14 ms·
Semiconductors Demand 30% Above Supply, 20% Year-on-Year Growth
- Zenst 6y agoGiven how many times in the past how electronic tech production has been impacted by natural disasters, from a simple few minute power loss down to earthquakes or tsnami's. It is somewhat worrying that with the shortfall as it is, any climate impacting event as been in the past would be way more impacting noe and with the way the climate is, such things are more likely year upon year. That with current trends and for good reason to expand capacity more globally, with the time involved to do such things, we may well see over capacity headlines 5 years down the line and with that thought. If history is to be learned from, the good times are ahead, until then - we might see tech longevity support and tech repair become more of a thing.
- thewarrior 6y agoGood thing we aren’t doing anything to destabilize a climate system that’s not causing us too much trouble as of now.
- ppf 6y agoYou mean, like manufacturing electronics? It takes about 1MWh to manufacture a laptop, the same energy needed to drive a Tesla for 3000 miles. https://www.networkworld.com/article/2229029/computer-factories-eat-way-more-energy-than-running-the-devices-they-build.html https://www.networkworld.com/article/2229029/computer-factor...
- dewlinedew2 6y agoalso lots of purified water
- thewarrior 6y agoIt’s all interconnected and inter causal in a gigantic mess.
- kryogen1c 6y ago> the same energy needed to drive a Tesla who are the memeticists driving this analagy into our collective consciousness? why is this popularizing? ive been seeing this crop up more and more frequently. it feels a bit like begging the question, except the arguer also holds TSLA
- ppf 6y agoIt's just a handy reference for energy usage, and I assume this figure is more readily available due to the car being battery powered. It's a bit harder to work out for an ICE-powered car, as you'd have to calculate the energy required to move the car based on aerodynamics and weight. I have no interest in TSLA stock, nor do I think Tesla is anything like the sustainable future of transportation. I mostly picked Telsa because it's Hacker News. As you insist though, it's about the energy required to cycle 100,000 miles.
- simias 6y agoYou can do exactly the same back-of-the-envelope calculation for ICE engines as you did for the Tesla, you just need to know the average fuel consumption per mile and the energy density of gasoline. No need to worry about areodynamics.
- ppf 6y agoI was using that number to represent just the energy required to motivate the car, and assuming that an EV has near-perfect energy translation from battery to movement (and therefore providing an accurate enough representation of that energy). It gets a little complicated if you want to consider the fuel input, as you start getting into wells-to-wheels calculations. Depending on your power grid energy mix, it also makes things quite a bit worse for EVs.
- CyberRage 6y agoActually you already have something like this. MPGe is used across EV and ICE vehicles alike. Fuel is far more energy dense for ICE engines are far far less efficient. I don't get this comparison point as well, electronics is dwarfed compared to other far more energy intensive industries.
- bfrog 6y agoSo probably 10MWh to build a Tesla, before even driving it?
- ppf 6y agoNearer 25MWh, and that's just for the battery pack. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0007850617301099 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00078...
- ppf 6y agoAlso, just for fun, the embodied energy of a 1960's Fiat 500 (assuming its entire 500kg weight is made of steel, which is probably a good enough approximation) is 3MWh, or three laptops. So what is more sustainable?
- imtringued 6y agoAn electric bike?
- ppf 6y agoYou're not wrong. However, every time I think about that, I just tell myself to pedal harder ;)
- xxs 6y agojust for reference 1kg of aluminum raw material,not alloy, not processed, not packed, not transported - just mined is over 40KWh. In that regard even the raw materials for the car are orders of magnitude over.
- ppf 6y agoIndeed. The embodied energy of the items we use every day is so under-appreciated, probably because we have outsourced the production of almost all of them to countries that have no problem burning oil and coal in the process. Really, if we actually wanted to make motoring sustainable, we would all be driving a 60's era Fiat 500 or Honda C50 moped. They cost very little to make, in every way, are very fuel effecient (even with their very old engine designs), and discourage long journeys. That won't work though, because there's too much money to be made from EVs.
- vkou 6y agoSince we're trying to use human-understandable units for measuring energy inputs, It's also the same amount of energy that is necessary to boil 600 pots of soup.
- jschwartzi 6y agoThat's almost as much soup as I eat in a year.
- ppf 6y agoNot much use unless you specify the size of the pot ;) By my calculation, 1MWh is enough to boil 600 17-liter pots, which isn't very human-relatable.
- vkou 6y agoWe're talking about the full energy budget of common household objects, like laptops, so you need to take into account the inefficiency of your gas stove, as well as the full energy cost of extracting and transporting the natural gas to your apartment.
- ppf 6y agoWell then, let's see your working. Gas is really quite efficient in all ways.
- NonEUCitizen 6y agoYou can avoid a lot of flying and driving by using zoom on that laptop.
- qazxcvbnmlp 6y agoYeah but flying is more fun. - Sent from the Seattle Airport
- ppf 6y agoNow take a look at all your other laptop-like gadgets (the infotainment in your car, your smartphone(s), TV(s), PC, gaming rig, etc etc), and tell me how much flying and driving they prevent.
- cma 6y agoDid you account for how much energy to create the Tesla as well?
- ppf 6y agoNo, I was just using it as a easily-understood reference of comparative energy usage. Really, it's about the same value for any other car with the same aerodynamics and weight as the Tesla. As you point out, it gets a lot more complicated when you start adding up how much energy it takes to make a Tesla (or any other EV). Really, if we actually wanted to make motoring sustainable, we would all be driving 60's era Fiat 500s or Honda C50 mopeds. They cost very little to make, in every way, are very fuel effecient (even with their very old engine designs), and discourage long journeys. That won't work though, because there's too much money to be made from EVs.
- cyberpsybin 6y agoWhat about energy expended manufacturing the Tesla?
- ppf 6y agoI really regret using the example of a Tesla, as it conflates too many issues. I meant that it takes around 300Wh to move a car about the weight and shape of a Tesla, one mile. It is a very interesting calculation to look at the energy cost of manufacturing any EV, and how long it takes to "pay it back" compared to an ICE-powered car, and under various sources of power for the electrical grid used to charge it. However, that was supposed to be beyond the scope of this conversation.
- imtringued 6y agoI drive more than 3000 miles per year and I've got this laptop for 4 years now.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoEquipment companies are running at an all-out sprint to ship fabrication equipment. Applied Materials, the world's largest by revenue, has 1,390 open positions. #4 Lam Research has 570. The equipment space is brutally cyclic, akin to the oil services industry. Revenue can jump as much as 60% year over year, only to plummet 40% the next. It's always worrisome to see these macro-trends, feasting now, but famine sure to follow...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> Applied Materials ... has 1,390 open positions. #4 Lam Research has 570 With this many openings they must be having problems actually getting stuff done. But as you suggest, by the time they get a good chunk of these openings hired for they'll be looking to cut heads again. People who have been through one cycle before probably aren't inclined to go through the buzzsaw again and so move onto other industries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gbil 6y agoMaybe they are just planning on enhancing their manufacturing capabilities. Quote from their Quarter call: "Applied Materials is also trying to tap into efforts to bring more chip manufacturing to the US and reinforce the nation's leadership in chips." And the majority of the job openings are CA and TX
- syntaxing 6y agoI think this is the problem. The downcycle for the semi industry should of came around 2-3 years ago. The issue is that never came and the industry is growing at an even more ridiculous rate. The semi industry is single handed buying a good chunk of the OEM equipment space these past 3 years. Just get a THK rail quote and look at awe at the one year+ lead time.
- the__alchemist 6y agoI'm having a tough time buying STM32 MCUs. When I started my most recent designs about 6 months ago, the SMT-assembly service I used, and retailers like Digikey and Mouser had ample stock. Now, I'm unable to start production due to being unable to find MCUs. The whole STM32 line is affected - Only a handful of variants are available, which may or may not be the ones a given design can use.
- chadaustin 6y agoWhat assembly service do you use?
- the__alchemist 6y agoJLCPCB. I'm curious if there are others that have stock; may have to switch if JLC and the retailers are all out. I posted on the ST forums; the replies speculated it would be months for this to sort out.
- bsder 6y agoSurprising. ST runs their own fabs. People must be stockpiling, and ST is replenishing the most profitable stuff first.
- mastax 6y agoI started a new project last week and I chose my STM32 by sorting by stock High -> Low. A year ago it wasn't even a consideration (I make low volume stuff). I sent a big complicated board to manufacturing a month ago. I was making changes up to the last minute based on availability. One of the parts went out of stock and I provided an alternate part number. A week ago my assembler contacted me and said that went out of stock as well. I'm a bit pissed off that they didn't order it when they confirmed the change and there was plenty of stock, but I'll cut them some slack because they're in Houston. Now there's no stock of the part anywhere in the world except a single Aliexpress store. I can't overstate how strange it is to see such widespread availability problems. Pretty soon I'll have to design things with nothing but discrete transistors.
- baggy_trough 6y ago30% above supply at what price? (shrieks in economist)
- UncleOxidant 6y agoThe free market has a bit of a problem here: A new state of the art fab can cost many $Billions and takes a good 5 years to go into production. Not a lot of companies have this kind of cash on hand or the ability to wait that long to achieve profitability. Also much of the current fab capability (TSMC, Samsung for example) is located in some geopolitically unstable places (Taiwan, South Korea). There's lots of risk to the global economy here.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoI think the point is more that there's an obvious remedy to demand being above supply: raise prices until demand drops. But for some reason, this doesn't happen as much as you'd expect.
- seventh-chord 6y agoIsnt supply price-inelastic in the short term, so "30% above" is the same quantity at all price levels?
- pedrocr 6y agoDemand is not inelastic so the 30% drops if the supply becomes more expensive as orders will be cancelled.
- jpm_sd 6y agoPrevious discussion https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26042085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26042085
- zokier 6y agoAnd people scream at nvidia trying to segment the market a bit and/or price gouging. Meanwhile nowhere near all launch day orders (7 months ago) 3080 orders have been delivered, and at this rate I suspect there will be new gen out before all the outstanding 3080 orders have been fulfilled.
- fomine3 6y agoI believe (something looks like permanent) ETH crash is enough to fix GPU demand including miners selling their GPUs as used. By introducing PoS or gov's regulation?
- UncleOxidant 6y agoGiven the strategic importance of semiconductors and how expensive new fabs are and how long they take to start production (if you start planning a new state of the art fab now it'll take ~5 years before it's ready to produce chips) it seems like perhaps we need to look a public-private partnerships here in the US. The Chinese government is funding fabs. While we tend to be squeamish about such things here in the US, it's likely we need to start looking at doing this. At the very least the US Gov could step in to capitalize two or three companies to start foundries similar to TSMC. When they get on their feet they would become fully private entities that would pay back any government loans as they become profitable. I'm not sure we have the time to wait to see if Intel will decide to go big into the foundry biz - they seem to vacillate on this pretty regularly.
- scott_codie 6y agoAre you saying that Chinese semiconductor companies are outcompeting US semiconductor companies because they have greater access to capital? That doesn't seem right to me.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoI'm saying that the Chinese government has determined that semiconductors are strategically important and is willing to pour yuan into fabs and developing their own process equipment industry. Semiconductor manufacturing is a very capital intensive business and the short-term market view in the West isn't well suited to remaining competitive in that space. Silicon Valley has very little to do with silicon anymore because our markets decided to pour money into other areas where the payoff is quicker.
- scott_codie 6y agoThats great for them and great for US semiconductor companies since we are trading partners.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago
- lend000 6y agoWhile the demand is cyclic and volatile in this industry (compared to software), the huge demand and influx of capital is very exciting for those who care about the advancement of computing. Note that there are only major shortages of leading edge nodes, not basic electronics on older nodes that people aren't as excited about using. So if some critical safety system needs a basic sensor, there is plenty of 65nm capacity available. That's why Global Foundries isn't experiencing the same growth and bookings as the leading edge fabs are.
- zucker42 6y ago> Note that there are only major shortages of leading edge nodes Is this true? Do automotive companies use leading edge nodes, because they're experiencing a shortfall too.
- lend000 6y agoProbably "a" leading node (<= 22nm), but I'd also be interested to see specific orders and shipment numbers in 2021 vehicles. Products like the Intel Atom are still built in the same fabs as desktop/server silicon, and these are presumably going into automobiles.
- testfoobar 6y agoDrought in Taiwan is a problem as well. "Taiwan's chip industry under threat as drought turns critical TAIPEI -- Taiwan's tech manufacturers fear their output is under threat from the island's worst drought in decades, risking more turmoil for global supply chains already strained by shortages of semiconductors and other key components. Taiwan's government will on Thursday further tighten water use in several cities that are home to a cluster of important manufacturers. Plants in Taoyuan, Taichung, Hsinchu and Miaoli will have to cut consumption by up to 11%, on top of a 7% cut requested last month." https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Tech/Semiconductors/Taiwan-s-chip-industry-under-threat-as-drought-turns-critical2?utm_campaign=RN%20Subscriber%20newsletter&utm_medium=daily%20newsletter&utm_source=NAR%20Newsletter&utm_content=article%20link&del_type=1&pub_date=20210225190000&seq_num=2&si=79447 https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Tech/Semiconductors/Taiwan-...
- bsder 6y agoA lot of this is people now over-ordering since they can get stuck by a shortfall. As soon as the crunch passes, there will be a big drop in demand while people burn down their inventory. Normally, planning is 18-26 weeks out and nobody really worries. Now, planning is 52+ weeks out, and people are stockpiling.
- ipsum2 6y agoThis is known as the Bullwhip effect: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect
- waterhouse 6y agoCould people have anticipated this and speculated to make a bunch of money (with the side effect of smoothing out the demand)? That is, bought a bunch of ... semiconductors of some interchangeable, reliably-demanded sort (I dunno, RAM? Generic Cortex-A77 cores?) a year ago (or whenever production was plentiful), stockpiled them, and sold them for profit today?
- bsder 6y agoAbsolutely. Companies with stock are making bank--there aren't many of them and they're draining. Companies with their own fabs are making bank because they can prioritize their production runs by profitability. The problem is that inventory has both risk and weird tax consequences so nobody wants to hold it. The risk is simply that nobody ever wants the part so you lose the money you spent. The weird tax consequences are how you "write down" inventory--the problem is that the IRS lumps a lot of inventory into the same boat: bolts are sort of treated the same as semiconductors even though they have very different life cycles. The real lesson in all this is that there is no longer a surplus in worldwide fab capacity. The "fabless" semiconductor business plans relied on this surplus to beat up the "fab owning" companies for years. The fabs all just figured out that "Fabs are the walled garden" and the fabless guys just got a reminder that "Your profits are dependent on some else's platform and they can take it away." It will be interesting to see what the reckoning is after this all shakes out.
- hristov 6y agoThat all sounds great, but with semiconductors you always have to worry about double ordering, stockpiling, etc.
- DorothyOns80 6y agoНi! Рleаsе vоte for my егоtiс рhotоs оn my раge - https://xlink.cc/sXE1m https://xlink.cc/sXE1m
- runeks 6y ago> Some market observers believe that demand for semiconductors currently exceeds supply by up to 30% […] Then raise the price until it’s too expensive for the extra 30%. Problem solved.
- Leherenn 6y agoRather problem transferred down the line. Sure, we can do without those 30%, but wouldn't it be better to find a way to satisfy demand rather?
- prennert 6y agoThe supply chain disruption last year made me think of the beer distribution game [0], and the Bullwhip [1] effect it exposes. I am very far removed from the semi-conductor industry and the supply chain they feed. But given that lots of manufacturers slowed production because of COVID concerns and expectation of lower sales due to the expected recession only to find that demand was stable or even up as people adopted to remote working/learning, are we seeing now the peak of the Bullwhip effect? In other words, as manufacturers now try to catch up, how possible is it that manufacturers panic and over-order only to find that people got what they wanted and are not going to buy as much as expected this year? If that is the case, increased demand is not sustained growth. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_distribution_game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_distribution_game [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullwhip_effect
- kvgr 6y agoAnd Intel other Us chip companies are trying to get money from Government... there is something very wrong in the CEOs minds.
- dalbasal 6y agoThis isn't a real criticism, because I understand what they are trying to say but.... "Demand exceeds supply by X%", often a labour related headline, always makes me make the Marge Simpson noise. The framing is a direct contradiction of the main supply & demand theories/concepts. Supply and demand (within theory) are curves not amounts. It grates my circa 2005 economics education. That said... either definition of supply and demand are arbitrary. It is actually true that in many scenarios, the definition of supply and demand used here (demand is a number) is much more insightful and predictive of what happens in real life. Useful lesson that many/most abstractions and models are useful when they're useful, but we tend to get overly attached to them. There's a babushka doll element to all this. Divergent economic perspectives defined this industry, and the difference between US policies from (eg) South Korea. The Korean industrial policy is built on the "demand/supply is a number" concept. US industrial policy built on the "demand/supply is a curve" concept. South Korea subsidized the industry on the assumption that it's a massive growth industry. US policy of this era (circa 2000) expected declining US production as marginal profits declined. They also saw the process as natural and positive. Leading economies hand over cutting edge industries to the next tier economies, focusing on the new cutting edge industries. Next tier countries (ATT, south korea) can focus semiconductors, and offload their second tier industries. Textile manufacturing is at the bottom of this stack. Both US and Korean policy makers were correct. Apple is a great example. The product design, software and other high ROI (because low/no capital cost) elements remained in the US. Apple's profits are great. Their jobs (except retail) are all high paying. The parts of Apple with high capital investment requirements, lower margins, lower ROI or lower paid jobs were outsourced. This is pretty much the future 1990s economists in the US wanted. South Koreans were also right. The idea was that certain industries, like semiconductors are massive growth industries. A good place to establish a competitive lead. True. The also treated capital investment as a good thing, even though it lowers ROI by definition. I think the US mistake, if it was a mistake, was considering manufacturing a dead end... or a terminal destination. The truth is there will be more things to manufacture in the future, and a cutting edge manufacturing industry is the way to get a lead on that. Pathe dependencies can be important. It's an interesting story to pay attention to.. maybe a turnaround in some decades-dominant modes of thinking about industrial policy.
- imtringued 6y agoGood news for semiconductor companies. It's time to expand production!!