3 ms·
It's not fraud though, is it? They advertise that you'll get food from Restaurant X and that's indeed what you get. It's not fraud to resell product, you don't
by chrisseaton 6y ago
It's not fraud though, is it?
They advertise that you'll get food from Restaurant X and that's indeed what you get. It's not fraud to resell product, you don't need permission from the original seller to do it (in fact I think that's a specifically protected right), and it's not fraud or any kind of trademark violation to describe a product as being from Restaurant X if that is a fact.
- whelming_wave 6y agoThe objectionable behavior is that they represent themselves as being restaurant X, or at least present themselves in such a way that finding out that they aren’t actually restaurant X but a reseller is difficult. edit: This got way more discussion than I anticipated. I think that even if there was a massive banner on the top of the site that told you GenericDeliveryCo was operating this website as a front for the restaurant, we are not them, etc, this behavior by GenericDeliveryCo is still damaging to the businesses they are creating websites of because they tend to absolutely bury the real website via better SEO. There’s an argument to be made that some restaurants would enjoy having a website made for them - for business or whatever other reason - but there’s no reason GenericDeliveryCo couldn’t... ask first.
- chrisseaton 6y agoOk but see how we've slipped down from full-on 'fraudulent' to just 'objectionable'? People are allowed to be objectionable if they want to.
- roenxi 6y agoMr. Wave may have meant legally objectionable as in "the objection that would be the core of the legal case" or "the legal system objects to this". Similar to how a legal complaint doesn't mean someone whining.
- chrisseaton 6y agoIf they did then what do they think is the infraction or offence that is being committed? They're being objectionable by committing or infracting... what? What law or regulation would they be breaking?
- jychang 6y agoTrademark law, mostly. If I open an Apple Store, I'm gonna get a lot of lawsuits headed my way in no time. You can't just use another company's logo and name without their permission.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> You can't just use another company's logo and name without their permission. I'm afraid I think you're mistaken. You're allowed to use someone's trademark to factually describe the product you're selling. You don't need the owner's permission to do that. If you're selling an actual Apple laptop, you can use the trademarks 'Apple' and the Apple logo to describe it. If you're selling an actual Bob's Burger, you can use that trademark and logo to describe it.
- varjag 6y agoIt could be eye opening to create an applestore-sf.com and try selling apple laptops there.
- chrisseaton 6y agoOr macrumors.com for a website about Macintosh computers! They'd surely shut that down since it uses a registered trademark! Oh no wait...
- alistairSH 6y agoExcept macrumors is obviously a news/gossip site and makes no effort to pass themselves off as an actual Apple-operated website. apple-sf.com (and the various food delivery sites being discussed) pass themselves off as the restaurant. It's not clear to a casual user that the order is being processed by a 3rd party.
- amelius 6y ago> People are allowed to be objectionable if they want to. Isn't that what we (should) have judges for? I mean, if a judge blindly follows the letter of the law, we can replace him/her by a computer.
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut you need some kind of infraction or starting point if you want a judge to consider it. 'They're being objectionable' is not a reasonable starting point. 'They're being fraudulent' would be... but they clearly aren't being fraudulent.
- jacquesm 6y agoMisrepresentation isn't fraud but it is still not legal. You can't pass yourself off as someone or some entity that you are not. See also: 1-900 numbers pretending to be 'the company' but actually just switchboards connecting you through to the company that they pretend to be.
- tobmlt 6y agoYes indeed. I guess I will use this comment to explore its objectionable properties. I think I can come up with a somewhat nuanced reason for objection (not saying this has any bearing on legality). Let me talk it through. Here goes: The Resturant gets paid and the customers get food. The delivery service adds value and gets paid for it. If someone doesn’t realize doordash is not the Resturant by now... who cares? As long as the restaurants reputation is not hurt... (here’s were the issues start) To that end, if I am the Resturant, I see that I can add my own delivery service, undercut doordash by a bit, and make more money, and control my reputation by employing people who have incintives aligned with me, then great! Thanks doordash, for showing me the way. Ah, but can I? Maybe not without forming a power group with other restaurants (or some other economic structure..?), as the cost of adding a “real employee” may be greater than the margin added by the delivery service. I need a structure that both aligns incentives between delivery service and Resturant, and is cost effective. Since restaurants weren’t already doing this, probably it has to happen at the meta-Resturant level of it can be done while preserving reputation at all. (Of course, the difficulty of it depends on the food being served, so that’s why, e.g. pizza was already being delivered.)
- FireBeyond 6y agoIn many environments, fraud contains a definition of "dishonestly obtain financial advantage by deception". Your example is flawed. It's not a crime or fraud to resell a product. It is still fraud, not merely objectionable, to resell a product while in every way possible acting as if you are not a reseller but the original producer.
- youngtaff 6y agoIt could be argued it's misrepresentation or passing off under UK law
- IdoRA 6y agoSeveral of the factors considered in trademark infringement are the use of the mark in commerce, that use being connected to the sale (including distribution or advertising) of the marked product, and naturally, likelihood of consumer confusion. A pro-restaurant argument might be that these alternative websites are interfering with new and extant restaurant-customer relationships, falsely implying a restaurant-delivery co. affiliation, and that the use by the delivery co. of the restaurant trademarks exceeds nominative use. The restaurants might also argue that the distribution of food, how and under what conditions, is part of their product: a delivery company taking too long to deliver an order could harm the quality of their product.
- wtetzner 6y agoSo just to look at this from another perspective. If I created a chase-bank.com website, and allowed users to interact with their actual Chase account through it, but I took a percentage of all transactions, it would be fine?
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoThis discussion has cropped up before. • https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24931128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24931128 • https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25114024 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25114024 • https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20625232