6 ms·
What about a voting system? That's the only application of a public, decentralized ledger that can kind of makes sense to me. I'm from Switzerland, every few mo
by dgellow 6y ago
What about a voting system? That's the only application of a public, decentralized ledger that can kind of makes sense to me.
I'm from Switzerland, every few months we have a public voting for various changes to the federal or cantonal laws. I currently do not have a way to be certain that my vote is taken in account. With a public ledger I can check and be sure that my vote is correct.
I'm generally opposed to software voting because I have a complete distrust for such systems, but a public ledger (preferably not based on proof of work, so not ethereum) has interesting characteristics. And the price or inefficiency isn't an issue in this context.
Edit: people commenting seem to misunderstand the proposition. I'm perfectly aware of the privacy around voting and not advocating against it. It should be possible to have a system where your vote is registered publicly as a transaction between your wallet and a "referendum" wallet, in that case unless you have a way to link the public identity of a wallet to an identity (meaning people would somehow leak their public address somewhere) you do not have a way to know my vote. The only thing you could know is the number of total votes and their choice. You can of course generate a new wallet per voting as a way to not have a history.
Edit 2: the plausibility deniability is a fair point, I concede.
- 1337shadow 6y ago> I currently do not have a way to be certain that my vote is taken in account. That is something we do a lot of R&D on @Electis, along with the fine fellows from InfernoRed, Microsoft and others. Because the value of an election is the thrust that voters have in it! It is part of what the homomorphic encryption protocol we use (electionguard) aims at solving. Your ballot is encrypted with a joint public key, and all the "artifacts" of the election are published after it closes. You can verify that your encrypted ballot is present in the artifacts, and that the whole artifacts archive verifies mathematically. https://www.electionguard.vote/ https://www.electionguard.vote/ https://electionguard-python.readthedocs.io/ https://electionguard-python.readthedocs.io/ https://www.electis.io/ https://www.electis.io/ https://electeez.com/ https://electeez.com/
- dgellow 6y agoThat's great, thanks for sharing. That could be its own HN submission!
- the-smug-one 6y agoThat destroys plausible deniability, no? How would that system work?
- moomin 6y agoThis may surprise you, but most voting systems make verification hard deliberately. If you can check your vote at home, others can verify your vote as well, which means you've lost the advantages of a secret ballot.
- dgellow 6y agoYou can only know my vote if you have a way to associate an address with an identity. Unless that's the case, you may be able to check the set of votes, but that's it.
- Nullabillity 6y agoWhoever forces you to vote a certain way can force you to reveal your address too.
- dgellow 6y agoFair point
- KallDrexx 6y agoMaybe I'm missing something, but I think the original point is that blockchain will help the voting process by providing the transparency and verification in the process. And part of that is everyone being able to see that yes the winner won because we can see every vote and clearly see who won. However, that doesn't help unless you know that every vote was a legitimate and eligible vote. How do you know the votes are legitimate and eligible if the address is anonymous? You need some system to either publicly identify each address or you need a central authority saying which addresses are allowed to vote. The latter goes right back to the situation we are in today and the blockchain becomes no more useful than a centralized database, because we are still reliant on the centralized authority to tell us how many valid votes mattered.
- dgellow 6y agoYou have a list of citizens, their personal information are stored in your country databases. They have a unique key pair assigned at some point during their life (let's call it Citizen Key, may be paired to a Citizen ID or something like this). There is a new voting event, each citizen can now create a voting wallet using their Citizen Key then vote on the various motions by sending a transaction to a destination wallet created for this event. At the end of the voting event, the votes are counted and no transaction can be send to the destination wallet. You do have a central authority, it's the country (or state). Only citizens can vote, and only citizens have a valid set of keys. The benefits is that anyone voting or people who want to verify the voting numbers can do, and without having to trust the software managing the database (I mean, you of course have to trust the blockchain itself...).
- lopatin 6y agoA public ledger can be achieved without a blockchain right? My understanding is that a ledger can guarantee that your vote was counted, but it can't guarantee that all the other votes are legitimate.
- dgellow 6y agoThat may be the case. My point was to say that there is at least one potential application for a blockchain. But I'm sure that's not the best way to approach the problem, just a potential solution I could think of.
- jlokier 6y ago> With a public ledger I can check and be sure that my vote is correct Any voting system with a public ledger where you can later check your vote is a disaster for election integrity. It's probably surprising, and certainly counter-intuitive, but that's a vector for fraud. That's why we have a long history of secret ballots. And no cameras in the voting booth. From a comment a few weeks ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25739051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25739051): > you could look up your own vote and the votes of your friends to confirm You can't do that because visibility causes voting fraud. By coercion. If votes can be checked by other people, a very large number of people (enough to change the result) will be forced under threat by someone else to "vote correctly". The same happens if you can check your own vote, because any mechanism that lets you do that can usually be used by someone else - "give me your phone so I can check you voted for X like I told you to" (while holding a gun). That's why free & fair elections have secret ballots, without personal identification on the ballots. To prevent coercion fraud.
- dmichulke 6y agoIsn't this more about whom I trust less, the politicians or a third party (that might as well be the politicians)? If so, why is it in the state's power to decree that we have to trust the politicians but not the 3rd parties?
- jlokier 6y agoNo it is isn't. Secret ballots aren't about whether you trust those administering the election, although that's a factor. They are to let you vote as you privately decide with safety from everyone who has an interest in the vote, whether that's third parties, your boss, insurance company, local mafia, etc., or the state. The state's role, in a democracy, is to ensure state-level elections take place with the various ingredients that ensure it has high integrity. That requires a lot of things; a lot of resources, making sure everyone knows about it, making it clear the result will be respected by the state itself, acting as a coordination point with some kind of authority so that people will tend to respect that an election actually took place. If you have a third party available who can do that, by all means go for it, but generally you don't have one, and if you did you would start calling it the state. However, in a democracy the electoral process should be administered as separately as possible from the politicians of the day. Politicians of the day should not be getting much involved, other than to ensure it takes place with all the usual resources. Note that "the state" and "the politicians" are not the same thing in a democracy. The state consists of multiple institutions, many of which do not particularly trust politicians either. The people most directly involved in actually running it should demonstrate a commitment to the integrity of the election itself foremost, ahead of their personal political views. On the principle that democracy itself is more valuable than winning any particular election, while still being drawn fairly from a range of people. But they should be observed (without interference) at multiple levels by representatives of different political groups. Making a combination of people, systems and motivations to achieve integrity is the art of institution building (and maintenance), an electoral commission or something like that. Its independence from politicians of the day is one of its key features. Regardless of who runs it and who you trust, you still need secret ballots to ensure integrity of the result.
- irjustin 6y agoI'm against doing electronic voting and tracking [0]. Others have commented on the tracking/anonymous issues, so I'll leave that. Make the whole system as hard as possible to manipulate by involving a lot of people who distrust the person they're working with. There is a tiny chance your personal vote will get lost in all the paper handling, but you can be assured that the system is a lot harder to manipulate simply because of the sheer number of people involved. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkH2r-sNjQs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkH2r-sNjQs
- probably_wrong 6y agoThe main problem as I see it is that such a system would be completely inaccessible to anyone who is not a software developer. With a paper-based system, all you need to understand is that your paper goes into a box and someone counts it later on. Everyone understands every step, including the steps required to secure that box. But once you require people to understand blockchain you are putting the intregrity of the election in the hands of a privileged elite.
- dgellow 6y agoYes, that's a very good point and another reason I personally advocate for paper ballots. But you can also see it the other way: anyone can learn how to check their entry in the ledger, that takes time but it's not some rocket science. That can be democratized in a way paper ballot cannot be as it requires a huge amount of people and has an important cost for the community.
- the_snooze 6y agoIt's sad so many technically-minded people fail to account for this when it comes to trust, especially in the context of voting. You can't get people to trust a system by cloaking it in cryptographic black magic. It has to be scrutable to the people participating in it, especially the voters and volunteer poll workers who most closely interact with it.
- charcircuit 6y agoI don't understand that system. I drop off a sealed ballot in a ballot box and then that's it. I just have to trust that the system works. I have to way to prove that my vote was counted. I have no way to count the votes for. I don't understand the process behind how my votes get counted and it would be fine if people didn't understand how blockchains work.
- OldHand2018 6y agoIf you want to understand how your local elections work, just go volunteer when they ask for volunteers.
- 6y ago
- joshspankit 6y agoWhat about government spending? All the way from taking taxes to paying vendors. Including the spending of all politicians. (Minus a reasonable “dark fund” for military and whatnot simply because it can be important to hide your cards from other countries) If citizens can see exactly where their dollars go it could make corruption very difficult and lead citizens to be far more engaged in their democracies.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoWe could do that without bitcoin. Lot of things we can do, like make democracy more direct by allowing people to vote on issues from an app on their phone. The technology is there.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoThe difficulty with that is getting trusted information published, not storing it in a secured manner.
- joshspankit 6y agoIf citizens paid in COUNTRYCOIN (publicly-visible blockchain-based currency), all spending was done in COUNTRYCOIN, and all government loans (in or out) were in COUNTRYCOIN, then trusted information would be integral to the whole system. Yes a contractor could still charge $10k for a hammer, but citizens would uncover that almost immediately.
- rmah 6y agoYou can see where your tax dollars go now (except for the classified items, but even there you can see the totals). You can get detailed breakdowns of nearly everything, including salaries. For example, you can see every NYC employee salary here https://www.seethroughny.net/payrolls https://www.seethroughny.net/payrolls. If you want, you can scroll through the massive list of federal, state, local gov contracts on a variety of websites today. For example, Florida state gov contracts https://www.dms.myflorida.com/contract_search https://www.dms.myflorida.com/contract_search But the fact is, (almost) no one really cares. Many people want to believe they would care, but they don't really. Either way, knowing what's being spent where only makes corruption marginally more difficult. It certainly doesn't lead citizens to be any more engaged. We know this because what you want is already here and it has solved precisely nothing (IMO).