6 ms·
It's never made any sense that any county in the USA has mandatory single-family zoning. If a community wants to keep things sparsely populated they should have
by endisneigh 6y ago
It's never made any sense that any county in the USA has mandatory single-family zoning. If a community wants to keep things sparsely populated they should have to purchase land and houses at market rate to do so. As surrounding areas become more and more popular it would become more and more expensive to do so. That's how it should be.
If voting was mandatory in the USA this would've been fixed centuries ago.
- dtwest 6y agoWhile I agree with the general sentiment, increasing city density takes careful planning. If a neighborhood doesn't invest in the necessary public services such as transportation and education, more density can be a problem. So the entire community who pays for these services should have some say in what happens. That said, I'm still pro growth as long as we plan accordingly.
- duxup 6y agoAgreed. Unwavering the weave takes some care if you want to do it right ... do it wrong and I suspect you get even more opposition / problems.
- jeffbee 6y agoBerkeley's population has been static for more than 70 years. In the meantime we've built a freeway and a subway with three underground stations. Also the number of _jobs_ in Berkeley has more than doubled. It is high time the city grew its population in order to benefit from these infrastructure investments.
- runako 6y agoThe purpose of single-family voting is not to maintain sparse density, it's to keep the city white: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26252258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26252258 > If voting was mandatory in the USA this would've been fixed centuries ago. Those negatively affected by policies like this have only been able to vote for about 50 years.
- jacob2484 6y agoSigh... not everything is about race - folks may prefer live in a less developed, single-home community no matter the color of their neighbors.
- shuckles 6y agoSingle family zoning is about what you are forced to build, not about what people choose to live in. In fact, if the demand for detached SFHs was as real as you suggest, there would be no downside to zoning for multi-family; nobody would prefer to build it! Also, ultimately, the history of single family zoning is definitely all about race.
- caturopath 6y agoNot everything is about race, but American suburbanism is. I'm not saying that everyone who lives in the burbs is making a choice about race, but that is 100% how we got here.
- danans 6y agoFolks may prefer that, but the original policy in Berkeley was put in place 100 years ago specifically in response to the perceived threat of the African American influx. In highly developed urban/suburban areas today all over the country (not bucolic hamlets that people imagine), this zoning policy (along with others like large minimum lot sizes) effectively function as a demographic and economic sieve.
- omginternets 6y agoTo add to this, some things can be tinted with racism while also being motivated by other -- sometimes even legitimate -- things. It's easy to throw out the baby with the bathwater. It takes effort to throw away the bad and keep the good. As stated in another thread: it's not a bad idea to prevent apartments from being built such that they overlook a single-family dwelling's back-yard. EDIT: in all fairness, I should point out that others seem to know something about the historical origins of zoning policy that I do not. It's possible that I'm underestimating the degree to which racism played a role in shaping the legal landscape. Nevertheless, I can imagine a handful of legitimate reasons for single-family zoning...
- jeffbee 6y agoVoting is how we got here. A city or any entity can adopt exclusionary policies based on the votes of the people who already live there, which obviously excludes the people to be excluded. What we need is the next higher level of government to set basic ground rules. There should be a state right-to-build law that automatically permits a moderate level of density. There shouldn't be any place within incorporated cities of California you can't build a four-family dwelling on a 4000-square-foot lot.
- endisneigh 6y agoYou are right, however if voting were mandatory nationwide the situation you're describing wouldn't happen. If 1000 people live in California and 100 of those people live in Berkeley, even if all 100 people in Berkeley agree with something, if the majority of Californians disagree it would and should override what the Berkeleyians want. If voting is mandatory there's no situation in which a majority decision is actually suboptimal, unless you believe that a minority should somehow be able to override a majority. The way democracy is implemented in this country is effectively rule of the minority over the majority - the catch is the minority just has to draw arbitrary boundaries surrounding their decisions. You can already see this if you just look at the Bay Area - how can it be so difficult to build if polls show the majority of people support it? Turns out the minority (homeowners) have more power than the majority (renters) in the Bay Area.
- jeffbee 6y agoBasically you are saying that California cities should not have planning authority. I happen to agree but that's not on the table.
- endisneigh 6y agoIt's not about California specifically - in general the majority should always have to ability to reject the decision of a smaller body by pure simple majority. To believe otherwise is basically to not believe in democracy. To some extent this is already possible, but with gerrymandering and non-mandatory voting the obvious solution to this problem for the minority is just to suppress votes - hence mandatory voting.
- ed312 6y agoYou literally just need a thin majority of people in a community to force through zoning changes. Maybe people actually prefer to both live in and live around SFH-style development?
- Lammy 6y agoIt never made any sense to me either until I learned that there was effectively no black population to speak of in the Bay Area until World War Ⅱ and the Second Great Migration, but now I just see it as a form of easily-deniable economic segregation: https://i.imgur.com/Ke7GP1Q.png https://i.imgur.com/Ke7GP1Q.png See also: the "freeway revolts"
- dalbasal 6y agoNeither extreme is viable. OOH, interest groups exist and restrictive zoning can cause illogical cityscapes with way too little housing. OOH, no planning, no zoning and laissez faire dynamics don't really get you to a logical metropolis either. Both tend to fail at density. High density cities need as much investment in difficult infrastructure as they do in real estate. A lot of successful examples in the world at large are pretty highly planned. I'd also note that most are guided to some extent by national-level agendas. A purely local agenda isn't generally going to select fast change. All sorts of vested interest to the contrary. Property scarcity, but also other things. More people usually want their towns to stay the same. IMO, there really is no way around the need for competent, well intentioned decision making... on average. There's also now way around a need for intention. What's the actual goal for Berkeley? Where do they want to be in 30 years.
- ars 6y agoAnd what if your goal is low density? Your post assume the density is a positive goal. I disagree, I think it's a miserable way to live. Let people live how they want, and keep voting very local. Each city can have different density levels and housing styles. You want density? Move somewhere dense, and vote that way, I have no issue with it. I'll move to low density areas and vote that way, and I expect you not to have an issue with that either.
- endisneigh 6y agoI disagree - if you want low density and the area is popular you should have to pay for the privilege. People can live however they want in this world, just not for free.
- frongpik 6y agoThe US in general is a low density country and is a popular destination. Does it mean it should pay to whoever expressed the desire to immigrate to the US?
- dalbasal 6y ago
- caturopath 6y agoYour argument seems to be against all zoning of intensity, possibly against all zoning period, and doesn't address the fact that living in a rowhouse across the street from a high-rise building or factory can suck. Certainly, R1 zoning is a scourge: low-intensity should never mean "large lot, huge setback, short house, one door". Certainly, also, a land value tax that is allowed to grow with actual value should charge folks based on what they're taking from society by living somewhere (or whatever other use), to make single-family homes and parking lots and the like pay their fair share if they are going to exist. But I still think you might be making too sweeping of a statement in this post.
- endisneigh 6y agoMy argument is not about zoning at all - it's about democracy and the will of a population. In your example, if the majority of the people don't want the factory or high-rise building to be there, it won't be there. And if they do, who are you, or I to say otherwise? You either believe majority rules, or not. I happen to believe the former, but I do see many comments or believe the latter.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> You either believe majority rules, or not Coming up with a procedure to translate the opinions of people into actions by the state is not a yes/no question. There's the nuance of direct vs. representative, appointees, how things are structured. You can't boil down political philosophy to an "either/or" on democracy.
- Schiendelman 6y agoZoning period only exists to stop people of particular races from moving into neighborhoods. All the other things we see as benefits of zoning came later, in order to justify that original reason. And most of the things we assume zoning is protecting us from are misunderstandings. "A rowhouse across the street from a high rise building or factory" is not something government has any constitutional basis to regulate on its own; all that comes from a court case that was pretty explicitly to keep black people away from white people.
- u678u 6y agoIt makes a lot of sense if you like living in a neighborhood with single family housing. I live in an apartment, but if I had a house I'd hate for an apartment building to be built next door overlooking my yard. In most of the country private gated communities with HOAs are getting a big percentage of new housing. Keeping neighborhoods consistent is one of the reasons. I can't find a good link easily but wikipedia says 40% of all new housing in California is gated communities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gated_community#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gated_community#United_States
- jonahx 6y agoHonest question: Is the argument that, as a developer, I should be able to construct a large building with 1-person apartments the size of prison cells, say, if there is a market for that? Should the only limit be restrictions imposed by fire safety policy or similar?
- whimsicalism 6y agoThese are called SROs and their demolition in SF is among one of the many causes of the current visible homelessness.
- spiralx 6y agoNo, building codes are a separate issue from land-use restrictions. Apartments must still meet whatever standards exist which can include minimum facilities, size and number of floors. Although at the limit such standards can be effectively the same as simply banning apartments outright, so there is crossover.
- jdeibele 6y agoBefore we moved to our current house, a house a couple of blocks away was a meth lab, there was an accidental fire, and the fire department let it burn to the ground. My next door neighbor bought the property and had to go before the local neighborhood association to get their approval for building 4 houses on the acre of property. They were not happy with the idea of trading 1 for 4 until he showed them that one alternative was putting 28 townhomes on there instead. Then they got on board with his plan. As I understand it, the city would not have allowed a single home to have been built on the property. 4 was the absolute minimum. This is Portland, Oregon and things are pretty different here compared to a lot of other places.