15 ms·
“I will slaughter you”
- sn41 6y agoWhat a strange person and what a peculiar email. What does any of the listed software have to do with curl? You might as well attack GET and POST. And in the middle of a violent rant, he also gives a backhanded compliment - "Formula 1 racecar" - that's the part I agree with.
- lrossi 6y agoThe elephant in the room is the poor choice of domain name. A lot of people are getting the wrong idea about the purpose of his software.
- krick 6y agoI think the elephant in the room is putting a personal email there in the first place. Honestly, you shouldn't act surprised you've received a threat, when you already know people constantly misunderstand that thing. In fact, it is quite literally like writing your phone number on a concrete block next to some dumpster in LA where all sorts of junkies constantly gather together, and then taking a personal offense when you receive a call from somebody who thinks this is Satan's phone number and he is the one who has been chosen to defeat you. But, yeah, the domain itself obviously doesn't help the matter.
- M3phist0 6y agoThis is some victim blaming here. The domain is not the website of curl, but the personal blog of curls main developer. Not the same thing.
- kube-system 6y agoIt's the domain of the contact email for curl. I think that is exactly what this person latched on to, given it was the first screenshot this person sent. Of course, Daniel is not to blame for people's uninformed reactions. But, one might point to this as a potential reason to avoid drawing the attention of the misinformed.
- insomniacity 6y ago> Normally I don’t respond to these confused emails because the distance between me and the person writing them is usually almost interplanetary. Daniel is clearly smart, but he's not thinking big enough. This is practically inter-galactic.
- aritmo 6y agoIn the seven stages of grief, isn't that Stage 3?
- zhouyisu 6y ago"AS-IS" clause still counts?
- dewey 6y agoDo you feel like this person would read the licensing terms?
- Google234 6y agoUm, so is this a bad time to bring up Rust?
- simion314 6y agoyes, very bad . It is off topic 100% and just increases the fatigue we all suffer when Rust is forcefully pushed everywhere.
- oytis 6y agoAs I understand it he's not complaining about some vulnerability in curl, rather that attackers used curl to hack him.
- neysofu 6y agoYes.
- sn41 6y agoYes it is. And also, all the other times. This has nothing to do with any vulnerability in curl, just that someone might have used curl to script requests. You might as well attack the HTTP protocol.
- XorNot 6y agoYou know initially I was thinking "wait did the author write an exploit PoC?" and then I looked closer.
- corobo 6y agoNot sure what this solves really. Some pissed off weirdo is an idiot aye. Either it's scary and get law enforcement involved or it's not and we're gawking and laughing at someone at their worst moment. In an attempt to take this post at its most charitable I agree, it fucking sucks there's not enough focus on mental health in the world.
- veltas 6y agoWhen you get messages like this, sometimes you end up taking it differently to how it appears as a third party. Any threat of violence online can be interpreted as a joke, it's not easy to tell the difference sometimes and it's harder when you're on the receiving end of it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- perpetualpatzer 6y agoIf you're looking for ways to be charitable, I found this (and this similar Tim Ferris post[0]) to be eye-opening view into the range of noise that people with large social wakes deal with. It's a small slice of empathy that I (and possibly others) would have lacked otherwise that makes me more understanding in interactions with folks like OSS maintainers, corporate governance, etc. I agree, there was no need to include names in the article. [0] https://tim.blog/2020/02/02/reasons-to-not-become-famous/ https://tim.blog/2020/02/02/reasons-to-not-become-famous/
- corobo 6y agoThe only difference here is I'm empathising with both sides
- secondcoming 6y agoI initially thought the emailer was complaining about the curl_multi functionality, and I empathised a bit, but I was not expecting the rest.
- Ndymium 6y agoThis feels to me like a person with some sort of mental illness or breakdown and delusions of grandeur and persecution. Their explanation doesn't make much sense. If I were Daniel, I wouldn't respond any further.
- Huwyt_Nashi021 6y agoWithout that last sentence, I would have assumed you were referring to the recipient, not the sender.
- pmiller2 6y agoYeah, I agree. In his place, I either would have done nothing, or, maybe made a police report (not that I'd expect the police to actually do anything at this stage). Generally speaking, the less you antagonize someone whose first exchange with you is "I will slaughter you," the better, IMO.
- gspr 6y ago> maybe made a police report (not that I'd expect the police to actually do anything at this stage). Indeed. But one shouldn't underestimate the chance that this wouldn't be the first report about this person. Lots of similar reports like this may actually cause them to do something.
- pmiller2 6y agoI agree, in the sense that someone who has done something of this nature is more likely to have done such a thing in the past. However, in this case, the victim is someone who is being targeted through his email address, which is embedded in open source software that's contained in gazillions of systems worldwide. That makes it significantly less likely that whomever he would report this to would have gotten another report about this particular individual.
- arp242 6y agoI once tried to have a conversation with a women who tried to drive me and my bicycle off the bus lane (where she shouldn't be driving in the first place); and shouted "fuck off you pissy little cunt" to me. For some reason I thought that if I explained my perspective, she would understand. It ended up with a broken back wheel (she kicked it) and a damaged phone (she took it out of my hand when I wanted to take a picture of the license plate and threw it on the ground). She was clearly unhinged, but I was stupid as well. I should of just let it go; no one who starts a social interaction with "pissy little cunt" is likely to be calmed down by reason. You have nothing to gain from trying, and much to potentially lose.
- Huwyt_Nashi021 6y ago>walked around my house for a few minutes to cool off >it hurt me deep in my soul >you don’t deserve my code Grow a pair. This would be pathetic enough for a grown man to think or say in private, let alone sook about on a public blog for the world to see. And it all seems like a thinly veiled excuse to boast about how popular his code is. I'm sorry that there aren't public parades to celebrate your unparalleled genius, your majesty.
- rscho 6y ago? (Is all I can think of as an answer)
- the_only_law 6y agoDon’t want to delve into any accusatory territory, but I’ve seen several new accounts with names following a similar pattern that post such material and dip.
- Huwyt_Nashi021 6y agoNot by choice. I'm usually auto-flagged/shadow-banned/banned after one or two comments, so I make a new account to join the discussion when necessary. I would prefer to use the same account but it's out of my hands. The mod warned me that using a new name each time could be interpreted as deceptive so I've been using the same name (with an incremented suffix) for a little while now to not obscure my identity.
- yetihehe 6y ago> I'm usually auto-flagged/shadow-banned/banned after one or two comments, Maybe there is a reason? I had my comments downvoted, but thinking about this, it was deserved, those comments were really not constructive and severely lacking in empathy. No one normal likes reading such things and HN is a place where it matters. It's not a place to just vent.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThe general demeanor of that person, some of the lingo used like "rooting" or "federal server hijacking", the fact that in the screenshot he's using some text editor with ads in it to browse the offending code combined with the fact that he doesn't know what Curl is (if he did he wouldn't have sent this e-mail) screams "script kiddie" to me. I'm not sure whether this person is actually responsible for a multi-million dollar defense project, but if he really was, it's probably a good thing he lost the deal because I definitely don't want that kind of person managing such a project.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bjarneh 6y agoI agree; this seems like someone with so little technical ability, that I wouldn't be surprised if he did manage to talk someone into a buying a multi million dollar defense project he could not deliver... > I lost my family, my country my friends, my home and 6 years of work trying to build a better place for posterity. I get loosing your family / home / friends, but a country? Where did that go?
- bombcar 6y agoThis sounds like the result of unscrupulous "boot camps" that are common in countries like India - people are told if they sign up and pay $life_savings they can become a programmer and be hired by "The US Government" or other companies for enormous amounts of money. A mundane class is offered with impractical advice and they're left with no money, little skills, and spamming the internet trying to get "their contract" - and if it doesn't materialize and they go back to the boot camp to complain the scammers blame it on "curl" - see the haxx.se domain? Clearly a hax0r ruined your chance at a better life.
- ThankYouBernard 6y agoReally? The kind of language used in that post about defense contracts and "my country" and "dipshit" screams India to you? Or do you just have a prejudice about India and you wanted to make that point anyway?
- michaelbuckbee 6y agoSome context: Daniel is the primary maintainer of curl (the ubiquitous utility and library for HTTP requests) [1] His name often shows up in the licensing disclosures/attributions of applications that include curl. The general opaqueness of modern software leads people to latch onto him and his email for all manner of things, and for non developers to attribute to him all sorts of bad motives ("You hacked me!"). This is especially unfortunate as Daniel has been such a genuinely positive and helpful face to a popular open source project. I feel awful that his generosity gets repaid with this kind of crap. 1 - https://github.com/sponsors/bagder https://github.com/sponsors/bagder
- oblio 6y agoIt's just the law of big numbers in play. Do something that impacts enough people and the crazies will for sure come out of the woodwork.
- jacquesm 6y agoThis is quite true. I've had my 'fifteen minutes of fame' back in the 90's, and it led to years of crazies approaching me with all kinds of idiocy.
- aasasd 6y agoThat's the exact reason why I don't leave my real information anywhere on public web. Or at least try not to. Weird that people spend each day on Facebook and Reddit among unhinged bozos, and still fail to realize how it might not be the best idea to spam their name and location on the web for all to see.
- ProAm 6y ago> This is especially unfortunate as Daniel has been such a genuinely positive and helpful face to a popular open source project. I can't agree more, Daniel is one of the friendliest approachable maintainers out there. Several times he takes time to answer menial questions and is friendly about it. I recommend the curl mailing list if you work with it in any manner as for you will learn a lot from other people.
- 6y ago
- mr_woozy 6y agoFor other coming here who didn't immediately get the joke either. The kiddies attacking the sender were using curl to steal data, it wasn't an exploit in curl itself.
- rob74 6y agoI agree it sounds like a joke, but when someone starts making death threats because of these misguided conclusions, it stops being funny...
- CogitoCogito 6y agoIt's not even guaranteed curl was used at all.
- extropic-engine 6y agoimagine being so bad at computers that you decide to blame curl for inventing hackers
- m12k 6y agoThe is the equivalent of sending death threats to the car company that manufactured the car that the robbers used to get away in after robbing your bank.
- mkl95 6y agoI'm not a psychiatrist, but it seems that this person has some severe psychotic disorder. The whole thing reads like a cheap knockoff of "A Beautiful Mind".
- csunbird 6y agoIt also could be a alcohol induced rage moment, where the sender just vented out random stuff.
- user-the-name 6y ago"A drunk man's words are a sober man's thoughts"
- ChrisRR 6y agoIt doesn't read like that to me. It reads like someone who's an arsehole who had grand plans of their prototype being sold for billions and likely getting hacked for having no security knowledge
- Tepix 6y agoSeems like a death threat from an icloud.com address. Chances are the real name and location of the sender is available to the authorities (with consent by a judge) from Apple.
- TheRealDunkirk 6y agoRelatedly, someone on the blog posted a comment that it might be more effective to report him to Apple than to turn a credible death threat over to law enforcement! Comments here seem acknowledge that he's delusional, but he may very well have lost a huge contract. He claims he's lost family, friends, house, and can't go back to his home country. What would Apple's move be? To lock him out without warning or due process of any sort. I don't know about any of you, but I KNOW how devastating it would be to suddenly be locked out of MY iCloud account. Do we really think that getting Apple to deplatform him will somehow assuage his stated murderous intent?! What kind of cyberpunk megacorp police state future are we advocating for here? No, the answer is to report this to local LEO and the FBI, let THEM deal with Apple to get his details, and handle whatever comes next.
- AtlasBarfed 6y agoI wonder what the market is for a sort of super-it lawyer service, that affords the protections of legal counsel in order to secure your data across multiple platforms and protect you from deplatforming as you describe, where they can take YOUR data, and is protected by legal counsel so that it generally can't be deplatformed by governmental entities. Encryption has a sort of brutal effectiveness at doing this if you distribute copies of your data, but it is hard to maintain and has exposure in extreme events with your health. Encryption + distributed data + legal protections from counsel could be an offering. It might be a "big fish" service though.
- oldkn 6y agoI've seen the theme of "maintainer of popular open source product is threatened by person who doesn't understand it's just a component" show up a few times, but when I think about it most those times have been related to curl specifically. Maybe it's because of the domain haxx.se? Or maybe Daniel just writes about it a lot? Does this kind of thing happen so regularly to others?
- masklinn 6y agoIt’s because curl and libcurl are used virtually everywhere, and clearly identified. This means in any problematic or malicious device or software, odds are good the first clearly identifiable thing you’ll find are references to curl. Though the domain probably doesn’t help with the association. If you got hacked and the first clear string you find is “haxx.se” it’s not a big leap to interpret it as a taunt.
- sime2009 6y agoI'm guessing it is because people who create these hacking tools often need to do HTTP requests, so they just copy in libcurl source and before you know it Daniel's name is associated with all these tools and attacks.
- FriedrichN 6y agoIs it just me or is the response really unhinged? I have no idea what he's talking about. I'm assuming his systems got abused by someone using Curl?
- samuel 6y agoI'm trying to make sense of the response. Someone used curl/libcurl in a rootkit? Is that all?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fraktl 6y agoJudging by what transpired and how the other person behaves, it sounds like he got what he deserved. Such a rotten personality shouldn't be allowed around people, let alone computers.
- RGamma 6y agoIt reads more like mental illness..
- phendrenad2 6y agoDaniel was probably warned by many not to respond a second time, or maybe he thinks that this emailer is a crank who isn't worth responding to, but I kinda wish he would. The emailer is either experiencing the effects of curl exploits, and doing a bad job of explaining it, or is very confused about the role curl plays in exploits in general. I'm not willing to assume the latter, although I think that's the assumption most are making here.
- gregoriol 6y agoI agree: it's a good way to handle angry people by taking it in a soft tone and explaining; it may have a positive impact on the person because someone cares, and if the person was just angry at the moment it may also help them learn something. I often tend to take some time to respond to such kind of angry messages though, you really need to make an effort on yourself to get back to a "kind" state of mind for it to work.
- Nextgrid 6y agoYeah I think a reply ignoring the threat and just explaining what Curl is would be the best approach here. Either the person is just a crank and in that case no harm done, or the person has legitimately been affected by an exploit and at the very least it will inform them of what actually happened and how Curl isn't to blame at all.
- nwellnhof 6y agoI'm sure Daniel Stenberg's life would be easier if he had chosen a different domain name.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dmingod666 6y ago'man curl' lists Daniel. I think morons that don't know what curl is only see the 'haxx.se' domain and think it's some hacker.. it's sad a person who's written a tool used by so many people and systems everyday has to deal with nonsense like this.
- zach_garwood 6y agoThe thing that confuses me about that faulty line of thinking is why would a hacker include a license under their name with the software they use to hack you? What sort of gentleman hacker would follow this legal procedure in the process of illegally compromising your machine? It would be as if a burgler stole all of your stuff but left you a contract so you could legally give them ownership. I just don't understand the reasoning.
- graywh 6y agowhite hat hackers -- we got manners and shit
- nullc 6y agoI'm sorry to hear that. libCurl is great and my life is better for it. It's really best to not reply to the mentally ill people (and you can be pretty sure anyone sending something like the first is at least temporarily mentally ill). It can sometimes be extremely tempting, I know-- especially when they've managed to say something almost perfectly constructed for pithy comeback. But it will not help you and it will not help them. If it does anything it will just encourage the behavior. If it is any consolation lots of other people receive nasty kookmail messages -- I know first hand, in addition to the ones I get directly some of the kooks like to send massive carbon copy blasts-- as a result I have a bunch of very strange mail rules, like discarding any email that copies both a whitehouse.gov email address and Jeff Bezos, or another if both George Soros and Noam Chomsky are copied.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- notthegov2 6y agoLol that is smart and impressive and odd and disturbing.
- konjin 6y agoI never got more hate mail then when I tried doing outreach for my physics group. It did include death threats (I think) it was hard to tell if I was being accused of being part of a modern inquisition that burned people at the stake or should be burned at the stake or both. It was pretty close to: https://web.archive.org/web/20150506055228/http://www.timecube.com/index.html https://web.archive.org/web/20150506055228/http://www.timecu... Another good time was when I was running a crypto meetup and we had to call the cops because someone came in naked, the CIA had put chips in their clothes and they had to burn their house down so they weren't homeless but on the run. Then there was the time I was on the board of a hacker space: https://shitnoisebridgesays.tumblr.com/page/3 https://shitnoisebridgesays.tumblr.com/page/3 it wasn't noise bridge but it had the same vibe.
- cmsefton 6y ago> libCurl is great and my life is better for it. This is not directed at you specifically, but your comment got me wondering how many people contact individuals like Daniel who are behind Open Source projects like this to share positive feedback, or even just to say "Thank you." I know I've not done it anywhere near as much as I should, and I suspect that doing so would help take the edge of what can often feel like a thankless task. I imagine it's a bit like reviews: people with a bad experience are more likely to leave a review. Perhaps the best way to help people like David is to stop once in a while and thank them for the things they've done.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoI think this is a good case for being pseudo-anonymous online, even in free software. The vast majority of the community is nice, but it only takes one crackpot to make your life difficult. If you are pseudo-anonymous, you are at least protected, both physically and reputation wise, on the internet. We've always told kids to not give out their name or address online; it might be good advice for everyone.
- mb720 6y agocURL is one of the greatest pieces of software I ever used. Thank you, Daniel, for creating it and all the volunteers who maintain and improve it. I donated some time ago to the project here: https://curl.haxx.se/donation.html https://curl.haxx.se/donation.html I encourage everyone who used it to do the same. Don't let the crazies get to you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Arnt 6y agoI suppose this is an argument in favour of the asset downloading scheme pioneered by maven/gradle and nowadays adopted by many languages: The unhinged and/or ignorant won't see sane/good library code mixed into worse code that uses the libraries. But oh god, it's not exactly a technical argument.
- mettamage 6y ago> That code is used to root and exploit people. That comment made me think and I realized the following. Open-source code like curl is inevitable when a society gains internet [1]. It's not Daniel's fault. If anything is to blame, blame the internet and human nature on a grand scale [2]. [1] If he wouldn't have made it, someone else would. If no one else would, then people would've done it privately. Some of that code would've been leaked and popularized as an open source project (it's basic probability: many people would need to do it privately, since they have to if they want their CLI to interact with the web). [2] There was an interview I read/heard somewhere where some Twitter employee said: if there is a 1 in a 500 million chance that something could happen based on a small piece of text, it means that at Twitter, it happens every day.
- krick 6y agoUh... I mean, you don't really think that person has an accurate understanding of what actually happened? Because I'm having a hard time trying to imagine that. It's not that there aren't any vulnerabilities in curl that can be exploited that way, but I struggle to think of situation where curl would have been an actual culrprit. Also, it sounds like he thinks curl is something purposefully malicious. On the matter of "inevitability of progress": yep, I even think it applies to much bigger extent. I just don't see how is this connected to the troubles of the-victim-of-curl guy.
- mettamage 6y agoOh, the statement just made me pause and think that's all. > but I struggle to think of situation where curl would have been an actual culrprit. I agree, I think it's much more likely that there was a 2 stage type of exploit where curl was used to download the second stage locally on the machine. That's at least how curl (or wget) is used on hackthebox.eu (where everyone hacks boxes for fun).
- akhilkg 6y agooff point > if there is a 1 in a 500 million chance that something could happen based on a small piece of text, it means that at Twitter, it happens every day. really interesting, do you remember what interview/who the employee was or anything?
- TheChaplain 6y agoI see someone who ended up in a bad situation because they messed up, and in their anger tries to blame someone else instead of taking responsibility. I use free and open source software everyday in my products and I am fully aware that all of them have licenses specifically telling me that there is no warranty or liability of damages. If something goes wrong, it's on me, I made a wrong choice and I have to deal with the consequences. And threats are not okay and should be reported to the authorities.
- vegancap 6y agoThis is like someone sending death threats to the inventor of bricks for a house falling down.
- BLKNSLVR 6y agoI think we all owe Daniel a certain amount of thanks for somehow, incidentally, maybe, preventing nutjob exhibit A from getting a multi million dollar defense project. And anytime such unrealistic threats are made, this always makes it seem like maybe it's not so bad: https://youtu.be/Nw1643T0RD0 https://youtu.be/Nw1643T0RD0 (One of these days I'm going to cut you into little pieces, by Pink Floyd)
- ChrisRR 6y agoI think any defense agency would've looked at his code if it were so easily hacked and not awarded him anything
- Jtsummers 6y agoSadly, no. V&V in defense projects are often short on evaluating security in any meaningful way. It’s mostly theater, show you ran a couple of security assessments or have a code review process that includes checking for buffer overflows and you’re fine.
- david_draco 6y agoThere are two things wrong here: The person saw some exploit with curl headers, which damaged their life. That's upsetting, even if the email is misdirected, because Daniel just provided the infrastructure, and did not cause the specific abuse. What is wrong is the threat to life. The second thing that is wrong is to respond to the second email by doxxing the author to the public. The second email showed that the threat was likely not specific and immanent, but venting. A reasonable response would be to notify the police. Or to reveal this case to the public explaining why this is misdirected, but without the author's name.
- Clewza313 6y agoNobody is being doxxed here. "Al Nocai" is a pseudonym, and Daniel redacted the actual email address.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aFaid7see0ni 6y agoMust be the persons wordplay on Nicolai
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mahart 6y agoI disagree with the idea that sharing a singular name of someone you had a conversion with is doxxing. Especially one voluntarily sent without a prior agreement that the email conversation would remain private.
- lilSebastian 6y ago> The second thing that is wrong is to respond to the second email by doxxing the author to the public. What evidence do you have for this?
- jraph 6y agoCurl is such an essential tool that hadn't Daniel invented it, someone else would have. Nobody is right to hold him responsible for bad uses of Curl. We already have wget by the way. A lot of love to you Daniel if you read this and thanks for Curl!
- carlsborg 6y agoUnfortunately this is what a mental health problem looks like. Our society is ill trained to identify and deal with this category of heart breaking disease.
- stonepresto 6y agoThis mental health problem is called defense contracting.
- jessaustin 6y agoYes it would be nice if free software could get rid of all the "multimillion dollar defense projects".
- girvo 6y agoI mean he could just be a shitty person who’s bad at their job? I think it’s likely there’s something wrong, sure, but sometimes I worry about this constant rush to associate bad behaviour with mental illness, when none of us are psychologists and we’re certainly not that persons psychologist. Not picking on you specifically, just musing, btw
- peach45 6y ago> You built a formula 1 race car and tossed the keys to kids with ego problems. I laughed. Curl: The Formula 1 race car of command line tools! Aside from that, I am surprised that the harasser followed up in a mostly non-violent way. I expected an absolute troll. Sadly in fact it seems the harasser is in need of psychiatric attention.
- krick 6y agoIt's actually surprising this is the first one, given all the stuff he's been showing off before.
- cryptica 6y agoI worked for a cryptocurrency project which was using my open source project as one of the main components and the price of that cryptocurrency dropped in price by about 99% from its peak... Thousands of anonymous people lost huge sums. I was a bit worried at times about blame potentially being misdirected towards me but it didn't happen, people were supportive in fact. Token price is back up high now.
- blinkingled 6y agoThis reminds me of the OK city manager threatening Centos developer - https://www.theregister.com/2006/03/24/tuttle_centos/ https://www.theregister.com/2006/03/24/tuttle_centos/ Although in that case the city was not actually hacked. It looks like this person actually got hacked by someone using curl and he is complaining that curl made it possible. I wonder if he knows anything about the people who wrote the actual exploit(s).
- Taniwha 6y agoA bit like the time the scientology lawyers were desperate to find out who was running that server at 127.0.0.1 that had all their files on it, and really really wanted to find the person who was using the 'majordomo" login so that they could depose them
- blinkingled 6y agoI read the transcript of that incident - that was some elaborate joke explaining.
- unanswered 6y agoWoah, that should have been reported to the FBI as extortion. Through the (interstate) threat to report a crime falsely to the FBI, the extortioner successfully extracted a valuable service, viz. tech support, from the victim.
- notthegov2 6y agoTwo days ago I received my first online ‘death threat’ which I suppose technically were invert inert observations. I posted an image of my family and someone instantly commented, “are you ready to die” by a_famous_comedian. Honestly it takes your breath away even if you know the threat isn’t real. A few hours later, in #bitcoin on EFNet, a person joined with a nick of my name. They stated my address then posted several inverse threat comments “you will die in Beverly Hills” and various things. The person demanded I quit EFNet. I was intrigued by what he was saying so I agreed and quit. This person said I can’t be intimidated but I think they had a different reason. I don’t think the threats are tied to anyone who dislikes me, rather it’s some mythical poker game strategy involving a great primordial mystery. Yesterday afternoon, I decide to jump on a small hardware hacking channel. Within 20 minutes, in comes my friend with my name as his nick. This time he made several outrageous comments including, “Your mother will slash her throat in front of me” — again this is an inverse or 3rd party like threat. He then tells me again I need to quit EFNet and calls me a loser. I started to think this person was Diamond/Chrysippus/cwt who threatened Variety Jones and talked about kidnapping Ross Ulbricht’s family for private keys. I sometimes investigate federal employees for the ODNI and I’m currently investigating Diamond via connections in Thailand. And I’m investigating Christopher W Tarbell and Sabu. Especially now with Individual 1 being labeled Shaun Bridges, the Secret Service agent with NSA assignment who stole multiple Silk Road wallets worth billions of dollars. In real life, I have been threatened 20+ times including last week by a partner of Gery Shalon, the JPMorgan hacker who paid $405 million to the USG and had the Israeli government get him a non prosecution agreement of some sort. When this happens, I aggressively and directly confront whomever is threatening me. Which has high risk but it seems better than cowering and appearing weak. Gery’s partner who he directed was sentenced to 12 years in federal prison last month. Russian hacker goes to prison while Israeli affiliate con man continues to run scams and de facto foreign intelligence operation in the US — specifically in Houston, Texas. https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/russian-hacker-sentenced-12-years-prison-involvement-massive-network-intrusions-us https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/russian-hacker-sentence... Gery is working with a man named Alex who recently fled to Costa Rica after buying 250k in BTC. They work with Caleb McCreless and Michael McCreless, who is an old time bank trading scam con man. Now they’re into PPE scams. I have so many federal agents and federal prosecutors investigating me, both current and former. Currently the FBI and DoJ are investigating Attorney General Ken Paxton of his investigation into alleged criminal behavior by federal employees in the Nate Paul case in Austin. Fwiw Nate Paul still hasn’t been indicted after almost 2 years since when federal agents raided his home. I am Paxton’s special investigator that he was sending to Austin to investigate the US attorneys and federal agents. Then Paxton’s staff wrote the letter accusing him of corruption and the ‘special prosecutor’ appointed was removed. They did not know my affiliation with ODNI. While Brandon Cammack knows me, Paxton did not know my identity. Anyway, sure I’ll be shadowbanned again by the elite hackers and cypherpunks of “Y Combinator”. But just thought I’d share my story. I’m 100% confident that the person on IRC is a federal officer. Last week, that person sent a 0day exploit for my iPhone 11 and bricked my phone (it works except won’t activate on SIM). I’m currently looking to have the phone analyzed for signs of the 0day. I am assuming after a factory reset the phone will work again. If any elite hardware reversers are interested in imaging my phone or analyzing it, contact me at satoshi@137.lol. Thanks. Gery - https://www.financemagnates.com/forex/regulation/israeli-scammer-pay-403-million-us-authorities-following-sting-operation https://www.financemagnates.com/forex/regulation/israeli-sca... Gery’s friend Caleb McCreless arrested in drug trafficking ring but is not indicted, he is affiliated with military intelligence and I believe scamming Houston residents under the guise of complicate non profits, bank trading scams and via protection of affiliation with US intelligence or Israeli intelligence. https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtx/pr/federal-and-state-authorities-arrest-el-paso-based-drug-trafficking-organization https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtx/pr/federal-and-state-autho... And my site to host the Bitcoin White Paper and discuss early global currency histories from the Sovereign Individual in 1997, to the Declaration of Sovereignty written by me on July 5th, 1999 as a kid. I’ve been hoping Craig Wright sues me because he is another intelligence affiliated con artist. I myself am a confidence artist with principles. Also a social engineer thus I am a liar and you shouldn’t believe anything I write- https://bitcoincore.Lol https://bitcoincore.Lol
- eznzt 6y ago>As an open source maintainer since over twenty years, I know flame wars and personal attacks and I have a fairly thick skin and I don’t let words get to me easily. It took me a minute to absorb and realize it was actually meant as a direct physical threat. It found its ways through and got to me. This level of aggressiveness is not what I’m prepared for. Posting this is just an open invitation for people to send you more threats.
- kstenerud 6y agoThe problem is a common one, where someone reaches a conclusion after a sloppy investigation. From the letter, it sounds like this guy had his life ruined, and upon investigating the hacker tools used to ruin his project and life, he jumped on the name that appeared the most in the source code. The screenshots would have been an "I know it's you" message to him, which the sender would assume is more than enough to let him know the meaning of his email. And indeed, if Daniel had been writing haxx0r tools, the message and intent would have been crystal clear. At this point the sender would be assuming that Daniel is just playing games with him and playing dumb, so he's pouring out his story to shame Daniel over the damage that his hacker tool has done. If someone were to write tools specifically for evil purposes, and your life were ruined by use of said tools, you'd be screaming mad, too. And probably seeking revenge. Except that his investigation was sloppy and incomplete; Daniel doesn't write hacker tools, he writes a HTTP client library. He's no more guilty of facilitating hacking than the writer of any runtime library's HTTP client code. Normally, this would be a matter of setting the facts straight, but in this case a criminal investigation would probably be in order.
- electro_blah 6y agolol. I think "troll" is the word you are looking for.
- pornel 6y agoMany comments rush to label this guy as "mentally ill". Being an entitled asshole with misdirected anger is not necessarily a medical condition. And there are plenty of people with actual mental health problems who are not aggressive at all (statistically, mentally ill people are more likely to be victims of violence). Health issues are a thing that happens to people, and they don't have control over it, which absolves them from responsibility for it. OTOH if the guy making these threats is just pissed off due to his own failures, or even is just a troll making it all up, he should be held responsible for his actions.
- Cederfjard 6y agoI think people are saying that not just because of the aggression, but also because the story is all over the place and makes little sense.
- duskwuff 6y agoPrecisely. The list of attacks (?) described in the email is an assemblage of meaningless phrases (like "favicon XML injection" and "JS stochastic Templating") and unrelated occurrences ("Solarwinds Oct/2020").
- NoInkling 6y agoDon't forget the strange PDF - that coincidentally happens to mention Terry Davis on it?
- skissane 6y agoThat kind of gibberish is actually a symptom of psychosis (thought disorder). I've interacted with a few people with psychotic illness over the years (both in-real-life and online) and the distinctive language style is rather hard to miss.
- joombaga 6y agoYou're drawing a brighter line between mental illness and being an asshole than I would. There may be more grey area between absolution and being held responsible than you're allowing. I'm not implying we shouldn't hold trolls responsible when they know better. From an outside perspective it would suck to have a brain that releases dopamine when causing others to suffer.
- mewse-hn 6y agoLove that in the middle of this guy's insane loser rant he casually mentions that he's confined to the united states
- woofwoofwoof 6y agoLooks like Markov chain generated text to me.
- tw04 6y agoFor someone who claims to have done all that, it seems odd they blame curl for the solarwinds hack... I’m guessing the idiot went through the source of some exploit dump and just decided that whoever was in the license files was the one who wrote the root kit. Because everyone knows malware authors leave their real email address in their payload.
- herewego 6y agoI have dealt with a similar situation, in a sense more than once, and my strategy was to first integrate the identified risk into my model and then compare it against my own risk profile. If the risk was above a threshold (simplifying), I take an offensive posture in cases like these. For example, in this case, I would minimally identify and locate the individual responsible for the email. I think that is doable.
- plesiv 6y agoI have nothing but respect for Daniel, but having a domain like haxx.se while being a maintainer of a general purpose powerful and popular(!) software tool is not smart. This liability could've been mitigated to some degree by having a more innocuous sounding domain name. Having it as is, given enough time and thanks to the tremendous popularity of libcurl/curl someone somewhere is going to jump to conclusions that Daniel is responsible for making this "race car" hacking tool that script kiddies are now using to wreck his life. Stalman has failed culturally, distance yourself from the "hacking" culture of the past if you care about your marketability and reputation.
- aaron695 6y agoAs per other advice, mental illness, best case is to ignore, the world is to big to help everyone online personally. > JS Stochastic templating utilizing comparison expressions to write to data registers This has zero meaning? I can't even guess what it might be? > I lost over $15k in prototyping alone from bullshit rooting to the charge arbitrators. "charge arbitrators" is not a thing. It's normally verb, noun. Not adjective, noun. I'd almost go a nasty GPT-2/GPT-3. There's complexity but no links, this is 3 unrelated things - "Multiple Sigover attack vectors utilizing favicon XML injection"
- airhead969 6y agoDelusions of grandeur, scapegoating, catastrophization, odd phrases, and lack of ownership. Sounds like a mental health crisis or a sick joke. Either way, whoever was behind it didn't accomplish anything. There can be situations where tools get inappropriately placed as critical infrastructure that are developed as hobbies by people with hobbyist-shrug attitudes, but this wouldn't be a constructive way to address it. Blame or personal attacks don't make improvements.
- hushhush 6y agoDeath threats are pretty normal for open source devs but I actually got a rape threat recently, which kind of surprised me. Cultural differences from international communities. It was not in English.
- datavirtue 6y agoThis is the funniest thing to come across HN in...well, forever. So entertaining.
- jaybeavers 6y agoSeems serious to me. Definitely report to the police and maybe seek help at the federal level of they crossed state lines.
- Havoc 6y agoInsane people are scary
- GistNoesis 6y agoAfter reading it a few times, I think it's not about some script kiddie using curl to hack into his system. Although I condemn Al Nocai's method, I feel for him and I am inclined to adopt the contrarian opinion that he probably got screwed because of the bad quality of curl. Curl had some remote exploit last year, and curl is used everywhere as the author reminds (often as libcurl). https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2020/02/03/remote-exploiting-curl/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2020/02/03/remote-exploiting-cur... The deeper underlying systemic problem is that open-source is a way to disclaim all responsibilities. When some open-source project has some level of reach there needs to be quality requirements and regular security audits. (like they (last?) did in 2016, https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2016/11/23/curl-security-audit/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2016/11/23/curl-security-audit/) Otherwise it's like the OpenSSL's heartbleed story where a few unpaid project maintainers hold the keys to the world. In today's interdependent world, when trying to build something, we are more and more reliant on the quality of the library we use. As a product builder facing the client you get to bear the responsibility when your client has a problem because of a library you use. But when open-source software removed the possibility of competing solutions by providing free "as is" software, you can't realistically chose not to use it, and you are the one left holding the bag and paying the price for others mistakes.
- rurounijones 6y ago> When some open-source project has some level of reach there needs to be quality requirements and regular security audits. (like they (last?) did in 2016, https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2016/11/23/curl-security-audit/ https://daniel.haxx.se/blog/2016/11/23/curl-security-audit/) I think the key question with that is: It all sounds nice, but who is realistically going to pay for it. _especially_ repeatedly.
- GistNoesis 6y agoThat's indeed the failure of the system : something sensitive used by billions not being able to pay for a regular audit. If no one wants to pay for it to have the required quality, why not make it a public utility properly funded by tax, as a public service ; instead of later paying the costs in various form of the consequences of the vulnerabilities.
- pp19dd 6y agoLets get our facts straight here. Does the Perseverance rover contain libcurl? It has ffmpeg, so, ... "on the planet" could be changed to "two planets in this system." [1] https://twitter.com/FFmpeg/status/1362509273029353472 https://twitter.com/FFmpeg/status/1362509273029353472
- flippinburgers 6y agoI feel like the sender should take it a bit further by blaming the sun for nurturing the plants that feed the animals that sustain the belly of the coder Daniel. In other words go out on their lawn a shake a mighty fist towards the sky.
- jbirer 6y agoNot going to lie, I would not even reply to such an e-mail. The person seems like a psycho and it is not a good idea to provoke them.
- znpy 6y agoIf this hadn't been such a dangerous threat, I'd have replied like this: "oh i'm sorry, I'll refund you of all the money you paid in licenses for curl specifically". But, quite frankly, I'd go to the police immediately.
- adrian_mrd 6y agoThis surfaces an important point that our communities (online, offline, families, etc) have no easy solution for: if indeed some one does have a mental illness* how do you factor that in and make allowances for it? How do you quantify that the actions come from someone who is mentally unwell? And without diagnostic tooling, how do you know they are mentally ill? * In this case there is no way to comfirm if the sender/s are mentally ill because all you have is inference to play against the words written and the images sent to Daniel.
- yalogin 6y agoThis person clearly doesn’t understand what software is and how it works. If he really lost a multi million dollar defense project to a hack it’s not a bad thing at all. Of course this has nothing to do with curl or any other software, one can only get hacked because of their ineptitude.
- danmur 6y agoIt's it remotely possible it's a sophisticated troll?
- jc4751 6y agoCan we please stop saying this person has mental illness without a diagnosis? Let's not feed into the stigma. Thanks.
- injb 6y agoThere's a valuable lesson in this: always reply! I wouldn't have dreamed of replying to an email like that, since I wouldn't expect to get any satisfaction from the sender. But incredibly he responded with what is probably more than enough info to secure a conviction, assuming he can be identified.
- fattegourmet 6y agojust read the post. This is absurd
- rurban 6y agoMaybe it's now time to change your license to be more "unfree". Like adding contact or usage restrictions for psychopaths or warfarer. One does not need to deal with this.
- bagder 6y agoDaniel here. Thanks everyone for the positiveness and expression of appreciation I've sensed here. The threat has been reported to the police and I'll move on. I love you all. Now I'll go back and continue working on curl.
- mchusma 6y agoYou have done great work and I appreciate it.
- kstrauser 6y agoWe love you too. Thanks for everything!
- Rovanion 6y ago<3
- sagebird 6y agoThank you for your useful project and sorry you have to deal with this. Consider reporting to US authorities as well if you have not done so, (or wherever you think the threat may have originated from).
- ToniCipriani 6y agoAs someone who uses curl on a daily basis, thank you.
- richer6605 6y agoI use curl daily and just want to thank you for your great work!
- neurostimulant 6y agoBlaming Daniel for being for being hacked is like getting robbed and blames sneaker manufacturers because the robber happen to wear a pair of sneakers.
- RedComet 6y agoWhat a cry baby. It's the internet, get over it.
- kazinator 6y ago> I tried to develop a trade route in tech and establish project based learning methodologies to make sure kids aren’t left behind. But that bears no obvious relation whatsoever to "multi-million dollar defense project". Right there, we know this is stream-of-consciousness fiction generated by someone who is mentally ill.
- bouncycastle 6y agoYou should never respond to these emails. Showing a reaction is exactly what they want.
- tempuserpost 6y agoThe person needs care and help and patient kindness. The person wants to resemble the late Terry Davies of Temple OS. The person isn't a serious threat from a sentence. The Internet is the threat. That's the fear.
- Spoiled_toast 6y agoI’m sure this is a troll. The pdf referencing Terry Davis is telling.
- peanut_worm 6y agothis guy sounds like a child making shit up