10 ms·
The real problem here is that there is no consequence for incorrect takedowns. If content is taken down and then it turns out to be fair use, no one suffers a
by jedberg 6y ago
The real problem here is that there is no consequence for incorrect takedowns. If content is taken down and then it turns out to be fair use, no one suffers a penalty.
The DMCA and similar laws provide protection to the platform if they act quickly on takedown notices, but the law needs to be updated to provide penalties for the reporter for inappropriate takedowns.
This would allow Google/Facebook/et al to change their tools from automatic takedown to reporting the violation to the copyright holder, and then it is up to the copyright holder to file a claim. If perhaps the copyright holder makes too many erroneous claims, they lose their copyright altogether.
Let the platforms be neutral, put the liability on the copyright violators and copyright holders equally, so both have a reason to act fairly.
- theelous3 6y ago> they lose their copyright altogether Big no to this, as that can and would be abused by scavengers, but the rest is sane and broadly agreed to be the way. What tou want instead is fines by revenue / income.
- jedberg 6y ago> Big no to this, as that can and would be abused by scavengers How would scavengers abuse this?
- theelous3 6y agoYou hold a copyright I want. I fraudulently pose as you and make dcma claims until you lose your copyright.
- joshuaissac 6y agoA solution is to require that the DMCA notice contains proof of ownership of the copyright (or proof that you are acting as an agent of the verified copyright holder).
- jedberg 6y agoBut if all copyrights required registration, then all the notices would have to go along with that registration. You'd have to commit identity theft, which is a separate crime that you would be prosecuted for.
- underwater 6y agoThis is not about the laws. YouTube has their own copyright processes that are more stringent than DMCA. They allow companies to automate take down and take over requests with no repercussions. Everyone who shares a video to their platform has agreed to this process.
- jedberg 6y agoI'm aware of that, but the reason YouTube has that process is because they don't want to get sued. If the law gave YouTube immunity by simply reporting copyright claims instead of taking them down, they would switch their process. Especially if YouTube had a penalty for getting it wrong.
- MrStonedOne 6y agoYouTube has a process outside of the DMCA to let rights holders take down videos without risk of a false DMCA suit.
- jedberg 6y agoYes I know, which is why the law should be changed to make this extrajudicial process illegal and expensive for YouTube, so that their most prudent course of action is to notify the copyright holder and then do nothing.
- notahacker 6y agoA proposal which amounts to making it 'illegal and expensive' for an internet platform to do any kind of moderation other than the process mandated by US copyright law sounds like a far more grotesque imposition on the internet than anything the most aggressive copyright lawyers have proposed. The status quo where YouTube is full of voluntarily uploaded material by rightsholders, other videos featuring their songs (for which the rightsholders get compensated) and even some cover bands getting revenue share, and most copyright-struck videos just get demonetised sounds a lot better than the RIAA simply trying to get everything taken down. Judging by the amount of unofficial Santeria videos on YouTube, I don't think anyone would struggle to publish cop videos with Sublime playing in the background on there anyway.
- h_anna_h 6y agoI am honestly wondering, is this case "fair use"?
- xsmasher 6y agoAmateur analysis: for the citizens filming, yes. The copying is incidental, does not harm the market for the work, and the filming is for news/informational purposes. For the police? They may be in violation of copyright law for playing the music without a Public Performance License. I don't see an argument for fair use on their part.
- jcranmer 6y agoThere are three changes I would make to the DMCA: 1. All DMCA notices must contain an analysis of fair use and explain why the content does not meet fair use. 2. Anyone who has received an improper notice (including an analysis of fair use that would not survive summary judgement) can countersue (or sue, if the copyright owner declines to bring suit after a counter-notice) for at least $1000 in statutory damages. 3. Any non-DMCA system that can take down user-generated material for alleged copyright violations must give users the same rights as the DMCA: the (new) mandatory analysis of fair use and the right to counter-notice (and host the content until it is determined in court). These rights cannot be waived by contract.
- munk-a 6y agoI think #2 is probably too high for private citizens to risk needing to pay if their claims are reversed. Individuals can and do exercise DMCA notices for protected content that they personally own and if that route for reconciliation would be taken away and alternative would need to be provided. There are some serious issues with DMCA abuse but I think that it'd be better to address the issues of abuse with a regulatory body that's specifically empowered to go after bad actors. The core problem here is that the internet moves really really fast and is really really worthless so trying to protect owned content on it is extremely difficult.
- croon 6y ago> I think #2 is probably too high for private citizens to risk needing to pay if their claims are reversed. As a musician I have a hard time imagining a case where an honest DMCA takedown could be reversed by someone listening to the same music I am and identifying something else.
- jimbob45 6y agoJust fix the root problem. Copyright should last fifteen years max. The system now just incentivizes companies to hoard old stuff and eschew making risky new stuff.
- 6y ago
- tzs 6y agoWhat you've described is largely how the DMCA already works. 1. Copyright holder files a claim. 2. Platform takes down content, and notifies the poster of the content. 3. If poster thinks the claim is incorrect, poster notifies the platform. 4. Platform restores the content, and notifies the copyright owner. 5. If the copyright owner wants the content taken down again, they have to sue the poster. If the copyright owner must swear that they believe their claim is true. If they intentionally make a false claim it is perjury. All that's really missing is it sounds like you would penalize the copyright owner for being wrong about fair use regardless of whether they were wrong because they honestly thought it was not fair use or they were wrong because they knew it was fair use but lied about it. Fair use is subjective and tricky enough that it is not at all uncommon for both side to go into a case expecting for the court to go their way. Some major platforms don't follow the above, because they have decided to handle copyright using their own procedures instead of following the DMCA procedures.
- jedberg 6y agoI know how the DMCA works. The problem is step 2. Step two should be "platform notifies possible violator that claim has been made". The platform should not be punished for leaving the content up. Right now, under the DMCA, if they leave the content up, they become liable. That should not be the case. Furthermore, YouTube et al don't follow the DMCA. Their process is outside the DMCA, and starts with automated enforcement on behalf of the copyright holder, with no recourse for the potential violator.
- schoen 6y agoBy the way, the arrangement you suggest is called "notice and notice" (by contrast with "notice and takedown"). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notice_and_notice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notice_and_notice
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- minikites 6y agoReally? Copyright law is the real problem and not the extrajudicial murder of citizens by police? Must be nice to be insulated from worrying about that.
- zepto 6y agoErm yes. Documenting police activities with video is a good way to improve accountability. Copyright law is getting in the way of that. Merely being aghast at extrajudicial killings doesn’t stop them.
- minikites 6y ago>Documenting police activities with video is a good way to improve accountability. The Rodney King beating was filmed 30 years ago, so evidently we need more than just documenting it. We need to elect people who will actually defund the police, because reform clearly doesn't work.
- zepto 6y agoYou can’t seriously be suggesting that the ability to record video with cellphones that even the homeless now own and upload it to be viewed globally by millions in real-time has existed for 30 years.
- dcolkitt 6y ago> Let the platforms be neutral, put the liability on the copyright violators and copyright holders equally, so both have a reason to act fairly. One simple solution is that every time a bad takedown notice is successfully challenged, the copyright holder has a 1 in 10,000 chance of losing their copyright. So, DMCA takedown is successfully challenged. Now we roll two 100-sided dice. If they come up snake eyes, the IP is now in public domain forever. That would make copyright holders only challenge content that they are confident is in clear violation. Disney's not going to give some copyright troll the contract to shotgun DMCA notices across YouTube, if it means a serious risk of losing the rights to Frozen.
- deeblering4 6y agoThat's one of the problems, and I agree with your idea. It would be vastly better to put the burden of claiming the copyright on the holder, as they are the party who benefits from that action. However unchecked use of police force and lack of effective oversight are also serious problems. These are a large part of what has led to the situation today, where it is necessary to film routine police encounters. And why would police actively try to sabotage a video recording of themself? "If you aren't doing anything wrong, then you have nothing to hide" cuts both ways.
- bawolff 6y agoIANAL, but there are penalties for filing a false DMCA notice already. Almost never happens, but it exists. > This would allow Google/Facebook/et al to change their tools from automatic takedown to reporting the violation to the copyright holder, Is there anything stopping them from doing that now? I was under the impression that the current system was something google chose, not something forced on them by law. Like they have to respond to take down notices, but the content-id thing was something they chose themselves.
- jedberg 6y agoThe main thing that makes them use the current system is the liability they could incur by not doing it. And because it's cheaper than processing all the DMCA claims. If they were indemnified by law and even worse liable for penalties if they keep the current system, then they would quickly change it.
- vidarh 6y agoBy encouraging the use of non-DMCA notices by providing increased ability, above and beyond the DMCA, to take content down, they reduce the legal risk of not properly handling a DMCA notice simply by getting fewer actual DMCA notices. It's a win-win for Google and the copyright holders, but a loss for everyone else, who loses the (very limited) protection provided by the DMCA process.
- chrismcb 6y agoWow there are issues with dmca, and fair use is a problem. Recording copyrighted music and reposting it is not fair use.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> ^The real problem here is that there is no consequence for incorrect takedowns. [..] While your points are valid I think the real problem is that the Police is trying not to be accountable and to escape its responsibilities.
- Guthur 6y agoAnd being live streamed without consent is the right way? The problem with the adversely approach is that it gets behaviour like this. You back someone into the corner and how do you think they'll react, defensive and insular or open to mutual understanding and growth. I'm not a US citizen but I do feel there is something generally wrong with the policing there and a need for universal improvement that aligns the police closer to the citizens.
- notagoodidea 6y agoNot an US citizen but the issue with police is that for a start in every country that I know of, they are not your equal law-abiding citizen when wearing a uniform. Most of the time, they have law tools allowing them to arrest, fine you, etc. if they feel threaten, being at risk or insulted and only by their own appreciation. Nobody will review their appreciation and to contest such case, it fail on you side to make all the necessary steps to contest (best case scenario if you don't end up dead on the street). So being live streamed without consent is first and foremost a citizen tool to overwatch the police's action and honestly you don't have anything else allowing to do that in real-time. Policemen are not backed in a corner when filmed, they are acting in broad light. It may seems adversely but police proved since decades that they always took the violent path when interacting with people one way or the other and giving policeman the power to take it down on people profiled or randomly is a repeated proof. If great powers comes with great responsibilities, an uniform does not seem to come with a way to enforce the later.
- mcdevilkiller 6y agoThey have the same ability/powers in my country and it virtually never happens. To my mind, there's a problem with how US citizens view police officers, an how US police officers view US citizens.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 6y agoThis is the worst part of this whole copyright mess, defenders of youtube constantly preach the "They have to do this", "they are forced to do this" etc. defense. However the way Youtube handles dmca and copyright claims means that if you are a smaller musician, a big corporation can just steal your music and profit off it. Good luck if you don't live in the US and don't have the money to take back what is yours. From that point you can basically just hope that you make the news so that a human at Google looks into the mess they created for once. Just leaving a reminder of how infuriation Youtube copyright handling can become even for larger channels: Back in 2018 TheFatRat got his music claimed by some randoms and Youtube just gave it to them on a silver platter https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4AeoAWGJBw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4AeoAWGJBw . TheFatRat was a popular youtuber even back then, and even for him the process was hard. Now imagine how that situation would have played out for the average musician. When people talk about "protecting the musicians" they typically only mean the richest musicians, the top few % and the largest record labels. No one cares about regular musicians. The same logic also means that dmca claims can be easily weaponized by any entity as long as they choose their targets strategically (or own enough money to tank the situation in which a target fights back, but even then that can create more damage for the target).
- Shivetya 6y agoNo, the real problem is the cops know what they are doing is an attempt to circumvent the spirit if not the letter of the law and they need to be punished. Copyright laws and DMCA take downs are an issue, yes, but not here. If police recordings are being taken down because the cops are playing music then make it known far and wide which cops are doing it and get their local district attorney involved. Hell we likely are going to get a few Qualified Immunity rulings on this protecting both the cops and other officials but the only issue we should concentrate on is bad cops doing whatever they please and purposefully making society worse
- corobo 6y agoCan you not sue back for losses or anything in that situation? The US does punitive damages don't they? I'd imagine you could make a mint baiting the RIAA if you were ok with being as sleazy as them
- tony101 6y ago> The real problem here is that there is no consequence for incorrect takedowns. If content is taken down and then it turns out to be fair use, no one suffers a penalty. There are exceptions to this. See Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 801 F.3d 1126 (9th Cir. 2015). "Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., 801 F.3d 1126 (9th Cir. 2015), is a decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, affirming the ruling in 2008 of the US District Court for the Northern District of California, holding that copyright holders must consider fair use in good faith before issuing a takedown notice for content posted on the Internet." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenz_v._Universal_Music_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lenz_v._Universal_Music_Corp. "In ... Lenz v. Universal Music Corp., decided by the Ninth Circuit on September 14, 2015, a mother's 29-second home video of her two toddlers dancing to Prince's 1984 song "Let's Go Crazy" has made important new law with respect to "takedown notices" under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA"), holding that copyright holders must consider fair use before sending a takedown notification. This decision increases the potential liability for copyright holders seeking to enforce their rights through the DMCA and should serve as a warning to ensure fair use is considered before sending a takedown notice." https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2015/09/ninth-circuit-says-fair-use-must-be-considered-before-sending-a-dmca-takedown-notice https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2015/09/ninth-circuit-s...