16 ms·
The Art of Reading More Effectively and Efficiently
- Hnrobert42 6y agoIn 4-Hour Work Week, Tim Ferris brags that he is a judo champion because he found a loophole in the judging criteria. By forcing people out of bounds 3 times in a match, he could disqualify them and win by default. Ok, sure. Those are the rules, and he won. But in any way that really matters, he was not a judo champion. Further, this guy’s association with Tim Ferris (see his Youtube) is an automatic disqualification in my book.
- cinntaile 6y agoSo your argument to dismiss this blogpost is guilt by association, am I understanding you correctly?
- leesalminen 6y agoYes, this is the current flavor of the month to show off one’s level of internet outrage. See: Scott Alexander / Astral Codex Ten. It’s funny, I’d never heard of Scott before the HN outrage. I’m now a paying subscriber and have been enjoying his writing.
- TeaDrunk 6y agoI've also enjoyed his writing but I can most certainly see his biases. He has a peculiar way of thoroughly researching some assumptions but then apparently having a complete blindspot to others, which is only made more apparently by how critically thinking all his posts are. I guess that's most people, though, they just rarely do so with the precision and eloquence of scott.
- waxpoeticwhy35 6y agoHave you seen this? https://twitter.com/ArsonAtDennys/status/1362153191102677001 https://twitter.com/ArsonAtDennys/status/1362153191102677001
- TeaDrunk 6y agoNo, I haven't. Thanks for sending this over. I don't know the parties reporting.
- waxpoeticwhy35 6y agoScott Alexander was recently exposed as horrifyingly racist and naive among other things. Just FYI. https://twitter.com/ArsonAtDennys/status/1362153191102677001 https://twitter.com/ArsonAtDennys/status/1362153191102677001
- croissants 6y agoThe blog post's author lists a Ferriss book as one of his "3 favorite books" in a video on his channel, so it's more like "guilt by endorsement".
- BeetleB 6y agoThat's still guilt by association.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoNo. That is not what guilt by association means.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoYes. This article is about how to read a lot of books. In the author’s Youtube channel, he has Tim Ferris talking about speed reading. If the author is holding up that con artist as an exemplar, I will take the risk of skipping this post.
- YinglingLight 6y agoOf all qualms you could have against Ferriss, this is the pettiest.
- watwut 6y agoIt is explicitly against the judo rules.
- suketk 6y agoWhat are some more reasonable qualms to have? As a recent fan of Ferriss, I'm curious if there's something I'm missing.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoHaha. It as just the easiest the type out on an iPhone.
- alfonsodev 6y agoInteresting, "holding a title" vs "being a champion", it's like "passing an exam" vs "learning". If I recall correctly I think Ali makes this distinction on his videos when he speaks about dedicating time to pass the exam or learning as much as you can from a topic, are two different issues, sadly. I'd disqualify neither of them, it's just about defining what's the goal.
- kinghtown 6y agoThe fact that Ferris is completely transparent about how he won tells me that he probably doesn’t actually think of himself as a war machine. You are also underestimating Judo here, too. It’s all about grappling and throws, positioning. Maybe keep that in mind a little bit when you say he won by forcing his opponent out of bounds. It’s not a street fight.
- watwut 6y agoIn judo, intentionally pushing opponent out of bounds is against the rules. Explicitly.
- kinghtown 6y agoOk.. so he’s still transparent about how he won. I’m not even going to google the specifics about what happened because judo is hardly something he legitimizes his image on. He’s not “judo champion” Tim Ferris. Be that as it may, judo is pretty fierce and legit. I used to work as a bouncer with an ex multiple black belt judo champion. Not world class or anything but this guy was crazy, I’ve seen him take out pretty tough guys like it was nothing. If Tim Ferris could force him or someone like him out of bounds then colour me impressed.
- Hnrobert42 6y agoHe also made his initial fortune by selling dietary supplements with no scientific backing. And on and on. He is a con artist. He is open about it, but that is part of his con.
- apples_oranges 6y agoTim hacked the competition. This is Hacker News. Why are you here? ;) (I don't want to insult you, I just wanted to formulate my point it in a slightly more provocative way. That hacking is also about finding such loopholes.)
- mcguire 6y agohttps://www.martialdevelopment.com/how-to-win-kickboxing-wrong/ https://www.martialdevelopment.com/how-to-win-kickboxing-wro...
- timoth3y 6y agoThere was a bit of a scandal about this a few years ago. As I recall, no one could find any record of Tim Ferris ever winning the Chinese kickboxing competition he claimed to have won. Was that ever resolved? In a sense, I suppose, his point is valid either way. It is much easier to claim to have done something than to have actually done it, and you get the sane benefits either way. So, lifehack?
- purple_ferret 6y agoThere are many things that can be optimized, but I don't think reading is one of them. I think being a heavy reader makes you better equipped to breeze through poor writing, for instance. It's just a basic form of deep work.
- newbie578 6y agoFor such a long blog, I still didn't understand how does one read more effeciently, or did I miss something? Or is it just a clickbait title, since the majority of the blog just defends reading and counts it's pros.
- C4stor 6y agoTL;DR : Start taking notes about what you read if you want to actually remember a bit of it. Here you go.
- BeetleB 6y agoWhile correct, this won't be enough. I've been doing that for years and doing it well is fairly challenging.
- aftabh 6y agoI highly recommend that you consult the original book (also referenced in TFA) as your primary source to find answer to your question. > Let it be understood at once that we are wholly in favour of the proposition that most people ought to be able to read faster than they do. Too often, there are things we have to read that are not really worth spending a lot of time reading; if we cannot read them quickly, it will be a terrible waste of time. It is true enough that many people read some things too slowly, and that they ought to read them faster. But many people also read some things too fast, and they ought to read those things more slowly. A good speed reading course should therefore teach you to read at many different speeds, not just one speed that is faster than anything you can manage now. It should enable you to vary your rate of reading in accordance with the nature and complexity of the material. > Excerpt From: Mortimer J. Adler. “How to Read a Book.”
- ohduran 6y agoAgreed. Go straight to the source: How to read a book, by Mortimer Adler. Ironically you will find there that you must grapple with the good books, which arguably disqualifies just reading about it in a blog.
- 6y ago
- croissants 6y agoI like the idea of "synoptic" reading to learn about a concrete topic. It makes sense when different works offer different versions of what happens and why. But it seems weird to do it with fiction. If I'm reading fiction, I want to get into the world created by the author. I think repeatedly stepping in and out to compare it to other works, or analyze its construction, or think about a GoodReads review, all of that is going to impede that process. So I usually just get into the book's world, finish it, and then step back for 30 minutes a day or two later and write a few paragraphs of my thoughts. This little essay often includes connections to other books, and articulating thoughts on a book right after reading it contributes a ton to my appreciation and understanding. It makes it a lot easier to pitch the book to somebody else, for example (easier than saying "it's...it's just so good, just read it"). And for me this process works best if I refrain from doing it too consciously during the reading process. The experience of immersing your unconscious in something is pretty unique. That said, I don't finish every book I start, and I don't write comments unless I feel like there's something to work out. But there's usually something to work out! Unrelated pedantic comment: TFA attributes this quote to Edgar Allan Poe > Marking a book is literally an experience of your differences or agreements with the author. It is the highest respect you can pay him. But it doesn't sound like him, and the internet suggests it's actually a quote from this other Adler guy also referenced in TFA?
- jannyfer 6y agoI interpreted the four levels of reading to be a subsection of "Category 3: Reading to Understand". So as I understand it, reading fiction in the way you describe would be reading to entertain, but if you are reading to study fiction of a certain kind as a topic, synoptic reading would apply? Also, to your other point, the author seems to be fast and loose with his facts - clickbait titles and unverifiable Einstein quote too! https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/compound-interest/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/compound-interest/
- lemonberry 6y agoI'm rereading "How to Read a Book" by Mortimer Adler and Charles Van Doren right now. It's worth picking up if you're interested in getting more out of your reading.
- 600frogs 6y agoInteresting to see Ali Abdaal's content on HN. I regularly watch and enjoy his videos, but I've come to view them as light entertainment rather than anything genuinely insightful or actionable. They're well-produced and they talk about topics I'm interested in, but they don't say a lot. They're definitely algorithm-bait, and it's something that Ali openly admits, but I still (willingly) fall for the bait - there's something nice about procrastinating by watching videos on productivity and systems rather than Tik-toks or anything else. Ultimately, it's just as much of a waste of time, but you can more easily console yourself that the time is better spend "in case there's any life-changing insights here". There never is, but best click the next video just in case.
- suketk 6y agoIt's great that you're conscious of it, but many people aren't. This entire genre (I call it productivity porn) is problematic because it creates the illusion of progress. People wonder why the algorithms have so much grip over us - it's because all we do is consume and don't act.
- 600frogs 6y agoProductivity porn is a great name for it. For me, it's akin to a trashy gossip magazine - you know it's kind of trash, but enjoy it for what it is. It always makes me smirk when the videos themselves call out your last point, and say "you can't just think about it, you need to act on it, go out there and Carpe Diem!" and we all smile and nod and click the next video without moving from our chairs. I hope I'm not coming off as too negative though, as I think they are marginally better than most types of content on YouTube. Especially the more popular channels such as Ali's may appear on people's feeds that have never once even thought about _having_ any sort of system, and for them it's a big win. Once you're past surface level though, they generally don't have much more to offer, but are kind of fun to watch regardless.
- benrbray 6y agoI think this is missing an important fourth objective: reading to remember. I'm not sure how much others can relate, but I am hopeless at remembering most of what I read or watch. Even when I spend several days pondering the same book chapter / paper / recipe / etc, taking thorough notes, there is no guarantee I will remember it six months or even one month from now. I started to realize that I was collecting new data points about a topic but rarely making connections between what I already know and what I read. So, I've been trying to slowly improve my retention by being more purposeful about what I read and how I take notes. Some guidelines that have helped in the past two or so years I've been trying to become a better reader: * Before reading, I try to make a mental note of what I hope to learn from reading, in as much detail as possible. * While reading, I underline key words and take brief notes in the margin so it's easy to look back later and get a rough idea of what each section of the book or articles is about. I will write "?" where I am confused or where I disagree, "@" for interesting citations I might want to follow up on later, etc. * After reading, I take very rough notes about what I thought the most important points were, my reactions, and what I want to know more about. Since I take Markdown notes, I can use #tags and [[bidirectional links]] to help myself find these notes later if I am ever reading about the same topic again. * Some topics are important enough to spend more time on. I basically have my own "encyclopedia" of Markdown files for certain topics that I can add to every time I come across an interesting bit of information. This has been especially helpful for keeping track of random tidbits of information I learn about cooking.
- DanBC 6y agoI like your points, and I think they'd be useful. > I'm not sure how much others can relate, but I am hopeless at remembering most of what I read or watch. Even when I spend several days pondering the same book chapter / paper / recipe / etc, taking thorough notes, there is no guarantee I will remember it six months or even one month from now. Have you tried teaching other people? That forces you to re-arrange what you know into a form that other people can understand, and that helps you understand it and retain it better. And those people get to ask you questions which help point to gaps in your knowledge. I guess this is similar to "see one, do one, teach one" methods.
- apples_oranges 6y ago
- dawg- 6y agoI have noticed an interesting trend in our discourse about reading lately - there seems to be more and more moralizing and virtue signaling. So much self-help and "motivation porn" focuses on reading books, as if it's a magical activity that will unlock the best version of oneself. It's part of the new aspirational message - imagine yourself rich, happy, driving a Lamborghini, living off dividends from your stonks, and reading books. The people pushing that message get lots of eyeballs on their content because too many people have come to see reading as a lofty, obscure activity only fully accessible to the morally (and therefore financially) superior. It's almost like reading has been elevated to a kind of rare alchemy, whereby you can unlock secret cheat codes to life. The feeling that you're in rareified air to actually read books. I think anyone who regularly reads books for pleasure should easily see through this - reading is just a hobby. It's a fun, intellectually challenging, infinitely variable hobby with a very long and distinguished history. But ultimately you could learn just as much about yourself and the world by doing pottery, woodworking, kayaking, knitting or whatever else you like to do with your spare time. Making it into such a self-serious pursuit kills most of the joy (and value, for that matter). Let's try to make reading commonplace, something we almost take for granted. Of course I read books, you read books, we all read books. Everybody poops, and everybody reads books. Wouldn't that be great? In that world, a Youtube commercial or Medium article promising that you can unlock secret lamborghinis on the moon by reading exactly 18.75 books a week would suddenly be absurdly transparent in setting off everyone's bullshit meters. The question "read any good books lately?" could take on less of a challenging air and more conversational, the way so many people can casually drop 10 quotes from their favorite Netflix show they've been binge watching during their commute to work. Longform reading is magic because it's rarer than ever - it's an art now, according to people like this author. That's why we have so much performative reading, a cheap replacement for the real thing. I'd rather reading be boring and commonplace, something we do as easily as breathing.
- criddell 6y ago> imagine yourself rich, happy, driving a Lamborghini, living off dividends from your stonks, and reading books I was immediately reminded of Lambo Tai. I still think it's a parody of something... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv1RJTHf5fk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv1RJTHf5fk
- ohduran 6y agoI have a contrarian view about reading productively, which is: READ WHAT OTHERS AREN'T READING. It's as if there is a similar process as the Efficient Market Hypothesis happening with books: the best-sellers define our shared reality, and apparently (at least for me), they aren't worth reading. For example, think of Outliers, by Malcom Gladwell. Virtually everyone has heard of the 10'000 hour rule. That means that the first thing you have to do to be more productive in your reading is start by NOT reading Outliers: all its content is already common knowledge. Which brings me to this post. No matter how many books the author is reading, he is simply reviewing what everyone else (Atomic Habits, Thinking Fast and Slow, Grit) is reading too. So there is little value in what he reads, because it's discounted by what "everyone" knows already. What do you guys think about that? Am I too off course?
- tvanantwerp 6y agoIf you're paying attention to what people are saying about the books "everyone" is reading, then sure, you can probably skip them. Lots of popular books I never read because I got 90%+ of the content from a podcast interview. But this doesn't answer the question of what you should read. Simply "not the popular stuff" could land you at an amazingly insightful but ignored classic, or a celebrity gossip tabloid you picked up at the grocery store checkout.
- martin-adams 6y agoI think you're right when it comes to finding new and original ideas by reading less popular texts. This helps you get an alternative perspective than the mainstream. I do feel it depends on whether you're reading to address something personal, or reading for advancing the subject as a whole. If I'm struggling with habits, then Atomic Habits is a good book to read, even if everyone else is reading it. It's not the only one, but a good recommendation saves me time. I remember one person in the HN comments a while ago say that they would rather than see a list of all the books someone recommends, they want to see the list of books they don't recommend. You can make a better assessment of whether this person has value to add by showing their exclusions in their line of thinking.
- algebrazebra 6y ago
- tagfowufe 6y agoThis is just an unashamed ripoff of "How to Read a Book" by Mortimer Adler and Charles Van Doren. Seriously, he didn't even get "syntopical" right.
- 5etho 6y agoyes it is, just ban his website :-) it will be more spam of his
- groos 6y agoHaha, the first thing I noticed.
- rollinDyno 6y agoHe doesn’t even credit the book appropriately. How scummy.
- sn9 6y agoHe literally mentions Adler 7 times in the link....
- 5etho 6y agojust dont follow the rabbit hole to learn about author, I did and his yt channel is pure scam a'la Tony Robbins knowledge is for free, here is my 3000$ course beacuse wE nEeD AcCoUnTaBiLiLty
- approxim8ion 6y agoIt's pretty much the same grift with every self-help channel out there.
- Bakary 6y agoI really don't see the point of all that productivity in every facet of life. It sounds like cargo-culting to me. Generally, people who do fascinating things don't need to analyze their own productivity since they are naturally drawn to their projects and work on them on their own and for their own sake. People who do things out of ambition don't need the boost either, by definition. And for people who just want to enjoy life, this sort of thinking is antithetical to what they see as worthwhile. Therefore this content can only appeal to those in a state of dissatisfaction and confusion as to what they want out of existence, but does not provide them with any sort of useful answer. From a cursory glance at the channel, it's all very ironic: the guy shares tips about having become a doctor and done extremely well in medical school, but quit after two years because his channel about productivity was taking off. Don't get me wrong, I respect the hustle and the cashflow, but it highlights the circularity of the whole enterprise. The productivity is channeled to create content on productivity that is itself of no particular value except as entertainment for unproductive and anxious people. It's like those online courses on becoming rich that are themselves the source of the wealth. From an individual perspective, it's great that the author can make a lot more money with a lot less stress compared to medical work, but from a societal perspective it seems like we've created an ocean of perverse incentives.
- a9h74j 6y agoAs you suggest, there is something so transparently ironic or off about his path in particular. For me his videos were part of a quick off-ramp from the productivity porn. In the irony department, I am reminded of a woman who once billed herself as the smartest person alive or something. My thought was: You are the smartest person alive, and you are writing articles for the Sunday supplement in my local newspaper?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant
- wombatmobile 6y agoI love reading but I’m not going to tell you it’s the best thing in the world or that you have to be like me. Like Hemingway, Kerouac, and James Bond, I also like going to bars in exotic places, meeting women and other people, and not reading.
- brudgers 6y agoIf you have to understand what you read, you will avoid challenging books. You will avoid experts writing for experts. You will avoid books that are way over your head. And if your reading has to be efficient, what you read will be ever more dumbed down. Ever more a landscape of mowed lawns and two car garages. Never a dark wilderness sky. Never a smelly sidewalk crowd in harsh noon sun. There's nothing wrong with the missionary position. But the world is bigger.
- brokencode 6y agoAm I the only one who thinks most novels are 90% fluff? Like, they can certainly be entertaining, but the idea of the author making an argument that you need to decode and become enlightened by sits with me the wrong way. Why not just come out and say your points in a condensed form without the story around it? Does it improve learning to have to decode information from a novel? Does it stick with you better, or make a more relatable case? The same is true for most non fiction books. Endless stories and examples for something you could have said in 10 pages. This is why I prefer articles, blog posts, etc. I want to learn, but don’t want to spend hours reading fluff. I enjoy TV shows for entertainment, and don’t feel the need to decode them, because I don’t believe there would be anything in there that isn’t the 50th variation of something I’ve heard before. Am I missing out on incredible revelations? Upon reading a great book, I’ve never felt enlightened, even when prodded to analyze it in school. Maybe I haven’t tried hard enough, or maybe the point is lost on me, but it just doesn’t seem as worthwhile as so many people claim.
- ceilingcorner 6y agoIf you are reading literature, real literature, purely for information, I'm afraid you've lost the plot somewhere. As with everything worthwhile in life, good literature is work. Don't expect to pick up a classic novel and understand it immediately.
- brokencode 6y agoThat’s a pretty weak argument. You are saying that I should invest time and effort into a book to understand it, but also that the purpose of literature is not information. What is there to understand then, if not information? I always hear the author is making a point about life, but why water it down in hundreds of extra pages instead of saying it directly? The only thing I can think is that the story helps us connect with the author’s point and learn from it better. It can influence and persuade in a way that just laying out arguments can’t, because it stirs up emotion in the reader. Is that what you are trying to say? I can’t say that I’ve ever experienced something like that from a book, but it sounds enjoyable. Maybe I’ll give it another shot sometime.
- 5tefan 6y agoI don't wamt to remember what I read. I want inspiration. Being inspired and being creative serves me better then remembering stuff.
- abc_lisper 6y agoStraight from How to Read a Book. I highly recommend it; it felt like my IQ went up a couple of points after reading it
- Veen 6y ago> it felt like my IQ went up a couple of points after reading it That's the problem with productivity porn. You feel smarter and more productive, that you're becoming a better human being. In reality, you've accomplished nothing and all the hard work is still ahead of you.
- abc_lisper 6y agoThat’s a valid point probably, but that’s not what I meant. I am more aware of myself, and am more methodical when gathering information or reading a book after reading “How to read a book”
- weathawi 6y agoJust monitizing
- xtiansimon 6y agoThis article is a book report on the classic, Adler, Mortimer J. How to Read a Book. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster (1940, 1972) [1] Adler tackles the subject of reading both in breadth and depth. The work is ambitious, rigorous and challenging. It's a complete guide to reading for any academic. And also, it's a 80 year old measuring stick of your own reading practice for any who subscribe to life-long learning. For my part I discovered Adler's book at the apex of a personal challenge ten years after my undergraduate studies in art and design. During a summer of underemployment in a terrible job, I returned to beloved professor's syllabus, and decided to read the extra-curricular books--recommended but not required. So, no help from classmates, or instructors. Just me and the text, but a couple of very lucky coincidences happened... First, I heard/read about a retired professor who liked to write a "book report" on his reading. He graded the books as he did his former student's assignments. A, B, etc. Haha. Whatever, but now I had something to do with my reading. Looking back 10 years at this syllabus I couldn't recall what I had read. I had no memories of these books. All I had were random digital files on an old CD-ROM. Second, I also needed practice typing (never had one lesson). It just made sense to copy passages from the books--verbatim. I would start by summarizing the text, and realize the author said it better, and I would quote them in my 'book report'. Of course, I was entertaining my ambition to also write about my reading. Third, to find the quotes I liked, I would tag the lines with different keywords. More often, I would encounter a term or foundational definition, and this evolved my writing notes into reading notes as a system of marginalia. [2] Finally, I discovered the book which the OP's post is summarizing for us (in broad strokes). It has only intensified my love of reading. Not because I follow it as manual, but because it _explained_ what I learned about reading that summer in words better than I could ever conjure or put to paper. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/How_to_Read_a_Book [2]: https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/139g4uFXFCL1ZYrcWKTShbPswnV6ti7ost_584pC9QmU/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/139g4uFXFCL1ZYrcWKTShbPsw...