8 ms·
A lot of people on HN scream against location-based pay, because for some reason they assume they'll make more without it. If they live in Europe, or rural Amer
by pc86 6y ago
A lot of people on HN scream against location-based pay, because for some reason they assume they'll make more without it. If they live in Europe, or rural America, they might be right. But HN has a highly disproportionate number of Valley and NYC residents. They're all getting [big] pay cuts if you get rid of location-based pay. The biggest (but not only) reason someone in SF makes $250k+ total comp is because it's so expensive to live in SF.
Not too long ago, I remember threads on HN where people were saying that $200k or $250k wasn't enough for a SF dev and using real estate prices and general cost of living as justification. You can't have it both ways - either your general cost of living is taken into account in your salary (location-based pay), or it's not. If it's not, get ready for a market where the average senior developer makes $90-110k/yr, total comp.
- adkadskhj 6y agoYea, i really don't get so many of the comments here. If i live in a low COL area and i apply, why wouldn't i want the competitive advantage of being able to charge them half as much and make twice as much profit as my competition? People outside the bay area can make a good living charging well below crazy SF rates. This isn't even an argument to me. It's not even a discussion. Of course when you have a pool of talent, and that talent is competing for a single job, they will use every tool possible. If you can work for half the price of some SF guy paying massive SF rates, why wouldn't you use that tool? Yea sure, i could make $200k a year - that would be neat i suppose, but it's insane imo. The number only exists because of SF specific problems. And i'm not in SF.
- User23 6y agoThere is no nice way to say this anyhow, but it needs to be said to further the discussion that does in fact exist: this is thinking like a chump. Being a chump is not a competitive advantage, it’s being taken advantage of. I fully respect your right to sell yourself short, but please don’t present it as somehow economically sophisticated and potentially lead less experienced readers here to follow the same foolish path.
- adkadskhj 6y agoNot at all. It's playing the numbers. If you're aiming for $50k/y in profit after all COL, your required pricing is different in SF than it is in rural America. If you live in rural America and compete at hiring with SF people, it's your competitive advantage to keep the same profit as them but negotiate a lower price. This increases your relative value in the hiring process. Sure, i _could_ keep the same SF rates, but then my competitive advantage may just be my skill. If i want more than skill alone, i could lower my rates. I'm not making less profit. I'm competing to get a job.
- kortilla 6y ago> advantage to keep the same profit as them but negotiate a lower price. This increases your relative value in the hiring process. That is how you negotiate when you’re struggling to find a job. By doing this you’re admitting that you’re not going to be as good as the high CoL candidate so you adjust your price to make your offer more attractive to the company. That’s a terrible position to put yourself in (but entirely understandable if you can’t get offers otherwise). If you’ve passed the same bar and the company is truly fine with remote, there no reason to accept anything less than what they would pay a local. Speaking from experience in several tech companies in the bay, a proven remote employee is just as valuable as a local and getting decent software people is fucking hard. It’s unlikely as a candidate that there is even any competition for the position you are filling (as in not multiple candidates that have passed the bar being picked over). Talking you into cost of living adjustments or whatever bullshit is just salary negotiation, not competition with other engineers. Get multiple offers if you have to, but there is literally no reason a company willing to pay Bay Area salaries can’t pay that to a remote employee. Accepting less is just letting them convince you your labor isn’t as good as Bay Area SWE labor.
- adkadskhj 6y ago> That is how you negotiate when you’re struggling to find a job. By doing this you’re admitting that you’re not going to be as good as the high CoL candidate so you adjust your price to make your offer more attractive to the company. That’s a terrible position to put yourself in (but entirely understandable if you can’t get offers otherwise). Yup. That's what i said. If you see no reason to negotiate, why negotiate? Set your price at what your think your value is. Don't indulge COL requirements of another location. > It’s unlikely as a candidate that there is even any competition for the position you are filling (as in not multiple candidates that have passed the bar being picked over). Talking you into cost of living adjustments or whatever bullshit is just salary negotiation, not competition with other engineers. As someone who hires, i disagree. Every one of our hires has been a debate on expected output when compared to cost. But we're a fully remote company. edit: Oh, and we're not flush with VC cash. We also can't afford any SF employees for this reason. We're much more willing to hire a junior engineer if their priced accordingly. Likewise, if we hired someone at $250k/y, we'd expect twice the output of him/her - and that's unlikely. I don't get why this is controversial.
- jorblumesea 6y agoYou're assuming a highly optimistic scenario where you take an even pay cut but make out like a bandit. The reality is that a "fair wage" for many rural white collar workers is 40% of what you might make in SV, or even worse. Getting $250k in SV sucks, but try getting paid $50k in Cincinnati. Then imagine a scenario where there's maybe 2-3 local companies that hire, and they all collude on prices. I feel like people saying "just move to a low COL area" have never actually lived and worked in a low COL. If you lose your job or get fired, there's no one to back up that "half as much, x2 profit" unless you find remote work again, and then you're also at the mercy of whatever people feel they can get out of you. Without competing offers or local competition, you're at the mercy of the market. People are underselling the competition that nuclei of talent can produce from top competing companies.
- Swizec 6y ago> Getting $250k in SV sucks Ok hold up in what world does $250k in SV suck? Median household income here is around $120k last I checked. Making more than double that cannot be described as sucking, come on.
- jorblumesea 6y agoIt was mostly sarcastic. I don't actually believe it's bad, that's just "average market rate" for senior/mid level engineer. Roughly translated, 250k in SV is 120k in the Midwest. Housing issues aside.
- pc86 6y ago> Roughly translated, 250k in SV is 120k in the Midwest. I'll believe this only insofar as $120k in the Midwest means you are "set" in the sense that you can max out your retirement, buy a home, have nice cars, etc. and basically live on autopilot from a financial sense.
- kortilla 6y agoThat’s how bad housing is. If you grew up on the dream of a nice house with a garage and a big yard, $250k still doesn’t get you there in SV. This type of housing setup that would cost $300k in, say Dallas, will cost $2.5 million on the peninsula. Between property taxes, mortgage insurance, interest, and principal payments and a jaw dropping $140k down payment, that is a monthly payment of $14k or so. Your take-home after taxes on 250k in the bay is probably around 160k, or 13.3k a month. Whoops, no “American dream” home for you.
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoThe point is that the companies are making the same amount of revenue regardless of where you live. If Google cuts your salary 50% because you move to a cheaper area, maybe that doesn't make a difference to you but it is free profit for Google shareholders. It makes it more obvious to people that the amount they are paid and the amount of marginal profit they earn for the company is WILDLY incommensurate, even for over-compensated Silly Valley engineers, and would be even moreso if you move somewhere cheaper and take a pay cut.
- adkadskhj 6y ago> The point is that the companies are making the same amount of revenue regardless of where you live. Agreed entirely. It depends on what specifically we're discussing. I often look at hiring. > If Google cuts your salary 50% because you move to a cheaper area, maybe that doesn't make a difference to you but it is free profit for Google shareholders. It makes it more obvious to people that the amount they are paid and the amount of marginal profit they earn for the company is WILDLY incommensurate, even for over-compensated Silly Valley engineers, and would be even moreso if you move somewhere cheaper and take a pay cut. I wouldn't work somewhere that did this for this very reason. But there's a huge difference to paying someone based on their finances, and negotiating hiring pay. I'm just talking about hiring pay being negotiable.
- xorencrypted 6y agoThey could also hire more engineers or expand into new territory which requires additional (non-engineering) labor. The cost of living in the bay area seems almost an artificial constraint on the supply of labor at these companies
- ActorNightly 6y ago>. If Google cuts your salary 50% because you move to a cheaper area, maybe that doesn't make a difference to you but it is free profit for Google shareholders. And thats exactly how a company should operate - maximize profit while minimizing cost. And conversly, as an individual, you should do the exact same, which is get paid as much as you can for your work (or do the minimum amount of work for the pay you get). When both of those strategies meet in the middle, you get a paid job position.
- loufe 6y agoI'd argue the opposite. The price of living rose to meet the means of the people who lived there. People in tech are highly paid because it is a workers' market where talent and special education and skills are generally required. If the industry could hire people who could do the same job remote at $50k per year this trend would have begun decades ago.
- galangalalgol 6y agoIt did, didn't it? faangs have been moving development to the Midwest for at least 20years.
- fast54 6y agoLook carefully at what is moving to midwest. Either projects that are in maintenance or non-tech workers.
- galangalalgol 6y agoInteresting! In the embedded systems arena it has been happening even longer than that, including developers. Maybe that explains part but not all of why webserver developers make double on average an embedded developer's salary, or last time I checked.
- ehnto 6y agoThey aren't isolated of course, SV is expensive because SV has money. Rentals go up because people keep paying stupid high rents, property goes up because people CAN afford it. Rent seekers keep pushing their luck and it keeps working. I have become interested with the real value of software, and how getting rid of stupid high wages could be a great thing for the industry. As an analogy, if a country has reasonably priced infrastructure workers (laymen and engineers) it can afford to build the infrastructure it's community needs. If you blow your annual budget building 6 miles of train line, you'll never have high speed rail. Real world example: Australia, one of the richest countries in the world, notoriously high infrastructure costs. While the rest of the world is speeding away with high speed rail, we could barely afford a two stop tram extension in the CBD. Now have a think about all the software that doesn't get written because it's prohibitively expensive to make it, lots of boutique applications for specific needs, or local communities that need software to help with problems in their community. There are probably a lot of companies that could really do with an inhouse software team, but would never entertain the idea on account of the cost.
- jacksonkmarley 6y agoIs Australia and HSR really a good example of this? I would think the only viable route would be Sydney-Melbourne, and that seems far enough apart to be directly competing with air travel, likely a major reason for it to be marginal profit-wise. Also Australian workers are no doubt well paid compared with some, but compared with the U.S. or Western Europe? Taking into account cost of living etc.? Certainly engineers in Australia in general don't seem to be getting SV wages.
- phinnaeus 6y agoI can confirm, I moved from Seattle to Sydney. It's not even close.
- jacksonkmarley 6y agoSingle data point on new grad s/w engineer salary at small/medium business in Melbourne, circa 2015 ~40k in USD.
- ummonk 6y agoTwo different groups of people. The ones complaining about location based pay are the ones who would rather work in cheaper cities.
- klipt 6y agoOf course getting paid Bay Area salaries while simultaneously living somewhere you can buy a big cheap house is a great arbitrage, but not achievable for many. But many engineers can work in the Bay Area for 10 years to become a millionaire then move elsewhere, buy a house cash and retire early (or work a lower pay job if they feel like it).
- kortilla 6y ago> But many engineers can work in the Bay Area for 10 years to become a millionaire then move elsewhere, buy a house cash and retire early (or work a lower pay job if they feel like it). This sounds good on paper, but what you’re saying is establish roots in one place and then rip them up (take your kids out of schools, away from their friends, leave your friends, hobbies, etc). 10 years isn’t exactly an in-n-out stint on an oil rig.
- ummonk 6y agoOn the coasts it's normal to not have kids until your early 30s, so you can definitely graduate and work 10 years in the Bay Area before moving elsewhere and establishing a family.
- wayoutthere 6y agoFrankly I would be ok with that. The situation in the valley developed in the 90s and 00s, so that companies could be located close to their investors. That was a time when remote work tools sucked and work practices forced people to be in the same office as the founders, so it made lots of sense that the proximity to capital spiked rents and comp to match. But now, post-pandemic, remote work is the norm. The founders can relocate to the valley because investment finance is largely a relationship game and those are still way better done in person, but there’s no longer any reason the technical team needs to be located near the founders or even each other. There is huge disparity in engineering salaries — if you work for a smallish company in a rural area you’re probably making $80k/yr for doing the same job someone in the bay gets $175+ for. Ideally it will work the other way around though — the folks making $80k are much more likely to jump ship for a remote job that pays $125k than the folks making $175k are to jump to the same job. Of course, if organize via collective bargaining we can likely push that even higher, so listen to your union organizers.
- bennysonething 6y agoI always assumed that it the high paid jobs in SF were proper software engineering positions as opposed to line of business apps that lower paid jobs else where often are?
- ZephyrBlu 6y agoWhat is "proper software engineering"?
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoCalling it "proper software engineering" is little pretentious at best, but there is some distinction to be made between software engineering in the bay area and most software engineering elsewhere. When we think of SF software, we think of software created by a company whose core product is the software itself, especially when the end-users are individuals or other software companies. This is quite a bit different than most software developed outside of the bay area. Most of it is either in-house stuff or industry-specific B2B stuff. In these situations, the software doesn't have to be pretty, it doesn't have to use cutting-edge tech to woo investors, resource utilization is much less important, and hell - it usually doesn't even have to scale. It just has to work. It just has to make someone's job incrementally better, and it'll be a success. This software can be tremendously valuable, and creating it has its own unique challenges, but the job is indeed a bit different than software engineering in the bay, and the compensation is different as well.
- michaelmrose 6y agoNot having it both way is an argument to fairness. You should want fairness in a game of checkers. It was never a thing in employment anyway nor will it be. A high local real estate price is a reason you can't profitably work for less and its something you can profitably express to an employer if they will take it into account in order to access the local labor market. A lower local real estate cost is a reason you could work for less not a reason you ought to want to. You absolutely should try to have it both ways to the greatest extent possible because they are too.
- cm2187 6y agoAt the end of the day, it is neither a matter of fairness or formula, it is a market, supply vs demand. If companies switch to remote working from any location, it will be easier to find a cheaper workforce, the equilibrium will go down. If you don’t like the new rate, find an employer that will pay more. If there isn’t one, then the new rate is a fair rate. I am not sold on full remote working for most companies. I am not even convinced the little covid experiment demonstrated anything, as companies still benefit from employees knowing each others from before the lockdown. Long term the effects in term of productivity, employee morale or culture may be quite different. A compromise is having more local offices, but even then, everywhere I saw it before, it creates a “them” vs “us” between offices, people feel remote from the centres of decision, etc.
- anticristi 6y agoTo me, the "little covid experiment" kind of validated the value of an office: Situational awareness. Previously, it was so easy to grab a coffee or lunch, and get an overall awareness of who is doing what. I'm still struggling to find a substitute for that.
- TravHatesMe 6y agoNot sure why you are downvoted. I observed this as well. One manager hired a few new grads during covid. I spoke with them over Zoom to introduce myself, seemed like really smart and passionate people. One later told me that they are really lonely, managers are rarely there to push them / give them work / check up on them. I bet they feel awkward .. they're barely working, they don't know anyone in the company, and no one really cares about them. Perhaps this is just a symptom of mismanagement but I bet they feel invisible, they're probably asking themselves "why am I here? oh well the paycheque is nice"
- vkou 6y agoThis holds true for junior engineers, but not for seniors. Raises tend to be percentage-based. The junior making 200k in SF may be worse off than the junior making 100k in Pittsburgh. But the senior making 400k in SF is much better off than the senior making 200k in Pittsburgh. Since Silicon valley is that one weird place where it takes five years for a junior to become a senior, taking that job in Pittsburgh is quite short-sighted.
- sedachv 6y ago> You can't have it both ways - either your general cost of living is taken into account in your salary (location-based pay), or it's not. Cost of living allowance/adjustment (COLA) was a retention strategy originally designed to give workers being transferred overseas and to large metropolitan areas more money, not less. You should do some reading up on HR practices if you want them to stop taking advantage of you.
- HenryBemis 6y agoWas approached by a headhunter for a role in Bratislava for Amazon. They were giving a 'generous' salary of €20k (net) per year (it was a few years ago). The headhunter was desperate and wanted to convince me that "this is a lot of money!!!" (for Bratislava). My simple counter was that "if I save 20% of my salary per month, I will have 4k in the end of the year. If I take an €60k (net) job in Frankfurt and again I save 20%, I will have 12k". Why would I 'sell myself short' for 8k of savings per year? It only made him angrier because my narrative did not match his sales-pitch. I never got to work for Amazon (or anyone else in Bratislava). Location matters. If you want €100k then don't look in Bratislava. If you want a 'slow calm life' (away from the madness of London/Paris/etc.) go to Bratislava or Ljubljana and be happy with the €40k. > You can't have it both ways.. No but people love to complain. PS/Addition: it feels like "bait and switch". It's like hiring me in Bratislava, giving me a small (net) salary and ask me to work from London. I wouldn't accept that. The employee would also feel cheated the other way around. And with that said this is my favorite cities' cost comparison: https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/comparison.jsp https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/comparison.jsp
- sgtnoodle 6y agoLjubljana is lovely for a vacation by the way. Slovenia is a very beautiful country. Unfortunately we were sick with a cold for most of our stay and I didn't partake in the beer fountain or drink nearly as much wine as I wanted to. Our landlady was a bit uptight and got upset that we were hand washing clothes in the bathroom sink, but with the communication barrier I don't think she fully appreciated that we were dealing with sick baby throw-up 3+ times a day...
- Viliam1234 6y ago> it feels like "bait and switch". It's like hiring me in Bratislava, giving me a small (net) salary and ask me to work from London. Many IT companies in Bratislava hire local people for local salaries... and then make them travel to other countries exactly 49% of the year (so they still pay taxes locally); the remaining 51% of time working for a foreign client remotely from a local office. My friend had a job where he had to fly to a Western country every Monday morning, and fly back home every Friday evening, to maximize the number of working days within that 49% of the year. (This way you can work abroad for 36 weeks a year, instead of "mere" 26.) And of course he had to spend 8 hours working each Monday or Friday, so he left home on Monday soon after midnight, and arrived home on Friday shortly before midnight, so he basically spent the whole weekend sleeping. (He already quit that job.)
- AOsborn 6y agoYou're right. I think so much of this discussion is missing the forest for the trees though. The bigger picture question is whether dense, expensive metropolitan areas, or other locales with expensive cost-of-living are the right fit for many jobs. I think there will be major changes in the next five-to-ten years.
- SkyPuncher 6y ago> But HN has a highly disproportionate number of Valley and NYC residents. They're all getting [big] pay cuts if you get rid of location-based pay. The biggest (but not only) reason someone in SF makes $250k+ total comp is because it's so expensive to live in SF. I'd argue that this isn't really what location based pay is worried about. In this case, you're being paid specifically be close to some location or collective building because your employer values that collectiveness. That's okay. That's the company communicating "we value the ability for you to be here, in person, with this group of people - so we're going to incentivize it". The problem with location based pay is when an employer says, "You can work from anywhere you want, but we want to know where that is so we can pay you less". You provide them the same value from mid-city America as you do in rural America. They simply want to pay you less when they can.
- llbeansandrice 6y agoThis exactly. If they want me to live somewhere specific they should pay me more to live there. If my employer isn't requiring me to love somewhere, I should be compensated for my value and work, not judged for living where and how I choose.
- alisonkisk 6y ago> I should be compensated for my value and work, No, you are compensated for how much someone doing the same work would demand.
- Aeolun 6y agoYes, so if we all demand that that isn’t based on where we live we should be fine right? I don’t understand why pepple keep repeating this. Obviously we are paid what they can get away with. We’re just trying to change what that is. If everyone starts accepting location based pay, we’ll be fucked in the long term. Or, well. It’s strictly better for me if I get paid SF wages anywhere in the world.
- 6y ago