7 ms·
Bitcoin is the greatest scam in history (2018)
- ktm5j 6y agoI can't say I agree with this authors points.. most of the problems they outline about bitcoin are also problems with any fiat currency. He keeps calling bitcoin a 'scam', without defining what entity is perpetrating this scam. Is it the developers of bitcoin or is it the exchanges they talk about? Those aren't the same people. Oh sure, bitcoin is used in crime.. so it's a scam?
- heavydukeb 6y agoI'm not expressing my support for or against the author here, but the statement made about the problems being applicable to any fiat currency is troublesome. Fiat currencies are a store of value because they are backed by a Central Bank and by extension by the economy/economies that Central Bank supports combined with the 'general trust' in the currency. Bitcoin only has the latter, so there is a key difference here.
- gota 6y agoYeah - the 'fiat' in the fiat currency is the trust that the entire population of that country will keep working, paying taxes, and producing wealth - a bit of which they 'owe' me because I hold this piece of paper (or bits in the bank, a trusted institution)
- gota 6y agoRegardless of agreeing/disagreeing with the author, I think it's clear he means it is a scam by all "promoters" of Bitcoin that are in it for the 'Greater Fool Theory' IMO that does not necessarily involve a developer that 'believes in the message' but it does involve every buyer or seller that wants to 'make money'
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAs much as we hear about blockchain, carrying coins across the border in your mind wallet, store of value, and other Bitcoin narratives, most people don’t care about those things. They only care that their number goes up. Why would it go up? Because more people buy Bitcoin. Why would more people buy Bitcoin? Because the number goes up. It’s a great system for early adopters, right up until the music stops. Currently there are a lot of businesses, billionaires, and massive mining corporations heavily invested in keeping the hype going, though.
- jqpabc123 6y agoHe keeps calling bitcoin a 'scam', without defining what entity is perpetrating this scam. A more appropriate question would be, "Who is not perpetrating the scam?" Crypto and the exchanges are unregulated --- which means that anyone and everyone can get in on the scam. Example of a bitcoin "pump and dump" scam. The pump --- "Famous wealthy entrepreneur" announces with much fanfare that he bought a large quantity of bitcoin. The dump --- "Famous wealthy entrepreneur" sells said large quantity of bitcoin after the price increases 20% in reaction to his announcement. I am not saying this scam is what happened. I am saying there is nothing currently in place to prevent this sort of scam from happening. Do this with any regulated security and "famous wealthy entrepreneur" would be in legal trouble. Instead, he is scamming naive crypto "investors" for fun and profit and daring the SEC to take action to stop it.
- wizeman 6y agoWow, bitcoin bashing is getting really strong here this week, isn't it?
- technicolorwhat 6y agoMaybe, but Bitcoin is getting more mainstream so I think there is also more space for people getting educated about it and understand the real implications it has. As far as I can tell, most people in my circle that invest in bitcoin really don't understand that its polluting, or that the KYCs are abysmal or the existence of mixers etc and that in the we need laws and regulations anyway. They just hop on board the 'us against the financial system', transparency is good, etc etc bandwagon, whatever utopian dream they have without actually doing the research.
- wizeman 6y agoYes, bitcoin is much more mainstream this week than last week </s>. My experience is exactly the opposite, I think most people don't understand bitcoin at all (or monetary systems, for that matter). For example, you say that bitcoin is polluting, but in reality it's the power generation companies that pollute, isn't it? The carbon-based power generation facilities, at least. Why don't you "need laws and regulations" for those, but you need them for bitcoin, huh?! KYCs are abysmal? Clearly you've never used a serious bitcoin exchange with large sums, have you? Personally, I've faced more a lot more scrutiny and privacy invasion in bitcoin exchanges than banks. The propaganda is mindboggling!
- technicolorwhat 6y agoSorry you feel that the propoganda is mind boggling. Interesting that you have an opposite experience, would you care to elaborate specifically on the matter. Maybe you can clarify some points. If you ask me, Tesla is openly going to accept bitcoin and MasterCard is also starting to accept crypto, so I would say indeed it's becoming more mainstream and yes more than last week. Bitcoin is polluting because of the way their POW works, in comparison to other coins. Its literally banging random data to the hash function until it starts with a couple of zeros. Even if you get it this energy from renewable resources these resources will still go into mining instead of going into homes or cars. I personally would go for a less energy taxing financial system, that doesn't burden the energy system as much. Yes, we also need regulations for those carbon based power generation facilities, which is besides the matter, but that doesn't make the energy consumption of bitcoin any less, nor justifies it. From my experience, the KYC is only something that recently started. And only on certain exchanges is this really enforced. And afaik it's not done retroactively, something that does happen with current banks. KYC didn't exist for a long time. Furthermore, due to the difficulty/power consumption of mining people will naturally swarm into pools which will eventually grow bigger, which in turn might result into schemes that could create incentives to pump. There are no regulations in place. On top of that you can use your money however you've acquired it to buy tons and tons of graphics cards, and mine bitcoins and convert your money. With our current monetary system we have things in place. They are shit, and sometimes s corrupt, but at least they are there and we have something to work with. A subpar technical solution which bitcoin at this moment is. Is not going to solve anything of this, it's a fundamental human problem, and technology is not going to solve it, and in this case I think it's going to make matter worse. Bitcoin hasn't proven to be more transparant, more open or more efficient. How I see it is that Bitcoin represents a vision, or an ideal for many people which resonates because people don't like the system and are upset. Bitcoin hailed as a saviour while it ain't better or faster, or more transparant than the current system in power. It also doesn't stop people with loads of money now buying large sums and selling it to the 1% believing in a false prophecy. If you see it differently let me know, how exactly. I really would love it to work.
- Proven 6y agoIf you look at the amount and number of victims, the US dollar is the greatest scam. Bitcoin isn't a scam or fraud - advocates don't sell anything to the buyer and the price is transparent. Also, remember that all exchanges that sell it are state-approved exchanges. If it's a scam, it's a government approved scam, just like fiat currency and government bonds.
- rich_sasha 6y agoFor me as a potential user of Bitcoin, all this pollution talk is actually dwarfed by one of the components of the argument: virtually all Bitcoin mining is in China. As the Hong Kong debacle shows (politics aside), Chinese government can exercise its power very strongly and very swiftly when it wants to, and with little regard for international protests. That, and its use of technology to exercise influence, like selectively blocking the 996 repo on GitHub, the Great Firewall etc. suggests to me that Bitcoin, that holy democratic unmovable "store of value" is in fact owned by the Chinese government, which just hasn't exercised its option to meddle in it yet. In this light, most of the economic assertions about Bitcoin enthusiasts are just wrong. It is state-controlled, hackable by a single entity, and can disappear into thin air whenever. It is just that China doesn't choose to do that yet. And no, offline wallets don't help. You don't even need to think China is less trustworthy than the US to be concerned. Half the shout about Bitcoin is how trustworthy it is compared to the US dollar...
- simon112 6y ago> Bitcoins are accepted almost nowhere, and some cryptocurrencies nowhere at all. Even where accepted, a currency whose value can swing 10 percent or more in a single day is useless as a means of payment I'd bet it's a popular method of payment when it comes to illegal activities. And I doubt those people would have an issue with the fluctuations of 10% a day when you consider the benefits they get - anonymity, ease of transport, storage and liquidity. > Store of Value. Extreme price volatility also makes bitcoin undesirable as a store of value. Again, same argument, storage of assets you'd lose otherwise (confiscated, repo'ed) if it's from criminal activities. I got downvoted in another thread for being against bitcoin, but I don't think these concerns are addressed properly out there. Different from gold? You can't transport billions of it easily across borders, or give to a politician as easily.
- bsenftner 6y agoI've been saying these same points since the day I learned about bitcoin. It is the perfect fraud for today's entitled grifter society. And it does not matter if bitcoin is not a fraud at it's core - our significant population of grifters in our society will convert it into a scam for their own purposes regardless of anyone's desires.
- hello_world_btc 6y agoRegardless of whether it's a scam or not, one thing is undeniably true: bitcoin has staying power and with a lot of institutional support being built around it, it's not really going anywhere anytime soon. Yeah sure there will be volatility in the price for some time or maybe even forever, but at some point we'll have to accept that there are two camps of people: one that believe in it and have a vested interest in it, including in pushing for its wider adoption and the other group that believes that it has no inherent value. For what it's worth, I'm in the camp that believes that it does have some value, but no where near the level that it's currently trading at. But I'm also a bit biased/bitter, see my submission history :'(
- getlawgdon 6y agoBitcoin's price dynamics are pure manipulation; there isn't more to it. People participate for the vol that comes from that price manipulation. There isn't more to that either. This Animals Spirit is not very evolved. "Plain manipulation" isn't a bad thing unless you react emotionally to such words, and that's kind of the proof, isn't it?
- api 6y agoHeard any good ideas about what caused the latest pump? It wasn’t Elon/Tesla since that came later. It’s really interesting that it came right after the election, but I can’t see a causal connection unless a bunch of Q nuts are shoveling money into Bitcoin to avoid the “great reset.” I was surprised by the pump, but didn’t buy in because by the time you see such a thing it is always too late.
- 0134340 6y agoIt seems it would be contradictory for the "Qnuts" to buy bitcoin. Cryptocoins do more to enable and perpetuate a global economy than standard localized currency. If not soon enough, I can see those types finally realizing the beast they catered to, cryptocoins owned by new globalist ruling classes, just so they could stick it to the man and feel good for a moment. Not that I believe globalism is necessarily a good or bad thing, depends on context but it just signifies once again the myopia of many extremist ideologies.
- pureliquidhw 6y agoRobinhood allowing easy, fractional purchases probably has a lot to do with it. That with the gambling nature, 10 million people playing with 1000 bucks each is a billion dollars. All Bitcoin are not worth $50k each, but a Bitcoin is. Someone who can't afford to buy a Bitcoin, will buy 1/50th of a Bitcoin for $1000. That's affordable. Then they'll sell that 1/50th to the next guy for $2000. That prices a Bitcoin at $100k. Try to sell 1000's of coins at that price and the buyer pool will eventually dry up, prices will begin to go down, and all those white knuckle retail investors who can't afford to lose $1k dump and the price collapses. Millions of people each lose a grand here or there. Hedge funds sold long ago to those fractional buyers. Pump and dump 100%.
- jean-malo 6y agoI wonder why the ex CEO of Paypal and Intuit, founder of an actively managed fund doesn't like Bitcoin. There are many valid points to be made against bitcoin but "It's used by criminal" isn't one of them.
- corrys 6y agoThere are many published studies highlighting the volume of Bitcoin transactions associated with illegal activities. For example, this one from the University of Oxford: https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/business-law-blog/blog/2018/02/sex-drugs-and-bitcoin-how-much-illegal-activity-financed-through https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/business-law-blog/blog/2018/02/sex-...
- jean-malo 6y agoSure I'm not arguing that Bitcoin isn't used by criminals. But, to make the obvious straw-man, USD and knives are used by criminals too, should we ban them ?
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAs much as Bitcoin proponents talk about the protocol, the majority of Bitcoin buyers couldn’t care less about anything related to the blockchain. They just want to buy some BTC in Coinbase and see the number go up and down (preferably up). They don’t want to hold their coins or be their own bank. Meanwhile, the amount of misinformation around inflation and fiat money is getting ridiculous. Bitcoin proponents talk about Bitcoin as if the only alternative investment was to keep all of your savings in cash under your mattress. Too many people think that inflation means everything loses value except Bitcoin, all while ignoring the fact that inflation literally means the value of traditional assets and commodities goes up in dollar terms.
- Ancapistani 6y ago> inflation literally means the value of traditional assets and commodities goes up. No, the value of assets doesn’t change - the price goes up.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoValue goes up in dollar terms, which is the same as price going up.
- Ancapistani 6y agoThis makes no sense. Price in dollars (or any other currency) is a proxy for value, but not the same thing. A loaf of bread has the same value whether it costs $1, $5, or $0.05.
- axiosgunnar 6y agoA bread that costs 10 USD would take a worker earning 10USD/hour an hour to earn. Surely a bread that requires the worker to work only 5 minutes has a lower value than a bread that requires 2h or labor?
- 6y ago
- axiosgunnar 6y agoWhen arguing with a Bitcoin-fanatic, try this line: "Yeah I agree that cryptocurrencies are interesting, perhaps some day one will replace the USD. It will probably not be Bitcoin, but rather some other cryptocurrency“. Watch how they recoil! For they have been found out, they do not actually care for financial freedom, etc., all these noble crypto goals which can also be achieved with a cryptocurrency that is not Bitcoin. All they care about is their speculative investment in Bitcoin in particular, so it won't help them much if another crypto becomes the world standard. It‘s probably <1% that are true believers and >99% that have missed out on a few bull runs and are now hoping to get rich quickly. Really, try this line some time and you will come to the same conclusion.
- CryptoGhost 6y ago>perhaps some day one will replace the USD USD is fiat currency. Fiat simply means by decree. USD is a currency by decree of the US Govt. It's highly unlikely Bitcoin would ever become a fiat currency by the US Govt. It's also highly unlikely the US Govt would allow a free banking system and allow a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin to fill the void naturally. Also, Bitcoin can evolve overtime through consensus of it's users. So it is highly unlikely it would be surpassed by a cryptocurrency that is like Bitcoin but marginally different, it would have to be something radically different.
- gillesjacobs 6y agoThis is a strawman argument against Bitcoin. The majority of BTC owners are probably not Bitcoin-fanatics or Bitcoin-maximalists as you described them. I personally know no cryptocurrency owner who only holds Bitcoin or who truly believes it is the be-all-end-all of (crypto)currency. Maybe these people exist as a small but vocal minority, but those should be disregarded in any online community.
- bondarchuk 6y agoGot-em! Very clever! Never mind trying to understand each others point of view without being hostile about it. It's better to stick to your preconceived opinions and defend them with witty slogans. In all seriousness, there are various replies to this line of argument. I'm not gonna post them because if you have a genuine interest in learning more instead of just "arguing with a Bitcoin-fanatic" you can easily find them on the internet.
- jhh 6y agoSo I feel the "Bitcoin is undesirable as a store of value because it's so volatile" point is not too fair. Firstly, fiat money can often experience instability which is quite extreme. Moderate instability, mostly in form of inflation, is even normal in large parts of the developing world. And just because the Dollar has been reasonable stable for a hundred years or so, people assume that this is the natural state of affairs. Secondly, is it a reasonable expectation, that a new store of value would be stable from the start? For example, platinum has become more common as a store of value in the last 30ish years, and its value has sprung up and fluctuated quite heavily (see here for example https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/57/Pt_price_92_12.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/57/Pt_price...). A similar argument can be made regarding storehouses being less trustworthy than traditional banks. This sort of thing would be expected with a new type of value.
- hello_world_btc 6y agoWhat's the anti-case against each country launching it's own version of Bitcoin/Altcoin? What's the bull case for bitcoin beyond the fact that it has been the first successful crypto? Genuinely curious.
- powellzer 6y agoJust chiming in here, but I would say the high mining hash rate makes it the most secure chain (secure like people can't go back in time and change the chain's history because it would be prohibitively expensive to do so). Ultimately I think Ethereum's market cap will come close to challenging BTC's in the next 10 years and when that happens we will see a rapid transfer of capital from the BTC chain to the ETH chain.
- jhh 6y agoSo I think it is certainly _very_ unsure that Bitcoin will become the dominant crypto asset. I think there's some reason why it might. Kind of subtle and hand-wavy, but I think it's dysfunctionality in terms of leadership and "emergent nature" may be features rather than bugs. For example a crypto asset sanctioned by a government is based on that government's legitimacy. This kind of means that the government could decide to "turn it off". And with Bitcoin, it's not clear at all who could do this. But yeah, that's very unsure, I guess.
- seibelj 6y agoWouldn’t be a day on HN without a crypto-hate thread. With the Tether implosion that was supposed to happen in January fizzling out, it seems like perma-bears are shopping around for the new attack line. Could it be this is revolution world-changing technology and the market is valuing it as such?
- lostmsu 6y agoTether implosion was delayed by 30 days.
- sixQuarks 6y agoBiggest scam in history is religion
- orange_tee 6y agoDespite claims of transparency, I find the exact opposite is true. Yes all wallets and transactions are public but because these are not tied to identities and are international (i.e. no consistent set of laws that might force owners to disclose their holdings), we know very little from this information. So we small holders are basically at the mercy of any big whale who might decide to nudge the price up or down for profit. Then on top of that, there are more elaborate plays like Tether and lots of WallSt money doing their voodoo as well. Which other asset has the property that it suddenly goes to 200% or 50% and nobody has a clear idea why? The whole thing is the opposite of transparent and if you really wanted to store your wealth you would not put it at the mercy of Bitcoin whales.