9 ms·
The market in power should only exist to optimise. Its become a rei-ified good in its own right, and is being gamed by bad faith actors with stranded assets (co
by ggm 6y ago
The market in power should only exist to optimise. Its become a rei-ified good in its own right, and is being gamed by bad faith actors with stranded assets (coal, oil) to make a point about green power and capital investment money they want.
It's possible no power network could have avoided some of this, but its patently obvious a regulated power utility function needs investment, and the market is not the best model to get it: its the one federal and texan politicians wanted.
A public utility model is not perfect. I argue it would have been better than this, and identified the capex required for systems resiliency before this crisis hit.
The energy market is not the solution. The energy market is the problem.
- mrDmrTmrJ 6y agoHonestly, I reach a very different conclusion. Comparing ERCOT to other grids (PJM or CALISO), ERCOT system has delivered very low prices and very high levels of renewable penetrations. PJM wastes billions of dollars a year in capacity payments to coal plants for no reason. What you write, "The market in power should only exist to optimise" well, that is exactly what ERCOT does. As for the disaster last week, that was a energy system failure as Texas regulations did not require the natural gas infrastructure to be winterized. Climate change creates more extreme weather events (in all directions but on average warmer) so polar air meant there wasn't enough methane ('natural gas') to power the turbines and heat. So the issue is the winterization standard in the natural gas infrastructure, but nothing about the structure of the electrical market. Certainly we need stronger resiliency standards! Events people once thought occurred "1-in-100 years" are actually like "1-in-5 years" in their frequency. And this will only get worse. But that's not a market structure issue it's a standards issue.
- godmode2019 6y agoI'm sorry but how does a trace element affect the polar vortex/ jetstream bending. It doesn't. Its not a good argument if all weather situations can be explained by "climate change". It's too hot - climate change It's too cold - climate change What you are describing is called weather.
- asmithmd1 6y agoAlso, when an obvious market failure kills dozens of people, “free markets fix everything” is not correct.
- Sparkle-san 6y agoClimate change leading to temperature extremes in both directions is an open question within climate science. There are some theories suggesting this is the case and there are skeptics of that theory, but if you've proven otherwise then you should probably submit your research to them.
- godmode2019 6y agoI agree, I feel the burden of proof is in the new theory, rather than - here is a hypothesis, prove its wrong. It's pretty clear in the small scale studies co2 concentration affects temperature in the direction or warming in the long term and the short term affect of cooling because less energy makes it to the surface. (Similar to clouds or smog/ smoke blocking light) But a causing extreme cold weather events..
- hn_throwaway_99 6y ago> the short term affect of cooling because less energy makes it to the surface That's absolutely not true, and I've never even heard climate change skeptics argue that.
- godmode2019 6y agohttps://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/02/210202164535.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/02/210202164535.h...
- carbonguy 6y agoThis article is referring to the effect of a class of compounds called "aerosols," which does not include CO2. Aerosols do prevent some fraction of solar energy from reaching Earth's surface, but this is separate from the effect of increased CO2 concentrations.
- Osiris 6y agoIf the market solves all problems why would the government even need to mandate winterization? Wouldn't smart businesses have done the risk analysis and done the work? Maybe the problem here is that loss of electrical power has a significant external cost that isn't absorbed by the utilities. In other words, the cost of winterization was more than the cost to fix the damage to their equipment but doesn't take into account the cost to everyone else. Externalities are, in my opinion, one of the primary reasons for market failure.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> If the market solves all problems Straw man.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIn a truly free market, Texas would have simply received power production from nearby states that were connected into their grid. This isn't a free-market situation because the state has gone to great lengths to keep this power system isolated.
- jtbayly 6y agoThe other states that were struggling with blackouts? No. Being on the same grid wouldn’t have solved this, as far as I can tell.
- josephg 6y agoFree markets seem to do a bad job with resiliency. Redundancies, winterisation, warehousing N95 masks just in case, etc is treated as inefficiency by a free market and eliminated. These aren’t externalities - is there an economics name for this? I’m sure it’s been noticed before.
- kortilla 6y agoFree markets do account for huge shortages, but we’ve eliminated the motivation for actors to do something about it with anti price-gouging regulations. There would be tons of stockpiles if businesses could appropriately upcharge when there was mass panic buying. Instead we stupidly lock prices, which wipes out most of the point of paying extra storage costs compared to a just in time competitor. The problem is we’ve as a society don’t like when prices go up with demand so we’ve crippled markets in their ability to deal with these types of events.
- ggm 6y agoIt optimised against resiliency and the state oversight did not capital invest. If the market was meant to ensure resiliency it failed. Now, the green sources are being blamed by AGW deniers for causing the outage, and the coal and oil baseload story is back on the table.
- katbyte 6y agoHow much lower then the rest of America? What about compared to Canada? Is that difference more then the human lives lost, property destroyed and time wasted during the last few days?
- dann0 6y agoA free market approach also places focus on the wrong performance indicators. Why is “very low cost” even a consideration when it leads to under investment which in turn results in significant power outages for significant periods of time. The low cost of delivery is irrelevant if there is a strong chance that I’ll freeze to death because my service provider tries to be efficient and profitable instead of trying to be 100% online. I understand the desire to avoid waste and inefficiency, but free market approaches tend to ignore the human factors and prioritise the financial. That’s not the correct.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe only way to exclude the market from the equation is for the state to have total control over the entire energy pipeline, from pulling natural gas out of the ground to the power plants to delivery. You can't simply mandate that energy prices will be a certain amount if the power plants still have to buy natural gas and other power sources from the free market. If you tried, the power plants would simply shut down when it wasn't profitable according to the legislated rate, making the problem even worse. If you tried to legislate that power plants or energy producers must sell energy at a fixed cost no matter what it costs them to produce and they can't shut down, they have to price that risk into their long-term model. You're now paying more for the same service just to make it worth someone else's while to take the risk. The energy market at least provides a feedback loop to large, energy-consuming businesses. Large consumers of electricity like manufacturing facilities will simply decide to shut down when energy prices are too to be profitable, and wait for the cost to go down. You don't see this as a homeowner, but there are industries that adjust their schedules around energy pricing.
- njarboe 6y ago"You can't simply mandate that energy prices will be a certain amount if the power plants still have to buy natural gas and other power sources from the free market." You can and that is what California did[1]. It lead to large scale blackouts, the first bankruptcy of PG&E, the successful recall of California's governor Gray Davis, and brought to light Enron's crazy company culture which lead to its bankruptcy. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000%E2%80%9301_California_electricity_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000%E2%80%9301_California_ele...
- Florinator 6y agoI think you've just described Germany, which has the highest electricity prices in the world.
- monadic5 6y agoGermany isn't an international embarrassment at the moment.
- cbmuser 6y ago> The energy market is not the solution. The energy market is the problem. No, unreliable power sources such as wind, solar and gas are the problem. Except for a short outage due to a sensor failure, the four nuclear reactors have been steadily supplying electricity. The overall availability of nuclear across the United States is >90%. It’s far more reliable than any other source of electricity. > https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/what-generation-capacity https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/what-generation-capacity To avoid such outages in the future, Texas needs to build more nuclear reactors. No other source of energy is weather-independent, can store fuel supplies for several years on site, is emission free and extremely high capacity factors.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoLots of regions with bitterly cold winters have wind, solar and gas plants that function just fine.
- j4yav 6y agoAren't all of those used quite consistently and without issue in many places much colder than Texas?
- hh3k0 6y ago> No, unreliable power sources such as wind, solar and gas are the problem. > Except for a short outage due to a sensor failure, the four nuclear reactors have been steadily supplying electricity. > […] To avoid such outages in the future, Texas needs to build more nuclear reactors. From an article I've read the other day: > “This is a perfect example of the need for reliable energy sources like natural gas & coal,” tweeted U.S. Sen. Steve Daines, a Republican from Montana, on Tuesday. > In reality, failures in natural gas, coal and nuclear energy systems were responsible for nearly twice as many outages as frozen wind turbines and solar panels, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which operates the state’s power grid, said in a press conference Tuesday. "Texas blackouts fuel false claims about renewable energy": https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/texas-blackouts-fuel-false-claims-renewable-energy-75936319 https://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/texas-blackouts-fuel-fal....
- KDJohnBrown 6y ago
- silvestrov 6y agoI could argue that there isn't really a market as the Texas grid is (almost fully) isolated from the rest of USA. The first change should be a federal law that all electric grids in USA are well connected so there is one big market place and Texas would be able to get electricity from other states. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Interconnection For a reference: see how many other countries that a 3-million citizens part of Denmark is connected to: https://www.electricitymap.org/zone/DE?page=highscore&solar=false&remote=true&wind=false&countryCode=DK-DK2 https://www.electricitymap.org/zone/DE?page=highscore&solar=... (Needs Chrome/Firefox due to WebGL).