26 ms·
YouTube blocked chess channel after mistaken detection of racial slurs
- vinger 6y agoWhat triggered it white pawn takes black queen
- ggurface123 6y agoI guess the decision to take down the channel wasn't as black and white as they originally thought.
- afavour 6y agoNot sure what a thinly resourced piece like this is doing so high up on HN. There’s really very little evidence that this has anything to do with racial slurs. From a quick read: last June, the channel was banned for “harmful and dangerous” content. The ban was removed in under 24 hours. YouTube has not confirmed the reason. And yet: > Experts suspect that it was the usage of words like "black" and "white" that confused the Yutube's AI filters. Well, if experts said it, it just be true! The experiment they ran is speculative as best and the article just ran with it as absolute fact. If the filter was caused by use of “black” and “white” wouldn’t every chess channel fall victim to it? The filter isn’t new, why was it triggered once last June? A lot of questions raised and an article that has no interest in answering them. It’s credited to “Buzz Staff”… I think it’s always suspect when no one wants to attach their name to something they wrote. A smell of clickbait running all the way through this one.
- andrewzah 6y agoWell, what else might it be? Agadmator is just a chess channel. He does breakdowns of chess games and that’s pretty much it.
- afavour 6y agoThe block was for “harmful and dangerous” content. That’s incredibly vague. Even describing a game using aggressive language could fall foul of such a broad filter. How many times do non-chess channels get caught in this filter? That’s the first question I’d be asking. I have to assume more than zero times. How many chess channels have not been banned by this filter? Again, presumably more than zero. And yet the article makes conclusions with a dataset of 1.
- deepnotderp 6y agoHave you watched adagmator? He doesn’t really use aggressive language
- afavour 6y agoIt was just an example. Another example: “bishop attacks king” could be interpreted as dangerous or harmful content. It’s so vague we have no idea.
- DixieDev 6y agoThere are plenty of other chess channels using the words "black" and "white" to describe each side that have yet to be automatically and mysteriously banned. If it were as simple as usage of the word "black" in the various circumstances that might arise during a discussion about chess, surely some of those would have met the same fate, no?
- metiscus 6y agoYou would think so. I can construct many sets of sentences that could appear in an excited chess commentary discussion that would probably run afoul of various automated censorship systems. ...and black steals a pawn from white here. White springs his trap and white is now crushing black on the back row. .. and we can see black is completely dominating white's position. White is getting killed by black here... .. and black now has white in a complete stranglehold.
- aksss 6y ago..black queen takes white bishop ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
- arp242 6y agoThe real problem, IMO, is that we're all left guessing what the reason is. YouTube has a gargantuan task moderating its content, and I don't expect them to be error-free in this: false positives will happen, and that's okay. But it's the complete lack of transparency, as well as some YouTubers having difficulty getting their accounts restored that's the real issue. Maybe he used some specific phrase that triggered something? Or maybe he used some words just a tad too often? Or maybe something else? No one seems to know...
- zests 6y agoChess commentators might use various phrases that sound $COLOR-supremacist at different rates like "$COLOR is better" or "I prefer $COLOR".
- justapassenger 6y agoIt’s so high because it fits general HN narrative of evil big tech.
- anigbrowl 6y agoI posted it because it was an example of automation yielding an unwanted result.
- ttt0 6y agoAnd what do you do to force them to confirm the reason? That's right, get it to be so high up on HN.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- colejohnson66 6y agoOr get someone big enough that they can ask YouTube on Twitter WTF is going on. Like Markiplier in November 2019. He asked his fans to spam emojis in a livestream. So they did and were banned for spam. Their appeals - which YouTube says are reviewed by actual humans - were denied. It wasn’t until he went to Twitter that the problem was fixed. https://twitter.com/markiplier/status/1193218509804695552 https://twitter.com/markiplier/status/1193218509804695552
- ttt0 6y agoIf I remember correctly, it wasn't just YouTube. Because of that people lost their entire Google accounts, including e-mail, drive and whatever else people trust Google with nowadays That in particular made me go from just not using Google personally and occasionally bitching about their practices to actively discouraging everyone from using anything related to that company
- SilverRed 6y agoThis is why I like my accounts unbundled. One account per service thanks. Far too many horror stories of Rift users getting their facebook account banned without the option to have it reviewed and then losing access to all the games they had purchased.
- gameswithgo 6y agoagadmator doesn’t do anything hateful or dangerous at all, so we can see here his name is being tarnished as well
- incompatible 6y agoIt's old news, and it was discussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23729156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23729156
- twirlock 6y ago>A lot of questions raised and an article that has no interest in answering them Kind of like Alphabet.
- stubish 6y agoIndeed, hate speech is just a guess. It is just as likely it was taken down because it was a Pawn Site.
- lmm 6y agoIf YouTube won't give any explanation for these decisions then assuming the worst is entirely fair.
- dagmx 6y ago> Not sure what a thinly resourced piece like this is doing so high up on HN. Honestly, and anecdotally, I think there's been a large influx of people recently on the right wing spectrum and/or the more outrage driven spectrum. I've noticed a considerable shift in the number of outraged comments and right wing view points in the last few months. I believe this ties in to the deplatforming of Parler. I can only surmise that it either led to a lot of lurkers becoming more active, or an influx of new members joining to share their outrage and sticking around. Or maybe it did shift existing members over to being more sensitive about what they perceive as internet policing.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoThe tech world, while seen as largely as being left wing, has had a strong right-wing libertarian streak. This streak seems to have followed the same right-ward march and increase in rhetoric as your standard conservatism.
- dagmx 6y agoOh definitely agreed. Even in silicon valley, which is perceived as a liberal tech Mecca, I'd say I run into a significant number of right wing libertarians. I read a really good post somewhere that it's because libertarianism is highly based in absolute logical theory. This correlates really well with software engineering. There's a sense that the world can be reduced to an ideal localized function. But it ignores why we need designers to accommodate the human element or architecture that considers error handling. Furthermore as a result of it being based in logical absolutism, it's really easy to corrupt by introducing polarizing concepts under the guise of "rational thought experiments" and the like.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- redisman 6y agoMaybe the median person just doesn’t hold extremely intricate positions in these issues but they are being forced to choose a position. You really need to break these claims down a lot to get any sensible discussion. All in or all out are not the options.
- jandrese 6y ago> Well, if experts said it, it just be true! The experiment they ran is speculative as best and the article just ran with it as absolute fact. It’s not like Google is going to explain why they were blocked. All the creators can do is guess.
- Bodell 6y agoThis article does contain very little information. But this channel is one I watch a lot of. It is dedicated to in depth chess commentary with some bits of chess history and I highly recommend it if you play. This it not the first time this has happened to Antonio. He even discussed it a bit the first time, 7 months ago. In that instance it was a single video that was removed. In that video he says “white will always be better” while analyzing a specific position (interesting to note that in the starting position of chess this is also always true). YouTube said it was removed for “harmful and dangerous content”. Without anything else to go on I’d say it’s a fair assessment the it was banned for racial content. I’m not sure what else could be “dangerous” about chess analysis. https://extra.ie/2020/07/02/news/world-news/chess-youtube-video-removed https://extra.ie/2020/07/02/news/world-news/chess-youtube-vi...
- aaron695 6y agoTranscript here I think- https://downsub.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DvrFa4B0Ghjk https://downsub.com/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwat... Very little talk of black or white or covid. I'd most likely guess "Suicide" from the skydiving talk but perhaps "Shooting" from the film talk. I guess you can make stuff up really. "oh man like you look like you're so high you're just going to jump to your death but uh then then once you actually cross that across that that line you just jumped it's uh just exhilarating i i really enjoy it i do plan on doing it again in the future" > Not sure what a thinly resourced piece like this is doing so high up on HN. Very strange comment.
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoIt's because it hits on the widely held position of right-wing ideologies and white supremacists being "censored" by big tech
- anonytrary 6y agoYou're not sure why this has so many upvotes on HN? The title is anti-google and most people on the internet only read titles. It makes sense that this community would heavily upvote this post. I did not read the article either, mostly because IDGAF anymore. Big tech companies banning whoever they want is the new normal unfortunately.
- wait_a_minute 6y agoThis must be nipped in the bud before it just turns into a billionaire’s tool for shutting down conversations on class consciousness.
- andrewzah 6y ago“ The researchers now suggest that social-media platforms should incorporate chess language in their algorithms to avoid future incidents like this.” Or maybe don’t automate banning YouTube channels via nebulous black boxes? Or can advertisers stop being afraid of anything and everything?
- bartread 6y agoBear in mind what we have here is an example of the cutting edge of AI in its real world use. It doesn't exactly inspire faith in AI if some of the best is this thick when it comes to making decisions that would be incredibly basic for a human of even below average intelligence.
- das4119 6y agoFrankly the whole thing stinks. On the whim of an unaccountable AI basically anything can happen. We need laws around this sooner rather than later. AIs are getting more powerful but less responsible. Just don't have an argument about a book or you could end up on death row. Gordon Dickson wrote a short story about this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computers_Don%27t_Argue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computers_Don%27t_Argue
- Aerroon 6y agoWhy do we need laws around this? We need to hold the people accountable that put this into production and/or produced it. People should be able to build bad AI, but if that causes poor real world outcomes, then the people that okay'd its use need to take responsibility. "An AI erroneously banned the channel," shouldn't get any more leeway than "A support staff member banned the channel."
- texasbigdata 6y agoBecause the inner bias that humans have that might lead to similar exclusion is implicitly hidden and somehow excused and the machines are held to a higher standard, for some reason.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yissp 6y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem
- andreynering 6y agoI recently took some actions to reduce the damage if Google ever ban my account. I'm now using a custom email domain (although it's just redirecting to my Gmail for now), and doing regular backups of my emails (through Thurderbird) and Google Drive. With these news being more and more common, you never know when it'll happen to you.
- cube00 6y agoThis is a good reminder. Many people don't realise if any one of Google's services ban you it takes down your Google account at the same time (GMail, Drive, Docs etc), it doesn't just block that single service where the alleged violation occurred.
- judge2020 6y agoIt depends, but generally yes. YouTube DMCA strikes, for example, are known to only nuke your YT channel(s) and the rest of Google still works[0] (although this page does say your entire account is subject to termination[1]). Getting banned from the other services is much harder, of course. 0: https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/respond-to-copyright-takedowns_copyright-strikes-basics_list https://creatoracademy.youtube.com/page/lesson/respond-to-co... 1: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2814000?hl=en#strikes:~:text=If%20you%20get%203%20copyright%20strikes%3A https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2814000?hl=en#stri...
- tenpies 6y ago> Getting banned from the other services is much harder, of course. Is it? All it takes is someone at Google not liking what you're saying for Google to conveniently allow a bug to "accidentally" de-activate your account[1]. Google's slogan may as well be "self-censor or be censored". [1] https://medium.com/@zacharyvorhies/open-letter-dear-attorney-representing-tulsi-gabbard-this-is-how-google-is-accidentally-ee9ebac11dbd https://medium.com/@zacharyvorhies/open-letter-dear-attorney...
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y ago
- impendia 6y agoIncidentally, if you like chess the channel is outstanding. (And back online now.) https://www.youtube.com/user/AGADMATOR https://www.youtube.com/user/AGADMATOR I enjoy watching on my lunch breaks. Great breakdowns of games between top players past and present.
- cambalache 6y agoAgadmator is a mediocre player (as in no titled) and his analysis are pretty simplistic but he has created a good community of kids around his channel and he is a nice fellow. For actual analysis of quality you could check out the Chess24 channel where you have guys like Peter Svidler and other GMs analyzing games. The Spanish version is great too, you can find there all the top Spanish speaking players (Dominguez, Vallejo, Anton,Granda, etc)
- ourmandave 6y agoI'm an unrated "kid" and subscribe to Agadmator channel. That happened a while ago and was practically a none event.
- zests 6y agoChess24 has the highest level of commentary by far but chess.com can come close. Also, Peter Svidler is on the roof.
- pgwhalen 6y agoAgadmator may be "mediocre" (aka still better at chess than anyone I've ever met in person) and his analysis simplistic, but that might actually help him on his mission. Which seems to be to make chess as consumable as a mainstream sport: nearly immediately following a game, he gives you the highlights - just enough so that the game has an exciting narrative, even if the analysis is not extensive.
- jojobas 6y agoDelegating prosecution of possible hate speech to commercial entities was always going to be bad. Youtube is essentially a public forum with audience of entire countries, where the people who run it choose what gets amplified, what gets shunned and what get outright blocked. Who would be happy with a private entity deciding the future mindsets at this scale?
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoThat is it exactly what I’ve been saying about twitterführer Dorsey ever since he blocked the NY Post. Though in his case he went so overboard with banning and blocking everyone with a viewpoint he didn’t agree with that he made all the other world leaders take notice and be concerned that they could get blocked just as easily. I expect that after the next G7 summit we will start to see the social media companies broken up and/or regulated, or countries may just bleed them with fines to enable new players to get a foothold.
- jojobas 6y agoWe're at the point where social network companies can break up countries, not vice versa. Some related fiction (or is it?) https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/10/30/sort-by-controversial/
- StanislavPetrov 6y ago>Who would be happy with a private entity deciding the future mindsets at this scale? The people who own the private entities (and those with close connections to them).
- haunter 6y agoinb4 someone will suggest that FIDE should change the color names to be more inclusive + why does white have the first move advantage, why can't black be the first. Perfect breeding soil for just another day of pointless race drama on Twitter
- waterhouse 6y agoYou joke (I think), but given what happened to the "master" branch on GitHub, it seems likely that some people will try to push the point, and, if they make enough noise, it's likely that the organizations involved will eventually cave (not the chess grandmasters (!), but the administrator types). I googled a bit and turned up a couple of news articles: https://apnews.com/article/184386cc09be6c69535919402a13fa3f https://apnews.com/article/184386cc09be6c69535919402a13fa3f and https://au.sports.yahoo.com/chess-centre-stunning-racism-debate-which-piece-moves-first-012917664.html https://au.sports.yahoo.com/chess-centre-stunning-racism-deb...
- dmingod666 6y agoThe github change is brought up by a lot by people, but, all github does here is this. On the default set of commands it shows you if you don't have a repo pushed, it shows you the help command with 'main', instead of 'master'. Just a word change on a default help document, that's it. If you knew your commands you wouldn't even notice this. If you just make a repo and push your existing code to github, it will work with 'master' as it is.. they actually don't have much of a say in how people name the git branches without severely shooting their whole service in the foot..
- SilverRed 6y agoiirc git was also looking in to changing the default name when you run git init. Yes, it makes no difference at all, its just a name. But the fact is that a lot of people felt it very important to make this nonsensical change. There is no reason why the colors of chess pieces would not fall under the same justifications.
- wheresmycraisin 6y agoSo, assuming YouTube makes some manual adjustments to their algorithm to not flag/ban chess content, I wonder if actual hate speech will start pretending to be chess content in order to avoid detection.
- smitty1e 6y agoWe're never going to achieve justice Justice until we ban those ultimate bastions of hate, the English language and Roman alphabet. Anyone who has ever used these instruments of injustice is tainted. Oh, wait.
- Simulacra 6y agoIIRC the technology industry has moved away from master and slave terminology, is this still true, and could that get someone blocked?
- abacadaba 6y agoTime for chess to follow our lead on this one.
- noobermin 6y agoTheir either needs to be competition for Youtube or they need to face regulation. You can't have it both ways. The system does not work without one or the other.
- ignoranceprior 6y agoThere already are competitors to YouTube, and technically there's nothing stopping anyone from making their own video hosting site. Except overwhelming first-mover advantage and network effects, of course.
- dmingod666 6y agoand sneaky practices like not allowing you to uninstall YouTube from android devices. Remember Microsoft and Internet Explorer..
- mensetmanusman 6y agoTheir face regulation wouldn’t recognized certain faces.
- dmingod666 6y agoAmadgator is a one of the top chess youtubers, after carlson and hikaru. They should have a human-check placed by channel size - if for nothing else just to not get bad PR like this.
- JshWright 6y agoGotta include Gotham in that mix (personally I'd rate Gotham over Amadgator).
- ignoranceprior 6y agoI personally like Eric Rosen, because he's got that calm and relaxing Bob Ross energy.
- mahathu 6y agooh no my queen!
- trhway 6y agothe chess is a very aggressive game of premediated threats and attacks with the goal to achieve dominance and control over another player. It fosters individualism and combativeness instead of teamwork and collaboration. I think it should be age restricted like say alcohol and driving.
- LocalH 6y agoIt should be a criminal act to ban someone from your platform without pointing exactly to why they were banned. "Oh but we can't expose details of our ban process for people to game" Bullshit. They just don't want to have to answer to anyone for cutting them off.
- jfoster 6y ago> "Oh but we can't expose details of our ban process for people to game" Bullshit. Exactly. If that were the reason, they should also make the rules of the platform secret, since making the rules public will result in people "gaming" (aka "acting in accordance with") them.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoGDPR contains automated decisionmaking rules: https://gdpr-info.eu/art-22-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-22-gdpr/
- perryizgr8 6y agoWhy? YouTube has no obligation to host anyone's videos. If these chess channels don't like it they can make their own YouTube.
- ttraub 6y agoSo, create your own platform, like Parler tried to do?
- Bakary 6y agoIf YouTube doesn't like (still hypothetical) laws that regulate it, it can always look to other markets
- LocalH 6y agoAnd business owners should have no obligation to provide fair access to their services, right? They should be able to refuse service for any reason?
- aksss 6y ago
- jonathankoren 6y agoIsn't this old? We were just talking about this very problem seven months ago. It's hard to believe Youtube didn't put in some hack or retrained for chess to avoid this high profile embarrassment in seven months. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23729156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23729156
- raarts 6y agoIsn't the biggest structural problem with ML that it can't explain how it came to a specific conclusion? Anyone knowledgeable on this subject?
- viraptor 6y agoThere's a difference between "we can't tell you exactly why X was classified as it was", and "this phrase was classified as bad". Here, YT knows exactly what triggered the issue and can review the decision.
- lmm 6y agoML absolutely can, if you bother to implement it that way. And non-ML systems can be just as opaque. The problem isn't ML per se, it's lazy organisations that don't care.
- fastball 6y agoNot really. The limitation is mostly in the training set. If you train an ML algo on a set of videos that you either banned or didn't, sure, when you run that in prod all you'll get out of it is "ban or no". But if the training dataset includes a ban reason, then the inferences will include reasons too. What is opaque is how the algo decided the thing was violating the policy. That applies to supervised learning. For unsupervised learning, you can still do this by requiring a valid rationale as part of the "win condition".
- lmilcin 6y agoIt gets more ridiculous with every day. I fully expect people to start developing vocabularies to harden their group communication against these automatons. Also, please, don't use term "AI". Calling it intelligence is too charitable for something that can't distinguish game of chess from hate speech.
- lovecg 6y agoSort of like Soviet dissident authors developed a roundabout way of writing to bypass the “algorithm” of the state’s censorship bureaucracy.
- egerardoqd 6y ago"In this position, black is better."
- Applejinx 6y agoI know I've got an audio plugin (AU/VST) called Bit Shift Gain, because it applies the exact gain changes required to just bit-shift the exponent of the floating point value one bit without touching the mantissa. It's a handy plugin for clean gain changes (completely reversible without loss so long as you're gain boosting, not clipping, and then cutting again). I can't say its name on youtube on my own channel, 'cos YouTube thinks I'm saying something else. (not sure what would happen if I kept on doing it. Maybe they would start sending me apprentice Nazi traffic :D )
- bryan0 6y agoAgadmator’s channel is truly a gem. He provides excellent analysis of interesting games and includes some great dives into chess history as well. I hope google gives an adequate explanation for this and makes sure it doesn’t happen again (not holding my breath)
- CalChris 6y agoIt has happened before already. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSjrYWPxsG8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KSjrYWPxsG8 You would think he'd be whitelisted.
- whoooooo123 6y ago> whitelisted Bzzzt! You have been banned from HN for using racist terminology.
- constantine42 6y agoLots of talk about false positives. As a human, when dealing with fuzzy logic, I like to focus on recognizing when something is wrong to reduce false positives. Maybe Google should put more effort in training AIs to recognize when they don't know instead of shoehorning an answer. An analogy is I would expect a non-stupid human who has never seen a screw before, but trained to work with hammering nails to quickly recognize something is wrong the first time they're presented with a screw and not attempt to hammer it flush.
- ttraub 6y agoTheir algorithms seem to be looking for the words "black" and "white". I posted a comment to a YT video just today describing my daughter's experiences in high school, the school's recent heavy emphasis on black lives matter (the topic has crept into History, Cooking, Math, and even Chemistry) and the kids, including the few black kids at the school, think it's excessive. The comment disappeared when I refreshed. I reposted (have learned to always cmd-C), and it was taken down again. So I substituted "bite" for white, "back" for black, and this time it stayed up. Ridiculous and counter-productive, in my opinion.
- fortran77 6y agoThis was only speculation. It's a pretty weak story: > Even though the channel was restored within 24 hours, the YouTube did not explain why it had blocked Croatian chess player Antonio Radic, also known as 'Agadmator,' from its platform briefly, the Dailymail reported. > Experts suspect that it was the usage of words like "black" and "white" that confused the Yutube's AI filters. They found that 80% of chess videos that were flagged for hate speech actually ahd terms like 'black,' 'white,' 'attack' and 'threat.' YouTube didn't say why, and they simply "suspect." It's just as likely that is was flagged for other reasons. For example, mass "reporting" of the channel as offensive by people with an axe to grid against this particular chess YouTuber. (It's been my personal experience there's a lot of politics in the chess community.)
- sytelus 6y agoWhat is amazing is how there is no way to recover from all these algorithmic banning. I'm getting banned on Twitter every other day from following anyone because I follow a lot of academics. It's all legitimate but algos detected some pattern and I'm now toast. Twitter provides exactly zero ways to report this or fix this. They simply don't care if some monority users suffer. We see same things when Google disables account and you get locked out from your electronic life. I used to think working with governments is very hard. Getting support in places like DMVs and passport renewals is super hard. But never thought so futuristic tech world will be so much more arcane and worse than even the governments.
- doctorOb 6y agoI had a friend call me–practically in tears–because YouTube removed his highest viewed video game montage for violating their hate speech policy. Context: WWII tank game playing as the Germans, usually with some old german language folk song in the background. It's algorithmically removed and most likely algorithmically reviewed upon appeal, and there's basically no recourse for him. Meanwhile, similar videos by other creators have their content left up. I have to remind him that, unfortunately, YouTube has no shortage of content and absolutely nothing to lose from false flagging a subset of it, compared to the pushback they get for letting something truly horrible slip through the cracks.
- m1keil 6y agoClick-bait title.
- jimmytucson 6y agoI didn’t know Agadmator was censored so I looked for information and found a video of him talking about it here: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KSjrYWPxsG8 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KSjrYWPxsG8 He doesn’t know why his podcast was flagged. He mentions a few possibilities-one of which is the black and white thing, which would be a mistake. It’s notable how guarded his speech is, as though he might say something else verboten. I’ve watched hundreds of chess videos on YouTube and never heard of one getting flagged until now.
- kyleblarson 6y agoIt is fascinating to witness tech giants and the academy move towards a singular focus on melanin and gonads in the name of wokeness.
- cdolan 6y agoIs it just me, or did this article have an incredible amount of typos and grammar mistakes given its length? Various missingspaces, Carnegie Melon[sic], etc.
- kdmytro 6y agoResponse from the YouTube support team: > Sorry about that
- avipars 6y agofitting for a site named news18.com
- _a1_ 6y agoI wait for the day that chess will be banned in USA, or some fork of chess will emerge, because obviously chess is racist: white is always first.
- mik09 6y agoare there any mirrors to youtube? i tried to search this but nothing promising showed up. i think this might be due to the sheer size of the video site. but is there a site that saves the newest videos for the last 3 days?
- rsynnott 6y ago> They found that 80% of chess videos that were flagged for hate speech actually ahd terms like 'black,' 'white,' 'attack' and 'threat.' Surely effectively all chess videos, banned or not, have those words in them? This all feels pretty speculative.
- doublekill 6y agoWhat happened during start of pandemic is WHO and big tech meeting up to discuss the threat of an "infodemic". Companies such as Google, Facebook, and Twitter, agreed to suppress amateur takes on COVID. Mentioning COVID would vastly decrease your reach if not a verified public health source. It would get you demonitized, to not incentivise low-quality clickbait COVID videos. Of course, these algorithms are way more aggressive and produce more false positives (ads removed for just mentioning COVID without giving false cures, like happened here). It has nothing to do with white or black and race. Just the nitwits at WHO and big business mismanaging crowd intelligence during a pandemic. WHO said masks do not work. Youtube banned users for mentioning vitamin D defiency and COVID. But they meant it well...
- f137 6y agoHow come that in 21st century we are still using the racially degrading terms, like black and white, in so many places? Does it take a lot of effort to replace them with neutral non-offensive colors? Speaking about chess, don't you think that chess being mostly-male mostly-white is a direct consequence of the language they use?
- killtimeatwork 6y agoI'm (only) 80% sure your comment is a parody.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI'm not sure how to word this... I'm confused that we are still calling people "black" and "white", when their actual color is nowhere near those two. It's no longer cool to call people "yellow" or "redskin", so why are those still accepted? People I know actually use "dark-brown", "light-brown", and "light-skinned" and other such more accurately descriptive terms when actually describing someone's appearance, and I like that much better.
- StanislavPetrov 6y agoThat sort of nuance is diametrically opposed to the tribalism pushed by race essentialists currently en vogue in the United States.
- torgian 6y agoExcept no racial slurs were used. Just “black, white, attack, threat”. People love making clickbait titles.
- sjaak 6y agoClbuttic.
- toto444 6y agoI wonder if this could be manipulated the way redditors used to manipulate Google image by posting 'this is a house' with an image of a potato and after enough upvotes, the potato would appear first if you searched house on Google image. What if people start publishing hate speech but replace the hateful words by, say, 'Alphabet' ? Will the AI learn that Alphabet is a hateful word ? Surely someone with enough resource should be able to do that.
- singularity2001 6y agogood idea but no need for that: The word 'Google' is increasingly so loaded with hatred against it, that in the future the algorithm will just ban the whole mother company.
- prepend 6y agoWhat’s funny is how this shows how bad poor algorithms can be at scale. Even with human intervention. These cases have lots of exposure and people who notice. So the real QA is in these edge cases where customers find bugs. I worry about how not so visible algorithms. I had a company market to me about sentiment analysis. I asked their accuracy and they answered that they can’t actually test but their training model has x%. So to make decisions accordingly. But then I had coworkers doing stuff like what percent had what sentiment vs the other with no assumptions. I think the problem is people are kind of bad with probabilities so something either is or isn’t. And I seem to witness a gulf where there are people who kind of understand and then people who don’t but trust the output.
- 02020202 6y agofree speech on youtube is tight!
- cletus 6y agoThe mistake a lot of companies are making is they view ML as a replacement for humans. It's not. At least, it's nowhere near that now. You should view ML as an enhancement for humans. So the problem here is that no ML system without essentially being an AGI is capable of fully comprehending context, in this case use of "black" and "white" in Chess that has absolutely no racial context. So the mistake here is (likely) automated action against the channel. That should never happen. At least, not for this particular signal. What should happen is the channel should be flagged for review by a human. Any human would appreciate the context and take no action. This is the "enhancement" part. With no automated assistance, a human might be capable of moderating (made up numbers) 100 channels. That doesn't scale at Youtube scale. ML systems might enhance that human's moderating ability to 10,000 channels. Even better, by flagging for review, you're actually producing training data for your ML. The P-R for your automated disciplinary system needs to be incredibly good before you take humans out of the equation. False positive bans or blocks on channels is bad for the individual channel. It can be devastating in fact. The corporate view is that "one channel doesn't matter". And they're right... to a point. At some point it undermines confidence in the platform and then it does matter.
- tinus_hn 6y ago> They found 82% of the comments flagged in a sample set didn't include any obvious racist language or hate speech, So 18% did include obvious racist language or hate speech?
- throw7 6y agoAgain with the lies. Youtube did _not_ block agad's videos for racial slurs... "Experts suspect" that may have been the reason youtube blocked the video(s). Youtube didn't say why.
- benlumen 6y agoYouTube should not be blocking any channels or taking down videos in all but the most egregious circumstances. These companies are absolutely out of control and have been for a while.
- theknocker 6y agobut computers are good and help people so that’s why I think it’s good that google fights nazis
- jgalt212 6y agoWhy is Google so averse to "human in the loop" solutions?
- jC6fhrfHRLM9b3 6y agoYet they allow rampant anti-white racism.