10 ms·
WhatsApp alternatives that respect privacy
- sschueller 6y agoThere is also: - Jami (https://jami.net/) - Briar (https://briarproject.org/)
- sneak 6y agoIt shocks me that non-open-source or non-e2e-encrypted options are included in this list. Listing Telegram (effectively not encrypted) in a list next to Signal/Threema makes no sense to me.
- reader_mode 6y agoTBH Telegram makes the right kind of tradeoffs for me - I like having cloud based chat sync between devices way more than I care about someone reading my shopping discussions with my wife or my friend group chats. And then if I need to make something private I can start a private chat. And the interface is easy to sell to non-techies, especially compared to Signal. This is all in theory anyway - it's entirely possible that Telegram sends everything to some government entity somewhere even for private chats - but frankly I don't care that much so I'll trust the claims and audits.
- sneak 6y ago> And the interface is easy to sell to non-techies, especially compared to Signal. Could you elaborate on this? I personally find that Signal's interface couldn't be simpler, and have on-boarded hundreds of "non-techies" without support or explanation beyond "download an app called Signal and message me on the same number, but on there". > TBH Telegram makes the right kind of tradeoffs for me Given those tradeoffs, Facebook Messenger or Whatsapp is probably a way better choice than Telegram.
- reader_mode 6y ago>Could you elaborate on this? I personally find that Signal's interface couldn't be simpler, and have on-boarded hundreds of "non-techies" without support or explanation beyond "download an app called Signal and message me on the same number, but on there". Telegram feels more polished and distinct, for example it has very nice animated emojis. Signal looks like programmer art and a random system SMS app - it's hard to convince people to use it, I started using Telegram with my wife just for the animojis and stuck with it because of a nice desktop app. I got my entire family and some friends on it eventually. >Given those tradeoffs, Facebook Messenger or Whatsapp is probably a way better choice than Telegram. I actually like Telegram as a chat app more than those two - Messenger is bloated garbage tied into Facebook which is another bloated garbage platform so I avoid those if I can. WhatsApp doesn't do cloud sync well actually, my phone needs to be active for webapp to work and when I switched from iPhone to Android and back I would lose history between the two.
- soco 6y agoI would say non-techies won't even notice the difference between WA, Telegram or Signal. I'm not sure which differences you mean. PS: oops I found a difference: in Signal you need about 7 clicks to send a local picture.
- 7786655 6y ago>it's entirely possible that Telegram sends everything to some government entity somewhere even for private chats No, private chats use end-to-end encryption, and unlike WhatsApp the Telegram client is open source so this can actually be verified.
- reader_mode 6y agoUnless I spend time to look into who verified it and decide if I trust them - this doesn't mean much - for eg. the article above claims their crypto is criticised - since it's their own implementation it could be intentionally weakened for all I know, even with a review it's possible to sneak by a backdoor vulnerability - security projects with a lot more users had major flaws discovered well into the project lifetime (eg. OpenSSL heartbleed).
- decrypt 6y agoTelegram private chats are not end-to-end encrypted. They are opt-in, in the name of "secret chats". If that's not done, chats are stored on their cloud in plain view. While Signal can offer synced end-to-end encrypted messaging, I wonder why Telegram cannot. Probably comes with a few tradeoffs like slowness and loss of features?
- decrypt 6y agoI used to like Telegram for their cloud sync as well, but Signal does an equally nice job (at least for me!) in syncing my chats across all devices. The messages are end-to-end encrypted too, unlike Telegram. It has become the standard for me.
- user-the-name 6y agoTelegram and Keybase have been heavily involved with cryptocurrencies, which should be a huge red flag in terms of trustworthiness. That is an industry populated mostly by scammers, or at the very least people with very flexible morals.
- mam2 6y ago"people worked in a field with some bad people so they are bad people too"
- user-the-name 6y agoIf you see a field that consist almost entirely of scammers, and you then choose to also enter that field, that is going to make me suspicious of your motivations and morals.
- s_dev 6y ago>Telegram Also seems to be deeply distrusted by authoritarian states which to me is a green flag. e.g. it's banned in Iran and Russia
- merlinscholz 6y agoIt is also inherently insecure and offers no encryption by default, and not at all in group chats, which to me is a red flag.
- s_dev 6y ago>It is also inherently insecure How is it inherently insecure when it provides encrypted chat? Defaults are a powerful way to influence user behavior and there is good reason to have the chat not encrypted. It facilitates quick searching of keywords which for many chat users is an important feature. Many people chose to write things down or have discussion in text so they don't have to remember. If users want E2E by default they are free to use another service or just coninually use Secret Chat.
- jasonpeacock 6y agoIf it doesn't inter-operate, it's not really an alternative. Chrome, Firefox, Edge are all alternative web browsers, you can drop-in replace them when visiting websites. But none of these can be drop-in replaced when talking with your friends who are using WhatsApp. WhatsApp is the de-facto messaging standard throughout South America, Africa, and half of Europe. That's a lot of inertia to overcome.
- 3np 6y agoMatrix fits the bill. It's federated - you can have rooms and conversations across homservers seamlessly today. There are several implementations for both server and client. It's still a way to go to be 100% though; for example portable identities - right now your user account is tied to a specific homeserver, yours or somebody elses. And first class tor (or i2p?) support with enough federation over either. Performance of synapse and elemnt, spoecifically, are also pretty poor. I really think it's on the right track though - all my reservations for matrix in its current state have been recognized by the maintainers and are on the roadmap.
- 4ggr0 6y agoThat's what I thought as a european in the beginning of this year. But in a matter of weeks, all of my closest friends and family members downloaded Signal. I was able to convert some people by myself by just deleting my WhatsApp account. Last year I had a phase where I wanted to ungoogle/uncloud my life. I never thought that I would be able to delete WhatsApp for the same reasons you mentioned. Turns out, most people don't really care about installing another messenger, if they do, I just write them via SMS. I now chat 90% on Signal, the other 10% are split between Threema, Telegram, SMS and Discord.
- temp0826 6y agoOne thing that might be hard to overcome here in SA (Peru) is that many providers seem to have data caps, but will provide whatsapp (and facebook) access for “free”, even if you are out of data (the services seem to still work exclusively). I’m not sure what deal was made (or if the providers are doing this out of the goodness of their hearts..?)- but the same would probably need to happen before you see a migration.
- Darmody 6y agoThe real problem is almost nobody cares and those who care, might end up giving up. A messaging app is not like a personal app that you use on your own. Its value is not only in the software itself but also in the number of users. It took Telegram years to get 500 million users. Now people are being told, "switch to this other app, it's better", "look how many alternatives". How long would it take Signal to be an alternative to Telegram user-wise? And once they get there, some problem will pop up and then what? Do we migrate to a new app and wait 10 years to have almost all our friends there?
- rimeice 6y agoIt's pretty straight forward to have both Whatsapp and [alternative messaging app] installed on your phone. You still have an SMS app on your phone, which was the primary messaging application prior to Whatsapp. A lot of people migrated to Whatsapp because it was more secure and private than SMS. Now that advantage is being questioned, I think it's logical to see a migration to something more secure or private.
- j3th9n 6y agoMost people migrated to WhatsApp because it was free, not because it was more secure and private, for a long time it wasn't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reception_and_criticism_of_WhatsApp_security_and_privacy_features https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reception_and_criticism_of_Wha...
- rimeice 6y ago"A lot of people" is a bit different to "most people". SMS is free in the same sense that Whatsapp is free and you need a phone contract to use either when you're not in a wifi network. In fact there was a period where adding 3G to your phone contract was noticeably more expensive. Regardless, my point is that there is a logical path that some people will take to move to more private options. I'm doing exactly what I described in my comment, a bunch of my friends are doing it and I don't think we're that exceptional.
- 6y ago
- rjzzleep 6y agoIt's quite sad that Wire never made it mainstream and then was sold to a third party that isn't as trustworthy. They had great UX/UI both on mobile and on desktop early on. Used the same signal double ratchet and were originally owned by a Swiss entity. A real shame they didn't get the momentum they needed.
- newscracker 6y agoWire is good because it syncs conversations across devices and allows one to sign up without a phone number. But its sluggish client apps (especially on desktop, where I guess it’s an Electron app) have been a bane for a long time.
- Kelamir 6y agoWhy is signing up with a mobile number an issue? Where I live, you can buy cards freely l, so I could just use a throwaway card to sign up, and use it only when I need to sign in/restore account.
- bogwog 6y agoNow imagine if you could do that without having to “use a throwaway card to sign up, and use it only when I need to sign in/restore account”
- gggtt 6y agoIn most countries (eg Europe, US, Brazil, China, etc.) it's not the case and you have to give your ID (or some sort of identifier linked to your real identity) to get a SIM card or any internet service
- alexashka 6y agoThis never ending attempt to affect systems by ignoring systems and changing individual behaviour instead has always struck me as a fool's errand. Nevertheless, I predict it'll continue, perhaps until the end of time.
- qntty 6y agoI'm confused, it says that Threema costs $3/month, but as far as I can tell it's a one-time $3 cost on the apple app store. Am I missing something?
- sschueller 6y agoThreema is free after you purchase the app unless you are using the business services.
- jcul 6y agoYa I noticed that too and I think it's a mistake. It's a one off purchase for non business use at least.
- miyuru 6y agoIt also says that telegram is hosted on AWS, which is false. telegram has their own network with 4 ASNs. https://bgp.he.net/search?search[search]=telegram https://bgp.he.net/search?search[search]=telegram
- jsilence 6y agoIt does not.
- sunshinekitty 6y agoIt does not what? From the article: > Cons - Hosted on Amazon Web Services (AWS)
- jsilence 6y agoThat is on the Signal segment, not on the Telegram segment.
- newscracker 6y agoI’m still hoping that Element (of the Matrix network) would gain more users and become as popular as email is, with several providers around the world that make it easy to sign up and use. Funding for the infrastructure and running costs is going to be an issue for all these platforms. Only donations and grants seem to be viable to some extent (and maybe ads again), not payments or subscriptions from end users.
- bobkrusty 6y agoI think we need different app/server as matrix servers depend on one software ig., matrix engine. Imagine if theres vulnerability it will affect all matrix servers.
- 3np 6y agoWhile synapse is the main reference implementation, there is also dendrite (getting very close) and at least 4 other actively developed Matrix homeserver implementations.
- stryan 6y agoMatrix is a protocol, so there can be multiple Matrix home server implementations. There's already three: Synapse (python, main implementation with full support), Dendrite (golang, beta level feature support), and Construct (C++, alpha/beta feature support, fully third party).
- BrightOne 6y agoThere's also a Rust homeserver called Conduit (https://conduit.rs https://conduit.rs)
- fartcannon 6y agoIt's odd that they recommend Signal, when their own chart shows that Element is the superior option.
- 6y ago
- deadalus 6y agoCourt documents show FBI may have tool to access private Signal messages on locked iPhones https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/fbi-tool-access-private-signal-messages-locked-iphones https://www.foxbusiness.com/technology/fbi-tool-access-priva...
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoI don't think most users expect their chat app to be protected if the police seize their phone. The main concern is about intercepting messages between 2 parties or mass exploiting the history stored by the provider. Sure, for some case, it can be important, but that's a much more difficult and rare threat model to address.
- hackermailman 6y ago>The court documents, filed by the Justice Department and obtained by Forbes, showed screenshots of Signal messages between men allegedly discussing an illegal weapons trade and attempted murder. I translate that to 'an FBI informant involved in the criminal conspiracy saved screenshots of the messages'
- decrypt 6y agoThis title in this article is aimed at generating clicks. The flaw that's described here applies to all other apps, including Google Chrome, Telegram, WhatsApp, literally any app on your phone.
- upofadown 6y agoProbably not offline stuff like encrypted mail. That tends to be protected separately from the phone stuff.
- drummer 6y ago> Cons: Requires a valid phone number to register, Hosted on Amazon Web Services (AWS) I like how using AWS is a con. They should be avoided after their deplatforming of Parler. Cant be trusted
- CyanDeparture 6y agoGenuine question because I can't think of a good answer - why is iMessage (Apple's messaging service) not on the list. It looks like it would have a good few green ticks on the chart.
- 4ggr0 6y agoBecause the privacy benefits are only present for Apple users, for others it's just SMS.
- CyanDeparture 6y agoAh yes of course, they need to release a Windows and Android app. How very apple-centric of me. Sorry about that.
- 4ggr0 6y agoMost of the other apps are available on multiple platforms. I'm not saying that Apple is bad or wrong for only developing iMessage for iPhones, but it explains why no one mentions it when they discuss messaging apps for EVERYONE. Apple may have a huge market share in the US, worldwide they "only" account for roughly 27% of the devices, compared to Android with around 70%. Maybe try to think for yourself why the article wouldn't mention it, instead of writing such a snarky response towards me. Cheers.
- dastx 6y agoWhatever happened to Tox project?
- 0x64 6y agoThere's also Session, which runs their own p2p network of onion routers as a part of their blockchain initiative [1]. Status is another, which runs p2p waku nodes and is heavily connected to Ethereum [2]. Neither of them requires a phone number, plus both are open-source and p2p. [1] https://getsession.org/ https://getsession.org/ [2] https://status.im/ https://status.im/
- lazyeye 6y agoI dont get this "its based in Switzerland so its secure" thing.. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_AG
- elisaado 6y agoI hate how the plot reveals itself after only 2 or 3 sentences on the wikipedia article.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Labo333 6y agoI wish the comparison could also include "message sync across devices". Currently Signal requires one to export past messages in a file (that can be unencrypted). This means that to be sure to keep their messages if they use new devices or lose their old one, one has to use a cloud storage, an area where privacy violating providers are still prevalent. Note that WhatsApp was doing exactly that (with an opt in IIRC) with google drive sync on android and I guess iCloud on iOS, so I always found even their e2ee claim dubious. At least Signal doesn't make it easy to use unencrypted cloud storage but I wish to see more services with message persistance. On the other hand, it certainly has a much higher server cost.
- paraknight 6y agoAs far as I can tell, Element does _not_ actually support E2EE group video, or any kind of group video at all? At most, you can install a Jitsi plugin? Also, even though Matrix is technically superior, Element the defacto client is so buggy and full of UX issues that it's nowhere near as user-friendly as Signal, especially to e.g. my mother.
- gitanovic 6y agoa couple more alternatives: https://mega.io/ https://mega.io/ https://tox.chat/ https://tox.chat/ Mega has a chat, phone and video calls Tox is actually quite decentralized (I think you cannot be more decentralized than p2p), but has many inconveniences of not being cloud based EDIT: readability
- aneemzic 6y agoI find it odd the only accusation they list against Whatsapp is it was sending metadata, then list a group of alternatives who largely use the same metadata. I understand the hate for Facebook and why people are obviously skeptical. But is there something more I'm missing here around what whatsapp/facebook are accused of? It seems like it was just timestamps and public profile information.
- shock 6y agoI wish more people knew about DeltaChat. It has WhatsApp's UI, but the transport is email.
- Multicomp 6y agoThey make slow progress towards greatness. Delta chat now supports some group chats, but it still has ux challenges explaining that you just login with your email address on the app and that you are not giving a server somewhere your email login credentials. They are also still working on multi account logins and per conversation outbound email aliases, but I'm watching them very closely because like you I wish more people would use this.
- shock 6y ago> Delta chat now supports some group chats, but it still has ux challenges explaining that you just login with your email address on the app and that you are not giving a server somewhere your email login credentials. Yes, I've encountered precisely this with some of my friends.