4 ms·
> These things were put together in haste in the 90's and Oracle keeps pushing them and their corporate customers keep these things going long past when the int
by skissane 6y ago
> These things were put together in haste in the 90's and Oracle keeps pushing them and their corporate customers keep these things going long past when the interface becomes utterly unfamiliar.
Actually the history of this app is a little more complicated. In the early 1990s, Citibank decided to establish an outsourced software development group in India to rewrite their banking software from scratch–they established it as a subsidiary company called iFlex. From 2005 onwards, Citibank progressively sold a majority of its stake in iFlex to Oracle, who then renamed the company Oracle Financial Services Software (OFSS). OFSS is listed on the Mumbai stock exchange, but Oracle owns the majority of its stock.
So, rather than being a product which Oracle developed themselves and sold to Citibank, this is actually in some ways the opposite – a product Citibank developed themselves and sold to Oracle.
I used to work for Oracle. I never worked on OFSS software directly, but I did work on an implementation project for some of it. I never saw the internal banking UI, all I ever saw was backend stuff – LDAP, BPML, JVMs, databases, load balancers, firewalls, etc. Indeed this article is the first time I've seen that particular UI in my life. But I can tell from the visual appearance that it is not one of Oracle's more recent UI development frameworks. (I don't know if this is because Citibank is running an older version, or if there are parts of the product still running on a legacy UI framework.)
- orthoxerox 6y agoYes, that's Oracle Forms, one of the older versions. 6, I think.
- dragonwriter 6y agoIt certainly looks like Oracle Forms 6 (not sure if earlier versions looked similar, though.)
- sepin4 6y agoI can confirm it is OF. However versions 7 through 10(maybe 6 as well) all look like that so I can't say which one it is. I used to work in a company using OF for the UI and I can say that while it is horrific to look at, it had its strengths. However it was appropriate 20 years ago when monitors had standard aspect ratio and resolutions. Nowadays with scaling and all kinds of aspect ratio it just doesn't work. Also Java... Ironically for one client our software was interfacing with Flexcube. However the OF technology is still supported by Oracle and while they themselves are trying to kill it, nobody is willing to migrate their core systems to something new.
- HideousKojima 6y agoCurrently rewriting a bunch of stuff in Oracle Forms 6i to .NET 5, definitely looks like Oracle Forms 6
- AaronFriel 6y agoOh wow - gotta wonder how this "arms length transaction" got past any internal auditors or technology officers, or if no one was looking. (Then again, did Citibank have a CTO in the 90s?) Citibank developing in-house software then selling it to Oracle so that they can charge recurring licensing and support fees for eternity is incredibly short-sighted if you're Citibank or Manna from heaven if you're Oracle. My guess though is the Citibank executives who signed off on this got promoted up and out of the department that has to budget for these licensing fees and support costs, and on both sides they received tidy bonuses for "increasing revenues".
- dagmx 6y agoThe software fees are likely reduced/free. I've worked at companies that have sold in house software to other companies to make them public. It's usually resulted in lowering in house maintenance costs and the licensing agreements have a sweetheart deal for the original company. Usually it's a win win, unless you value keeping control (which can be quite valuable)
- wegs 6y ago> Usually it's a win win, unless you value keeping control (which can be quite valuable) My experience is that it's usually overvalued. An external, focused company will usually do a better job than an internal project. It's emotionally hard to give up control, but successful companies tend to focus on a few things, do them really well (areas of competitive advantage), and outsource everything else. A best-of-breed external solution almost always beats an in-house solution. I'd just never do something like this with Oracle. Their business model seems to consist of locking companies in, and then milking them.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoWhy would the arms length principle be a concern here? It’s generally only a concern in regards to transfer pricing of transactions between entities that have common ownership/control.
- skissane 6y ago
- abdulhaq 6y agoWhen I saw the screenshot of the app I first thought, "that's Swing". But then I saw that tick mark and I thought, holy moley oculd that be the tick mark from Borland (e.g. OWL)? https://sourceforge.net/p/owlnext/wiki/Replacing_usage_of_BWCC/attachment/Bwcc1.png https://sourceforge.net/p/owlnext/wiki/Replacing_usage_of_BW...
- pow_pp_-1_v 6y agoMost probably not Borland. That scrollbar looks like Swing.
- ficklepickle 6y agoSomeone on ars said its Delphi. But I don't have a ton of faith in ars commenters.
- joezydeco 6y agoThat green check was in Borland Delphi too. https://damieng.com/blog/tag/delphi/ https://damieng.com/blog/tag/delphi/
- mkup 6y agoYes, it looks like OWL framework which was bundled with Borland C++. Google Image Search for "borland c++ owl" yields more screenshots in the similar visual style.
- rbanffy 6y agoThat scroll bar is an Oracle scroll bar - you can see it in the GUI installer for the RDBMS (and in all Oracle Java apps). The Borland-like checkmark button can be something Citi-specific or just a developer who liked Borland enough to import the graphic into the app's UI. When the 3D look became the norm for Windows apps, introduced by Office and, later, by Windows 3.1 (or 3.11), I used the DLL to 3D-fy my Windows app dialogs automagically. I also took some liberties with using Office graphic elements reasoning that a Windows or Office user would know the 3.5" floppy saves things.