11 ms·
This article echoes a lot of the reasons why I ultimately ditched MacOS. Apple no longer respects when the user wants to update, it's all just a different flavo
by smoldesu 6y ago
This article echoes a lot of the reasons why I ultimately ditched MacOS. Apple no longer respects when the user wants to update, it's all just a different flavor of Windows at this point. Thankfully, leaving MacOS has put most of those issues in the rearview. Hopefully someday Apple recognizes that a bloated OS doesn't make anyone happy, I'm kinda surprised that more people don't talk about the 50 gig download that xCode requires. Kinda insane for a glorified text editor.
- sdfjkl 6y agoAgreed. And on Windows at least there are now mitigation measures created by the community, such as WUMT.
- alfiedotwtf 6y agoSame feeling here. I reinstalled yesterday and sold my MacBook Pro last night. Feels so refreshing to be going back to Linux after all this time. “Freedom as in liberty”
- kitsunesoba 6y agoWorth noting that Xcode doesn't just include the IDE, but also an entire LLVM/clang toolchain as well as SDKs and simulator OS disk images for macOS, iOS, watchOS, and tvOS. It probably wouldn't hurt to split that up a bit — perhaps Xcode could install only the toolchain and macOS SDKs by default with the rest being downloadable on demand, but there's definitely a lot more going on there than just IDE/text editor. It's an all-in-one appleOS development kit.
- _qulr 6y ago> SDKs and simulator OS disk images for macOS, iOS, watchOS, and tvOS Yes, the vast majority of Xcode's size comes from inside the folder Xcode.app/Contents/Developer/Platforms
- MarkyC4 6y agoAndroid Studio is better in this regard, there's an SDK manager so I don't need to have watchOS/tvOS installed when my apps don't target it
- pjmlp 6y agoYou just need the Studio that actually works, the "stable" to try stable updates, then the beta and canary versions to try out stuff that take months or even years to arrive to stable and still bork on first stable release.
- intricatedetail 6y agoDid they pay for development of that toolchain or just "embraced" the open source?
- laingc 6y agoThey most certainly paid for it, as well as financing many of the key contributors to related open source projects.
- intricatedetail 6y agoSo not all contributors got paid? Sounds obscene given how much money they have.
- kortilla 6y agoSounds like you’re not a fan of open source software.
- eddieh 6y agoApple has been involved in the toolchain since nearly the beginning. They hired one of the original authors and sponsor its development: https://foundation.llvm.org/docs/sponsors/ https://foundation.llvm.org/docs/sponsors/ Not only have the paid for it, but it wouldn't likely be anything more than an academic project without Apple.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- anaerobicover 6y agoI'd even (somewhat tongue in cheek) say that the text editor is the worst and least important part of Xcode. :) (In fairness it's been improving in recent years but it's still not flexible/customizable to my TextMate taste.)
- _qulr 6y ago> In fairness it's been improving in recent years Has it? In my experience, the Swift rewrite of Xcode source editing has made it vastly more buggy. I forget exactly when this happened, Xcode 8? 9?
- kitsunesoba 6y agoIt's definitely been improving since that initial rewrite. There's still a few rough spots, but they can be avoided almost entirely by writing idiomatic Swift — the stuff that trips SourceKit up tends to be things like nesting closures deeply and ridiculously long optional chains. SwiftUI has done well to expose SourceKit/Xcode's weak spots. Nearly all of the performance improvements brought to both in the last major release were a result of SwiftUI applying pressure in the previous release.
- josephg 6y agoI was playing with swift a few months ago on my 2016 MacBook Pro and Sourcekit sat on 100% cpu for hundreds of milliseconds whenever I typed a keystroke for some reason. There’s also a bug / horrible design choice in the macos kernel from the last couple of years where if the cpu is pegged, the computer drops keystrokes. These two bugs combined to make my computer lose keystrokes while typing function names - they came out garbled unless I purposefully typed really slowly. I was gobsmacked. It was the worst code editing experience I’ve ever had. Maybe I’m “using the wrong swift features” but it really just feels like its amateur hour at Apple. Did all the senior engineers leave in the last few years? Xcode as a whole has sort of felt like beta software since Xcode 3. Every version they fix one bug, add a headline feature and add 3 new bugs to work around. And everything gets 20% slower. It seems like they keep rushing releases out the door for wwdc then they never fix it properly afterwards. Swift is a lovely language but the experience is thoroughly and totally ruined by Xcode. Xcode manages to make eclipse feel lightweight and snappy.
- bombcar 6y agoIt is possible to install just the tool chain - brew asks you to do so if you don’t have Xcode installed.
- i386 6y agoYou can just install the command line tools without having to download Xcode. It has been this way for a decade.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoIn a way it's worse than Windows now. Microsoft doesn't lock parts of the filesystem or prevents you from editing files. As an example, I like to change /etc/ssh/sshd_config to permit only pubkey authentication. But even since Catalina it deletes any changes to this file with any system update.
- mplanchard 6y agoI have also switched back to Linux after about 8 years in Mac world, and have been really pleasantly surprised. Things still aren’t perfect, but they’re a far cry from where they were in 2010. My wife and I recently got a new Lenovo ThinkPad and Dell XPS, respectively, both with Linux preinstalled. The fingerprint readers work! The webcams work! Audio works! Wifi works! All with close to zero hassle (had to enable a PAM option to use the fingerprint reader with sudo, but otherwise no problems). I miss MacOS keyboard shortcuts a bit, but most of the software I use for work and personal projects (emacs, terminal/tmux, docker) runs an order of magnitude faster. I love having a real package manager again, and I get first class support for most of the developer-centric tooling I really care about (e.g. Nix). I like many was a little tempted by the M1 Macs, but seeing two coworkers have to switch away from them because critical dev tooling isn’t functional, reading about the SSD write issues recently, and now this about the insane size of update files helps temper the temptation.
- jagger27 6y agoKeyboard shortcuts are a big sticking point for me switching away from macOS. I expected I could wrestle Linux into something that resembles macOS shortcuts but it’s tricky and inconsistent. The clearest example of where macOS excels with shortcuts is in a terminal window: Command+C for copy, Control+C to kill a process. Control+Shift+C just doesn’t cut it for me on Linux. I agree with you on software. Real package managers are great. I hate to say it, because it’s so against what Linux has been for 25 years, but it would be great if there was a $99 distro with a heavily tweaked window manager that looks consistent across most apps, doesn’t have huge top bars, and conforms to macOS keyboard shortcuts. A lightning fast Spotlight analog would be great too. I recognize I can probably get pretty close to this vision with a patchwork of already available software but I want someone to tie a bow on it and maintain it for me.
- smallstepforman 6y agoYou just described Haiku
- 6y ago
- mdoms 6y ago> it's all just a different flavor of Windows at this point Frankly I don't think that's fair to Windows. There would be a shitstorm of epic proportions if Microsoft unilaterally broke compatibility with thousands and thousands of programs, tools and workflows like Big Sur has done. Big Sur has been out for 3 months now and the company I work for, like many others, has a blanket ban on upgrading to it because of mountains of compatibility problems with mission-critical software.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoUnfortunately you have the PR of Apple to deal with too. I manage hundreds of Macs and the users are constantly howling about not being able to use Big Sur yet. I can explain there are still many dealbreaking bugs (the 11.2 upgrade space problem caused major headaches taking hours to fix in my testing!), it's slower and more screenspace wasteful but they keep wanting it because of Apple's snazzy PR. There's also a major issue with AD accounts getting completely blocked after the upgrade. Of course what doesn't help is that new Macs come with Big Sur by default and can't really be downgraded. So we have to support it at least for new machines.
- Razengan 6y ago> I'm right, everyone else is wrong.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoNo, like I'm saying there are actual issues. If there were no issues I'd be very happy to let people upgrade. Just a grab: - Box Drive still doesn't work properly: https://www.macrumors.com/2021/02/01/box-drive-macos-big-sur-m1-mac-issues/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/02/01/box-drive-macos-big-sur... . This is our main online file storage. Edit: I meant Box Drive, not Box Sync, thanks a2tech - AD accounts get completely broken after the update (can't log in due to an MDM profile intended for local accounts now applies to AD mobile accounts as well). Confirmed by Apple support but still pending a fix - Apple keeps introducing bugs, I was close to push the button for mass upgrades with 11.2 but then they introduced the space bug which caused macs to be locked in a bootloop that can't be fixed without another Mac present with an older OS version: https://www.macrumors.com/2021/02/15/macos-big-sur-11-2-1-revised/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/02/15/macos-big-sur-11-2-1-re... . This really should never have made it through QA. - Our VPN still has issues with random disconnects that are still being investigated (they switched over to network extensions so this was a big rewrite for them) - Our antivirus only supports Big Sur as of about 1 month ago. So this was a blocking point for a long time that's only just been resolved. This was also due to the system extension thing mainly (and yes they could have done this sooner as this was already on the cards with Catalina, absolutely) All in all this is not at a level I call "stable" and that's not all third-party compatibility issues either, some of them are pure Apple. When I say that it's slower and wastes more screen space, that's a matter of opinion (at least of the impact of these things). But these are not a reason for me to block the upgrade, it's just something I would mention to explain why it's not such a big deal that they can't have it yet :) I will allow it when it actually works reliably. As the article explains, Apple's PR is not always aligned with reality. Updates are indeed slower and I often hear the fan running hard since Big Sur when it wouldn't before. Especially the WindowServer process uses a lot of CPU now for some reason.
- Razengan 6y agoI'm happy with macOS and the UI/UX on Windows and Linux still feels crap in comparison, not to mention the mandatory spyware on Microsoft's side of the fence.
- fortran77 6y ago> not to mention the mandatory spyware on Microsoft's side of the fence. I'm curious. What does Microsoft do that Apple doesn't? I'm a happy Windows 10 user. What should I be worried about?
- 8fingerlouie 6y agoTry taking a look at the "privacy" page under your live.com account. They know _everything_ you do on your computer. It's of course for "your benefit". They know every application you lauch, how long it was running for, and if it had input parameters, they also know which files you opened. They know what you search for (if you use IE/Edge), and lots of other "telemetry" data. Here you go : https://account.microsoft.com/privacy/activity-history https://account.microsoft.com/privacy/activity-history
- smoldesu 6y agoHow does that differ from the telemetry Apple uses?
- 8fingerlouie 6y agoMicrosoft collects all this information despite having answered "no" to every "do you want to" during setup. _If_ Apple uses telemetry, it tends to keep it "on device". Frequently visited locations ? Yup, on device. If you buy a new device, you restart your frequently visited locations. Anything AI ? Yup, also on device. The only exception i can think of is photos with iCloud enabled. If you store your photos in the cloud, Apple will process them for faces/locations/whatever AI use. That's the reason you can enter "car and dog" into the search field on your iPhone and get all images containing both. It's all here : https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/ https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/en-ww/
- crazygringo 6y ago> Apple no longer respects when the user wants to update Huh? You set exactly if, how and when to update in System Preferences. You can set it to never, always, to ask, to download but not install, etc. It's been that way for as long as I can remember, and Big Sur doesn't appear to have changed anything. All the checkboxes are still there.
- radley 6y ago> All the checkboxes are still there But they don't do anything. I have had all of the checkboxes off for years and I still get "Update Now" notifications. The only work-around is to say "Update Tonight" because it won't work and will buy me a few days before I get another pushy "Update Now".
- AlphaSite 6y agoThose only turn off auto updating not update notifications, which you could argue should be an option, but I disagree people are entirely too good at not looking for updates if they don’t have too (out of sight out of mind and all).
- crazygringo 6y agoThey prevent the auto updating so they absolutely do something. They do exactly what they say. Notifications are another matter. And if users didn't get notifications how would they even know when there were updates? Because updates include security patches it's important to nudge people towards updating.
- randallsquared 6y agoIf you click on the left side of the notification, it opens System Preferences, which you can just close again or ignore. However, while this avoids setting any attempt to update overnight, it doesn't actually stop you from getting another prompt the next day or whatever.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThey intentionally broke ignoring updates. You used to be able to ignore updates through a terminal command so you can keep everything else untouched and still use update notifications or auto-updates for unrelated updates. Since Catalina, this is intentionally broken, so now you have a constant red badge on the System Preferences icon and regular notifications to update to macOS Big Shit, which in the end causes the user to ignore other updates (like security updates) they would actually want to install.
- ksec 6y ago>it's all just a different flavor of Windows at this point. That is giving too much credit to Microsoft or Windows. Edit: Windows 10X [1] is quite good though. I also think the discussion completely miss the key point of this update - > There's a risk of damage to the notebook if you are using a non-compliant powered USB-C hub or a dock. USB-C. For crying out loud USB-C, Again. Despite all the evidence the vocal Internet and HN still think USB-C as the holy grail. How they should be able to change using a single cable. ( Which is not true ). I really hope the rumour of MagSafe coming back is true. [1] https://youtu.be/EPirgHua2sE https://youtu.be/EPirgHua2sE
- cproctor 6y agoI've been a mac user since 2002. I've been getting tired of fighting for access to my own system with each successive OS update. I upgraded to Bug Sur last week, and will be switching permanently to Unix or Linux within a week.
- pjmlp 6y agoI thought you were already on UNIX. https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3668.htm https://www.opengroup.org/openbrand/register/brand3668.htm
- sumanthvepa 6y agoWell 50gb for a complete SDK and compiler suite and IDE isn't that large. Visual Studio, the comparable IDE for windows starts at around 20GB but can easily exceed 100GB if you include all the features of the product. For Linux, a complete development tool chain for C++, Java, and Python with all the associated libraries will easily exceed 20GB. So Xcode is in the ball park. The difference between Xcode and Linux toolchains is that the latter are broken up into smaller pieces that can be independently updated and Linux has package managers that handle those updates gracefully.
- smoldesu 6y agoYou're partially correct. It's been a while since I've used Visual Studio, but I've heard that a "full" installation will occupy close to 30 gigs, and the default install uses less than 2. Still pretty large, but the 100gb mark might be a bit of a stretch. It's definitely a stretch on the Linux side of things though, my dev toolchains and associated libraries barely occupy 2 gigs, much less 20. Maybe I'm not quite "enterprise ready" though ;)
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoWhen you describe it this way, and I think it is an accurate perspective, it feels like the situation calls for a "new" OS to fill the space the others have abandoned. An OS for people who actually understand something about computers but are not just trying to exploit that knowledge for money. IMO, the market these OS are targeting generally has no idea what "bloat" even means in the context of computers. The exceptions include people who do understand the concept but are happy to trade bloat for profit.
- smoldesu 6y agoNobody wins when the public isn't educated, that much I can agree with. Our goal needs to be shifting to a more equitable digital world, where people aren't "the product" so to speak. That begins by putting the user in control of their own computer, even if it isn't something they're fully capable of understanding or managing themselves. It's always safer for someone to blindly use open source software instead of proprietary software. If the end user truly "doesn't care", then they ultimately won't notice the difference. Eliminating the silly social pressures around computing will hopefully pave the way for a more empowered, creative and effective user.
- mstade 6y agoFor us developers and tinkerers that like to abuse our systems every which way: I’m inclined to agree with you. For everyone else: I’m not so sure. MacOS (and iOS) has made it super simple for me to help my parents and other lesser tech literate people I know, and really hard for them to screw up (too badly.) I bet there’s a better middle ground to be found, but I’m not yet convinced that macOS is fundamentally broken beyond repair. I’m on the fence, currently.
- zepto 6y ago> Apple no longer respects when the user wants to update, What do you mean by this? I’ve never seen anything forcing me to update. > I'm kinda surprised that more people don't talk about the 50 gig download that xCode requires. Kinda insane for a glorified text editor. A glorified text editor which also includes - A machine learning model builder - Two complete visual UI builders - A 3D game asset previewer - Simulators for 4 different classes of hardware device. - Instruments - an absurdly full featured profiling and debugging system. And those are just some of the more obvious features. You can argue that you’d like a glorified text editor instead of XCode, but it’s weird to say that’s what XCode is.
- coldtea 6y ago>Thankfully, leaving MacOS has put most of those issues in the rearview. In what way, except in the: "I can short of build myself exactly the functionality I want from disparate parts and endless customization in some Linux distro, losing other things in the process, and with the end being even more of a hodgepodge (e.g. of UI toolkits and design sensibilities), and equally subject to change with the creators of this or that distro or DE are bored and want to rewrite/redesign everything for no good reason".