11 ms·
Metallica's BlizzCon Performance Ruined by Twitch
- cbanek 6y agoI really hope the South Park creators run with this one. The episode about Metallica and Lars fighting Napster is one of my favorites. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Rock_Hard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Rock_Hard Not a big deal?!?!
- bitcharmer 6y agoAwesome, it was Metallica who started the whole nonsense behind today's state of DMCA. Finally getting some taste of their own medicine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- splaytreemap 6y agoMetallica almost certainly still got paid, so I doubt they care much. Blizzard is probably furious.
- kzrdude 6y agoMaybe they'd need to be paid twice - is there a way to license the music for online streaming? And was it done as part of the contract in this case?
- Mc_Big_G 6y agoMetallica is probably not in it for the $ much these days. I'd wager it's more about ego, so this probably stung. Deservedly.
- lawnchair_larry 6y agoAs a teenager, I thought I had a right to enjoy their work without paying for it. But this attitude surprises me from adults. Why don’t bands deserve to be paid for their product?
- blandflakes 6y agoI want to pay artists for their work. I don't want to lease the bytes representing my access from a company, and then have them vanish later, because some kind of licensing agreement changed. Metallica was a huge driving force and public supporter behind the shitshow behavior. Do you like rootkits? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agowell the industry corrected itself by pushing a la carte subscription music services which is what the freedom fighters hate but it turns out it's exactly what the people wanted all along.
- blandflakes 6y agoI think it's pretty valid to want to pay a price for music, and then take that file wherever you go, without having to reconnect to update a license (I both pay for a subscription to Spotify and mp3s a la carte). Of course, that's also available today, but that's not really relevant to the problem being discussed, which is: it's possible to want to pay artists, while also finding overzealous enforcement of the DMCA problematic.
- ulisesrmzroche 6y agoI don’t think so. You have no right to ownership just because you buy the song. You didn’t commission it, you didn’t write it, produce it, market it, and so on. All you did was pay a couple dollars. In effect, all you’re doing is buying a license to play the song for personal use, not the right to keep the file forever.
- blandflakes 6y agoThis is a weird take. There are stores that literally grant you that right, today. I'm pretty sure that even in the US, a court is not going to grant a musician the right to force you to delete the MP3s you bought off Amazon music. What is the basis for your belief that you don't have a right to the file you bought? Or are you disagreeing with the existence of stores that operate that way? Or with... basically the entire history of hard copy distribution, like cassettes, CDs, vinyl...
- Dirlewanger 6y agoPeople just can't let something from 21 years ago go, can they? The band's done a complete 180 on everything regarding digital distribution, and it's been this way for years (I'm sure owning their masters and own label has something to do with it). You want a real culprit who actually thoroughly abused (and still to this day) the DMCA? Get mad at the RIAA. Also, if it weren't Metallica, it would have been someone else; virtually every big artist at the time felt the same way but didn't speak up.
- michalstanko 6y agoNot sure why are you downvoted. It's hard to find a similarly popular band sharing more stuff online for free these days than Metallica. Besides, the entire Napster thing was about a song "I Disappear" being available through Napster BEFORE it was even finished and sent to CD manufacturing, and, don't forget, it all happened in 2000. It has not been on their radar for about 20 years now. Hating based on skimming headlines of inaccurate articles is surely easier than trying to understand the band's motives.
- jcpham2 6y agoI guarantee you people still volunteer their time to bootleg anything this band does on the internet, forever.
- capsulecorp 6y agoI think many people don't buy their "complete 180", as that only came after their massively failed campaign. I have no doubt that if these guys were successful in their initial endeavor there would have never been a 180 as you call it. So really, there's not much to praise about a group who tried their hardest to do the wrong thing, and settled for the alternative when they failed measurably. Glad this happened to them, well deserved.
- throwmusician 6y agoAs artists, why shouldn't Metallica get paid for their work? I can't believe the audacity of people thinking they should just be able to steal others' (by virtue of copying) music. The people I know in the music industry are some of the hardest working that I know... And to be clear, Metallica was never against online streaming / downloading, only illegal piracy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 6y ago> we have to imagine the band is "madly in anger" with Twitch over the fiasco No, we don't. It's unlikely they care.
- johnday 6y agoYou may have missed the joke.
- Supermancho 6y agoThe irony is the only thing about this event that is noteworthy. The attempts at humor (album title) beyond that fall flat, but YMMV. Regardless, that quote was the heart of the assertion from a non-story.
- chromatin 6y agoThis is poetic, really.
- fixmycode 6y agoI watched the stream on YouTube and the audio was kept as is. I doubt it would be the same for the VOD later but, couldn't Twitch do the same? Also, isn't Blizzard or Twitch breaking their ToS by simultaneously streaming on Twitch and YouTube?
- kmfrk 6y agoIt wasn't just Twitch's platform: it was Twitch's own channel /twitchgaming. On YouTube, Blizzard just streamed it to their own channel, and they've surely cleared the rights (for now).
- pkroll 6y agoI don't believe there are any ToS covering simultaneous streaming on Twitch and YouTube for either service.
- grogenaut 6y agoPartnered streamers sign away co streaming rights to become partners and get those benefits. For most streamers, they want a community and costreaming does the opposite of that For super large events having a split works. Large events aren't usually partners in the typical sense
- thatguy0900 6y agoEven if there was a tos issue, I'm sure blizzcon will be on their own contracts for this kind of stuff
- f1gm3nt 6y agoTo this day I still boycott anything Metallica. I loved Napster and would run out and buy CDs to support the artists. This makes me happy, but doubt they even care.
- nightowl_games 6y ago> I loved Napster and would run out and buy CDs to support the artists. You realize how self-centered this is, right? How it isn't indicative of the general public? This is like saying "I love drunk driving. I live in Alaska where there's no one around so there's no one I can hurt."
- thatguy0900 6y agoAre you really comparing downloading music to drunk driving? That's wild.
- nightowl_games 6y agoYes I am making that comparison. It is a reducto ad absurdium argument. I skipped all the steps where I illustrate the value of copyright law and the value of music and then draw a parallel between "but I buy the CDs" with "but I don't hurt anyone".
- orwin 6y agoI didn't endanger people when "pirating" Metallica's (well, ACDC and Twisted Sisters rather) CDs when i was younger (and a lot poorer, single unqualified mom in a small city and all that). Emule and bittorent helped me get access to a culture i didn't even know existed, brought me awy from TV shows and helped me learn english and to books i now own. I'm sorry for Butcher, Feist and Sanderson early years, but i think i have the whole collection now, and i couldn't afford to buy those books anyway (i don't think i could even find them in my country) Drunk driving just made me gain 40 minutes while probably endangering a dozen people (and i immediately stopped after the first time). Also every time i buy storage i pay a tax to Universal and other CP owner while not having any licenced music (unless they own Tchaikovsky, Rachmaninov, Pachelbel, and a lot of pre-63 music in general) on those storage. Also they should give 40% of that tax to the Linux foundation since packer and weird images are taking almost half my disk space? Anyway, i know how prod works, more than half of them are parasites and don't add any value (well, not exactly, they add their daddy political connections, that's something). It does not surprise me, what is surprising to me is that this many people defend them.
- haunter 6y agoHow come Twitch aka Amazon can't solve this DMCA problem like Youtube aka Google? What does Google do differently than Amazon?
- Dirlewanger 6y agoBecause they don't care, and they have 0 competition (streaming on YT is a joke).
- boffinism 6y agoYoutube have solved this problem??
- haunter 6y agoThe Youtube stream was not muted. The VOD was not muted. Everyone else uploading the video cut of the song is not muted and removed. They are demonetized but the video is up with the original sound. So yes Youtube does something differently than Twitch where everyone deletes VODs asap or they replace the sound (like what happened on their own official channel)
- mhuffman 6y agoLet anyone have your content removed for any reason! -- problem solved! - youtube
- ttt0 6y ago"No man, no problem", as they used to say in Soviet Russia.
- plorkyeran 6y agoYouTube has built out a monetization platform which makes music companies want to have their music on YouTube. Twitch has nothing remotely comparable, and somehow I don't think streamers would be happy with a YouTube-like solution of "any sub money made while you're playing music go to that song's rights holder instead of you".
- 6y ago
- lrossi 6y agoThis is karma for all the pain caused to independent artists by copyright censorship “AI”.
- darkstar999 6y agoStreamer CDNThe3rd saw this coming live and played with it. https://mobile.twitter.com/CDNThe3rd/status/1362928445353787395 https://mobile.twitter.com/CDNThe3rd/status/1362928445353787...
- thatguy0900 6y agoThat's hilarious
- phone_book 6y agoThis is light on details. Blizzard had their own channel up and was playing the music. This clip is from Twitch's channel. Lots of streamers were restreaming the event and right before this performance, there was a message that said, "The upcoming musical performance is subject to copyright protection by the applicable copyright holder." I imagine only Blizzard themselves had the rights to stream it. You can watch it on Blizzard's channel https://www.twitch.tv/videos/920697882?t=1h24m52s https://www.twitch.tv/videos/920697882?t=1h24m52s
- henrikschroder 6y ago> and right before this performance, there was a message that said I understand the legality of it, but this is absurd! Anyone, anywhere, could watch the original livestream and hear the music. Or, you could watch it on Twitch, and get commentary on the whole thing by your chosen favourite twitcher, in addition to watching it yourself. But then, for legal reasons, the music was replaced. You could imagine a technical solution where Twitch just streams the twitcher against a transparent background, and you have to stitch it together yourself with the official stream, resulting in exactly the same experience as if Twitch did that stream stitching directly. That would be ok for legal reasons, even though it's completely identical to the not ok for legal reasons version above. How does that make sense? Why does it matter, to Metallica, where the streams are stitched together? Why does it matter, to them, that everyone watches the completely free stream of their music from a specific source, and not any other source? The value to Metallica is that they're getting paid by Blizzard. The value to Blizzard is that it drives attention to Blizzcon. Why does either of those entities care how exactly people are viewing Blizzcon? What matters is that people are watching it, and the how is secondary. But because of copyright laws, the how matters, and we get this absurd state.
- jcpham2 6y agoIs the internet’s memory really this short on this band’s historical stance on copyright, RIAA, Napster, and so forth? They’ve always been like public enemy number 1 of music pirates...
- trollied 6y agoAn idea for Twitch: 1) Allow you to link your Amazon Music/Spotify/whatever account to your Twitch account to prove that you are licensed to stream songs from a given platform. 2) Allow a streamer to provide a 2nd audio channel in their bitstream, from their choice of service. You then only deliver this 2nd audio channel to people that have a link in place to said service Simples. Probably needs rights geolocation checking adding
- rektide 6y agoTwitch is already adding 2nd, separate music tracks, via Twitch Soundtrack[1]. They have negotiated their own licensing of some music catalogs for use here. The article mentions "sync" rights, which is the right to have music accompanying a video system. So in your system the user having the right to listen to the music is not enough. In this hell-hole shit-world the RIAA & MPAA & others have created, there are endless infinite licenses & they all require brutally disgusting carefully negotiated licenses, each & every time. What terrible people. The legalese continually gums of the creative & cultural works of our society, causes endless nightmares & prohibitions. The systems seem to only grow in complexity & become ever more inhumane. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/12/21562372/twitch-soundtrack-riaa-music-youtube https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/12/21562372/twitch-soundtra...
- trollied 6y agoWhat a mess. It's almost as if they don't want people to use & enjoy music.
- noja 6y agoWas this just for the restreamed videos?
- hertzrat 6y agoThe online world is controlled almost entirely by buggy algorithms that have been given a lot of impactful decision making power. This sort of thing happens so often. Usually, it’s a permaban of an individual user for undisclosed reasons and without the possibility of reaching support
- paulsutter 6y agoThey were obviously playing pre-recorded music otherwise it wouldn't have been a match, which is actually even funnier
- lights0123 6y agoGiven that the message was > The upcoming musical performance is subject to copyright protection by the applicable copyright holder (emphasis mine), this was configured manually by a human before the performance even started.
- Shadonototro 6y agolot of hypocrisy from Twitch amazon has enough money to pay for rights to play the music and twitch streamers are also full of sh:t, they are the one who refuses their clips to be reused by people on youtube, and when it comes to people's music, they want to be able to freely use them I never liked this twitch community, they are very toxic and they take everything for granted!
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y ago> Several commenters online have pointed out the irony of this happening to Metallica. The band, particularly drummer Lars Ulrich, has been heavily critical of online music sharing, and the band had a high-profile case with Napster back in 2000. Is that not the opposite of ironic?
- aaron695 6y agoShhhh you are making sense, it gets in the way of outrage and schadenfreude.
- grawprog 6y agoSo, blizzard tries to team up with Metallica to garner publicity after some fairly terrible publicity only to have Metallica's stream removed from the most popular game streaming service currently existing due to DMCA and now it's gotten them both negative publicity. I feel like there's some irony buried in there somewhere...
- cush 6y agoSomething tells me someone at Twitch knew this was going to happen and let this transpire as a fuck you to Metallica and DMCA. Metallica is widely known as one of the absolute worst bands for cracking down on small creators for using any amount of their content. They ended Napster and pushed back against digital music for years. Absolutely love the band, but they just don't get it. Same for a lot of the best older bands too (Led Zeppelin, AC/DC, KISS, etc.)
- fencepost 6y agoClearly overlaid with the wrong music. It should have been a string quartet of very very tiny violins playing a sad song.