20 ms·
Well, Orwell had a thing or two to say about this in 1984. It's incredibly common in party politics. If you are the party that always criticize something, nobo
by marcosdumay 6y ago
Well, Orwell had a thing or two to say about this in 1984. It's incredibly common in party politics.
If you are the party that always criticize something, nobody will believe that you are doing it. So, if you plan on doing something, you accuse our largest opositor of doing it, loudly and repeatedly.
- cultofmetatron 6y agoThis puts that insane Qannon theory and the kids who went missing under Trump's kids in cages program in an entirely new context...
- z3ncyberpunk 6y agoYou mean Obama Biden's cages, they built them and continue to operate them after all. Exemplifying the point made above about hypocrisy
- cultofmetatron 6y agoLast I checked, Biden wasn't separating children from their parents at the border as a blanket policy and using them as leverage to get the parents to go away. Emphasis on BLANKET POLICY. Obama/Biden didn't put every child in a cage the way steven miller did. So no, I dont' see hypocrisy here. Its night and day. Trump's stewardship put these children in a lord of the flies scenario where they had to take care of each other and the leadership acting more like prison guards than caretakers. I agree that Biden should close those things down but he cant just release the children into the wild. He got left with a timebomb and care has to be taken when dismantling it. Time will tell if he commits to transitioning these children to more appropriate living facilities and finding their parents (https://reason.com/2020/10/21/545-migrant-kids-snatched-by-the-u-s-government-are-still-missing-parents/ https://reason.com/2020/10/21/545-migrant-kids-snatched-by-t...) or relatives. He's been president less than 2 months. it will take time to see if he honors his commitments.
- takeda 6y agoThe effort is in progress https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/lawyers-have-found-parents-105-separated-migrant-children-past-month-n1258791 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/lawyers-have-fo... They seem to locate parents for 1/6 of them within a month where trump administration just thrown hands in the air that nothing can be done, when court ruled that the children should be reunited.
- covidthrow 6y ago> ...it will take time to see if he honors his commitments. "I will not ban fracking." ...bans fracking "$2,000 stimulus checks for everyone." ...$1,400 checks for some "I have an extensive plan for COVID." ...doesn't have a COVID plan "We need to close the immigration facilities used to separate parents and children." ...Trump admin closes one site. Biden admin reopens it "I will eliminate President Trump’s... MPP on day one." ...hasn't ended the MPP So far, at least on the hot ticket items, he's not running a great track record. He's done a bunch of little stuff, but the big things promised during the campaign have systematically failed, and several the exact opposite direction. So, sure, let's see if the career politician honors his commitments. I'm not holding my breath.
- jjeaff 6y agoYou are reaching. re: fracking: When asked soon after the comment, he clarified that he was referring to fracking on federal property. The original context of his comments that he would ban fracking were usually centered around the controversy of Trump having opened up lots of federal land to fracking. Fracking on federal land is a small fraction of total output. re: 2k stimulus checks. Not sure what the actual intent was, but I immediately understood it to mean that they would send out $1400 checks because $2k was the initial amount that Dems wanted and GOP negotiated it down to $600. As for "everyone" well, do we really think -everyone- should get money? Very few people are in favor of high earners getting a check. re: covid plan. Not sure where you got that. He was working on covid and spending more time pre-Jan 20 meeting with covid experts and task forces than the president at the time. Who was preoccupied with his tv and phone. re: MPP. Looks like it is already underway. https://www.metro.us/biden-to-bring-in/ https://www.metro.us/biden-to-bring-in/ You have to unwind programs like this to avoid causing even more harm. re: immigration facility reopened. Biden admin provided extensive explanation of why they needed to re-open it. Unaccompanied children arriving at the border. They need some stop gap at the moment.
- adolph 6y agoHey, please correct this disinformation, its not a good look. Unaccompanied minor immigrants without documentation are safeguarded in facilities now, not jailed in cages.
- takeda 6y agoOk, let me correct these: https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/lawyers-have-found-parents-105-separated-migrant-children-past-month-n1258791 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/immigration/lawyers-have-fo... It's true they existed before, but they were used in situations when an underage child arrived to the border. Or child was found with human traffickers. They weren't splitting children from parents for longer than 42h. Trump was the one that made the cages full, by implementing the zero tolerance policy, separating children with parents and often deporting the parents making it difficult to reunite them.
- adolph 6y agoHey please focus on the issue at hand, Biden uses facilities not cages. Whataboutism isn't a good look for you. Please stop using the "C" word.
- secondcoming 6y agoIndeed, like fighting systemic racism with systemic racism.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoActually, that's one of the more reasonable strategies of this form. What would you have done to reduce the harm of that problem?
- covidthrow 6y agoWell, that "problem" presupposes an upward or stagnant trend, which are not demonstrably true. Then the admittedly harmful act of racism was used to accelerate resolution of "that problem". Here's the problem with that: - it was not demonstrated that other more productive forms of change were ineffective; in fact, history shows there has been tremendous progress in the absence of "racism to fight racism" - it has not been shown that "racism v racism" has improved "that problem" - it is yet to be shown the negative consequences of such a strategy, but history is full of examples of further suffering, not less You call it "reasonable", and yet I find a complete lack of reason in its use. When challenged to provide reason, all responses I've witnessed reflect an attitude of, "I don't need to give you a reason/justify it". To my mind, that is precisely absent of reason, so I challenge your assertion that it is in any way "reasonable".
- wizzwizz4 6y agoOkay, first up: make sure we're talking about the same thing. I'm talking about hiring (etc.) quotas requiring the demographics of (e.g.) a workplace to be roughly similar to the demographics of the general population. Fuzzy quotas, so a two-person team doesn't have to be representative but a 20 000 person company shouldn't be almost exclusively white men in their 30s.
- jjeaff 6y agoA steady forward trend of progress seems quite reasonable. As long as you are not the one who was on the receiving end of past injustice. In basketball, if someone gets fouled while trying to make a shot, is it unfair that everyone has to stand back while the person fouled gets to shoot free throws just because they are wearing the same color uniform? It would be great if we could leave race out of the equation when trying to right past wrongs. Unfortunately, when a past wrong was committed based solely on race, given limited resources, the remedy likely needs to be based on race as well.
- mito88 6y agobut if you're caught later on, then fasten your seatbelts
- varispeed 6y agoIf you own the media then you can sit back and relax. At most you'll get few days of moaning and things will go back to normal. Majority of people won't even know or connect things anyway. If media are licensed, then they will never run anything that will upset government too much. I've seen this many times. Even if hostile nation's media pick up the topic and report it honestly, the government can dismiss it as a conspiracy theory or just say it is an attack. Ultimately even if people see all the evidence, most of the time they'll pretend they didn't and stick with the status quo.
- marcosdumay 6y agoAs I said above, people will just not believe it. Things are obviously more complex than everybody just automatically not believing, and owning the discourse makes all the difference (although owning the press like a sibling comment says is overkill). But it happens again and again on politics, and rarely becomes a problem.