3 ms·
No it sets a terrible precedent. Businesses need to support their community. I would willing to bet that the city council will not let it happen. They may cut a
by stjohnswarts 6y ago
No it sets a terrible precedent. Businesses need to support their community. I would willing to bet that the city council will not let it happen. They may cut a deal but it ain't gonna be 100%. More like on the order of 10-25% like other companies get. Corporations are too greedy. I contract for a living and through local contacts never go more than a month between contracts. The job market here is still pretty great for people who have solid backend/embedded skills, in general it's solid for most people. Those other people can go work for the other big guys or the new Tesla plant who actually cut a reasonable tax deal.
- f430 6y agodoesnt samsung create thousands of jobs in the community with this? not sure I share your outrage. this isnt about some one trick pony YC startup hiring a dozen backend devs
- numbsafari 6y agoWhy should labor pay for all the externalities created by capital?
- f430 6y agoDid you not read the title? It's $17 billion dollar investment creating thousands of high paying jobs which in turn will create more jobs and create more capital in community. Why are you so against this? This isn't some VC backed zombie healthcare software company hiring a couple of developers per year and not getting to pay taxes. This is a major corporation investing billions with profound impact on the community.
- bildung 6y ago> Why are you so against this? Why should the people of Austin, Texas gift millions of dollars to a company that made a profit of over $8 billions in the last quarter alone?
- adriancr 6y agoI've seen places refuse to budge and lose out the investments I've also seen Intel refuse to negotiate price for chips with Apple for the original iPhone and look how great that turned out for them and TSMC
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoSometimes youve gotta show backbone. "I'be seen people refuse to give their boss a blowjob and lose out on promotions"
- imtringued 6y agoThe number of cities losing out does not change. If there are X competing cities X-1 cities will always lose out.
- hardolaf 6y agoThis is a company asking a city, that will see no income taxes from the at most 2,000 employees, permission to pay zero taxes at all to the city in exchange for the honor of housing a future EPA Super Fund site. Sure, the city will get some sales tax revenue from the 2,000 who will almost assuredly live outside of the city. So they'll get what, 6.25% of a $10 lunch from maybe 30% of workers per day? So they'll expect about $100k/yr in tax revenue in exchange for more road utilization and a future EPA Super Fund site. That doesn't seem like a good deal for the city. And that's assuming 100% of the sales tax goes to the city which it doesn't. Most of that goes to the county and state.
- numbsafari 6y agoWho said I’m against it? I merely raised the question. > This is a major corporation investing billions with profound impact on the community. Sure. Is that impact the same for everyone in the community, though? Or is it ultimately better for some, and not others? Could it also be that it may be a net negative for some members of the community? Also, as noted by others, Samsung already has strong incentives to build this facility in Texas, and has wanted/needed to build it for a while. This latest gambit is an effort to force local government to sweeten the deal.
- imtringued 6y agoThe investment is creating the jobs. The tax discount isn't creating jobs. It's just moving them around. Do you really think Samsung will give up if no city gives them a tax break?
- f430 6y agowithout investment there would be no jobs or taxes to collect in the first place. With this single move, texas gov will be able to collect more taxes from thousands of people making 100k+ and downstream suppliers also hiring and making more money. Samsung can easily find other cities to produce in at lower cost outside America. Why is being competitive for once such a big issue here? Without the tax benefit Texans won't have thousands of high paying high skill jobs. The tax break adds up to about $40 million a year which pales in comparison to the benefits Texans will receive.
- mywittyname 6y ago> Samsung can easily find other cities to produce in at lower cost outside America. No they can't. Austin and the surrounding area are key silicon fabrication regions. There are very few places in the world that can compete, and it is possible that they are forced to produce within the USA due to import/export restrictions on what they are manufacturing. This is a situation where the decision is already made, but it can't hurt to ask for tax break. Because hey, free money. Kind of like how Amazon "passed" on building out an NYC headquarters because the city wouldn't give them tax breaks (after locals protested), only to come back six months later and begin construction of their NYC HQ.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tooltalk 6y agoSure, the tax thing is probably one of the maor component here. In addition to local taxes, my understanding that SAS's current plant is in free trade zone where they also receive exemption for import/sales taxes, etc. The whole US semi industry is worried that the lion share of semi production is stlil occuring in Asia, not in the US -- which is probably why Trump admin started twisting TSMC and Samsung's arms few years ago: https://www.semiconductors.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/2020-SIA-State-of-the-Industry-Report.pdf https://www.semiconductors.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/06/20...
- kristianp 6y agoIt's an interesting question: incentives. Samsung can't negotiate away wages like they can land taxes.
- barbacoa 6y agoLook at it from the local government prospective, they could get 0 in tax income or they can settle from the tax income of thousands of new high income jobs.
- didibus 6y agoDo gigafab manufactures like that really create high income jobs? I assumed it was mostly low income close to minimum wage kind of thing. On a similar tangeant, how are these able to compete with similar manufacturing done in Asia or Africa?
- valvar 6y agoI don't know anything about how they are run, but I would assume you need a large number of on-site engineers and process overseers. What are the low-income jobs? Security?
- didibus 6y agoI thought it was mostly assembly line workers putting parts together, with machines doing the rest. Kinda like what this photo shows: https://bit.ly/3a8uRFM https://bit.ly/3a8uRFM
- sgerenser 6y agoThat’s board assembly, not chip fabrication.
- f430 6y agoSo you admit you were ignorant. That's a rarity on here. People will defend their wrong views here because they don't want to hear they aren't a polymath.
- adriancr 6y agoThis is how it looks like now: https://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/TSMC-Semiconductor.jpg https://www.extremetech.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/TSMC-... Machines feed each other via conveyor belts, everything automated, tight control loops check/move things around. Notice the difference in human presence.
- syshum 6y agoThe precedent was set long ago, and if Austin does not take it I can assure you some other city will.. Why, it is easy... a new factory (or a factory expansion) means more jobs, more jobs means more people, more people means more Home and more secondary businesses all of which the local government will get taxes from. In principle I agree, but in reality Austin will make more tax revenue from these other properties and business than the amount of the abatement
- chkaloon 6y agoSource? Just like this comment in the story - " Nonetheless, the deal still makes a lot of sense for the state". Numbers, please?
- tooltalk 6y agoSamsung has been around Austin, TX since the late 1990's and invested well over $15B. I think the state and county officials have enough dataset to evaluate whether Samsung's new expansion would benefit their community or not.