7 ms·
That's science fiction with no grounding in reality. You may as well be going on about transporters and transparent aluminium. Every time a Moon mission comes
by jiggawatts 6y ago
That's science fiction with no grounding in reality. You may as well be going on about transporters and transparent aluminium.
Every time a Moon mission comes up, Helium 3 gets trotted out, but it's just absurd.
For one, billions of tons of rock would have to be mined to extract any reasonable amount of Helium 3. Even with heavy machinery and robotic miners operating 24/7, this is a stretch.
But much more importantly, Helium 3 is utterly useless. It was proposed as one possible fusion fuel but then a much cheaper alternative was developed almost immediately: breeding the required fuel from a blanket of Lithium.
Last, but not least: There are exactly zero fusion power plant operational on Earth right now. There will be exactly zero commercial fusion power plants operational on Earth for at least a decade, no matter what new technologies are developed. At the current pace, according to current plans (e.g.: ITER/DEMO), there will be one (1) power plant generating a trivial amount of power staring in 2048. Likely well into the 2050s there won't be many more.
So to summarise mining lunar He3: We should spend trillions of dollars digging up the Moon for power plants that won't exist for three decades and don't need need the helium anyway.
- pfdietz 6y agoIt reminds me of an old saying: "if we had some eggs, we could make ham and eggs, if we had some ham."
- milkey_mouse 6y agoIf my grandmother had wheels, she'd be a bicycle.
- adolph 6y agoThe little old lady from Pasadena certainly has wheels, but she’s no bike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Little_Old_Lady_(from_Pasadena) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Little_Old_Lady_(from_Pasa...
- Aeolun 6y agoI just find those timelines hard to believe. We just condensed a 10 year vaccine development and rollout process into 1 year, and that was mostly because of human trials. The reality is that nobody is interested in funding such an effort for fusion.
- Invictus0 6y agoHard problems aren't comparable in that way. The vaccine timeline was "shortened" because the timeline doesn't include decades of foundational work in molecular biology that made it possible for the vaccine formula to be determined within days of the virus' genome publication.
- jiggawatts 6y agoIn principle, it is in the best interests of every nation on Earth to get together and organise along the lines of the famous Manhattan Project to develop fusion. Throw money at it like we've been throwing at COVID. Multiple teams working in parallel in a race to solve the problem, like the vaccine development teams were. Eliminate the red tape. Cut the bullshit. Get on with it. The payoff would be worth it a hundred times over. Not just because of cheap, clean energy, but also because the earlier we start weaning ourselves off of fossil fuels, the better. But did you notice my choice of words? I said nations, not governments. Governments do not represent their nations. They represent themselves. And they are made up of a small number of greedy, self-interested, mostly corrupt individuals looking out for their own personal benefit. They benefit from bribes (coughconsulting jobscough) from their "partners" in industry. The oil industry. The coal industry. The gas industry. Not just mining! Even power generation industries have a vested interest in delaying fusion as long as possible. There is no fusion industry yet, and non-existent industrialists cannot pay bribes. This is the essence of why governments are disinterested in the future. They're only interested in the bribes they get in the here and now. Oh, I'm sorry. "Alleged" bribes, I mean... perfectly legal donations. Worse, the scientific bodies involved in the nascent fusion industry, like ITER, have become cancerous. They exist now only to justify their own enormous scale. A growing bureaucracy that benefits only from its own size, not in achieving its goals. Hence the plans out to 2050. The longer the better. Got to think about all the project managers that want to reach retirement age and start collecting that pension without ever having to actually deliver.
- legostormtroopr 6y ago> Transparent aluminium Good sci-fi always has an eye towards the future - we have transparent aluminium now. The whole point of science is to push the boundries of our knowledge. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aluminium_oxynitride