9 ms·
As we noted previously, it means that many Kia owners may be unable to remotely unlock their vehicles or warm them up during an especially nasty winter storm hi
by userbinator 6y ago
As we noted previously, it means that many Kia owners may be unable to remotely unlock their vehicles or warm them up during an especially nasty winter storm hitting much of the country this week.
Cars had remote unlock and start decades ago (if not OEM, then aftermarket systems were and still are widely available), with zero dependence on what appears to be the company's servers. The only advantage I can fathom for being able to unlock and start a car over the Internet instead of only by being within radio range seems more oriented towards attackers and other user-hostile scenarios ("your car has now become a subscription, please pay to unlock it"). Have we gone backwards...?
- 14 6y agoThis is what I was thinking as well. It is frustrating to see and make me feel less sympathetic to Kia’s situation
- joe_the_user 6y agoThe amazing thing is realizing that despite the increasing dangers and actual disasters involved, more and more things are going to be put on the Internet. The equation everywhere is "the cost of the security is always too high because the failure of security is always an unusual situation and something that usually works and is cheaper will win in the marketplace." Have we gone backwards. Yes, expect more of this.
- faeriechangling 6y agoWhat's described in the article is not a security problem. It's an availability problem. I would argue consumers DO care about the availability and I see lots of cloud based systems with local fallbacks. When IKEA introduced cloud devices, IKEA hardly a company known for high prices or using expensive stuff in their products, they had local fallbacks. Their product is competing with the reliability of less expensive devices controlled with a light switch. Locks are another case where if you reinvent the wheel and get significantly less reliability people will be mad.
- PeterisP 6y agoAvailability is 1/3 of what we traditionally define as security (Confidentiality, Integrity, & Availability), so it definitely is a security problem.
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoYes, business continuation and disaster recovery is often considered a security discipline for this exact reason. Not every disaster is a hurricane or an earthquake; there are plenty of man-made threats to availability.
- jcims 6y agoI don’t know if it’s helping but I’ve started to blend in the term safety to try to bridge that cognitive rut of security = hack avoidance.
- siculars 6y agoThis is more or less exactly the scenario that played out in Texas this week, Feb 14-19 2021. All the players (gov, regulators, power generators) decided that it was too expensive to weatherize the network for a 0.1% chance event. Yet... here we are. Entirely predictable.
- kilotaras 6y ago> weatherize the network for a 0.1% chance event. The last one such event (also with blackouts) happened in 2011 and was generally called "1 in 10 years cold snap."[0] Not weatherizing for 0.1% chance can be acceptable, not doing for 10% is not. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/05/us/05storm.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/05/us/05storm.html
- Ma8ee 6y agoIt’s how capitalism works nowadays: I win or you lose. As long as everything is going well, like normal weather or excessive growth of house prices, the capital owners make a lot of money. But when something predictable goes wrong, the bill is left to the consumers and tax payers.
- faeriechangling 6y agoIf Kia's don't have a local override using a key or fob (?) it's just a simple misapplication of technology. Even where you are would want to control locks from the internet, security concerns be damned, you need a high availability way to open the lock locally. New technologies aren't nessecarily robust against misapplication
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoCurrent Kia models even at the base level have both keyfob and phone app remote start, the former obviously doesn't depend on their services.
- jgilias 6y agoI wonder if there are any car manufacturers boasting a 'dumb car' lineup. The current trend is pretty worrying. And sadly, it seems to get even worse with EVs. For some reason car manufacturers seem to want to market their EVs as 'smart-cars'. Which I find cringe worthy.
- crocodiletears 6y agoIt's likely a similar situation to televisions. Large fleet acquisitions may have the option to request telematics be disabled on their vehicles. Never operated a fleet, though - so that's my speculation.
- navaati 6y agoThere kinda is: Renault has Dacia.
- adav 6y agoAren’t Dacia cars just facelifted older Renault models with the manufacturing moved to markets with cheaper labour?
- vbezhenar 6y agoNo, they originated from Romania models and have nothing to do with original Renault models AFAIK. I own Dacia Sandero 2015, it's as dumb as possible and I love it. Not sure about latest models, I know that there's some smart stuff added, like remote engine start, but AFAIK no Internet connectivity yet, just radio channel (and, of course, it's optional).
- dingaling 6y agoOP was correct, the early Dacia models were license-built older Renault designs. The first post-merger models like Sandero were based on a stretched Renault Clio 3 platform. The new ones are built on the Renault-Nissan CMF-B, as are new Ladas.
- 6y ago
- sneak 6y agoWe have indeed gone backwards. Most homes and businesses have LANs, and yet almost every app works in a client/remote-server model, adding dozens of SPOFs where there need not be any.
- rixed 6y agoMost LANs have firewalls that only accept the model of a distant central server, though.
- chki 6y ago> The only advantage I can fathom for being able to unlock and start a car over the Internet instead of only by being within radio range seems more oriented towards attackers and other user-hostile scenarios Your car might be parked further away than the radio distance, especially if you're living in a big city with few parking spaces. There are also a lot of scenarios where you are not at home but want to preheat your car anyways.
- bartman 6y agoYes, exactly. I‘m very happy my Hyundai has this feature as city parking more often than not means walking a few minutes to my car. Being able to pre heat, check the battery level, etc remotely is a feature I would not want to miss.
- grawprog 6y agoThe whole idea of an internet connected car that constantly 'phones home' without any easy way to bypass or disable is kind of mind boggling to me. I don't understand why after this people weren't in an uproar. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/11/business/tesla-battery-irma-upgrade.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/09/11/business/tesla-battery-ir... When Tesla decided generously to temporarily grant residents fleeing a hurricane an upgrade that allowed full usage of their battery. People's lives were literally in the hands of an optional, upsold firmware softlock. The fact that it's come to that is completely appalling. When the manufacturer of your car has the power to save your life because if they didn't they'd suffer bad publicity is disgusting. And the fact is, the only reason why hackers are able to gain access to vehicles, the only reason for any of it is because companies have decided cars need to be a service provided by them so they can keep making money after the initial purchase. People buy cars so they can travel freely without relying on others. Making cars reliant on a third party server for something as basic as the ingition goes against the entire premise of owning a car.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago>People's lives were literally in the hands of an optional, upsold firmware softlock People's lives are literally in the hands of optional firmware softlock all the time in medical devices that you can find in hospitals. If the hospital doesn't pay for x feature or for support technicians to service them, then some people could actually die. Saving lives or not, you can't blame a company for not giving you for free features you haven't paid for.
- calvano915 6y agoAlso look to Boeing 737 Max crashes caused by the "base model" lacking relatively cheap safety indicators and redundant sensors.
- letitbeirie 6y agoDidn't the option just cover the AOA disagree indicator? AFAIK even the planes with that option only read from the pilot flying's AOA sensor before their fix was implemented.
- PenguinCoder 6y agoYes, it has indeed gone backwards. I refuse to pay for the remote start 'subscription'. Utter stupidity.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Cars had remote unlock and start decades ago Do you mean buttons on key fobs? That's not what this is about. This is apps on phones that let you access the car. Why would you want to do that? Range of the signal, additional functionality (you can see the fuel level for example), and you don't need to have your key fob to use it.
- faeriechangling 6y agoNot having your key fob is huge for... Well... Accessibility by multiple definitions of the word. ADHD for instance makes it very easy to forget your keys and very easy to remember your phone.
- bathtub365 6y agoThis is a pretty flimsy argument for always having your car connected to the internet. Could people with ADHD not drive cars until the era of smartphone apps?
- throwawayboise 6y agoWell anecdotally, my teen drivers are constantly misplacing their keys. They never seem to lose their phones. I don't remember losing my keys all that often as a teen myself, but it definitely happened a few times.
- bathtub365 6y agoProbably because if you lost them you didn’t have a way to start your car ;)
- umanwizard 6y agoAs someone with textbook ADHD... yeah, honestly, it was pretty difficult. I lost my keys constantly. Luckily now I live somewhere with good transit options, and haven’t owned a car in years.
- 6y ago
- ska 6y ago> Have we gone backwards...? Sort of. A lot of this is pushed by fleet sales, where it makes more sense (to the customer).
- justapassenger 6y agoBattery life is partially a reason. If your car would be online 24h, it’d drain 12V battery faster. And you cannot trust iOS or Android not to kill your app in the background, when it’s waiting for the car to be awake to communicate. Servers can queue that for you.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoKey fobs still work with or without internet access. No dependence on the company's servers. This would only break the mobile app's ability to unlock the car, for example if you misplace your keys.
- darkerside 6y agoPragmatic indeed. Wish this appropriate reaction were closer to the top.
- jtsiskin 6y agoAlthough I imagine there’s a nonzero amount of people who have lost their keys already, and have been relying on the app rather than pay for a replacement.
- capeterson 6y agoThis could be (partially) remedied through periodically requiring the user to pair the key and phone (bluetooth, wifi?). It's kind of an annoying solution, but it sounds like a bit of a security risk to just let someone permanently stay logged in to an app like that without requiring authentication every once in a while.
- thinkmassive 6y agoCan you actually drive these vehicles without the keyfob present? Unlocking and starting from the app make sense, but that doesn’t mean it will allow you to put it in gear without a hardware transponder.
- Ma8ee 6y agoA lot of car pools rely on the vehicles being able to be driven with only the app.
- Cd00d 6y agoI have a 2021 Subaru and can start and lock/unlock the doors from a phone app. But, I cannot put the car in gear without the key present, and it will not run for more than 10 minutes without manually starting the car from the driver's seat with the key even if the engine is already running.
- midasuni 6y agoThe “s” in IoT stands for security
- loosetypes 6y agoIs it not the same with most aspects of software as consumption reaches economic critical mass? Systems designed by and for users lose control to business interests. Leading to streaming over media ownership, as we become renters in every domain. Movies, shows, music, video games. “To improve the consumer experience” reads ever closer to “with DRM we can charge subscriptions in perpetuity (telemetry’s just a bonus!)”. Why would I want or require internet to play a single player computer game? At least with cars, perhaps we’ll begin to see some pushback.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krageon 6y ago> Have we gone backwards Yes, I think this is a reasonable conclusion from your priors.