggest influence on threads, so this matters a lot. Changing the title this way made a flamewar much more likely.