12 ms·
Apple Watch Identifies SARS-CoV2 Infection and Predicts Diagnosis
- joshdick 6y agoIt's crazy to think that a tech company like Apple might have the clearest picture of the pandemic
- bilekas 6y agoI don't think it's specific for apple, they did mention that the participants just had the apple watch, but from the sounds of it, any GPS hear rate monitor would help.. I think Maybe a collective app simular to Strava might be a better place to get a collection of data maybe..
- eli 6y agoThe Oura "smart ring" maker claims it can detect early Covid from variations in temperature https://www.fiercebiotech.com/medtech/oura-study-shows-its-smart-ring-can-detect-earliest-fevers-linked-to-covid-19 https://www.fiercebiotech.com/medtech/oura-study-shows-its-s...
- Jtsummers 6y agoI was going to mention them. Some members of the US military were given them as part of a study on COVID detection. Basically any wearable sensors covering the right metrics can be used for this. The question, really, was less about "Can wearable health monitoring equipment detect early signs of <disease>?" than "What are the early signs which wearables can detect and use for prediction once we know them?"
- miskin 6y agoOura was quite good with warning me that something is not ok and I should take it easy on the morning of the day when I started to have symptoms. I was tested positive later that day. Interestingly, nobody I met days before I was warned was infected, so in my case warning came in right moment.
- james_pm 6y agoAmongst rich people with Apple Watches, maybe.
- benbristow 6y agoHardly need to be rich to have an Apple Watch, they're not that expensive for a tech product really.
- bilekas 6y agoThis sounds great, I am going through the PDF, there's a LOT there.. But I'm not sure how reliable that it would be just to track the position (possible infection radius to known area) And the heart rate variability.. Its interesting though! Certainly every little helps..
- blakesterz 6y agoIneresting. So... Prior to the diagnosis of COVID-19 by nasal PCR, significant changes in heart rate variability (HRV), were observed demonstrating its predictive ability to identify COVID-19 infection. So in theory watching your heart rate closely you should be able to see it coming? (I tried to figure out exactly what to watch for and how to measure it, but couldn't figure it out, hopefully someone else can explain if anyone with a watch could do this)
- bilekas 6y agoThat would make me nervous, which would mess up my heart rate.. :)
- ryanmarsh 6y agoIncreased heart rate with decreased SpO2 commonly precedes diagnosis of respiratory infection. Increased heart rate alone is often seen as a warning to run pathology labs before beginning chemotherapy which can destroy neutrophils. Something you don't want to do if the patient is in the beginning stages of an infection. I'm not a doctor I've just been around this stuff more than I wish to. Frankly I wish the Apple watch was more aggressive in reporting anomalies to the user. Something as simple as "we noticed your heart rate always increases at this place and time" can make the user aware that something is wrong in their life... assuming it's not a gym.
- whoisburbansky 6y agoThe measure they’re talking about, HRV, is measuring variance of the peak to peak and trough to trough between successive heartbeats. Individual heartbeats are on the order of one or two a second, but are remarkably consistent, so this measurement of variance is usually on the order of milliseconds. Healthy ranges are, vaguely speaking, above 80ms, with unhealthy ranges being much lower, the idea being that when you’re sick or stressed, your heart rate control falls back to the nervous system since your brain has other things to deal with, making your heartbeat more consistent, which means lower variability. This is generally not great because you want to be able to switch up the spacing between beats on the fly for better efficiency, kind of like switching gears on a car. All of this is to say that the measurement they’re talking about is pretty tiny and you’re unlikely to be able to measure it accurately manually.
- sebmellen 6y agoThis reminds me of a great interview with two ER doctors on Amanpour (PBS) two weeks ago. Pulse oximeters can be used to help detect which patients need hospitalization before they themselves notice, with astounding results. I really recommend the episode: https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/how-earlier-covid-diagnosis-and-treatment-saves-lives/ https://www.pbs.org/wnet/amanpour-and-company/video/how-earl... Here's another article on a hospital implementing the early monitoring program https://www.nny360.com/news/publicservicenews/samaritan-utilizing-new-program-to-monitor-covid-patients-at-home/article_9378fe64-e639-598d-8df4-8232699f6cd4.html https://www.nny360.com/news/publicservicenews/samaritan-util.... > With the oximeter, Samaritan is asking patients to keep track of its measurements twice a day and to write the readings down. Then Home Health follows up with telehealth visits, either over the phone or via Zoom on days two and four, as well as days seven and 10.
- danesparza 6y agoThis is happening now in hospitals with Covid-19. I know, because I'm married to a nurse. Nurses call them "happy hypoxics" because they have no idea their SPO2 levels are dangerously low -- but a pulse oximeter clearly indicates they need additional oxygen.
- treeman79 6y agoI had a pulmonary embolism‘s was white as a ghost struggling to breathe and that dang meter said everything was fine. Even the bloodwork at the hospital said everything was fine. Lost some lung over that and took a year to recover.
- pintxo 6y agoNow, will Apple add this as a feature?
- soco 6y agoFor a healthy price premium.
- Jtsummers 6y agoI get that it's cool to ridicule Apple, but maybe pick something they've actually demonstrated a tendency to do in the past? In the case of health features on their Watch they've been pretty consistent about just making it available if the Watch has the right sensors (so older watches don't get all the new features because they lack some of the necessary sensors).
- _nickwhite 6y ago"Longitudinally collected HRV metrics from a commonly worn commercial wearable device (Apple Watch) can identify the diagnosis of COVID-19 and COVID-19 related symptoms." Having first-hand experience, I can confirm that my heart rate was WAY up, and my pulse-ox was WAY down when the virus was at its worst. I used the pulse ox value to make sure I was getting in good breaths (and yes, I know there is a hefty margin of error on these consumer devices.) I use a Garmin, but the sensors are pretty much the same on Apple Watch. It would be pretty easy for the device to tell I was sick but probably impossible to tell I had COVID-19 instead of the Flu or a bad infection or maybe pneumonia.
- joseph_grobbles 6y agoHRV is neither pulse rate or blood oxygen. It is variations between heart rates, and the reason this is fascinating is because HRV is a significant leading indicator, long before the other indicators which are lagging. HRV is increasingly becoming a very important metric. When your body is under stress (mental or physical) the heart because tightly sequenced. Under normal, healthy conditions it has slight lags and leads based upon breathing and other conditions. This post will be dead given that dang is a pathetic bitch and a *horrid* moderator, but for those enlightened enough to use showdead.
- miskin 6y agoIn my case HRV went down almost 30% before I started to have symptoms with 50% of average on the worst day. Resting heart rate went up 35% on the worst day and respiratory rate went up 18%. But only HRV was obviously changed before I started to feel symptoms and became infectious.
- mandis 6y agoumm speaking from personal experience (comparing garmin reading with hospital oximeter), garmin is waaaay inaccurate sometimes! Maybe it is because I always shower with it, or maybe it just loses accuracy over time. Didnt give it a second thought and just disabled the sensor.
- hobom 6y agoI am kind of jaded, but despite the interesting approach, I predict that this research will not end up being deployed in time to make any difference. The real world pipeline just takes too long.
- secretsatan 6y agoSurely more than 1 condition can cause heart rate changes? Is there a pattern they can match, or is it the most likely cause?
- pwinnski 6y agoFrom my reading, many respiratory illnesses can cause these symptoms, but right now if you have a respiratory illness at all, odd are it's COVID-19, so it's worth at least getting a PCR test. And if it's not that, you have a very serious flu or something which probably requires treatment as well.
- miskin 6y agoYou are right, I had similar data and same warning as I got for COVID-19 from Oura cca year ago with regular flu. It is now more important because of COVID-19, but it is also very helpful for any similar illness that one may spread.
- l33tman 6y agoThere are lots, as what you really are measuring are subtle variations in the sympathetic and parasympathetic drives of the heart by the autonomous nerve system. This can get affected by lots of things, a quick googling provided dozens of completely different papers looking it stuff like heart disease itself, but also clinical depression etc.
- sschueller 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26079918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26079918
- victor106 6y agoSlightly OT:- I really hope Apple Watch SPO2 is more accurate. The current version is not accurate enough to use as a replacement for a pulse oximeter https://www.medpagetoday.com/blogs/skeptical-cardiologist/88729 https://www.medpagetoday.com/blogs/skeptical-cardiologist/88...
- whoisburbansky 6y agoAgreed, but the article is about using HRV, not spO2
- victor106 6y agoAgreed, This is tangential to that article.
- whoisburbansky 6y agoFollow up that for most diagnostic purposes, you don't really care about the specific spO2 precentage beyond "is it below 90" or not, for which the Apple Watch is perfectly satisfactory: https://tidbits.com/2020/10/22/the-paramedics-guide-to-blood-oxygen-and-the-apple-watch-series-6/ https://tidbits.com/2020/10/22/the-paramedics-guide-to-blood...
- screamingninja 6y agoTitle is misleading IMO. The study has nothing specific to do with Apple Watch. They mentioned that they used "a commonly worn commercial wearable device (Apple Watch)" for testing. Any device with continuous heart rate monitoring will do.
- zepto 6y agoThey know the Apple Watch works. They haven’t tested any other devices. This is about the Apple Watch. Your comment is supposition. Likely correct, but not guaranteed.
- screamingninja 6y ago> Your comment is supposition. Likely correct, but not guaranteed. No, the paper was very clear that Apple Watch was used to measure Heart Rate Variability (HRV). There is absolutely no mention of any unique advantages that Apple Watch provided in the given scenario. The study is about using the HRV data from a wearable device to identify indicators of COVID-19; it is not an endorsement or an advertisement for Apple.
- zepto 6y agoIt doesn’t matter. Have you compared the HRV data from different devices? Have you compared the Apple HRV data and the data from other devices to a reference instrument, or confirmed that it meets some standard? The Apple Watch is the reference instrument for this paper. It would be a scientific error to conceal that fact. This isn’t about product endorsements, it’s about saying what laboratory equipment was used so that other scientists don’t have hidden confounds when they attempt to replicate.
- screamingninja 6y ago> The Apple Watch is the reference instrument for this paper. Exactly. It is an instrument used to gather metrics. The study is about analyzing the metrics and not so much about the tools used to gather those metrics. Read the paper's title.
- IgorPartola 6y agoWhatever happened with the MIT cough analyzer? That seemed like really promising tech that just kind of fell off the news feeds and was never mentioned again. I thought they were trying to apply for an FDA approval. Latest info is 47 days old: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54780460?fbclid=IwAR1bGRjoa-jKu_CKk4TcT6xWeaWno_sASk0qzVVqDH2enpQnHzN6ie43rCY https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-54780460?fbclid=IwAR1bGR...
- 2wrist 6y agoThere have been a few cyclists who use whoop and it picked up on HRV and they could see that something was not right. Hopefully HRV gets added to the AWatch soon, if it isn't already. (C'mon Apple, deliver my device!) It is pretty cool that we can take these measurements and hopfully make data driven decisions. Hopefully in time we can use these measures to be prescritive and be guided to make better decisions.
- jjevanoorschot 6y agoHeart Rate Variability is already measured throughout the day if you wear an Apple Watch. You can find the data in the Health app.
- 2wrist 6y agothanks for that! I wasn't sure.
- ben1040 6y agoYep. It takes a sample every few hours, but you can also get a HRV measurement on demand by running a session in the Breathe app on the watch. It doesn't tell you anything about HRV in the Breathe app or that it took a new sample for you, but you'll find a new entry in the Health app if you go look right afterward.
- vrc 6y agoThis is basically how the WHOOP band works. Anyone with an Apple Watch curious to see can find your tracked HRV in the Health App on your iPhone. However, looking at heart-rate (HR) itself will be misleading. Big swings in HR or high HR in general usually misinterpreted as having high HRV, when it's often the exact opposite. HRV is a measure of the variability of 1/(inter-beat time). So it's measuring the time-average of really small variations from a set point. And counterintuitively, HRV is usually highest when the sympathetic (flight or fight) nervous tone and HR is lower. In those situations, the parasympathetic control dominates, and small wiggles caused by "noise on the wire" conducted directly to the heart's pacemaker via the vagus nerve increases HRV. Often times this is when HR is lower, and because higher HR or spikes in HR are often caused by increased sympathetic tone, this leads to a blunting of this "parasympathetic noise". Source: https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/physiol.00041.2018 https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/physiol.000...
- grok22 6y agoIs there something else like the WHOOP band, but sold as a standalone device (the WHOOP band is given free with a fitness subscription service!)?
- vrc 6y agoI track mine on my Apple Watch which records it in the Health App. It's basic graph and I can download it if I want, but I've found tracking day-over-day/week-over-week is a good enough signal. For example, I did dry January this year and practiced meditation every day since and I've seen a step-jump up corresponding to that. Still have to keep another record of external factors to correlate with it, though. I've heard people finding success with a 3p monitor and the Elite HRV app as well [0]. [0] https://elitehrv.com/ https://elitehrv.com/
- pmw 6y agoI've never had the WHOOP, but I use Apple Watch combined with iPhone apps to track heart metrics. I recently discovered AutoSleep and HeartWatch, which both track HRV along with other metrics.
- aorth 6y agoOfftopic: what is up with this website? I just clicked the link and noticed that Firefox downloaded the paper's PDF 55 times automatically before I closed the window!
- kristjansson 6y agoIt gets points for being a novel form of broken!
- auslegung 6y agoIs there anything actionable for us, today, in the study? I’m not skilled in reading these, I read the first few paragraphs and knew I was over my head.
- freitasm 6y agoApple Watch and any other HR monitoring watch...
- stuartbman 6y agoSo some big limitations, speaking as a doctor. Firstly, I'm surprised that they allowed watches on the ward. They're a huge infection risk and most places are bare below the elbows (NHS), moreso for covid. Secondly, they only looked at symptomatic covid cases (1 day before symptoms started was their prediction as far as i can tell. This is completely useless as the 24hrs before symptoms start the patient is likely to already be highly infectious, and misses the asymptomatic carriers which have an indeterminate effect on spread as well. Far better to use the semi-proven (but equally controversial) lateral flow tests and avoid these risks. In the UK, hundreds of healthcare staff have been identified as covid+ >48hrs before symptoms in this way.
- rgbrenner 6y agoSpeaking as a non-doctor, I don't have any lateral flow test supplies or equipment. Do they sell that on Amazon? But seriously, a test I don't have easy access to is not an alternative. A lateral flow test has no predictive value to me because I'm never going to get one before I'm actually sick.
- sveme 6y agoLateral flow tests are rapid test kits to my understanding, so they should be available on Amazon if accepted by your local medical devices authority.
- zamfi 6y ago> But seriously, a test I don't have easy access to is not an alternative. Do you have access to the custom Apple Watch app they used here? I don't either. Health authorities could make either of these available to the general public -- the parent poster is making a comment about which is more valuable under the assumption of access. You're not wrong, a test you don't have access to obviously has no predictive value for you, but right now we (the public) have access to neither, so this isn't a distinguishing factor. Now, if you're making the argument that the Apple Watch app would be easier to distribute, then you can read the parent's criticism as "sure, but only knowing after you've potentially spread it is not very useful."
- germinalphrase 6y agoI wish I could buy a watch that continuously monitored my hydration levels. So many health concerns are directly impacted by hydration. Edit: My comment meant to recognize that while this tech doesn’t yet exist, it would be helpful as people end up in the hospital all the time for medical problems that are exacerbated by dehydration. Simply saying “drink water when you’re thirsty” is beside the point.
- uncledave 6y agoUse the Apple Watch. It reminds you to stand up every hour. Go pee then. If it’s not clear then drink a glass of water. Works for me.
- germinalphrase 6y agoI don’t really have a desk job, so a timed reminder wouldn’t be as useful to me as actual data.
- uncledave 6y agoYou’ve got sensors in your head and data when it comes out of you. I do a hell of a lot of hiking and that’s all you need to monitor hydration.
- Jtsummers 6y agoA lot of people have conditioned themselves to ignore the signs of thirst or misinterpret them as hunger. Our, largely, idle/still lives probably doesn't help here, as staying at a survivable level (even if not a truly healthy level) of hydration isn't hard if you're not working up a sweat or in environmental conditions that cause you to become dehydrated faster.
- nradov 6y agoIf you're thirsty then drink some water. We have no reliable clinical evidence that drinking extra water when you're not thirsty causes improved health. So far no one has succeeded in building a reliable, wearable, non-invasive hydration sensor. https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2019/11/lvls-hydration-sensor-rises-from-the-dead-gets-acquired.html https://www.dcrainmaker.com/2019/11/lvls-hydration-sensor-ri...
- eightysixfour 6y agoOura Ring also ran a study on this (which I was a part of). It is interesting because in 2019 I had a severe cold and the Oura Ring gave me a very low "Readingess" score in the 2 days leading up to it, despite me feeling fine and getting good sleep. I had never had readiness scores so low prior to that or since, so I don't believe it was any sort of confirmation bias. Quantified health is going to bring about some amazing QOL improvements that we're still only beginning to understand and it is one of the areas I am most bullish about for sure.
- 14 6y agoThis does not surprise me one bit. I have a child and every time he gets sick his heart rate rises. The last time I noticed the heart rate first and called his mom telling her I think he is getting sick. The next day he had a fever.
- floatingatoll 6y agoI’ve been donating my heart data to the Scripps study in this space, too. Glad to see someone nailed down the link in at least one instance.