6 ms·
The fascinating thing about this stuff is that you can have outlier people. For instance, tobacco is supposed to be highly addictive. Well, I picked up smoking
by renewiltord 6y ago
The fascinating thing about this stuff is that you can have outlier people. For instance, tobacco is supposed to be highly addictive.
Well, I picked up smoking from a girlfriend in college and we used to smoke all the time. Like ten cigs a day for a year and a half. Real bad, right?
Well, one day, I decided "Meh. I'll just stop" and I did. Not because of any reason. I just chose not to.
Now cigarettes are way addictive but I just chose to stop. More addictive than Benzos and shit and I just stopped cold turkey without any other reason.
Many of my friends struggled with quitting but eventually did. But I did it way easy. It's unlikely that I'm some super outlier, but clearly I'm some near the right edge of the bell curve in ease of exiting cigarette dependence.
That makes me think there are other outliers. This guy must be a heroin outlier. And considering the dependence inducing strength of that drug, he must be a far outlier.
- goat_whisperer 6y agoYeah, I mean some people smoke all of their lives and live to be 90 and die of natural causes. Doesn't mean that smoking isn't incredibly dangerous and bad for you. edit: this is agreement with the original comment, not sure why I'm being down voted. Just highlighting how outliers can exist, but it doesn't reflect on the danger of the underlying activity in general
- ecmascript 6y agoSame here, stopping to smoke was really easy but my candy addiction is real hard. It's like day and night for me. I struggle and have been struggling in not eating candy for years (or at least a lot less) but I have failed each time. I think different substances are differently addictive to people.
- renewiltord 6y agoLikewise, I found it impossible to quit sugar. Fruits especially still ruin me. I'll eat any amount of fruit you place before me.
- groby_b 6y agoWith any kind of addiction, it's worth exploring what the triggers are. There might well be some underlying emotional thing that makes you eat fruit. For me: I eat cookies because my Mom baked a lot, and I lost her early. This is a way to feel close to her. Knowing that makes it easier to not eat all the cookies. That doesn't mean all addictions are rooted in early childhood or psychological symptoms, or that your life gets fixed if you just talk about your parents a lot ;) But especially with addictions that only create mild physical addiction symptoms, it's worth looking at.
- king_panic 6y agoSugar is one of the hardest addictions to kick. I've kicked cocaine and alcohol too.. sugar was by far the hardest physically. It's also hard to stay sober because it's so accessible in foods and accepted by society.
- ecmascript 6y agoYeah it's like if people would put nicotine in every product, it would most likely make smoking harder to quit as well.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- umvi 6y agoThere most certainly are outliers, and you are likely one of them for nicotine at least. What you want to avoid though is using your outlier status to influence people into thinking "hey, maybe I'm an outlier too, maybe I can use highly addictive substances and still stay in control too" because statistically that's going to end in a public health disaster.
- hellohello1 6y agoPretty much. My mom's soon-to-be-former partner had been an alcoholic previous to their relationship and was clean when they met. She got him some whisky for Christmas and figured it would be fine if he drank a little, because its never been a problem for her. Big mistake. People are very very different in their drug tolerances and really shouldn't give advice to other people, because they are not the same.
- king_panic 6y agoThe argument the author is making is that addiction is an outlier. Many many many people drink, snort cocaine, smoke cigarettes and in the author's case, use heroin, and never develop addiction. I can understand why this infuriates people who've seen or known people who've died from an addiction but it's important for people to understand that alcohol, drugs, gambling, facebook, the internet, shopping, and everything that can turn into an addiction are not the problem. The problem is deep emotional pain from traumatic experiences.
- ta8645 6y agoYou had me until your last sentence. There are people who are born with huge lung capacity, they are able to swim faster and longer than anyone else. We would never believe that it's emotional pain that is keeping everyone else from swimming as well. And people are born colorblind, they don't lose that ability because of emotional pain. Physics and our individual body chemistry at birth plays a deep role in our unique life experiences. There's every reason to suspect the same mechanism affects addiction proclivity.
- renlo 6y agoI think OP is saying that trauma leads to addiction, not necessarily the act itself; ie, shopping addicts are addicted to shopping because of past trauma not necessarily because of the act of shopping itself. As a prior nicotine addict I don't necessarily agree with this, as I have felt firsthand what the addictiveness nicotine feels like and I don't believe it's psychological (and, it seems like heroin may be similar)
- datavirtue 6y agoIf you have lower dopamine levels watching TV can be enough to get addicted. Any opiate is going to grab you. Some people cannot stop watching TV as it bumps up the pleasure enough for them to feel normal or not depressive. Some people get from seeing comments/likes on their FB posts.
- Cederfjard 6y ago
- blamestross 6y agoNicotine is well established as a nootropic and use of it correlates with reduced incidence of dementia (even when corrected for mortality biases). I am at a really high risk for dementia and I keep trying to vape in hopes of that (possible) benefit but I keep forgetting to do it. Note that the logic for your health choices get weird when accounting for high odds of being a zombie after the age of 65. Plenty of room to dump externalities onto "zombie-you"
- foobiekr 6y agoI honestly don't think it's actually an outlier issue. In highschool almost everyone I know got into smoking pot, at least for awhile, and within a year or two 90+% of them just lost interest in it, maybe 5% kept using and maybe a quarter of them literally made pot the center of their lives and are still daily users with big impact on their lives and careers (or, honestly, lack thereof for all but one). The same thing happened with alcohol. As an adult, I've seen the same pattern repeat for people who just didn't try things, for whatever reason, or perhaps people who changed. What's actually happening, IMHO, is that you have a ton of overlapping processes that are filtering for with people who are vulnerable to becoming addicted to a given drug. Obviously those people will have trouble quitting.
- datavirtue 6y agoI practically tried to get addicted to cigarettes about 20+ years ago. Smoked quite a bit but could never quite cozy up to an addiction. The taste and smell was really bothering me so I just quit. Most of the people I know who smoked, never quit, and did various hard drug cocktails are all dead from heroine overdoses. I experimented with nearly every drug (no heroine, by they time that was available it was not something I would consider trying) but never formed an opiate or cocaine habit.
- staunch 6y agoThis is a bit silly. You never developed an addiction to cigarettes so you were able to easily quit smoking them. Well, yeah, of course. The hard part is quitting something when you want to but cannot make yourself i.e. addictions are what is hard to quit. The majority of people are able to smoke, drink, eat, and fornicate without developing an addiction. The people that become addicted are the outliers.
- renewiltord 6y agoAre the majority of people able to smoke without developing an addiction? That's not been my experience growing up. I only know three people total who quit cold turkey and I'm one. That's interesting, though.
- mattowen_uk 6y agoThe parent comment is being downvoted for some reason, even though the viewpoint is exactly the same as the original article.
- mattowen_uk 6y agoOh and now I'm being downvoted for pointing out a fact. Well done HN. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- neonological 6y agoIn the science of addiction what people have found is that if you change your environment you can literally get rid of any addiction. The studies from this are from Vietnam. Experts were expecting an unprecedented heroin epidemic from veterans returning from the Vietnam war as drug use among soldiers was rampant. Turned out these soldiers came back and were no longer addicted. Scientists are guessing the causal factor for the loss of addiction was a "change in environment." It is literally the same thing that happened to the European person who replied to your post. Your brain hard wires dependencies to certain drugs but when you change your environment it may trigger something in your brain to actually unconsciously eliminate these dependencies. This makes evolutionary sense. No doubt about it, people think that the above description means that the addiction is some sort of conscious decision. It is not the case. Addition is real, but the tricks to get out of addiction may be simpler then most people think. So the question to ask is, when you quit tobacco, were you in the process of moving? Were there big changes going on in your life that would change the environment around you?
- renewiltord 6y agoNothing notable in my case. I'd broken up with the girl halfway through the period of using but I was still using after. I know grandpa quit cold turkey after my dad (newly invested as a medical doctor) came home and said "You will die of lung cancer almost surely if you keep this up". And an uncle quit after his 8-year-old daughter (my cousin) said "Papa please. I don't want you to die" plaintively or something like that. I guess some things just change the game for people.
- bane 6y agoAddiction is an incredibly fascinating endless hole to get into, including these outlier folks. My wife for example has struggled to quit smoking for at least 10 years. As in very hardcore struggle. When I was young my father managed to quit from a 3 pack a day habit to nothing cold turkey. But it was obviously pretty tough on him during the process and took a couple of years to really break out of. My brother has a pretty bad pot addiction, a relatively harmless drug with almost no known chemical mechanism for addiction. Yet he can't shake it and it's haunted him his entire life. I'm a bit like you w/r to tobacco. I occasionally smoke cigars and have played around with cigarettes from time to time. Once I lose interest I just stop and it's over. No urge or desire or anything else. On the other hand, I have a bad day at work and all I want to do is shove shit food in my mouth.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI have repeatedly tried to stop eating pastries and candy but can’t do it. I can’t imagine how much willpower it takes to get off truly addictive drugs.
- mywittyname 6y agoSweets can be very addictive. You addiction might seem trivial in comparison, but you could be experiencing something quite similar to someone who is addicted to a "hard" substance.
- jimz 6y agoI don't know why you'd assume you're the outlier. Never mind the differences between physical and psychological dependence and problem use (which can happen without dependence, and one can be dependent but not using problematically), you personally experienced underwhelming withdrawal effects on multiple drugs that don't all affect the same parts of your brain, and some more physically addictive than others (benzos on top of that list). As for your friends, you know about their struggles because they had struggles in the first place. Just as the news doesn't report things when nothing bad happens, it's unlikely that, with the potential of stigmatization and jailtime, most people would volunteer something that caused them no issues but can only cause issues if they let it be known. If I were in your shoes I'd not assume that you and this guy happens to be the outliers, but rather, selection bias, the well-documented history of our drug laws being based on racial panics (Chinese for opiates, cocaine for African-Americans, marijuana for Mexicans, the crack sentencing disparity, et cetera) that happens to fund a lot of the economy via the prison-industrial complex, it's not much of a leap to think that a great deal of the harm linked to drug use is linked really to the various behavior undertaken to hide from detection and not necessarily from the drugs themselves, most of which - diamorphine included - are classified as having some medical use somewhere, although for whatever reason MDMA and marijuana are classified as having none. I think it's not hard to buy into the idea that problematic use is not the outlier because that's been taught to us for decades. But if your personal experience doesn't indicate that, why jump directly to thinking that you're the odd man out?
- renewiltord 6y agoA fair question. I haven't thought about it deeply. But smoking is a very social habit. No one hides the smoking. And it's really hard to hide because smokers have a sharp odour that's really hard to mask. So among the people I know, I know the smokers (or knew, since vaping wasn't common when I was young and had the habit). So I guess I had a pretty good hold on what the population of smokers was, and so I know most struggled to quit. As for the other drugs, yeah, I'm open to thinking otherwise. I have lots of friends who recreationally use cocaine, MDMA, LSD, mushrooms, and whatever else. Personally I've tried all of those and really just use shrooms now occasionally¹. No particular addictions there among my group of friends, so I'm open to your school of thought there. ¹ Cocaine is boring. MDMA is great. LSD is cool. Shrooms has massive therapeutic effects for me. I can skip my Adderall for two weeks after a trip. I feel so motivated to work and find it trivial to focus.
- zappo2938 6y agoThis video about our primate cousins, the alcoholic vervet monkeys in St. Kitts, might give some insight into addiction. [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSm7BcQHWXk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSm7BcQHWXk
- renewiltord 6y agoVery cool. Thanks.
- lamontcg 6y agoI used to smoke a cigarette or three a year. Get drunk on NYE, smoke a couple cigs. Wake up the next day with a hangover and have zero impulse to ever touch a cigarette again for another year. I outright abused alcohol early in 2020 because shit got a bit cray-cray. Then just stopped because alcohol got boring. Done that a lot with alcohol. Had an experience with Xanax several years ago though and I'm not touching that stuff again ever unless I'm terminal (then, yes, please). Still managed to identify the onset of addiction and stop it before it really got going, but I'm not touching that chemical again.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoMy dad quit smoking cold turkey one day and never thought about it again, my mom smoked until she died of lung cancer, she would take the oxygyn mask off to take a puff. It's bizzarre the genetic/environmental differences in addiction.
- bserge 6y agoIndeed, it's very dependent on the individual. Nicotine has me by the balls, very firmly. Alcohol even more so, it's something that I'm trying to quit for over a decade to no success. Cannabis? Smoked for months every day, decided it wasn't for me and that was it. Same for many other chemicals, including cocaine. I just... stopped. I feel like I could stop nicotine intake within a few weeks. Could be wrong about it. But not alcohol, that's the number 1 enemy. Every time I think about it, there's an insane urge to drink some, it's insane. I mean, I literally have access to something with effects between alcohol and cannabis, yet I go with alcohol. Ridiculous.
- confidantlake 6y agoThat is interesting because alcohol was extremely easy for me to quit. I decided at the start of last year to not drink for a year and that was that. Haven't hadn't a drink since last January. But 2 weeks without my morning decaf coffee, oh boy was that hard.
- chasd00 6y agoi remember struggling to start smoking tobacco in 8th grade to impress a girl (heh i saw her get sent home for wearing a Metallica Kill'Em All concert shirt, I was instantly in love). I just couldn't stand it the feel of tabacco. Same goes for weed, i hung around very heavy smokers all during college but just hated the feeling from THC so i never really got into it.
- Kaze404 6y ago> Well, one day, I decided "Meh. I'll just stop" and I did. Not because of any reason. I just chose not to. My girlfriend smoked for almost a decade and did the same thing as you, including drinking. She's been 2 years clean.
- tshaddox 6y agoI did the same thing. In fact, everyone I know who successfully quit smoking for a long time quit the same way. I’m not really sure that proves that cigarettes were any less addictive for you, unless you’re saying you never had any significant craving or desire to resume.
- renewiltord 6y agoInteresting. None of my friends smoke any more, with the last having quit two years ago after a long struggle and then reading Alan Carr's book and working with patches and gum. Cold turkey quitting hasn't been the norm. Most have tapered off. And no, I don't really even 'want' a cigarette. I know what addiction is, in that I feel this strong pull towards sweet stuff. I must have any kind of dessert, and if I see a novel food, I must eat it. I just must. It's like a fugue state. Try as I might I fall. Also with online validation for comments I write or stories I tell. The dopamine hit from an upvote has a debilitating hold on me. But with no drugs have I felt this desire. Not even shrooms which I enjoy or MDMA which has been my all time favourite. I have some shrooms and some LSD in my fridge so I can partake any time. I just don't. I'm amenable to the Rat Park hypothesis too. Maybe it's all Rat Park stuff.
- AntiImperialist 6y agoNicotine helps calm down anxiety. People with anxiety disorders get addicted to it because when they do it, the anxiety subsides. The anxiety starts setting in once the effect wears out. One doesn't get addicted to it right away because it takes time for the body to model what is this thing that is helping it and how it is getting access to it it. Once the body finds out, it seeks cigarettes; usually the body "overfits" and thinks it needs a particular brand of cigarette... and reliance on a particular brand is a problem, one can switch to another one by alternating with the brand you want to switch to... you can use the same strategy to switch to vaping or other nicotine delivery mechanisms. For people with no existing anxiety disorders, like you, there is no significant effect so the body doesn't bother seeking it. Same is true for any other drug addictions. They work by suppressing trauma or sadness or depression... and when the effect wears out, people need it again because the extreme emotions that were being suppressed come back with a bang.