13 ms·
I truly don't understand, from a security and privacy perspective, why would anyone outside of China would voluntarily choose to run closed-source software from
by walrus01 6y ago
I truly don't understand, from a security and privacy perspective, why would anyone outside of China would voluntarily choose to run closed-source software from a company that's subject to domestic laws and regulations in China. The MSS is no joke.
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=china+mss+data+sharing https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=china+mss...
This is the same reason that Zoom is banned at my workplace and many other partner companies.
You've actually got two problems here. One is the commercial advertising/for-profit related data sharing problem described in the article. The second is that Xiaomi, as a company with that collected data resident in China on its servers, is obliged to provide a pipeline for a copy of their database to the MSS upon request.
- lucideer 6y agoCould it be the same reason anyone outside of the US would voluntarily choose to run close-source software from a company that's subject to domestic laws and regulations in the US? The ECPA is no joke.
- walrus01 6y agoI'm sure that a Chinese citizen would see the NSA as an equal or greater threat. The difference from my perspective is that as a citizen of a NATO country with a functioning democracy, I'm highly unlikely to be rounded up by my government and put in a prison or concentration camp for expressing my political opinions or religion. You only need to look at the past several years of news from Hong Kong and the Uyghur/Xinjiang province situation to see the stark real world difference in human rights, political freedoms and press freedoms.
- lucideer 6y agoI'm not 100% sure from your comment whether you're making out that: (a). China is bad (yes, known) (b). The US is not quite as bad (debatable but for the sake of argument lets agree that this is true) (c). The US is benign My comment was only refuting the 3rd supposition. I'm not sure if you actually believe this is true. Though terms such as "country with a functioning democracy" make me think you might...
- walrus01 6y agoMy point was absolutely not (c). The US has a vast and complex array of sociopolitical, economic disparity, racism, police brutality issues, some of which have been highlighted throughout 2020. But I definitely consider it to be the lesser of two evils.
- chungus_khan 6y agoThe lesser of two evils is still collecting literally as much data as it can on you. And helping the Saudis with it too: https://theintercept.com/2014/07/25/nsas-new-partner-spying-saudi-arabias-brutal-state-police/ https://theintercept.com/2014/07/25/nsas-new-partner-spying-... US Intelligence has too long a history of its own largely consequence-free abuses too. Someone else having a surveillance state doesn't make the one at home any better.
- esclerofilo 6y agoSomeone from outside the US will probably worry more about its history of backing coups than the domestic problems you mentioned. If the US puts a Pinochet in my country and their algorithms say I'm likely to be a communist sympathizer, am I at risk?
- the_af 6y agoDefinitely. Those of us from Latin American countries have a history with the US that we don't have with China, and so while China might be bad to us, we are (mostly) outside its sphere of direct influence; on the other hand, the US has a proven track record of supporting blood-thirsty and ruthless dictators in the relatively recent past, and meddling with our democratic institutions and electoral processes, so it's the "biggest threat" to us, so to speak.
- at-fates-hands 6y ago> My comment was only refuting the 3rd supposition. I'm not sure if you actually believe this is true. The country is an imperfect union. Although the country attempts at every turn to work towards "A more perfect Union"; clearly we have similar issues that other countries do. In a comparative analysis, OP was merely saying the US is head and shoulders above a country that suppresses freedom of speech, eliminates political dissent and the people who promote freedom and sends them away to actual concentration camps under the guise of "re-education".
- checkyoursudo 6y ago*Insert joke: [internet <- Chinese router - US router -> home network]
- systemvoltage 6y agoResponses like this are so predictable and shed no further light or provide no new insight. They're unproductive and flame-war prone. I downvoted your comment.
- eznzt 6y agoThere is nothing new about the question "why would someone buy cheap phones when they come with spyware". So someone asks a shit question and gets a shit answer.
- f6v 6y agoWhy is it unproductive? Parent makes a point that non-US consumers don't care whether it's a US or Chinese product. Both nations have access to domestic company's data.
- lucideer 6y agoThe original message was saying they couldn't understand / couldn't empathise with someone making a conscious decision to use xiaomi. I gambled that they make the same conscious decisions using US software, but only see their decision to do so differently due to a set of pro-US biases that others won't have. It's difficult to look past such biases if they're deeply ingrained but I think this can definitely be productive to do so. If you can empathise better with conscious xiaomi users, and understand why people use non-optimal software, such understanding can have a lot of benefits.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoIt goes the same for any of the "Eyes" countries. They share intelligence and tracking of citizens as well. It's not just the US, so don't act like it is.
- Daho0n 6y agoDon't pretend any other country have as much surveillance capability as the US does. There are levels to the awfulness and not everyone is at final boss level. Most are random green scrubs comparatively.
- skynet-9000 6y ago> Don't pretend any other country have as much surveillance capability as the US does. The level of surveillance in Xinjiang vastly exceed that of anywhere else in the world except for military installations.
- approxim8ion 6y agoYou're drawing a parallel that doesn't exist. Xinjiang is a physical location that is controlled entirely by them. US (or any) surveillance, especially over data, requires no such ownership or control.
- marakv2 6y agoDon't forget our laws here in Australia. (I know you mentioned eyes countries, which we are, but I wanted to highlight this). Our laws are so damn barbaric in relation to security that it's scary. It's gotten to the point where I nearly gave up on security. Who's compromised? I definitely missed out on a job because I was Australian. (Confirmed later over drinks with one of the devs who I am friends with).
- phist_mcgee 6y agoCan you relate anymore about the industry and size of company you applied for? I'm an aussie dev, and I hadn't even considered my eligibility to foreign companies may be compromised.
- yibg 6y agoI would argue if you are American nor Chinese, the US has a greater ability to negatively influence your life. Chinese government has full control domestically but can’t (currently) do too much outside of their borders. The US on the other hand...
- MisterTea 6y agoSame could be said for countries outside of the USA buying US tech equipment.
- serial_dev 6y agoI agree, people give US companies way to much slack... But then what am I supposed to do if I'm European? The US and China pretty much covers the mobile market (and what's not covered is still not European).
- walrus01 6y agoFrom a purely pragmatic point of view: If you're European...? Consider that your country is likely either already a five eyes member, or a "five eyes plus" member with a historical record going back 45+ years of intelligence/law enforcement data sharing between the various NATO governments' intelligence agencies. And take a risk calculation, based on what you're doing in your life, if all your metadata and traffic was in the hands of the NSA, what's the most likely end result that might affect you adversely? Are you actually at risk of being persecuted for anything you're doing socially, religiously, politically? For instance, if you're a German, is all of your data being in the hands of the BND going to result in anything bad happening to you?
- neltnerb 6y agoFrom a purely pragmatic point of view, a lot of especially Eastern Europe and Eastern Germany are viscerally aware that "anything you're doing socially, religiously, politically" will always somehow include something illegal and worrying about surveillance results in self-censorship. I really don't think that's unreasonable, the fall of the berlin wall was within living memory. I hope that the NSA isn't going to do anything too, but the idea that they can't or won't is clearly not true. Staying under the radar might feel pragmatic, but I think a lot of people realize that's entirely inadequate with constantly shifting political environments.
- walrus01 6y ago
- La1n 6y agoI agree with your statement, but I'd like to get it a bit further. Why run any closed-sourced software from (or have servers in) countries that can request you data without a fair trial (e.g. secret courts). I feel just as uncomfortable about national security letters and the NSA/CIA as the MSS, this from someone who is not living in China or the US. I do think this shows the perks of open source software and being able to self-host or federated solutions.
- tiagod 6y agoCan you tell me which countries definitely won't force you to secretly do things you don't want to in matters of national security?
- La1n 6y agoMaybe ask OP, as they did bring up MSS. I myself try to self-host as much as possible, and try to use open-source roms/software on my phone/desktop. https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted https://github.com/awesome-selfhosted/awesome-selfhosted
- matkoniecz 6y ago> Why Because it is much easier. I am already spending plenty of time on badgering local government about green spaces and bicycle infrastructure, massive amount of time on OpenStreetMap - and my time is limited. I have no time to learn how to and run and maintain my own mail server.
- eznzt 6y ago> I truly don't understand, from a security and privacy perspective, why would anyone outside of China would voluntarily choose to run closed-source software from a company that's subject to domestic laws and regulations in China. They make cheap phones.
- notsureaboutpg 6y agoAll you have to do is look at it from more than a security/privacy perspective. Chrome is the most used browser despite Firefox doing nearly everything Chrome does the same and everyone knowing that Firefox doesn't track you like Chrome does. It's obvious why. It's a little faster, it has more money behind it, it comes pre-installed (and unremovable) on most phones, etc.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoMaybe they are spreading rhe risk, now i can be spied on by agencies with conflicting interests, so noone has a complete picture?
- Sebb767 6y ago> The second is that Xiaomi, as a company with that collected data resident in China on its servers, is obliged to provide a pipeline for a copy of their database to the MSS upon request. If you're anywhere near any scene you might consider not liked by the current government (which surely also includes journalists and the likes), your domestic agencies are a far bigger threat than the MSS, as long as you don't choose to go to China - and even then, you're probably fine, unless you're fighting against the Chinese regime in particular. And yes, the patriot act and the NSA are no joke. It's not like subpoenas are never head of (and the EU is, at least in parts, not much better).
- HNfriend234 6y agoI use a xiaomi phone and the reason I use it is because it is significantly cheaper compared to a samsung or apple phone. Example: A $200 xiaomi phone is equivalent in specs to a $600 Samsung. Also it is likely the Chinese are spying on me indirectly (data collection where the chinses military can access the data if they want to) but I really have nothing significant on me that the Chinese would want to be concerned with me.
- reaperducer 6y agoI really have nothing significant on me that the Chinese would want to be concerned with me. So you give them your email passwords? After all, you have nothing to hide.
- rglullis 6y ago> significantly cheaper compared to a samsung or apple phone. Shouldn't that be a huge red flag? Any time someone offers something too good to be true, it never is. > Also it is likely the Chinese are spying on me indirectly Why? > I really have nothing significant on me that the Chinese would want to be concerned with me. It's not just about you, dammit. [0] By accepting their offer, you validate their actions. You give them bigger reach and make it easier for them to get people that might be of interest. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_to_hide_argument
- pagutierrezn 6y agoEveryone of yours statements is equally applicable to Chrome, right?
- rglullis 6y agoYeap. Don't use Chrome if you can avoid it. I'm using Brave for years already and I am very happy with it.
- techrat 6y agoExcept Brave itself also collects telemetry and has been caught whitelisting cross site apis from sites like Facebook. https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2019/02/12/privacy-browser-braves-user-concern-over-facebook-whitelist/ https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2019/02/12/privacy-browser-... Honestly, when Brave makes the kind of claims that they do, an oversight like this is inexcusable. Privacy should mean privacy, even if that means losing functionality on a select few sites.
- grishka 6y agoXiaomi phones are frighteningly popular here in Russia because they're very cheap. Like, a-phone-could-not-cost-this-little cheap. A 7000₽ (around $100) phone? Why not, seems legit! And not many people really understand what Xiaomi is actually doing to offset that cost. Heck, when you open the built-in calculator app in MIUI, it has a freakin privacy policy and refuses to operate if you don't accept that. Same for the gallery and the music player — you know, all the apps that have no business knowing that the internet at all exists.
- walrus01 6y agoIn large software companies that have whole GUI/human interface design departments, they do lots of R&D and testing of interfaces. Traditional things like putting people with new software interfaces in rooms with video cameras and one-way mirrors of staff watching. It would be very interesting to see a random sampling of 20 'non technical' users presented with such a phone, and given instructions simply "here is your new phone, please unbox it and connect it to the wifi and do things on the internet for three hours". Record a video of their interactions with the screen. In my experience the vast, overwhelming majority of people when presented with a software popup like "Do you accept the license agreement to use this calculator?" will simply click yes/accept/okay/proceed as quickly as possible and disregard what it actually means. I have a theory that a very small percentage of persons would actually balk or become suspicious of seeing something like a privacy policy agreement for a photo gallery or music player.
- grishka 6y agoNow, I'm not a UX specialist, I'm merely a developer and these are just my own observations, but... Generally, if you interrupt the user's flow of thought (if that's a thing) with something unrelated, they'll do the easiest thing possible to rid themselves of that annoyance, like a modal alert you threw at them, to get back on track doing whatever they intended to do. That's what all those consent popups are about. And that's why dark patterns work more often than not. I roughly categorize UI/UX patterns into those that respect the user and those that don't. Showing a modal and making them decide something right now and right there is very disrespectful and off-putting. iOS of all things does this for system updates, low battery, and some urgent as hell alerts about your Apple ID. What you should be doing instead is use something non-blocking that can be ignored, like a notification, an icon badge, or a clickable bar at the top of the screen. Anyway, I digress. And then, if you need a calculator, but the one that came with your phone quits unless accept the terms of use, what are you gonna do, as a non-technical person? Go to Google Play and look for a better one? Probably not.
- duxup 6y agoThere's reason to be concerned about all software. But I agree that software from significantly non free nations is extra concerning.
- f6v 6y ago> why would anyone outside of China would voluntarily choose to run closed-source software from a company that's subject to domestic laws and regulations in China Because outside US it doesn't really matter whether it's Chinese or American company that has your data.
- cle 6y agoIt is critically important depending on your country's relationship with either country.
- taotau 6y agoThis question is particularly pertinent in a country like Australia. Both the US and China have strong interest in controlling our loyalty and GDP, and I for one dont want to be a subject of either regime.
- africanboy 6y agoif your Country has good relationships with both of them it doesn't really matter. EDIT: you have to understand that the cold war is over and you can't replace USSR with modern China, my country has good relationships with both the US and China so it doesn't really matters who's spying on you, they are "good friends" anyway...
- Daho0n 6y agoYes, if you are in a country friendly with the US it is better to have Xiaomi harvest the data than Apple.
- onethought 6y agoBut in context: - Australia has similar laws. - Snowden releases showed the US don’t even ask, they just take it. So it’s not like there is a huge amount of difference around the world.
- frogcoder 6y ago> But in context: > > - Australia has similar laws. > > - Snowden releases showed the US don’t even ask, they just take it. > > So it’s not like there is a huge amount of difference around the world. I am not familiar with Australia privacy law, could you give me a rough idea what is look like? Snowdon case made the US government look bad, please don't use the same reason to make the Chinese Communist Party look good or OK. It's kind weird when something bad happens, everyone just points at the US and says they do that too! The CCP did something bad, Somehow it's OK because the US government did something bad. If you are an US national and living in the US, you can complain and bitch about your government all you want and not worrying about your safety, hence you can talk about the Snowdon case or berate the president, and things might change. Would you dare doing that in Chinese soil even if your are not Chinese.
- onethought 6y agoNo, I was pointing out the "Don't by Xiaomi because you can't trust them" is logically flawed... because you can't trust any of the countries involved with the manufacture of phones. This isn't excusing the behaviour, it's pointing out that "privacy" is not a justification for not using Chinese goods, because American goods have evidence of exactly the same compromise.
- strangeattractr 6y agoAll mobile phone manufacturers are spying on you does not automatically follow from the fact that Xiaomi browsers are spyware.
- onethought 6y ago
- matkoniecz 6y agoI am using Xiaomi phone for roughly the same reasons as I am using Gmail. I dislike results of either, replacement of both is on my oversized TODO list - and was there since at least two years. I dislike that USA government, China government and God knows who else has full (partial?) copy of whatever I ever typed on my phone but I did nothing beyond selecting Android Zero, declining "send all what I typed to Google" and declining gloud sync. (I am already spending plenty of time on badgering local government about green spaces and bicycle infrastructure, massive amount of time on OpenStreetMap - and my time is limited)
- nicbou 6y agoI have massive respect for OSM maintainers. People don't appreciate how much work goes into the map data. Anyway, you're right. In practice, protecting your privacy is a massive hassle. I just do it step by step, knowing that even half-assing it is better than nothing.
- matkoniecz 6y agoI really hope that privacy situation will start getting better - or at least not getting worse. For email I basically gave up (for now) as it will likely leak on other side anyway. But I aggressively avoid cloud sync, and my files on cloud are either public or locally encrypted before uploading. Well, at least it protects against non-targeted attacks. > I have massive respect for OSM maintainers. People don't appreciate how much work goes into the map data. :) Just in case that you have an Android phone - I recommend StreetComplete, it allows limited editing with zero OSM-specific knowledge. Registering for OSM account is the most difficult part. It works by asking about already mapped elements, while you are in front of them. See https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete#screenshots https://github.com/streetcomplete/StreetComplete#screenshots
- nicbou 6y agoI do contribute through OsmAnd. I mapped a few gas stations in more desolate areas. However this is a much more exciting way to contribute. Thanks for sharing!
- vitorgrs 6y agoBecause it has cost benefit. Redmi Note here in Brazil are super popular. The only alternative for that, it's Samsung, but is not exactly better. I believe Xiaomi devices are still cheaper than Samsung here.
- dj_mc_merlin 6y agoIt's a choice between being spied on by the West or the East.
- Havoc 6y agoI’m running a Xiaomi air filter. Not connected to wifi. Even without wifi access it is vastly superior to previous choices. At similar pricing to my previous one. I’m quite wary of the whole monitoring scene but my next air filter purchase will be a Xiaomi again. Can’t really speak to their other products but on that front they have made a convert out of me despite my aversion to questionable data practices. Also apparently it’s home assistant compatible. So HA it and firewall it off is the plan
- skynet-9000 6y agoWhy does an air filter need wifi?
- Zak 6y agoSame reason a ceiling light does. I know, I know, you're thinking that doesn't either, but you can control it remotely through an app or website, and automate certain actions. You might want your air cleaner to start running when you leave your office, for example so that your air is dust-free when you get home. I've actually used a Xiaomi light remote-controlled over the internet to simulate being home while on another continent so that anyone casing the place for a burglary might be dissuaded. I disabled its internet connectivity when I was done with that.
- Havoc 6y agoI wanted to switch it off automatically at night. Doesn't seem to be necessary though so haven't connected it
- esyir 6y agoFrom what I recall, the Xiaomi air filter is known to underperform heavily. https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/xiaomi-purifier-auto-mode-leaves-air-unsafe-86-hours/ https://smartairfilters.com/en/blog/xiaomi-purifier-auto-mod...
- esperent 6y agoWell, to play devils advocate, as a random Irish guy it seems like my choice is between Chinese companies spying on me or US companies spying on me. I don't see that huge a difference - although I do acknowledge there's a difference in freedom of speech and culture in the US, that applies to US citizens and when it comes to spying on people outside the US the difference is much smaller.
- latch 6y agoSimilar boat, but I see a pretty big difference. Every time I have to fill out a FATCA form, I'm reminded of how much power the US government can wields over me - a non US citizen/resident.
- onepointsixC 6y agoConsider Document Number 9[1], and the fact that the CCP considers your existing Irish political system and liberal ideology as a threat and one which it is actively working to undermine. You already know what it's like living in a world which the US is a dominate super power, that's what the West has experience in the past 70 years and it had created some of the greatest prosperity both the US and West have experienced in their existence. A dominant China is interested in promoting their own values of Xi thought. And they're working very hard to promulgate it. Their coercive ability is remarkable in how it's already transformed Hollywood. Their ability to do so will only increase. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Document_Number_Nine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Document_Number_Nine
- amaccuish 6y ago> Consider Document Number 9[1], and the fact that the CCP considers your existing Irish political system and liberal ideology as a threat and one which it is actively working to undermine. You have quite literally also just described the US. "China and Communism are a threat which we should seek to undermine". It works both ways.
- kchr 6y agoThis.
- perryizgr8 6y agoBecause the products are literally 10x cheaper than the same thing from Apple or Samsung. The price gap is too large to ignore for most people.
- bassman9000 6y agoIgnorance and cost. Chinese phones are popular in Europe, where Apple/Google/Samsung flagship phones are prohibitive, and similarly spec'ed Chinese ones are a fraction of the cost. And we can't forget many Euro citizens simply don't care.
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> I truly don't understand, from a security and privacy perspective, why would anyone would voluntarily choose to run closed-source software from a company that's subject to domestic laws and regulations in the United States. Fixed that for you. Xiaomi offer an official bootlock unloader for their shitty MIUI roms which no one else on the planet does and is one of two companies out there that sells stock android phones. They are the easiest mobiles on the planet to install LineageOS on. Imagine being on HackerNews and not at least slightly acknowledging the fact this company makes the most hacker friendly phones on Earth. It's honestly embarrassing. Feel free to sniff the packets on any other device and realise how prevalent phonehomes are and how the eyes can access all of it on a whim if it's going to non-Chinese companies. If you were an activist in the Western world I would only recommend a Chinese phone to protect yourself. Cointelpro is still roaring hard today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COINTELPRO
- 12ian34 6y agoI think it's important that you raised your point, but I don't see that Xiaomi providing stock android phones and the ability to unlock the bootloader on their MIUI phones forgives them from the clear privacy issues highlighted in the original post, particularly given that the vast majority of their customers stick with the default/popular option.
- AntiImperialist 6y agoFor the same reason anyone chooses products created in any other country. All countries can force the companies to share data hosted in that country to companies which operate in those countries. Zoom is banned as a result of marketing efforts of competitors like Microsoft and Google. I have worked in companies which have either Microsoft products banned or Google products banned.