19 ms·
Users are losing out against Big Sur’s sealed System
- bredren 6y ago> What this month has demonstrated, reiterated and rubbed in until the wounds bleed again, is how massive and debilitating updating Big Sur has become. This is over the top. Most users are not noticing 3gb vs 1gb difference per download or the delta between what was and what is for short updates. They are just glad it’s getting done without messing with it.
- random5634 6y agoSeriously - my wife is on MacOS - and has never mentioned to me that her wounds have been rubbed until they bleed (??). Where does this type of language come from? If a MacOS update is so bad for you that you need medical treatment I don't know what to tell you.
- breakfastduck 6y ago'Not everyone is happy with the latest version of macOS' doesn't get clicks because I don't think there's a single OS update that everyone likes.
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agoFor a good many users, internet bandwidth doesn't grow on them trees. There's quite a bit of world outside of continental US, and even continental US got them so-called rural areas, last I heard. Those sure as hell gonna notice.
- eq1 6y agoI appreciate your point that not everyone has great internet but let’s also keep in mind that services like Netflix consume about 1GB/hr SD and 3GB/hour HD, and Netflix has over 200 million customers world wide. 1GB just isn’t what it used to be.
- mdoms 6y agoDo you think that 200 million Netflix users comprises the same set of people that are bandwidth constrained? I don't see how that's relevant to the point whatsoever.
- eq1 6y agoI was just putting 1GB into context for 2021. My point is there is a substantial number of people that are perfectly fine using 1GB/hr for just one of the things they do online. So the requirement of a few GB every few months is not likely to even register for an even larger segment of the population, regardless of platform. Of course there are those that this will matter to. And for those perhaps Apple, a premium brand, is not the best solution. But of course they will need to define “best” for their own context. Edit: And of course there are contexts where the long upgrade time can matter a lot, like a help desk. They won’t care about the data but they may care about upgrade latency. Again I just don’t think the Magnitude of data is going to be an issue for Apple’s target demographic.
- monocasa 6y ago> And for those perhaps Apple, a premium brand, is not the best solution. It's not a question of paying for better internet. There are places in the US where the best internet you can get has a 10GB/Month cap.
- dsabanin 6y agoWell maybe then the problem is with the ISPs and the unusable service they provide. Maybe their customers deserve better. I'm sure macOS updates are not the only thing that will benefit from the proper internet connection. If you think about it – Apple is building for the future, not optimising for the past. On HN posts about crappy ISPs are a regular occasion, but in this case the blame shifts on Apple for some reason. I agree, small delta updates would be the best, and I'm sure they'll get there, but let's be honest — 1, 2 or 3GBs is not a big difference with a proper connection.
- 6y ago
- nottorp 6y agoFunny because when I read the article I thought "he's in the US on a metered expensive connection". 1 Gb... 3 Gb... not much of a difference for my internet pipe.
- viktorcode 6y agoMany people outside of US don't know what "data cap" means. So, for them bandwidth do grows on them trees.
- InvertedRhodium 6y agoI can assure you that the entire population of Australia is intimately familiar with the concept.
- hda2 6y agoAs are most of people on this planet. GP's insinuation that most people aren't limited by datacaps is false.
- brokenmachine 6y agoI'm in Australia and unlimited on our amazing NBN.
- ridgeguy 6y agoI agree. My wife and I are facing the transition to a fixed income. We'll move to less expensive digs soon, in a rural area. We're both on Macs & iPhones. I'm worried about data charges for MacOS & iOS updates. No clear solution ATM.
- vinay_ys 6y agoI just did this update and it took roughly 15 minutes after I hit 'reboot now' till I was able to login and resume my work. All of the download and preparation work happened in the background without interrupting my work.
- carlosrg 6y agoIf they haven't noticed by now, they'll notice soon that even minor updates like 12.2.2 takes 40+ minutes to install, no matter the download size difference.
- acdha 6y agoThey won’t because they don’t take 40+ minutes on a normal system and most people are going to start the morning with the “your Mac was restarted to install an update” message and no idea how long it took.
- jldugger 6y agoYou all haven't noticed it takes 45 minutes of downtime to update macOS? It's not just the download, but there's a lot of time spent post-reboot actually applying that much data.
- 0x0 6y agoEven iOS can do delta updates, sometimes in the size of only a dozen megabytes to download, and I had the impression they've been using sealed system volumes for much longer. Hopefully Apple can get macOS up to par soon...?
- smoldesu 6y agoThis article echoes a lot of the reasons why I ultimately ditched MacOS. Apple no longer respects when the user wants to update, it's all just a different flavor of Windows at this point. Thankfully, leaving MacOS has put most of those issues in the rearview. Hopefully someday Apple recognizes that a bloated OS doesn't make anyone happy, I'm kinda surprised that more people don't talk about the 50 gig download that xCode requires. Kinda insane for a glorified text editor.
- sdfjkl 6y agoAgreed. And on Windows at least there are now mitigation measures created by the community, such as WUMT.
- alfiedotwtf 6y agoSame feeling here. I reinstalled yesterday and sold my MacBook Pro last night. Feels so refreshing to be going back to Linux after all this time. “Freedom as in liberty”
- kitsunesoba 6y agoWorth noting that Xcode doesn't just include the IDE, but also an entire LLVM/clang toolchain as well as SDKs and simulator OS disk images for macOS, iOS, watchOS, and tvOS. It probably wouldn't hurt to split that up a bit — perhaps Xcode could install only the toolchain and macOS SDKs by default with the rest being downloadable on demand, but there's definitely a lot more going on there than just IDE/text editor. It's an all-in-one appleOS development kit.
- _qulr 6y ago> SDKs and simulator OS disk images for macOS, iOS, watchOS, and tvOS Yes, the vast majority of Xcode's size comes from inside the folder Xcode.app/Contents/Developer/Platforms
- MarkyC4 6y agoAndroid Studio is better in this regard, there's an SDK manager so I don't need to have watchOS/tvOS installed when my apps don't target it
- codemac 6y agoNormally coworkers are excited to update and get new features. This time everyone was talking about how much they didn't want to, and how scared they were. Then the bugs and issues were a solid month of sadness, very rough release for Apple when looking from afar. Are there any big features of the OS that folks are excited about? The bugs will get fixed over time. Here I am on linux 5.11 with the ion window manager from forever ago, using emacs and firefox like I did with mozilla in the 90s. Happily getting less religious about the set up though.
- AmVess 6y agoI use Windows and MacOS, and I wince every time either of them has an update. For one, MS doesn't test updates anymore. You may get something pleasant like losing the ability to print, or having all your network cards vanish. I had a stack of Mac Minis years ago that I used for various things. One update bricked half of them. I was able to fix them easily, but it should not have happened at all. I installed from scratch on one of them, and an update bricked it. I did nothing to the computer in between the fresh install and pressing the update button. Neat. The bottom line is Apple and MS have long ago stopped caring about the quality of their products.
- techsupporter 6y agoMicrosoft famously canned their entire group of people who do testing (SDETs). If the problem you hit isn't caught by an automated test at build, Microsoft employees running it in some form of "dogfood," or the people running beta builds, it is getting shipped. Maybe that's good enough. Maybe people are getting used to software coming out with multiple updates per quarter to fix some "random glitch." I look at it as the computing industry getting away from the roles and pace that made computers reliable instead of just functional. We used to have Operations staff to keep a service reliable; we used to have Testing staff to make sure a code base was reliable. They had their own failings, but to cut them out entirely did wonders for stock prices and not much for the end user experience. But maybe being able to launch a pre-VC startup with one person and a stack of cloud services is a better trade-off.
- saltminer 6y ago
- wlesieutre 6y agoOn the plus side compared to its main competitor, when you uncheck “Automatically keep my Mac up to date,” it won’t spontaneously reboot your computer and kick off an update while you need to use it. I had no idea updates got slower in Big Sur, because I hit the install button and go to bed. It could take 8 hours for all I care.
- intricatedetail 6y agoI think M$ did this as a favour for people who need to weasel out of meetings etc. "Sorry guys Windows triggered an update." and that will sound plausible where in reality you had to close the laptop to spread a line on the lid.
- trevorishere 6y agoBig Sur updates are as bad as applying any patch to Windows Server 2016. But I agree, less of an issue given it attempts to auto update overnight.
- will4274 6y agoWindows also updates overnight.
- craftinator 6y ago> Windows also updates overnight. Lol not for me.
- mmis1000 6y agoIt tries to guess when will you use the computer(you can also change it in the config), except it did not work for everyone.
- wlesieutre 6y agoMost painful thing in Big Sur for me is all the paid major updates to utilities because it broke compatibility with a bunch of stuff. Even bigger headache for the developers of said utilities, but they’re at least getting paid for it.
- santamex 6y agoImagine the environmental impact of this design decision. 2-3gb download. Installation time of half an hour. Millions of macs. Crazy.
- katbyte 6y agoImagine the environmental impact of downloading all dependencies in a large project every CI run? and running it every commit of a pr? sometimes totalling in multi gigabyes. Crazy. If your going to apply that logic, take a closer look at a lot of build chains out there.
- throwsdadsd 6y agoThis is whataboutism. There is no way Apple's own development process was so wasteful as the waste they will bring to the millions of their own users. If anything, the moment a company notices waste it goes towards reducing it.
- wnoise 6y agoYes, that's bad too.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- InvertedRhodium 6y agoThis is why we have local cache.
- buildbot 6y agoIt’s actually basically nothing if you do the math… Let’s assume 50 million macs for a half hour at an average wattage of 20W TDP, wolfram alpha tells me worth that’s 360 metric tons of co2 , or about 24 USA citizens worth of co2 for a year. 24 <<< 300 million people in the USA, apple isn’t having much impact. I’d argue windows would be far worse anyway…
- stevenhuang 6y ago
- WesolyKubeczek 6y agomacOS can be booted from a .dmg for decades already, why make a "sealed" "read-only" volume if the updater then unseals it, basically copies all files from the update package into it, those files including generated stuff like the shared dyld cache, and then re-seals the volume again, recalculating all the checksums? All that work the updater does seems really superfluous, since the System volume is declared "immutable". Why replace files on it? Just drop a .dmg, boot from it.
- kitsunesoba 6y agoI don't know enough about macOS system internals to confidently speak about them, but my guess is that there's some kind of legacy cruft/holdover that's preventing a direct disk image replacement for updates. Wouldn't be surprised if this were fixed in the next major release or two, likely paired with dropping support for something.
- tekstar 6y agoMy ~2013 macbook pro has this issue where, if AppleThunderboltNHI.kext is loaded, it will crash and restart every couple minutes on batteries. I'm not the only one with this issue. If you google that kext you'll see it's an issue with a lot of us and it's a shame that it's such a dumb problem because otherwise this 9 year old laptop is absolutely great to work with. SSD, 2.3 GHz Quad-Core Intel Core i7, 16 GB RAM. Magsafe and good keyboard. So anyways, this locked-down system volume is a real problem because typically after a system update I reboot into recovery mode, disable CSR, remove the kext, re-enable CSR and then I'm good until the next OS update where the kext is re-added and my computer starts to crash again. It seems like a bigger issue now to remove that kext, to deal with Apple's own software problem, to keep using my old laptop. What a pain.
- katbyte 6y agoI believe it is possible to unseal the volume and disable these protections, a quick google seems to indicate this. Apple usually does seem to provide (a maybe annoying) way to bypass these sort security measures.
- bombcar 6y agoHe described how he does exactly this - and has to reapply it after every update.
- tekstar 6y agoI'm still on Catalina. I've read reports that on Big Sur you cannot remove the kext and re-enable CSR. Seems the only solution might be to leave csr disabled, which would be unfortunate.
- peterlvilim 6y agoI don’t believe you can turn on file vault if you do this (full disk encryption)
- uncledave 6y agoI hadn’t even noticed this to be honest. And I’m not particularly bothered. It just works for me. I’m sure at some point it’ll poke me in the eye but so far this has been the least painful OS for me to use for years.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoYes it's running smoother than ever on all my machines.
- Shivetya 6y agoI really still like my iMac and Mac OS as a whole is still very good. However I also experience Windows 10 daily as my work laptop uses that OS. That work laptop also is fully managed by my employer with updates pushed to me weekly mostly to cover the latest security issue. So I have biweekly updates at minimum to my work laptop; a nothing special i5 SSD based Dell; and these annoy me because I have to spend what feels like nearly five minutes between updates applied, boot, and more updates applied, before I can sign on. and there is my Mac. I have a 2019 iMac, i9, SSD, and 40g memory. Twenty five to forty minutes complete with a timer on screen just to rub it in, which doesn't show up for some time into the process just to add some spice. It is as long as the upgrade to Big Sur took or at least it feels that way. I am loathe to let my iMac update and while it claims it can do so overnight it always fails to do so. Apple's patch process even on iPads and to an extent my iPhone are abysmal too. I really don't understand systems that are otherwise fast take so long to do an update. PS: On a side note, Big Sur is the least stable OS from them I can recall in recent years. I have had hard freezes in some apps which they Mac three finger salute could not remedy and a few times I found myself signing back in as it just "rebooted"
- trevorishere 6y agoMicrosoft releases updates once per month for Windows and associated components (sans the rare critical RCE etc.) -- for Office, you may be on Current Channel which releases ~3x/month. This would generally be unusual in a corporate environment which favors the Monthly Channel or SAC, both of which get updates 1x per month.
- bartvk 6y agoAs for your side note, please consider a fresh install. I haven't had a single crash knocks on wood
- davidf18 6y ago"A fresh install a year keeps the bugs away." I do a fresh install from USB annually because computers are computers and it helps with a lot. I also do resets every couple of days for the same reason. I also reset my iPhone 12 Pro Max every few days because computers are computers.
- whoisburbansky 6y agoIt isn’t immediately clear to me from the article why these updates can’t just be patches; it sounded like a large part of the problem here is that what’s ostensibly a couple kilobyte delta to fix ends up bloated to multiple gigabytes because of things like each update requiring firmware for every single Intel mac, and a copy of the entire dyld cache for System libraries. What is it about the update process that makes it so you can’t just skip out on extra fluff if it doesn’t need changing?
- boopmaster 6y agoIt’s not immediately clear why the update system is like this but agreed with author that it totally sucks. There’s an OS update waiting on me to install, stating it contains only a fix for the Mac mini m1, which I do not have. It would be one of those “flash all ye firmware” updates if I would run it. Every update is. Updates are atrocious. The only upside I can think of is that rootkits might have trouble persisting?
- hctaw 6y agoMy uneducated guess is that they don't have a good way to keep the app signatures intact when patching binaries.
- williesleg 6y agoDebian is nice. MacOS is just a data collector for Apple. They have all those huge datacenters, that's not for compiling code or doing CAD work.
- eddieh 6y agoThe sealed/locked-down system gives me pause, but not in the least for the size of the updates or whatever the update does that takes forever. The things that give me pause are more in line with IPC, DYLD_FRAMEWORK_PATH, the App Sandbox, and Hardened Runtime. Plus any private entitlements or APIs that Apple can use, but an indy developer can not. I'm having to jump through hoops avoiding App Store review pitfalls for something I'm developer and I might not be able to get the app on the App Store in the end. Not looking forward to rolling my own store or distributing the app myself.
- cma 6y agoDealing in giant gigs of "adaptive" wallpapers in the sealed volume, seemingly just to make you have to upgrade SSDs, was it for me. Some of the included wallpapers are nearly 1GB in size individually, and to remove them you have to do all kinds of stuff only for it to be added back again on update.
- GekkePrutser 6y agoYeah I noticed that too. I'm always struggling with Space (my work only gave me a 128G MacBook :S ), and using DiskInventoryX I found that these wallpapers occupied a non-trivial amount of space. This is especially weird considering Apple has been pushing HEIF so much which is mainly intended to reduce space occupied by images, really they shouldn't be this large.
- smoldesu 6y agoIt's especially concerning for developers, since this mentality is sadly spreading through the rest of the ecosystem. If your Mac has a 128 gig drive and you install xCode, you'll be left with a little over 20 gigs of free space.
- lostmsu 6y agoTo give some contrast Windows 10 + Visual Studio (not VS Code, but C# workload only) leaves about 15GB from 60GB primary SSD.
- codetrotter 6y agoMy previous Mac was a 2018 model MacBook Air with 128GB SSD, and I soon discovered that 128GB was way too little. Even the 256GB I have in my 2020 model MacBook Pro M1 is a little bit on the short side tbh. I have a 1TB external m2 SSD with an USB-C enclosure, but I only use it when I really really need to because it’s still a bit of a drag to have it sitting on the side and taking up one of the two ports. If I could afford it I would probably go with 1TB internal storage. But even if I could afford it, I would then really really like to see such a MBP have 4 USB-C ports and not just 2.
- crazygringo 6y agoI'm curious if anyone definitively knows why macOS updates can't be differental -- why it requires a gigabyte or more to patch something tiny. Given the expense of bandwidth and servers needed at a global scale, it seems Apple would have implemented differential updates long ago if it were just a straightforward engineering task. So it seems pretty clear that something is making it incredibly difficult or essentially impossible. Does anybody know what it is?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- count 6y agoIn theory, its simpler to guarantee everything is exactly as it should be, so the 'baseline' is identical. Differential based systems can fail in multiple ways (e.g. do you know when it's all done? what if one file is missed? etc.) that are simpler than just a bulk replace. I'm sure they COULD be differential, but that's a lot of extra complexity.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoThis still doesn't make sense to me. I mean, I don't understand the complexity of this at all: 1. Machine keeps around a baseline version of the OS install 2. A diff is downloaded and applied to the baseline version - that entire new version is then checksummed and validated to ensure it would be identical to what an entirely new version would look like. 3. That new version is then installed. I could see a downside here of requiring more disk space, but even then doesn't seem like it would be that hard for the system to make some heuristic decisions (e.g. incremental vs. full) based on the amount of free space on disk. Incremental updates are really not that hard, we've successfully implemented them for decades. Apple engineers are obviously no dummies, so would just like to understand what additional considerations make incremental updates more difficult now.
- sneak 6y ago> that entire new version is then checksummed and validated to ensure it would be identical to what an entirely new version would look like. Some of the complaints with the current system are that it is slow and needs a ton of free disk space, which are precisely the issues with the system you describe here. Apple engineers aren't dumb but not all of their staff have their hands in every bit of code on every project. I do know the time pressure there to make deadlines is insanely high. The new hardware announcement/ship date is set in stone weeks or months in advance and the new OS must go out the door on those new machines that day.
- cptskippy 6y agoThis explains a lot. I have a 2015 Macbook Pro that I use irregularly. I haven't needed it for about 6 months and I dusted it off the other day to do something. It said it had updates to install. 6 hours and 5 reboots later it was up to date. Does Apple not do cumulative updates?
- jandrese 6y agoMy wife had exactly the same experience last night with her 2015 MacBook Pro. She was getting regular kernel panics so I went to the updater to see if it was just a software problem. It says Safari is out of date so I clicked "update", and literally 5 hours later (I clicked the button around 20:00, it didn't finish until sometime after 01:00) it finally finished. I'd thought I had it set up to auto-update, but apparently it got stuck on something.
- worik 6y agoI learnt to programme using Pascal on Mac Plus in 1988. I had my first job as a programmer in 1989 on Macs.... Until very recently I had a soft spot for Macs, I had not really used them since 1992 Recently getting a job developing for iOS in Swift I am amazed at how the developer experience has degraded. There is so much friction In 1988 the documentation was very useful (Inside Macintosh - I think that was the name of the book). In 2020 Apple has decided that documentation is not really worth the effort. There is a cursory description of most APIs, not all, and no examples. I had to get a license to develop software for the computer (paid for) sitting on my desk. I paid, but did not get the license. I swallowed that insult because if I make a fuss Apple could wipe out my employer at the stroke of a pen. Accessing the file system is a constant hassle. Why so hard? I cannot install emacs on my mac. (I probably could, but how hard am I going to struggle?) Software that is free (as in GNU) is charged for in the App store. For example I cannot get my hands on a simple interface to diff anything like ediff. The Xcode compiler/debugger has some serious bugs, and as far as I can tell Apple's policy is not to fix bugs in developer tools... I am amazed that they care so little for those who are not quite the most important. If I could find a quality tablet that runs free software (are you listening Pine?) I would lobby hard to get off iOS.
- artificial 6y agoA lot has changed over the decades, security models and stances have traded a lot of flexibility. To smooth some of the rough edges of purely compiling from source take a look at homebrew (https://brew.sh/ https://brew.sh/). Spacemacs (https://www.spacemacs.org/ https://www.spacemacs.org/). I don’t develop desktop software any more and didn’t rush get into it on Mac, I’ve played around with swiftui a bit for iOS and server side (https://vapor.codes/ https://vapor.codes/). Perhaps the server side will scratch the itch?
- smoldesu 6y agoThese are stopgap solutions made to imitate aspects of other operating systems, and ultimately "break" the security model of the Mac. Apple knows the end-user is the weakest link in any security model, so by reducing the end-user's capabilities, you limit the risk they pose to the system. I'd rather just use an operating system that doesn't second-guess my choices in the first place.
- SavantIdiot 6y agoIt's time for this month's installation of "HN Hates Macs!"... now with 150% more anecdotal complaining!!!
- smoldesu 6y agoHonestly, it's better than "HN Worships The M1".
- SavantIdiot 6y agoI know, I can avoid clicking on it, and I should. More like "Bug Sir", amiright?
- davidf18 6y agoPeople are complaining about really a non-issue. You can work off-line or on your tablet for the brief download time of a few minutes and the update. People that use Macs a lot besides Office should do yearly fresh installs because computers are computers and it helps to keep the problems down.
- mcguire 6y ago"Make is fine, but it’s not standard. Disturbingly large swathes of critical open source infrastructure are compiled using a hodgepodge of Make, autogenerated rules from autotools..." 1. Autotools use make. GNU make, but make. 2. There's a historical reason for this goofiness: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unix_wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unix_wars "Companies should be paying for this directly: if pyca/cryptography actually broke on HPPA or IA-64, then HP or Intel or whoever should be forking over money to get it fixed or using their own horde of engineers to fix it themselves." If pyca/cryptography breaks on HPPA or whatever, it's pyca's problem, not HPs or Intels. Unless your project is big enough that you already have HP or Intel working on it.
- comex 6y agoYou seem to have posted in the wrong thread.
- viktorcode 6y agoTL;DR macOS Big Sur updates got bigger.
- lilyball 6y agoDo Big Sur updates really take longer to install? I’ve been putting off installing a Catalina update on my laptop because my impression is they take ~45 minutes to install, which is what this article claims Big Sur updates take.
- viktorcode 6y agoPersonally I didn't notice, but I haven't timed them. Any OS update takes rather noticeable amount of time, so I switch to something else while this is happening.
- liminal 6y agoMy biggest gripe with the Big Sur update is that it's now incredibly slow to swipe between desktops. It used to be responsive and now I need to wait 5-6 seconds before anything happens.
- acdha 6y agoIt’s still instantaneous normally, even on old systems like the 2012 MacBook Air I still use. I’d look in Activity Monitor / Console to see if it’s something like being memory-constrained and the switch is forcing a lot of background activity.
- quenix 6y agoWeird, I can’t reproduce that at all. Swiping between desktops is just as (if not more responsive than) Catalina. What is your model?
- liminal 6y agoI'm running 11.2.1 on a 2018 MacBook Pro i9. Should be sufficient to swipe desktops, you'd think.
- lovelyviking 6y ago>The Big Sur 11.2.2 update is a good example of what’s almost a null change, yet requires ... 3.1 GB for an M1 model. What Is the change?! Official site doesn't have entry for 11.2.2 or am I missing something ? GUI says this: macOS Big Sur 11.2.2 prevents MacBook Pro (2019 or later) and MacBook Air (2020 or later) models from incurring damage when they are connected to certain third-party, non-compliant powered USB-C hubs and docks. Then for more details it sends here: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT211896 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT211896 What about massive writings to SSD? has it been addressed? Or it's not a problem? PS: GUI says for my M1 it's 2.17GB and article says 3.1 GB who is correct?
- csande17 6y agoBug fixes and performance improvements, probably. (The actual answer is that the release notes are only available in the US version of the support page: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211896 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211896 )
- _qulr 6y agoFor some reason the en-gb page is missing 11.2.2, but it's on the en-us page: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211896#macos1122 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211896#macos1122
- smoldesu 6y agoI get the feeling Apple isn't going to fix the swap issue anytime soon. I don't think they're being insidious about it, though: the BSD memory model is (arguably overly) complicated, and refactoring any portion of it's memory management is guaranteed to be a pain in the ass. The TL:DR is that MacOS doesn't virtualize memory, and when that memory is unified it will frequently spill over into the swap storage. I have no idea how Apple can pull themselves out of this one, and I have a sneaking suspicion that the swap usage will only increase as time goes on.
- astrange 6y agomacOS doesn't use the BSD VM (UVM), it uses a heavily modified Mach VM.
- mark_l_watson 6y agoI don't disagree with the author's points but I think that almost all non-tech Mac users are better off with Big Sur. My preference is mostly using my new M1 MacBook Pro for software development (Common Lisp, Python, Haskell, mostly), but having a nice System76 Linux laptop when I want to do whatever I want with my hardware or system.
- MarkSweep 6y agoApple seems to know how to fix this: they have small incremental updates for iOS.
- lupinglade 6y agoI think it’s in development, Big Sur is part one of heading in that direction. Still, macOS has become far too locked down and inconsistent UI-wise for me. Developing for macOS has lost its magic, just about everything is inaccessible to developers now and the Mac software community has become dull. A real shame - things used to be so vibrant when macOS was more open and more attentively designed.
- headgasket 6y agoI hope Catalina will be able to run the new versions of Xcode, otherwise I’ll have to stop updating iOS too!
- jldugger 6y ago> Had Apple explained these costs and penalties of the SSV at last year’s WWDC, wouldn’t it have been booed from the virtual stage? Judging from past WWDC events, no. Sessions about MacOS internals, or operating MacOS at scale are lightly attended. AFAICT, there have been no posts on HN about the new firmlinks file type which made that possible, and nobody in any sessions I attended really seemed to notice how fucked it would be when Catalina went to read only root.
- cletus 6y agoIT's not clear to me from this article why exactly a Big sur update needs 600MB of firmware updates and ???GB of dynamic linked libraries. I must confess to not really knowing the design and consequences of Big Sur's sealed system. This article could really use an overview like that. I'm going to go out on a limb and speculate that all updates need to be signed and this makes sure that every Mac gets the same update and uses the part it needs. I guess the alternative is a combinatorial explosion of different combinations of firmware and hardware. But... there's not THAT many Macs (even years old ones) so I'm a little confused. Does this SSV system actually improve security or is it just security theater (serious question)?
- AwaAwa 6y agoThe march towards a locked down iOS-esque experience continues.
- bezout 6y agoIMO this is something that Microsoft got right with time. I don’t mind the mandatory updates as long as they install fast.
- coldtea 6y ago>The Big Sur 11.2.2 update is a good example of what’s almost a null change, yet requires 2.6 GB of installer files to be downloaded for an Intel Mac, and 3.1 GB for an M1 model. For comparison, a minimal update to Catalina required less than 1.2 GB, and for Mojave less than 1 GB, much of which were the seemingly obligatory set of firmware for every supported Mac. Wouldn't the sealed and tree-hashed OS volume make it easier to provide tiny delta updates?
- vlucas 6y agoI upgraded to Big Sur, and I still can't use my older HP printer. It's absurd. As a user, I need to be able to override what the OS thinks of my HP drivers. They used to work. Now they don't. No amount of uninstalling/cleaning and re-installing works.
- astrostl 6y agoI was recently annoyed by this but didn't connect the ro distribution with the update pain. Then there's the Xcode CLI update lest Homebrew start compiling rather than pouring everything, every time :-|