7 ms·
The reality is that lots of places are actively shutting down coal & nuclear already and are replacing them with wind, solar, and batteries without blackouts be
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
The reality is that lots of places are actively shutting down coal & nuclear already and are replacing them with wind, solar, and batteries without blackouts being a thing. All that takes is money. And even that is changing as wind and solar bids now routinely undercut everything else on the market. That's basically driving the transition in the most unlikely places (like oil and gas producing Texas or coal producing Virginia).
Many places elsewhere have all but completed the transition to renewables and are well on their way to 100% renewable grids early next decade. That's not some fantasy, it's basically largely past tense in a lot of places not plagued by blackouts with any kind of frequency.
- Lammy 6y agoThe electricity I buy from PG&E is generated primarily with natural gas https://news.yahoo.com/news/sierra-club-took-26-million-natural-gas-lobby-054500586.html https://news.yahoo.com/news/sierra-club-took-26-million-natu...
- seanmcdirmid 6y ago> All that takes is money. The biggest case against nuclear actually isn’t environmental, but economic: they still take a lot of money to build and rebuild after their useful life is over. The reason no one is fighting too hard to keep nuclear around as an option is because it simply isn’t feasible without the government subsidies handed out in the 60s and 70s. But nuclear with its really cheap fuel and the new ability to store power in batteries when demand is lower might be feasible if the capital and insurance costs can be tamed more.
- DrBazza 6y ago> The reason no one is fighting too hard to keep nuclear around as an option is because it simply isn’t feasible without the government subsidies handed out in the 60s and 70s. I still find this argument hard to believe. The physics involved is pretty simple, immerse the rods in water, bring them together, water boils, water turns turbine. It's the polar opposite of fusion. What makes fission reactors cost money is the Government being involved from the first pen on paper, to the cutting of the ribbon and all the steps in between. Allowing private companies to design and build them, the Government to regulate, only, should reduce the price dramatically. SMRs are a thing: https://www.energy.gov/ne/nuclear-reactor-technologies/small-modular-nuclear-reactors https://www.energy.gov/ne/nuclear-reactor-technologies/small...
- jillesvangurp 6y agoSeven decades of financials around nuclear are pretty brutal too. Even keeping existing plants running is not cheap. E.g. France imports cheap wind at times when it has nuclear surplus that is just more expensive. They are actively planning to gradually replace nuclear with other options as plants reach their end date. IMHO the potential for fusion long term is amazing but unlikely to happen first half of this century. Nuclear options short term makes sense for some niche use cases but it is a hard sell on the grid given prices for wind, solar, and battery continue to trend down from already being vastly cheaper. Anyone looking to sell nuclear probably should be planning for 1-2 order of magnitude in cost reduction just to keep up.
- orwin 6y agoFrance import "cheap wind" (free wind essentially since the price is just high enough to match green energy tax) because the european power grid needs to match production with consumption. And it also helps Germany to reduce the cost of their energy transition. There is a reason why Germans electrical engineers are so cross with Denmark and their eastern neighbors.
- fsflover 6y ago> they still take a lot of money to build and rebuild after their useful life is over If markets valued the low-CO2 nature of nuclear, they’d be doing better https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html
- rswskg 6y agoOr shut nuclear down like in germany, ramp up coal usage and go begging to the russians for a gas pipeline.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoIt's something that comes up a lot that is simply not true: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-consumption-and-power-mix-charts https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-c.... Clean energy absorbed most of the growth and shrinkage of coal & nuclear in the years the transition happened. About 2/3rd of the nuclear capacity disappeared around 2010 and the combined growth of coal, gas, and brown coal is a fraction of that in that period. Rewewable growth around the same time on the other hand took most of that. And it didn't stop growing. At this point that dwarfs nuclear, coal, gas, browncoal combined (<40% together). Of those gas is pretty much the only thing that had some growth (beyond 2010 numbers); from the looks of it partially at the cost of black coal. Brown coal has been more or less the same in recent history thanks to the CSU (mainly) lobbying hard for keeping that around for a few decades). But they might have to negotiate with the green party soonish and I doubt they'd agree to continue backing that.
- rswskg 6y agoSo nordstream 2 is what then?
- todd8 6y ago> Many places elsewhere have all but completed the transition to renewables and are well on their way to 100% renewable grids ... I'm really interested in this progress, can you enumerate just a handful of these places.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoIceland, Norway come to mind as the obvious poster childs for hydro and geothermal and probably there already. If you count nuclear (and why not), France is another big one and even they are replacing nuclear with renewables. Countries like Denmark, Sweden the UK, , come to mind as places that are closing in on (or over) 50% at this point and have ambitious targets of getting pretty much to 100% by next decade or so. In many other markets (e.g. Germany, China, the US) renewables are either or both the fastest growing form of energy or the largest (by kwh) form of energy (typically displacing coal recently or in the near future). These will take longer but are probably going to close in on the 50% mark by the end of the decade nevertheless.