10 ms·
Robinhood sued by family of 20-year old trader who committed suicide
- BoorishBears 6y agoI've been following this story but this was new to me: > The suit says that Kearns made three attempts to contact Robinhood customer service regarding the massive underwater balance. However, his messages were met with automated replies, according to the complaint. I wonder how the people who set up a brokrage dealing with people's hard earned money in such a way you couldn't get in contact with a human easily must feel after hearing this? I get calls from Morgan Stanley just because a of a form error while initiating a transfer asking if I'd like them to do it for me, and RH is over here (wrongfully) telling people they're down almost a million dollars and then sending them to voicemail. Even though it was a bug, you'd think there'd be some provision for this, like if an account suddenly went that far in the negative they'd freeze the account and contact you immediately (and yes, people will point out that means they can't sell if it bounces back, but if you actually owe RH 750k I'm pretty sure all your positions will be liquidated before you can cough...)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- michaelt 6y ago> RH is over here (wrongfully) telling people they're down almost a million dollars and then sending them to voicemail. Perhaps they're hoping to be the Google of the finance industry /s
- diveanon 6y agoI don't know why you are getting downvotes, that's exactly who they drew inspiration from here.
- xiphias2 6y agoIs it that bad? I love Google, use it all the time. It's easy to complain, lots of companies tried and failed to comlete with it.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoThey are notorious for having no human support.
- xiphias2 6y agoSure, just like a toothbrush (Larry Page's favourite comparision for products). The only way to scale to all people in the world is to not have human support.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoIf toothbrushes were so great, Page would be in the toothbrush industry and their support models would be relevant.
- markdown 6y agoPlease stop spreading this lie. It's a falsehood I see on HN almost every single day. I have received almost immediate support from a real human every single time I've contacted Google (dozens of times). This includes chat, email, and even phone support initiated by them... and I live in the a "third world" country in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, and earn them no more than two figures a month. In my experience, Google provides stellar support.
- BoorishBears 6y agoPeople's who have had their livelihoods destroyed by random AdWords and Google Play Store bans with zero recourse but hoping they get traction on Twitter might disagree... In fact wasn't the Terraria developer who randomly got banned by Google just on the front page yesterday?
- Qub3d 6y ago> In my experience, Google provides stellar support. This is anecdotal. Here is a high-profile counter-experience to yours: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26061935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26061935 When dealing with large companies we must consider trends, not individual points. This same line of thinking is what causes climate-change-deniers to point at snow on the ground and say its all a hoax.
- vimerate 6y agoPreviously discussed https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23553794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23553794 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23523246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23523246 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23523379 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23523379
- bigpumpkin 6y agoI just opened up my margined account on Interactive Brokers and it shows a large negative cash balance (exactly equal to what I borrowed on margin). I guess an inexperienced trader could've mistaken the negative cash balance as having negative equity value. Alex Kearns had a negative cash of -730k but a positive equity of $16k . Why did Robinhood send him an email asking for $170k in a few days? Then later after his death, he received another email from Robinhood: "Great news! We're reaching out to confirm that you've met your margin call and we've lifted your trade restrictions." Did Robinhood's margin call system make a mistake?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beervirus 6y agoAllegedly he had a trade set up with multiple legs. He wrote some puts and bought some mostly-offsetting puts. He got assigned on the puts he wrote, but the profit from the other leg of the trade didn’t show up in his account until the next business day.
- totalZero 6y agoYou don't know that you're assigned until the day after it happens. Even if you immediately exercise offsetting options upon notification of assignment, it takes a business day to clear out the shares.
- quickthrowman 6y agoDoes anyone know what his position was? Probably vertical put spreads, credit or debit could’ve resulted in this situation. Short put vertical: Underlying is at 392, sell 200 390P, buy 20 389P. Underlying moves to 387, counterparty exercises 20 ITM puts, now you’re long 2,000 shares at 390, you exercise your ITM 389P and sell 2,000 shares at 389 for a net $2,000 loss. Long put vertical: Underlying at 392, buy 20 390P, sell 20 389P. Underlying moves to 387, counterparty exercises 20 ITM puts, now you’re long 2,000 shares at 389, you exercise your ITM 390P and sell 2,000 shares at 390 for a $2,000 net gain. Either one of these would’ve shown a negative $780,000 balance when the early exercise happened, poor kid didn’t know it was recoverable.
- Aeolun 6y agoWell damn, now I understand how this would confuse someone. Remind me to never get started with options.
- PHGamer 6y agothe more i hear about options/puts and then the short counterpart i feel as if the whole game is convoluted to hide the fact that its less investing and more gambling.
- ABeeSea 6y agoUsing various combinations of option for a single trade allows the risk/reward of the position to be more finely tuned based on changes to the underlying.
- Lucasoato 6y agoWhy downvoting? It's undeniable that some people are lured in bad investments practices because they share many characteristics with gambling. I'm not complaining about morality or ethic, it's just clear that these platforms are making a lot of money from trading addicted people.
- 6y ago
- waprin 6y agoIt was partially noted in past threads, and partially missed, but this 20 year old didn't actually lose the money he thought he lost. It was basically a "leaky abstraction" of the backend that bubbled up. Their total lack of any real customer support since it's not "scalable" also contributed to this tragic adn avoiadable death.
- potions 6y agoRobinhood's legacy is commission free equity trades at pretty much every single retail brokerage, whether they survive as an app or not. There is a reasonable argument to be made that whatever minute price slippage customers might experience(which I believe isn't even supposed to be legal due to NBBO and Reg NMS? not an expert) due to payment for order flow is much less than the $10 commissions at deep discount retail brokerages and certainly than the $50 trades in the old days of calling up your friendly local rent seeking broker -- for typical robinhood sized equity transactions. Robinhood has plenty of problems but they directly caused investors to be able to trade for free @ fidelity, vanguard, schwab, etc which is obviously a boon to consumers. Also imo at least robinhood is somewhat up front about like 'the market is a zany gambling game' with their UX. Contrast with IBKR and TOS who heavily market their stuff to Serious Portfolio Dads With 4 Monitors and then ALSO do sheisty manipulation appearing stuff to "protect their clients from volatility." RH targeting a smaller computer and being colorful doesn't make it any worse than other discount retail brokerages shoving derivative trading platforms at unsophisticated retail.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y ago100% agree. The $5 - $10 commissions that existed forever are still a great deal if you're moving around serious amounts of capital and it gets your order fulfilled a few pennies cheaper, but when you're only trying to purchase a double-digit dollar amount of stock, they're ridiculous. I really do believe Robinhood is a net positive in the world because it has provided the lower classes the ability to more easily buy a small sliver of the means of production. Most people lose money when they first start trading and investing. A lot of people are going through that the first time right now, but losing money in the market is the first step to making money in the market, and eventually I think this commission-free environment (paired with approachable apps) will build a great deal of financial competence among the general population.
- nealabq 6y agoIf only he'd realized that he could declare bankruptcy, he might not have been so overwhelmed. I think it wrecks your credit for about 7 years (?), but it's not the end of the world. This is so sad.
- filoleg 6y agoThe thing is, he actually probably would've made some profit on that trade (or a small loss) after it all was said and done. He had a spread position, but only one leg of that spread was executed, while the other was still pending. So while the second leg is pending, the UI would only show one on the chart (while the other one is clearly marked in the UI as still active). Until that second leg is executed too, you will see that weirdness on the chart. But if you know how spreads work even on the most basic level, you will easily understand that this is not the actual balance of your account, it is just the pending balance until the other leg is executed. And the other leg was guaranteed to be executed, so it isn't like there was some uncertainty about that. All it takes is one business day tops for the second leg to get processed. For those curious, there are other comments in previous threads that explain the situation in much better detail, such as this one. [0] This is a very known thing with spread positions, can be verified by just googling for a few minutes. And while his death is a tragedy that was easily avoidable, I don't think that it is fair to blame RH for this man's failure to do less than a few minutes of googling. Important to note, this isn't unique to RH, this is pretty much how every broker displays that specific kind of a trade in their UI. And it isn't because they are all bad at UI, but because it is indeed an accurate representation of the state of the account at that moment. You just gotta make sure you actually understand the information you are looking at. And if you are doing option spreads with even the most basic knowledge of those, you should already be able to easily understand what those charts are actually displaying. Not even mentioning that the parents claim he opened a trading account and started trading options as a college freshman, which is kind of impossible to get an approval for from RH (or any other broker) unless you make a lot of money already or lie on the application. And we know he didn't make a lot of money, because some of the headlines on the matter have mentioned "RH trader with no income manages to open a $750k position". So he indeed went around the rules (and the law) by lying to get a permission from the broker to trade options. Not trying to blame him for what happened, the situation is just unfortunate all around. I am simply struggling to think of anyone who could be honestly and justly blamed for this situation, aside from, maybe, his parents. But even that is a stretch. 0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23554588 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23554588
- pc86 6y ago> The Kearns’ family complaint says, “Not only did Robinhood permit Alex to open the account, but when Alex was a freshman in college later that year, it permitted him to trade options.” You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application. > “Worse, Robinhood provided almost no investment guidance, and its customer ‘service’ was virtually non-existent, consisting of automated e-mail replies devoid of any human contact or interaction,” the family alleged in the suit. How many brokers provide investment guidance? How many do it without additional fees? I've only reached out to Robinhood two or three times but a person has responded to the initial inquiry in all but one instance (where an automated email just said it would be a while, and a person followed up about a week later to actually address the issue). Robinhood is a shit company and I look forward to incoming class action lawsuit but this is a grieving family lashing out and should be dismissed. If anything comes of this the only thing that's going to happen is there are going to be more roadblocks for retail investors to invest.
- MattGaiser 6y ago> How many brokers provide investment guidance? It is usually quite explicit that they are not providing investment advice with the online ones.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edgyquant 6y agoAdvice and guidance are two separate things (even if they sound the same.) Vanguard, for instance, has volumes explaining trading and investment strategies but advice would me more like implying you should use a strategy or buy a specific equity.
- tidepod12 6y ago>You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application. If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's fault. Robinhood isn't absolved of responsibility just because the student did something dishonest. Given the fact he was 20 years old, his options application should have automatically been under a heightened degree of scrutiny, if not immediately rejected. That it wasn't indicates Robinhood is not responsibly implementing KYC controls, which is a huge deal.
- Gunax 6y agoThe real question is whether it would have been better or worse for the case if he actually had lost 700k.
- xyzelement 6y agoSad case but a completely inappropriate lawsuit. As society we allow people to chose to take risks they are comfortable with (otherwise everyone would be locked up in their homes wrapped in bubblewrap.) I am not a RH user but I expect that to get started you have to transfer in money. To do anything with leverage (options, etc.) you certainly have to opt-in to additional agreements including indicating that you understand the risks, etc. Ultimately the steps of "wiring money in" or accepting "I understand I can lose more than I invested" should trigger something in your brain. And if it doesn't unfortunately you have to pay the price rather than somehow making the whole activity illegal. Obviously this is a terrible situation for the family, but it's also a reminder that parents need to teach their kids common sense. For example: there's no free lunch. If your kid at 20 has the brain that says "oh duh there's free money here" you kinda messed up.
- Gunax 6y agoI think the lawsuit has more to do with RH accidentally showing a debt of 700k than actually letting people lose 700k on margin. It will be settled out of court.
- hypertele-Xii 6y agoHow about this for common sense: Don't kill yourself. Especially not over something as trivial as money.
- betwixthewires 6y agoThe article mentions the app misleading him into believing he had incurred the debt, but never goes into how it was misleading. Was he actually in that amount of debt, or was he misled? If he was in that level of debt, was he misled about the risks he was taking? I'm not a fan of the argument "they shouldn't have let him make decisions he didn't understand" because I believe the onus is on us to know what we are doing before we do it, and arguments like these are what led us to our current regulatory framework disallowing investors into markets unless they meet capital requirements, essentially pricing everyone but rich people out of markets.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoRobinhood’s app is notorious for indicating a margin call when one is not forthcoming for complex options strategies (options spreads, in this case). PSA: Please use a real brokerage when participating in capital markets. Fidelity is my recommendation, but others are at parity if not close. No one should be using Robinhood.
- swrj 6y agoMore people would if mobile apps weren't horrible. I have schwab and fidelity and the lack of basic features like listing option greeks, auto refreshing tick values, L2 data by established brokerages is baffling.
- throwawayboise 6y agoWhy the need to do this on mobile? This is serious stuff. You're not just ordering dinner. Do it on a desktop, and know what you're doing.
- nomel 6y agoThis is a silly no true Scotsman argument. A screen of information is a screen of information. There's nothing that can be displayed on a desktop screen that is somehow incompatible with the pixels on my phone or tablet, which both have higher resolution than my desktop.
- diveanon 6y agoThis entire disaster will be the end of robinhood, and frankly it couldn't happen to more deserving people. Kharma is a bitch, and when you build a business based on virtue signaling and lies you had better expect for it to come back and bite you.
- Meekro 6y agoThis is extremely sad. The lawsuit claims that Robinhood's shitty tech support was one of the major factors here. Between that, the numerous bugs, and the way they've been blocking people from trading in Gamestop, I can't understand why people choose to use it over the alternatives. I've always done my trading through Schwab, and my experience has been worlds different from what I read in the news about Robinhood. Schwab hasn't restricted the trading of any stocks or options, and they make professional support as available as air. Whether it's technical issues or basic investment advice, I can easily get in touch with them by phone or email.
- mizzack 6y agoI've had this happen after getting assigned on a short leg. Massive negative balance in the UI, locked account, angry margin call emails from RH. The messaging around this is terrifying because it is all boilerplate risk management stuff -- nothing you'd expect if you were naively engaged in a controlled risk spread. The thing to keep in mind is that RH won't let you engage in infinite risk positions. So, if this happens, take a deep breath and maybe re-read a few sections on Investopedia.
- ada1981 6y agoThis is tragic, but misguided. I was sued for $55MM this year after my (now former) business partner lost $5MM to Vietnamese mafia which triggered a loss for a customer. Was crazy, but I took a deep breath and realized worse case was personal bankruptcy if they pierced the LLC. The worse case scenario for this kid would have been 7 years of bad credit (had he lost $750k). There were some deeper things going on in his life and family system that no one is talking about. Oh, I ended up selling my position to my partner, getting indemnified and walking away with a few hundred grand (some still be to paid). It was super stressful, and I’m really grateful I’ve learned how to process painful experiences (I work as a mindset coach to billionaire tech founders).
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI haven't been following this, so I don't have a lot of context, and a quick google doesn't tell me if he had student loans or much of anything about the context of his life. Some initial thoughts that may be wildly off the mark: 1. Is it pertinent that he was a college student in a world where student loans are eating the futures of students while not giving them the good careers they thought it guaranteed? 2. Is it pertinent that the rich have gotten richer and the poor have gotten poorer during the pandemic? It's kind of a winner-take-all economy and we just crap all over everyone else and then blame them as lazy whiners who need to try harder and basically tell them "shut up!" if they try to point out "I'm doing all I can and it's never enough because the system is broken." 3. If you aren't one of the "winners" you get kind of this dystopian reality where you can't get health coverage, you can't get housing, once you are homeless no one wants to hire you so escaping seems nigh impossible, etc. 4. We have raised the ceiling on our economy and put in no floor. Then we wonder when folks slip through the cracks. 5. If you have overwhelming real world problems such that it makes you think suicide is your only option and you try to talk to someone, you will most likely be dismissed as "mentally ill" for being suicidal. This is tragic and I assume Robinhood does need to handle things differently, but I can't help but wonder what this says about or how this relates to other societal issues in the US today.
- syntaxing 6y agoIt’s such a hard balance between regulation to protect the people vs freedom of will. I’m not entirely sure what’s the solution is but RH is definitely inching towards user exploitation.
- throwitaway1235 6y agoIt's one thing (a quite annoying thing) for free non-monetary services to not have phone support, but a service that houses your money is inexcusable.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoHe was an adult and he's responsible for his own decisions. We can't turn the world into safe space for every poorly equipped adult. This is not to lessen the tragedy of this situation in any way. Acknowledging a tragedy doesn't have to involve trying to find a sue-able party to blame it on.
- scotty79 6y agoStock market investment services should be treated same way as gambling. Warren Buffet's long bet with hedge funds proves it is nothing more than that.
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoPeople have to start owning up to their decisions. Unfortunately, society has deemed suicide as acceptable. Where's the role of the parents to teach their children not to commit suicide? Shifting blame like this is not going to solve anything. Note that I'm not excusing the current financial system that has basically become legalized gambling more or less (like options and shorting).