17 ms·
I'll admit, I didn't read all four articles. I got about half way through the first one and was just wondering "I still have no idea what this is all about." Fo
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
I'll admit, I didn't read all four articles. I got about half way through the first one and was just wondering "I still have no idea what this is all about." Fortunately, the Wikipedia article on the author has a brief summary.
In particular, I thought this quote from the Wikipedia article really summarizes the differences between older and younger generations: "there is a profound difference between using a racial epithet in the course of a discussion about that racial epithet's use, and using a racial epithet to diminish or to wound someone."
For "socially conscious" people in my generation (Gen X), I think nearly all of us would find calling someone a racial epithet abhorrent. At the same time, while I understand culture has shifted and I wouldn't do it now, I still find it quite bizarre that the mere utterance of the epithet, even in a sentence like "You should never call someone a <racial epithet> because that is extremely offensive" is considered itself racist by younger people.
I recall hearing about a young popular YouTuber about a year or so ago who was accused of being racist simply for singing along to the lyrics of a popular rap song. Even more strange to me was that his defense (which was true if one looked up his Instagram video) was that he did NOT utter said epithet, in that he was singing along with the lyrics but when it got to that word he just skipped it and didn't say it.
I understand culture changes, but it still bothers me that we've gotten to the point where we completely disregard intent and focus instead just on the syntax of what was said. To be clear, I'm not sure if that's indeed what occurred in Mr. McNeil's case, but I certainly have seen it in other examples.
- sgustard 6y agoIs there a difference between calling someone a word and using the word to make a point about that word? More importantly, is it relevant for me as a non-POC to dictate how this word affects someone else?
- aidenn0 6y agoSingling out a student as a target of an insult is nothing like the situations under discussion. If a teacher said "How would Ronnie feel if I accused him of fucking his sister" the biggest problem isn't the use of the word "fucking."
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> Is there a difference between calling someone a word and using the word to make a point about that word? In my opinion, yes, absolutely, there is a gigantic difference. Though I certainly understand that times change and a large segment of the population no longer feels that way.
- NikolaeVarius 6y agoYes, yes there is. And that is your own prerogative to decide how much you want to self censor.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bondarchuk 6y agoNobody is actually offended by this sort of stuff, it's just one more weapon in the culture war.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoPerhaps so, but it sure seems to be a weapon that's used indiscriminately. It's used against (almost[1]) everyone it possibly can be used against. That is, this guy wasn't someone that the woke were perpetually looking for a chance to attack, and he finally slipped up and they got him. This guy was just someone that the weapon could be used against, and so it was used against him. [1] I presume that there are people who would not be destroyed for using certain racial epithets. Rappers are certainly an exception (or else they just don't care). Politicians that the woke like seem to also be exempt, but the right tries to use the same weapon against them. But the weapon doesn't seem to work when the right wields it...
- tsimionescu 6y agoI think that to a great extent this is a matter of trust in the speaker. When an audience trusts the speaker's opinions, they can easily accept the use of problematic language as benign. But when the speaker is not trusted, it's easy to take what to the speaker seems like benign use of a word the wrong way. For example, the speaker here believed they were just clarifying the use of a word, to distinguish between someone saying the literal phrase 'the N word' vs someone literally saying n**r. The speaker knows themselves to be above reproach and very conscious of their use of language, having often engaged in debate about appropriate VS inappropriate use of this word, with careful consideration etc. They are used to speaking to audiences who sees them in this way. However, one day he finds himself doing this with an audience who doesn't know much about their antiracist credentials, and who is weary of him as someone who seems to be pretty politically incorrect. They are probably primed to see him as an establishment old white man, who is by virtue of this alone usually, in their (real or just imagined) experience, on the wrong side of history on this issue. One of them is probing him on a sensitive issue, and is careful to say 'the N word' since that is what is proper in their view. And here this man comes and feels the need to use exactly the word that should be avoided, perhaps condescendingly or because he just isn't aware of how hurtful it seems to them. None of the parties is truly right or wrong here. The journalist didn't mean to cause any harm, and didn't think he could possibly be construed as meaning so. The kids don't trust his intentions are not easily convinced by nuanced debate. He should have known better than to use his usual discourse. They should accept that he knows better than them these topics and should know who to trust and who not to. Note that this is exactly the reason why rap is one of the very few places where use of the N word has persisted. Rappers were trusted by their audience, and their use of it continues to be trusted in general. But if Sean Hannity used it, who would believe that he was not being malicious?
- nthrowaway 6y ago>the mere utterance of the epithet, even in a sentence like "You should never call someone a <racial epithet> because that is extremely offensive" is considered itself racist by younger people. I'm not sure it's really younger people, it's more a journalist / leftist thing. Consider pewdiepie is a Gen X and he's supposed to have been cancelled 10x over by now for being racist / anti semitic / etc. And what gen X'ers are reading the NYT anyways?
- gremlinsinc 6y agoI kinda wish people in those racial classes for whatever <epithet> represents could find a way to instead of blacklist the word which ultimately gives it more power to embrace it. Say BLM for instance if they had people of all colors saying I'm an <epithet>... in some sort of markting videos... If you had the word become a different meaning instead of "stupid" lesser race, it can become: "strong, empowered" person of color with a strong identity. Example: I watched the history of swear words (excellent show btw) and one very controversial word is: Bitch. It's gone from bad to very bad to good to empowering to some women, and there's honestly a million ways and connotations to using the word. Gay is another word that I think has become more powerful to the community for using it in more positive ways. A word that cannot even be uttered becomes the pen-ultimate swear word for those who want to hurt someone. If it means as little as damn or shoot or crap - then it loses it's sting and I personally think we get closer to more racial tolerance.... but that's just me. How do we get this accomplished? No effing clue and I wouldn't even want to broach the subject being a white guy who supports BLM and wants to be an advocate and not cast out. Like the author I'm autistic too and have that empathetic to a cause but bad at reading an audience or how bad things I say can have an effect.
- BobbyJo 6y agoMaybe as a society we shouldn't focus too much on what those under the drinking age think of as offensive. If they are your target audience, sure, you'll need to pander, but for most, it really is only as consequential as you make it. I honestly don't think our norms have changed much, which is backed up in a few studies. I think, more than anything else, we've decided that outrage is worth attention. Thanks ad revenue.
- autarch 6y agoBut it's not just those under the drinking age who were offended. If you read the whole story it sounds like he was fired in part because some of his black colleagues at the New York Times also said they were offended and that they would no longer be willing to work with him.
- BobbyJo 6y agoSometimes you pull a short straw and end up with shitty coworkers. I've worked with groups of people that were uniformly high functioning and understanding, and other groups that dwelled on political positioning and avoided work at all costs. Happens in every industry, some more than others.
- im3w1l 6y agoThe New York Times is a highly influential newspapers, and who draws the short straw at that workplace and why is capital-p Politics. Do you keep in your mind that their joutnalists have a figurative gun to their head when you are reading their articles? No? Maybe you should.
- BobbyJo 6y agoBig, multinational, influential companies are just as likely to have shitty cultures or teams as any other company in my experience. As far as the gun to the head, every major news organization as of now survives on viewership, not quality. I always keep in mind that the point of EVERY published news article is not to disseminate information, it is to collect eyeballs.
- leephillips 6y ago“I got about half way through the first one and was just wondering "I still have no idea what this is all about."” He says what it’s all about in the first paragraph, and by 100 words in we have an outline of the whole write-up.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoHuh? He mentions nowhere in his first paragraph, or first couple paragraphs for that matter, the reason for why he was fired, which seems like a rather important detail.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>He says what it’s all about in the first paragraph I for one would not consider the paragraph: "On February 5 this year, one week after an article about me appeared in the Daily Beast, The New York Times announced that I would be leaving." a description of what it's all about. For what it's worth I already know the story, but if I didn't I certainly wouldn't have a clue from that paragraph. >and by 100 words in we have an outline of the whole write-up. The article is incredibly long-winded and has a difficulty getting to the point, in honor of which I should continue my comment, of which we are currently in the preambulatory phase, so yeah anyway, by 128 words we know: that the document will be in 4 parts, the first part is the introduction and we're in it! Something happened on January 28th! What Happened During the Investigation? (there was an investigation of something!!, what was it, someone got murdered, we don't know yet, we're in the introduction, but hey this guy was the lead guy on reporting covid 19 pandemic and he started as a copyboy in 1976, imagine!) What Happened in Peru? (something happened in Peru - was this after the murder investigation, don't know yet.) but hey I guess we're done with the introduction so now we can find out what it's about! Nope, we're still in the introduction. There are 963 more words were he tells you his reasons for writing on medium, gets flamboyant with the language about government corruption and gives examples of how words matter and he hates being misquoted etc. etc. I admit I didn't read very closely because it was uninteresting and as a consequence I find myself incapable of quoting him accurately. so now - a thousand words in he ends the introduction with: "I’ll tell my story in three further parts:" This guy is not Dickens or Twain, and his rambling narrative is as interesting as someone whining about how their wife doesn't understand their drinking embedded in the middle of a TPS report. But hey 1000 words in and I have a good feeling we're gonna find out what happened with what I have to assume was a murder and some sort of freakout in Peru!! this is going to be epic!!! He now lists the three further parts: What Happened on Jan. 28 and Thereafter? What Happened during the August 2019 Times Investigation? What Happened in Peru? Now this is truly WTF territory for me - is he going to list what he is going to write about at the end of each section? So then he writes a couple hundred more words - he says he remembers what happened in Peru because of emails, but wait, before we find out about what happened in Peru time for a look backwards about being interviewed on a TV program where he said some stuff he thought might get him in trouble, but it didn't I guess because it seems like something else that happened in Peru got him in trouble. Oh man, I am starting to worry this is going to turn out not to be a murder story after all.. actually I don't think the margins of this comment box are vast enough for me to recount all the details of how he comes to actually reveal whatever happened in Peru! and the investigation, which here we are nearly 1500 words and he hasn't actually said what that was about either. This guy tiptoeing around the subject is weird, is he trying to build suspense. You'd think he was trying to build suspense, and it was going to be the story about a voodoo cult, sex hippies, and a gun running cult! But it's so boring, it can't be that. As one keeps reading and nothing happens there starts to form the suspicion that in the end Peru will be some boring snooze-fest, like maybe he used the n-word or something and got fired.
- mc32 6y agoPart of the problem is that it’s okay to say those words and make money off those words, if you’re part of the in-group. But if you’re not part of it, then it’s forbidden. This duality prolongs misuse. )do as I say, not as I do) I agree epithets are uncouth and should be avoided. BUT I think they should be avoided by EVERYONE. And anyone who uses them freely should face scorn. There are epithets for just about any group. I’m inclined to think all the in-groups denounce internal use of the derogatory terms. For example the R-word. I doubt it’s welcomed to be used internally. That said I would make an exception for meta usage. Nothing should be so toxic it cannot be uttered in any context.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI think this is completely wrong. Use of charged words is governed by Trust. You have to trust the speaker that they are not using the word in a hurtful way - that they are either using it in jest, or for historical purposes, or for meta purposes. However, if there is no trust between the audience and speaker, almost any use can be misunderstood. In the particular example from this article, it's not that hard to imagine that him repeating the description the girl gave, but replacing 'the N word' with 'n*r' was not an attempt to be gratuitously shocking or even making fun of their use of more PC language (and not, as I do believe his intention was, an attempt to clarify what had been literally said). They already didn't trust his judgment on issues of race, and they had no idea of his vast experience and institutional standards of when it is acceptable to use this word. Another note is that, when you don't know what level of trust there is between your audience and you, it's better to err on the side of caution. For example, I don't think it would have been smart of me to use the full word here, because the HN audience doesn't know me and I haven't established my well meaningness and care with such matters. In fact, even if I had established such a reputation, it would likely be a bad idea, since HN is also constantly visited by many first time viewers who would be unlikely to know of said reputation and may well take my use of it as being needlessly hurtful or careless.
- DFHippie 6y agoThis is true for all groups, though: black, white, Asian, gay, Romani, Irish, Jewish, Catholic -- all of them. And it's a matter of degree. I'm pretty sure a white guy in Appalachia doesn't like being called a cracker (or maybe that's one of the C words) by other white guys in Appalachia, but he really doesn't like hearing this word come out of the mouth of a black person or a coastal, urban white person, or a tree hugger or whatever. And this isn't a new thing, either. It's just that people are more vocal in their irritation. People act like this is some new invention. It's not. People have never liked hearing people in some group who they feel has unearned power over them use the epithets that encapsulate and symbolize this relationship. Maybe it's wrong, but it's a common feature of people generally.
- undefined1 6y agoalso, as Stephen Fry famously said, “It's now very common to hear people say, 'I'm rather offended by that.' As if that gives them certain rights. It's actually nothing more... than a whine. 'I find that offensive.' It has no meaning; it has no purpose; it has no reason to be respected as a phrase. 'I am offended by that.' Well, so fucking what."
- msie 6y agoThat quote always bothered me. Does that mean that Fry doesn't care about other people's feelings? He sounds like an a-hole.
- defen 6y agoThe unbridgeable gap here is that the speaker of a phrase cannot with 100% certainty know whether a phrase will cause offense - "being offended" lives in the listener's mind. So we have to fall back to a "reasonable person" presumption. To do otherwise is to cede all control of public conversation to people who wield bad-faith claims of offense as a weapon. If I say something, and have a good-faith belief that no one would be offended by it, and 99.99% of people agree that it was not an offensive statement, but one person claims to be offended by it - should I be forced to apologize under pain of being branded an "asshole"? For the sake of argument let's say I'm offended by your "just asking questions" style statement that "Fry doesn't care about other people's feelings". Do you think it would be reasonable for you to apologize to me or retract your "question"?
- 6y ago
- gameswithgo 6y ago>I still find it quite bizarre that the mere utterance of the epithet, even in a sentence like "You should never call someone a <racial epithet> because that is extremely offensive" is considered itself racist by younger people. It isn't, it is found offensive by crazy people.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis situation is very similar to what caused the chief communications officer at Netflix to get fired: https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/22/business/media/jonathan-friedland-netflix-racial-slur.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/22/business/media/jonathan-f...
- nradov 6y agoAnd yet everyone gives a pass to popular actors like Leonardo Dicaprio who use racial epithets in movies. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1853728/characters/nm0000138 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1853728/characters/nm0000138
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoYou're being sarcastic, correct? (these days it's hard to tell) Dicaprio plays a brutal slave owner in that movie.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- joshuamorton 6y agoI'm not sure if you're aware, but Dicaprio was initially unwilling to use the n-word in the movie. It was only at the behest of his (black) costars that he did[0]. There's similar conversations about racially charged plays and the white actors who play racists that come up pretty often. [0]: https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/how-samuel-l-jackson-told-leo-dicaprio-to-handle-the-n-word-on-django-unchained.html/ https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/how-samuel-l-jackso...
- munificent 6y agoI find the current rapidly changing culture around the N-word fascinating, honestly. Decades from now, I'm sure sociologists will build entire careers on what we're going through. This is, I think, the first time in my life that I've seen a word in American culture become taboo. By that I mean not that expressing the meaning of a word is forbidden, not the idea, but the utterance itself. If, like me, you tend to assume that cultures become more progressive and tolerant over time, this is an interesting very strong counter-example. Having a word that you that literally can't say even in quotation or reference implies something almost akin to magical thinking. As if the two syllables themselves, even when stripped of meaning, still have some kind of power. What I think is happening is that (like almost everything) it comes down to group membership signaling. Progressive, anti-racist US culture has decided that not saying the N-word is a marker of group membership. If you say the word, even when simply mentioning it, it says that you didn't get the memo about not using the word. Therefore, you might not be part of the anti-racist in-group. And if you aren't one of "us", then you're probably one of "them". And therefore maybe even just mentioning the word becomes morally akin to actually using it. You can look at this as similar to other arbitrary-seeming abstinences that groups take up. It is almost a feature that the prohibition is arbitrary because it emphasizes that the abstainer is doing so for group signaling reasons and not for pragmatic ones.
- bradleyjg 6y agoHaving a word that you that literally can't say even in quotation or reference implies something almost akin to magical thinking. The only thing I can think of that’s comparable is how Jews treat the divine name. I’d be uncomfortable to type it out in Hebrew even though I haven’t been religious for many years.
- naringas 6y agodo you mean "yaweh" ?? all this reminds me of the way they treat the evil wizard's name "voldemort" in harry potter
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago
- eli 6y agoHe was accused by multiple people of racist and uncomfortable comments beyond using the N word.
- tootie 6y agoThis article has the best summary I've seen. It has less to do with the academic usage of a slur and more the arrogance and forcing everyone to agree with your POV and telling them how they should feel. It wasn't simply an utterance but their unwillingness to listen to opposing views. As well as some allegations that the n-word had been used much more casually by the same offenders at other times. It makes the academic argument seem disingenuous. https://defector.com/mike-pesca-slate-suspended/ https://defector.com/mike-pesca-slate-suspended/
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoThe only thing that is disingenuous is this argument. It has nothing to do with arrogance and everything to do with virtue signaling and fascism. Telling people how they should feel and unwillingness to listen to opposing views goes both ways. The easy way to tell that it’s disingenuous? Search this on Google: site:nytimes.com "nigger" Appearing in print in his same publication as recently as 2018, 2019, and even December of 2020. So it was fine to print in appropriate context before he said it, and after he said it, but that particular week it was racist and unforgivable. Pretty clear what’s really going on here.
- etchalon 6y agoYes, it is clear. A cultural moment that is causing a re-evaluation on how the word is treated. Dismissing it as "virtue signaling and fascism" is a cheap way to avoid the actual debate.
- gotoeleven 6y agoWhat is the actual debate? The magic n-word Im so offended by the sound fainting couch crowd seems to only be using it as an excuse to go after people they already don't like. Here's Joe Biden using the n-word in a quote yet not a peep from the re-evaluators of this cultural moment. https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-9146840045 https://apnews.com/article/fact-checking-9146840045
- 6y ago
- MisterTea 6y agoBack in highschool the n-word was a daily occurrence because my school was 60% black, 20% hispanic, 10%white, 10% asian. It was also the mid 90's and gangsta rap was en vogue. I remember an occurrence in shop class where a student used the n-word to greet his friend when the teacher became infuriated and told the student to "Please stop using that word. Its insulting to all of us of african descent." The student being the usual class clown he was responded "You mean NI*" shouting the n-word. Everyone laughed. The teacher just shook his head. Another time some of my classmates were singing lyrics to an Onyx song (judicial use of the nword in bakdafukup) and were messing with me saying "come on, sing with us, just say the word" I was petrified to say the n word and they laughed that I wouldn't say it "Oh the white boy is scared to say n** hahaha." Though they finally cracked me and I did sing along and they cheered when I said it. No big deal. Another time a white teacher was also upset with the use of the n-word that she strait up said to the student "So if I said to you 'whats up n**' you would not be offended?" the student casually said "nah its cool now." Times have changed. Though casually the n-word is used all the time. My puertorican tenant (commercial) uses the n-word with his black coworkers in normal conversation. Even my Guyanese friends use the n-word among each other and their black friends. So when I read articles like this I am befuddled.
- kylebenzle 6y agoIt is a function of privilege. The more privileged the more the person feels confident being outraged. Something weird about people is the less problems they have the more problems they make up. Hence the Karen meme. It is pointing out how the most privileged class of humans in the history of the world (35-45 year old white women) are also the most aggressive and easiest to be outraged by "injustice".
- kodah 6y agoThis is hardly a realistic take. Claiming white women are drinking from some firehouse of 100% privilege is provably false with even low effort research. Claiming Black folks suddenly have some strange privilege is also probably false, and though the article doesn't mention it, I'd be willing to bet most of the people casting stones in this story are white.
- svachalek 6y agoYeah, I'm also Gen X and have noticed the same. I have a hard time comprehending incidents like this: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-54107329 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-54107329 (professor suspended for saying a Chinese word mistaken for the epithet, in context that clearly identified what he was saying, on video)
- ErrantX 6y agoI mean, its not even ironic how racist (against Chinese) the response to that was :(
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- foobarian 6y agoI always found it amusing listening to my Chinese colleagues chat, because it always sounded they were talking about "n**as" and "young hoes." They were tickled pink when I explained this. I forgot what phrase they were saying that I heard as the latter but I remember it being very common in conversation.
- Udik 6y agoThere's also a long funny history with the use of the word "niggardly" (which means "stingy" and is in no way related to the racial epithet): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word_niggardly https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word...
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoStill, Aziz Ansari has a hilarious bit about that ("Umm, you could have just said cheap or stingy.") I mean, perhaps it was used in the past in a straightforward manner, but using that word today almost sounds a bit like the equivalent of "Look I'm not saying the N-word but haha it sounds exactly like the N-word so I can get away with it wink wink." It's like the "I'm not touching you!" game that 7 year old siblings play.
- Nacdor 6y agoThe NY Times accidentally exposed this whole charade when they attempted to justify McNeil's firing by saying "intent doesn't matter". People immediately started pointing out all the instances where another NY Times writer (Nikole Hannah-Jones) has used the N-word. Many of those instances are tweets that she has only very recently deleted: https://web.archive.org/web/20210211163617/https://twitter.com/nhannahjones/status/1359903830884970499 https://web.archive.org/web/20210211163617/https://twitter.c...
- aidenn0 6y agoSomething similar recently happened in my kids school district. In a staff meeting they were talking about what books were and were not allowed to be taught from. A teacher brought out a book and said roughly "So this book, written by a black author, stocked in our school library I can't teach in class because it contains the word n**." Cue rich white people fighting over who was the most offended by this in our school district that is is ~1% black, and most of whom have fled nearby schools that were majority latinx.
- matwood 6y agoI think if you place the word in a bigger context that many people just seem to realizing, is that racism, particularly against black people in the US is still common. In fact, in some circles it seems to be becoming ok to be openly racist. People are sensitive, sometimes overly sensitive, because we are not in some post racism utopia.
- lsiebert 6y agoThere's also been an increase in violent hate crimes. https://www.npr.org/2020/11/16/935439777/fbi-report-bias-motivated-killings-at-record-high-amid-nationwide-rise-in-hate-c https://www.npr.org/2020/11/16/935439777/fbi-report-bias-mot...
- ttoomm28 6y agoAren't you doing a similar thing by not typing the word 'nigga' or 'nigger' ?
- Tycho 6y agoIt’s a power play. Having a word that you can say, but others, under penalty of termination and ostracism, dare not utter, demonstrates that you have some power over them and raises your status. (Some people don’t grasp this dynamic and take the stated rational for the prohibition at face value.)
- hnick 6y agoI agree with your take on intent mattering and I'm of a similar age. I suppose some of the backlash is to remove plausible deniability of dog whistling, but it's gone further than I think is reasonable. Besides, an honest person will apologise unreservedly when called out on accidental usage, whereas a dog whistling racist will tend to backtrack and mumble excuses. Anyway, you can still say a lot of harmful stuff without using a specific word if you want. I don't see the point. > I recall hearing about a young popular YouTuber about a year or so ago who was accused of being racist simply for singing along to the lyrics of a popular rap song. Oh it gets sillier than that. "The rapper invited the woman, who identified herself only as "Delaney", to sing M.A.A.D City during his set at the Hangout Festival in Alabama. But Kendrick stopped her after she repeatedly used the N-word - which is heard multiple times in his song. As the crowd reacted angrily, Kendrick told her: "You gotta bleep one single word." https://www.bbc.com/news/newsbeat-44209141 https://www.bbc.com/news/newsbeat-44209141
- nr2x 6y agoI studied free expression in grad school and worked on advocacy in the tech space related to free expression, it's a topic I'm qualified to teach, and I have a lot of theoretical and practical experience to share with students. However, out of the most basic sense of self-preservation I would never consider teaching the topic and barely delve into it, even when teaching tech policy. I think the students are worse off for it, but it's not worth taking the career risk.
- nl 6y ago> I still find it quite bizarre that the mere utterance of the epithet, even in a sentence like "You should never call someone a <racial epithet> because that is extremely offensive" is considered itself racist by younger people. The idea that utterance of a word is offensive isn't uncommon. For example, in the US the C-word is almost completely taboo in common speech. In some other English-speaking countries it is just another swear word, perhaps more offensive than the F-word, but not in a completely different category.
- moron4hire 6y agoAnd then there is Scotland, where they claim it to be a term of endearment
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- moron4hire 6y agoYou're right, it didn't really get to the point until midway through the third part. If you get through all of it, the message is that NYT leadership opportunistically used a tabloid's hit piece on a cold story about an issue the NYT themselves claims they had already internally addressed as an excuse to oust a labor organizer.
- JeremyNT 6y agoSome more context: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/02/behind-the-scenes-of-donald-mcneils-new-york-times-exit https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/02/behind-the-scenes-of... I get the impression that this guy was a bit of a jerk as well, and his response ultimately turned what could have been a short and easily forgotten news cycle into him burning his bridges at the Times.
- HeadsUpHigh 6y agoIt's peak virtue signaling and the low quality of communication of the internet. Maybe a bit of cultural effect from harry potter. The negative connotations of the word itself are only a portion of it. I'm sure once this fashion is done academics will analyze it to death. I wonder how they'll mention the word on their titles though. Some future populist politician will also take the findings and abuse them as well.