12 ms·
The "traditional" way of fixing this would be a goatse.cx redirect of the image. I'm sure there is a more enlightened fix.
by m463 6y ago
The "traditional" way of fixing this would be a goatse.cx redirect of the image.
I'm sure there is a more enlightened fix.
- mey 6y agoA permanent redirect to a non-image page (owned by Wikimedia) may achieve the same thing. Either the calling system can't support a HTML response, or it's a webview in which case you could either report an error or provide a notice. Maybe even ask for donations :)
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoOr just downsample the image to a reasonable size and deal with it. Nothing inherently wrong with having a popular image.
- ehwhyreally 6y agoYes there is when you are hotlinking. Hotlinking in general is considered theft, you are using someone elses bandwidth and could even ddos the host if you are not caching the response.
- arbitrage 6y agoit's so easy to mitigate, though, that the fact that one doesn't sorta implies that one might want randos from the internet to use one's resources to view this image. it's not theft if you leave it out for everyone to use.
- JackWins 6y agoMy garden doesn't have a fence, doesn't mean you can host your picnic here.
- dylan604 6y agoNo, but if I wander into your garden and "injure" myself, I can sue you for damages. You will be held negligent for not properly protecting yourself from preventing other people from injuring themself on your property.
- gokhan 6y agoIs this something real (in US, most probably)?
- nikanj 6y agoYes, you can sue anyone for anything. Your suit probably won't prevail, unless you have access to very expensive lawyers and your opponent doesn't. But you can totally sue anyone for anything, and that makes for entertaining headlines - even though if plaintiff lost promptly
- olliej 6y agoThe problem of course is that the "victim" has a lawyer operating on a contingency, whereas you have to pay your legal costs, and generally cannot recuperate them.
- pastech 6y agoIn France (at least), all swimming pools are protected by a fence. If you own a pool and don't put a fence around it, you can be held responsible for a child drowning into it. It is possible this principle applies to other countries and other things than pools.
- wruza 6y agoHere in Russia, if you leave poisonous chemicals like methanol, etc, unmarked or put a bear trap in your locked house behind a locked fence with a generic warning sign, and then someone dies or gets injured by these, chances are you will go to jail. Idk if this applies to accidental traps like pools or rakes in grass. Same for taking a knife out of an attackers hand and stabbing them back. (Yes, our laws protect criminals better than citizens, not joking.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- concordDance 6y ago> Hotlinking in general is considered theft This is a pretty puzzling idea to me. How could linking something be theft? To explore this, I shall try a metaphor. Imagine you're on a big social media website (lets call it Programmer Olds) which has an oddity in that 99% of its users use adblock. You then post a link to another small (ad supported) website on your Programmer Olds page, causing a large number of people to click through and download the page using large amounts of bandwidth (for no monetary gain to the site) and possible DDOSing the site. Have you commited theft?
- JCharante 6y ago> causing a large number of people to click through and download the page using large amounts of bandwidth (for no monetary gain to the site) The difference here is that while a lot of users use adblock, there are some that don't. These users can still see the ads. Additionally even though it's a small website, it may lead to new readers that stick around or the content itself may even be sponsored. The equivilent to hot linking a picture would be like taking the content of a blog post without really linking to the source, because there's no chance of conversions there. If you're linking to the site itself then there's a reasonable chance that users can convert. So I suggest that it's theft just because the chances of readers being converted is nil while you're using their bandwidth.
- lorenzhs 6y ago> This is a pretty puzzling idea to me. That's because you're responding to an entirely different issue. "Hotlinking" isn't linking to something, it's including a resource that is hosted elsewhere. It's putting <img src="https://concordDance.whatever/images/big_image.jpg https://concordDance.whatever/images/big_image.jpg"> on my website without asking you. Now if my site ends up on the front page of HN, that could cause a lot of traffic to your site, potentially overwhelming your server or increasing your hosting bill. It's not nice, and rightfully frowned upon.
- concordDance 6y agoBut from a loss and gain perspective it seems equivalent. In both cases the site loses bandwidth for no gain due to your actions.
- yreg 6y agoNo, it's not universally considered a theft. Wikimedia explicitly permits hotlinking[0]. So does xkcd, imgur and tons of other sites. Of course when someone doesn't want us to hotlink to their assets then don't do it. [0] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Reusing_content_outside_Wikimedia/technical#Hotlinking https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Reusing_content_o...
- m463 6y agoI wonder if there's some way to have a frontend cache that or webserver shortcut that looks for that exact url and blurts out the image? Or maybe wikipedia is already mostly static. also, I wonder if HN is inadvertently ddos'ing the ticket system ?
- sangnoir 6y ago...or sending that image[1] jwz sends back upon detecting HN in the referer. I bet they'll find the app in a matter of hours, or at least reduce the traffic drastically. 1. https://www.jwz.org https://www.jwz.org NSFW!
- bzb6 6y agoThis makes me wonder why the hell referer headers are still sent by major browsers, especially to third parties. I can’t think of a single reason that benefits the user.
- qwertay 6y agoOriginally it probably just sounded like a cool feature to see what blog linked to you. Now its been around for so long that so much has been programmed to actually use it. If you turn it off you get every anti bot script blowing up on you. I think browsers did drop the path from it at least.
- jessaustin 6y agoFor one thing, examining referer is a common way that a server determines a request is not a hotlink. Sure you can do something more complicated with cookies or whatever, but lots of sites are just using referer and they'll break if the client doesn't send it.
- chrisjarvis 6y agoTo the people who didn't grow up with 4chan: do not search for this image, its pretty disgusting.
- pengaru 6y ago4chan didn't even exist yet when goatse emerged
- deathlight 6y agoIt seems plausible to me that the, ahem, "spread" of the image was greatly increased through the efforts of 4chan.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoMaybe widespread but it was already pretty wide open before there was a gap for 4chan to even exist.
- themaninthedark 6y ago** Kadmium changes topic to 'Our hearts are extended to the 18 victims of the recent internet fraud' http://bash.org/?434593 http://bash.org/?434593
- nomat 6y agoHey I'm on that website! IRC used to be so fun and weird back in the day. hanging out on slashnet took up most of my free time in junior high.
- Semaphor 6y agoBack in School, goatse was extremely well known. That was several years before 4chan. I hadn’t even heard of goatse in a 4chan relation until now.
- incompatible 6y agoI think it was popularized back in the days of Slashdot.
- bawolff 6y agoWhy does it need to be fixed? The mission of wikimedia is to serve educational content. Edit: this is a bit unfair, if its a specific app they should be convinced to cache just to avoid unfair resource usage, but hotlinking in general should not be seen as a problem
- unreal37 6y agoPresumably they are paying for the servers/bandwidth to support that, and that money is coming from donors. It's a waste of donors money if someone is using this image as some kind of "is this thing on" test using hacked computers...
- _joe 6y agoAny for-profit entity hotlinking Commons is unfair. Heck, they have the right to redistribute freely the image as they see fit, instead of consuming resources that are a common good. But this goes beyond that - it's some blind check of internet connectivity for the app, and doesn't get shown to the user. We're pretty sure of that, given that with the amount of noise that task generated, if there was an app featuring that image at least one of the ~ 90M daily "views" would've been someone reading these posts. Now, given we want to be nice, we didn't just blindly block the traffic, although making requests without user-agent is against our UA policy https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/User-Agent_policy https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/User-Agent_policy
- walrus01 6y agoThis is exactly what I used to do about 17 years ago.
- peterkelly 6y agoThis, perhaps disturbingly, was my first thought upon reading the issue. Things were done very differently back in the day. This problem would have been fixed real quick.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoI am a conservative man of tradition; fuck these modern liberal commies and their new age ways calling their degenerate diplomatic solutions “enlightenment”.
- jessaustin 6y agoA red flower rather than a lavender one.
- jobigoud 6y agoIf it's just used internally by an app to test connectivity as suggested in another subthread, this wouldn't solve the problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoLike so? http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/1011 http://ascii.textfiles.com/archives/1011
- BlueTemplar 6y agoBrilliant.