7 ms·
This right here. Benefits shouldn't be tied to employer. Pay me more and let me control my money.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y ago
This right here. Benefits shouldn't be tied to employer. Pay me more and let me control my money.
- munk-a 6y agoIf folks are losing their jobs (assuming they don't have a nest egg which the majority of Americans do not have) how will they be better off being personally unable to pay for health care instead of losing access to their employer provided insurance to pay for healthcare? Also - a lot of these benefits are things we'd generally consider "necessary" - if that's the case why would we open the door wider to allowing folks to continue being paid 7.25/hr and now not even have a chance at ever seeing a doctor? Or, if that money is personally controlled is it going to be secured against debt repayment? Will individuals have a guaranteed right to pay for medical care before any paycheck garnishing?
- nightski 6y agoI don't mean to speak for the parent but I'm pretty sure it's implied in this scenario that you'd move to universal health care.
- munk-a 6y agoI don't think so - the implication I read from "Pay me more and let me control my money." was an entirely private individual insurance market. If I misread the comment my apologies.
- rbanffy 6y agoI had the same impression, which is an insane idea. The reason people should have universal healthcare and universal pensions and so on is to use society's size to shield everyone from individual risks.
- nostrademons 6y agoIt's not too unreasonable if we could also have a transparent, competitive, reasonably priced healthcare market. Doing that would require a lot of changes to how we conduct medical school admissions, residency, and medical licensing that'd be fought tooth & nail by the healthcare industry, though.
- munk-a 6y agoI don't believe a transparent healthcare system is realistically achievable without essentially moving over to full government control - I wrote up a thing above[1] if it's of interest. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26187260 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26187260
- ska 6y agoThe biggest drivers of health care cost have little to do with physicians, their training, or licensing although they do all contribute a bit. So to make any impact you'd need a much bigger list of things to change.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoWhat are the biggest drivers? It feels like death from a thousand cuts.
- ska 6y agoI was maybe underemphasizing the labor costs - it's a real contribution. But you are right that everything is more expensive, and it's pretty interconnected. Big contributors: fee for service incentives, administration overhead, end of life care, inefficiencies due to fragmentation and licensing, insurance inefficiency (not the profit margin, but the tracking/coding level of detail), over subscription of expensive (e.g. capital heavy) procedures, pharmaceutical costs.
- vizzier 6y ago
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt already exists, visit healthcare.gov. Pretty slick website too.
- munk-a 6y agoI agree - but the comment above was, AFAICT specifically advocating for removing both Large and Small Group insurance pools provided by employers from the equation. Folks currently get insurance from a variety of sources, Medicare, Medicaid, Military Tri-care, Fed/State/County Insurance, Self-funded plans - there's a lot of variety here. I believe the comment above was advocating for closing Small and Large Group coverage (and probably self-funded pools as well) in favor of those customers being dumped on the Individual market which does exist - and does definitely have it's own problems. Oh, and the Individual insurance market predates the ACA and healthcare.gov - it was much harder to navigate before the ACA due to the pre-condition exclusions but there were a variety of plans on offer to individuals.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>I believe the comment above was advocating for closing Small and Large Group coverage (and probably self-funded pools as well) in favor of those customers being dumped on the Individual market which does exist - and does definitely have it's own problems. The only problems I know of in the individual market are due to the fact that so many healthy lives are locked up in the government/small/large business group plans. If everyone, and I mean everyone was dumped onto the market, then there would be sufficient healthy lives to balance the whole situation. Basically, it would be the same as taxpayer funded healthcare, except you get to choose your insurance company. >Oh, and the Individual insurance market predates the ACA and healthcare.gov - it was much harder to navigate before the ACA due to the pre-condition exclusions but there were a variety of plans on offer to individuals. The individual market pre-ACA and the one that exists now are completely different. It's actually possible to compare different insurances in the one that exists post ACA due to standardization and certain stipulations for being ACA compliant.
- ghaff 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 6y agoMedicare for all: individuals shouldn't be paying for healthcare personally.
- refurb 6y agoMedicare has premiums, deductibles, co-insurance and co-pays you realize?
- Spivak 6y agoSo does my PPO plan, that’s not the point. The point is that my healthcare doesn’t become more expensive when I’m unemployed.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIt doesn’t have to, that’s simply a policy decision. Policy can and does change.
- refurb 6y agoThe why call it “Medicare for all” if it’s not Medicare? Is this like “defund the police” where we aren’t trying I actually defund them?
- toomuchtodo 6y agoMarketing and branding. "Medicare" is what most are familiar with, even if there are some tweaks to make.
- midasuni 6y agoYet the cost per head in the US of Medicare is higher than the UK’s health system. That’s kot cost per head covered. That’s dividing government health spending by the US population. The US pays enough in taxes to provide great healthcare to every citizen. It chooses not to.
- whiddershins 6y agoWe already have unemployment insurance, it’s easy to imagine something like government assisted cobra for recent job loss. We already have Medicaid for people who are chronically poor. It’s possible to decouple healthcare from a specific employer without moving to single payer or similar. I often like to point to Germany to show there is are much more varied solutions that can be tried than people are likely to say. Conflating all these different ideas makes it harder to find an optimal solution, IMO.
- mjevans 6y agoIt's possible... Single bidder though. A reverse dutch auction in each market region for qualified providers to offer services, and if the price in that market isn't desired then short term bring in the military docs, and longer term fund the education of more doctors with the provision that they resettle among the target areas needing coverage.
- imtringued 6y agoThe problem with USA's private healthcare system is that it refuses to train enough doctors. You're supposed to overproduce doctors to drive prices down.
- ska 6y agoI'm not sure if you meant it this way, but way benefits work you'd actually be getting paid less (total compensation), as one of the driving forces behind benefits packages is it costs the company less than it would for you to get it on your own. If you are happy with cash salary + (what benefits cost the company ) rather than the bigger cash salary + (nominal value of benefits) then this can work, but you have also be happy with the idea that some of the benefits you are used to become less (or un) affordable to you.
- LordDragonfang 6y agoYou're assuming that those "benefits" aren't something that can could leverage the scale of an entire country's government. The biggest example of a benefit that's cheaper for a company to provide in bulk is healthcare, and basically every developed country has demonstrated that it's cheaper to let the government handle that. Pensions, paid days off, childcare, and others all make sense to provide at a societal level rather than relying on a company to do right by its employees.
- ska 6y agoI’m not assuming anything, I’m talking about what you could reasonably expect today of your company if you made this tradeoff. What you were able to do with that cash is a separate issue. Over time it could become better, sure.
- vinger 6y agoI hear this point a lot about the power of group purchasing. If everyone purchased their own insurance the market would be larger and be able to offer larger discounts. Doing it at the company level doesn't make sense. Companies with larger sizes have better leverage under this model. Would the purchasing power be greater at the state level or federal level?
- idunno246 6y agoI don’t think it’s purchasing power so much as risk pool. Or really a bit of both, it’s number of healthy vs unhealthy people in the pool. Employees of a company tend to be healthier. People on ACA tend to be part time / low wage, and have more health issues. Insurance companies pass that through by charging based on risk. I imagine what would happen is this would average out, the total cost(including employer contribution) would go up for most of the hn crowd who can afford it, but down for others who currently can’t