6 ms·
The Full Automation Fallacy
- imtringued 6y ago>Writers have only a 3.8 percent chance—“totally safe”—while machinists face an alarming 65 percent. Only one of those is paid poorly. Hint, it's not the machinist, whose productivity has massively improved thanks to automation. Software developers are well compensated despite the extremely high degree of automation in their jobs. The reality is that humans consume a fixed amount of resources and have a variety of jobs that produce value. As long as the value you produce is bigger than the resources you consume you can employ an infinite amount of people in a job. Automation increases your productivity and thus increases the amount of value you can produce. Those burger flippers are compensated poorly because you need a lot of them to run a restaurant that serves cheap food. If you had a way of increasing their productivity 2 fold you can afford to pay them twice as much. I said afford. You still need proper government policies that drive unemployment down to reap these benefits. However, without automation you are doomed to a low salary, no matter how well the economy is doing.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> Software developers are well compensated despite the extremely high degree of automation in their jobs. I don't see how that's meaningful. If it takes skilled human effort, we expect it to be well compensated. What does it matter whether that skill makes use of much existing technology? A racing driver relies on an impressive stack of technology. Should we consider their job to be under a high degree of automation? > humans consume a fixed amount of resources This could not be more wrong. [0][1] > Those burger flippers are compensated poorly because you need a lot of them to run a restaurant that serves cheap food This doesn't explain why they're poorly compensated. It implicitly assumes the competitive survival of the restaurant, and treats employee compensation as a function of the employer's needs. That doesn't work. The employees are poorly compensated because people will do that job for that level of compensation. Employers don't tend to pay more than the market requires them to. > If you had a way of increasing their productivity 2 fold you can afford to pay them twice as much. I said afford. What does it matter what the employer could afford to do, if we're talking about the actual compensation of the employee? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_energy_consumption_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_energy_co... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_%3D_PAT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_%3D_PAT
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThis is a bad expectation to have > If it takes skilled human effort, we expect it to be well compensated. Because this is true > The employees are poorly compensated because people will do that job for that level of compensation. I would rephrase to: “If the supply of labor is low relative to demand, and the purchaser has the ability to pay, we expect it to be well compensated.”
- ameister14 6y ago>I don't see how that's meaningful. If it takes skilled human effort, we expect it to be well compensated. What does it matter whether that skill makes use of much existing technology? We don't actually pay people based on skill. Take the example of an old man making phyllo dough by hand - he gets paid based on the weight of the dough produced, not based on the work he puts in or the skill to produce the dough. This was really prevalent in the Industrial revolution, where expert artisans were replaced by factories.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Automation increases your productivity and thus increases the amount of value you can produce. But not the price you can sell at, unless the demand curve also shifts in proportion to the increase in supply. > Those burger flippers are compensated poorly because you need a lot of them to run a restaurant that serves cheap food. They are compensated poorly because there exists other supply of burger flippers willing to flip burgers at that level of compensation, and because burger purchasers are only able/willing to pay a certain amount for burgers. > You still need proper government policies that drive unemployment down to reap these benefits. You need government policies to restrict the supply of labor because the increase in supply of labor is not being met with a proportional increase in demand for labor. Hence overtime, vacation leave, parental leave, minimum age, taxpayer funded education, etc.
- Closi 6y agoThis is the true answer - as per basic economics, the price of labour in a free market is set by demand and supply.
- pydry 6y ago>Those burger flippers are compensated poorly because you need a lot of them to run a restaurant that serves cheap food. If you had a way of increasing their productivity 2 fold you can afford to pay them twice as much. I said afford. McDonalds made $11 billion in 2019. They employed 210,000 people. They therefore made ~$52,400 per worker in profit. A $10 / hour burger flipper makes ~$19,500 per year. Those burger flippers are compensated poorly because of labor market competition. The value they provide only puts a ceiling on what it is possible for them to earn for their job to exist. The actual prevailing wage is determined by, frankly, how desperate the low skilled pool of labor is. If unemployment goes up, that means greater desperation. If public sector compensation goes down, that means greater desperation. If social services are cut that means greater desperation. If overseas workers in a country that practices chattel slavery starts taking orders, that means greater desperation. If prison workers start getting in on your industry, that means greater desperation. All of these things mean wages go down. This all has absolutely fuck all to do with automation. It is largely about power. The Roman empire also had mind-bendingly high levels of income and wealth inequality and they weren't exactly automating everybody out of their jobs. They were a society built on the selective application of extreme violence. Automation does provide the perfect excuse for paltry, declining wages though, largely because it's nobody's fault. If I were an industrialist I'd for sure be gently guiding the pointy pitchforks in the direction of the robots while I outsource, use prison labor, lobby for reining in public sector wages/pensions, cutting social services and gorging myself on gargantuan profit margins. I'm squishy and they are not. The other useful aspect of the automation narrative is that it plays well with outsourcing. Americans don't see the labor intensive factories that leave its shores in search of more impoverished, cheaper, possibly even slave labor. What they do see are the factories that didn't bother offshoring - the ones that required a small amount of highly skilled labor to maintain automated production lines, where the headache of offshoring wasn't worth the hassle.
- namdnay 6y agoMinor nitpick: > McDonalds made $11 billion in 2019. They employed 210,000 people. They therefore made ~$52,400 per worker in profit. Don’t forget that McDonalds is mostly a franchise business. They could have 0 people flipping burgers and still make 10 billion profit
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoobviously you would only be paying them 2X if there was a 2X burger flipper, once you have automated burger flipping and you need half as many you have twice the people on the market with the easy to learn skill you require. Why would you increase their wages, unless it was because of human decency?
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Why would you increase their wages, unless it was because of human decency? Even human decency only gets you so far. Restaurant margins are thin, and a different restaurant owner won’t hesitate to start selling burgers at a lower cost if lower priced labor is available. And most people are very price sensitive when it comes to commodity food items.
- rmah 6y agoThe reality is that humans consume a fixed amount of resources and have a variety of jobs that produce value. That is not the reality at all. People in industrialized economies today have, on average, vastly higher standards of living and thus consume vastly more resources than in centuries past. While a typical person 100 years ago may have been happy with 2 or 3 pairs of shoes, a half dozen changes of cloths, a bicycle and a radio. A person of similar socio-economic status today has a dozen pairs of shoes, a hundred articles of clothing, a car, a tv, multiple radios, a mobile phone, etc, etc. This massive increase in physical possessions for the same (or less) labor output is due in large part to automation increasing the overall efficiency of dozens of industries. What the "automation will take all our jobs" and "UBI for everyone" proponents seem to fail to realize --just as people who espoused similar views in 1910 failed to realize -- is that there is no limit to human desires. People can never have enough. People will always want more and better. Because people don't measure their wealth in absolute terms, but rather terms relative to those around them. Thus, even with increased automation, the increased demand will help to provide more employment (if in somewhat different jobs). This has all happened before and will happen again.
- vouwfietsman 6y agoThe article makes a good argument throughout, that automated work is often sold as complete replacement, but frequently introduces more work around the automation. Also that their is a real psychological cost to marrying (social) life and technology too closely. These are fair points. However, the article also berates self-checkout systems, which everybody I know perceives as a net benefit to their daily lives. It goes on to pretend that filling in a form on a webapp to send your leave hours to HR is somehow "doing HR’s job", omitting the obvious time savings, persistence, and error reduction for everybody involved. Finally, the article of course freely shows us the AI effect [0] as if it is a novel insight, by quoting a "technology critic", whatever that means, to tell us that actually nearly all achievements surrounding AI are just VC hype and mechanical-turk type shams. I don't get why everything always needs to be so polarized. When we invented plastic all of a sudden everybody started doing everything with plastic, even if it did not make sense [1]. After a couple decades, some uses of plastic stick, others don't. Its natural selection on a cultural/industrial level. Why can't we allow automation/AI to go through the same process, without pretending it's somehow making our lives worse, or treating it like it's magic. Dressing the misbehavior of industrial capitalism as a failure of technology is intellectually dishonest. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect [1] https://www.pinterest.com/pin/393713192402286646/ https://www.pinterest.com/pin/393713192402286646/
- nytgop77 6y agoPolarization helps with the click count. Intentionally or not. My unsolicited advice: When one finds a diamond in a pile of dirt, focusing on the diamond seems beter use of ones energy than the alternative.
- II2II 6y ago> I don't get why everything always needs to be so polarized. It is polarized since people are looking at how it may affect themselves rather than society as a whole. If there a 10% job loss is projected over their working life, they are concerned that they will be in the 10%. Even if their job is secure, they may be concerned that the threat of automation or displaced workers from other fields will force their wages to stagnate or decline. It is difficult to argue these worries away since they affect individuals and no one knows how automation will affect any given person in the long term. Granted, some of the concerns are about the nature of the job rather than the material loss. Consider something like teaching, where there will be no real substitute for people in the foreseeable future. That being said, what teachers do will change. There will be more emphasis on technical skills and technologically mediated communications. In a profession which attracts people who want to help others, the increasing role of automation will likely be seen as a drawback rather than a benefit.
- michele_f 6y agoI didn't notice that the word "algorithm" is now buzzy. OMFG.
- mcny 6y agoIn case you missed it, Stanford administrators tried to deny responsibility when questioned why CXO level executives (who were working from home) got priority over front line workers for vaccinations blaming "the algorithm". > According to an email sent by a chief resident to other residents, Stanford's leaders explained that an algorithm was used to assign its first allotment of the vaccine. The algorithm was said to have prioritized those health care workers at highest risk for COVID infections, along with factors like age and the location or unit where they work in the hospital. Residents apparently did not have an assigned location, and along with their typically young age, they were dropped low on the priority list. > Stanford has not provided an answer to NPR's request for an explanation of its process or its algorithm. > Neurology residents were among those who organized and protested on Friday. > One neurology resident, who was involved in planning Friday's protest, said that a flawed algorithm is no excuse. She requested anonymity for fear of affecting her future job search. > "[A]lgorithms are made by people and the results ... were reviewed multiple times by people," she wrote in an email to NPR. "The ones who ultimately approved the decisions are responsible. If this is an oversight, even if unintentional, it speaks volumes about how the front line staff and residents are perceived: an afterthought, only after we've protested. There's an utter disconnect between the administrators and the front line workers. This is also reflective that no departmental chair or chief resident was involved in the decision making process." https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/12/18/948176807/stanford-apologizes-after-vaccine-allocation-leaves-out-nearly-all-medical-resid https://www.npr.org/sections/coronavirus-live-updates/2020/1...
- aaron695 6y agoAn automated 'burger-flipping robot' is just a conveyor belt grill that cooks both sides at once being run in a ghost kitchen. Saying another robotic arm start-up has failed is just shooting fish in a barrel.
- monkeydust 6y agoAs someone who's is directly involved in developing and deploying automation software in complex organisations here are a few thoughts: - I can resonate with the author that automation can easily create new tasks (work) that didn't exist before. - These tasks generally speaking are of a more cognitive nature to the ones they replace. - If deployed right automation takes out the robot from the human to allow the human to focus on these cognitive tasks which all being equal are more rewarding and satisfying. - From our own deployment of automation (software in services sector) we have not seen a fall in number of humans in the business where we deploy automation. - However, we have observed these businesses adopting human capital at a much lower rate than they were in the past as their business grows in favour of technology. - Labour costs will have to come down a significant amount for to reverse this trend where business are seeing success through automation. - Automation is a not a one-shot exercise. For it to be effective firms need to establish (literally write down) what their intention are from investing in automation. What is the measure(s) they are trying to optimise and improve. - Firms need to re-evaluate these 3,6,12 months after deployment periodically and refine the automation machinery. This itself is one of the new tasks to emerge from deploying automation and lends itself to individuals who are more analytical and can make sense of vast amounts of data. If your interested in looking beyond the obvious with Automation I can highly recommend also reading 'Ironies of Automation Baindridge 1983' https://ckrybus.com/static/papers/Bainbridge_1983_Automatica.pdf https://ckrybus.com/static/papers/Bainbridge_1983_Automatica...
- tuatoru 6y ago> - From our own deployment of automation (software in services sector) we have not seen a fall in number of humans in the business where we deploy automation. Such a fall in absolute numbers would not be expected if the reorganisation made an organisation more competitive (assuming it's just one of many in its industry), so perhaps you're doing something right.[1] > - However, we have observed these businesses adopting human capital at a much lower rate than they were in the past as their business grows in favour of technology. This also is expected. It's what happened with the introduction of ATMs in bank branches. However those are side issues. One of the major points of the article is that labour shifting is sold as automation. So we need to know: how much labour and cost has been shifted onto the customers and/or suppliers of the organisations you automate? How much has been shifted out to piecework contractors? What has the effect been on the families of the employees? Without answers to questions like these we can't really make a proper asssessment of the full social benefit of your automation efforts. 1. A cynical take on automation projects is that they are often opportunities to shake out some of the dead wood that any large organisation accumulates--accumulates because, as other have noted, the incentives within large organisations act to increase the headcounts in various fiefdoms. The other half of that cynical take is that in other organisations they are opportunities for one group of managers to gather more power over others. This is probably the case in hospitals, where specialist bureaucrats have an advantage over doctors, so "automation" projects shift clerical labour onto doctors (and nurses and patients) while "upgrading" admin work into endless and unnecessary "cognitive tasks".
- natemo 6y agoWhile I agree with much of the article, I think the following points were not sufficiently explored: 1. I got the impression that he felt this "fauxtomation" was the final iteration of any service practicing it. To me, "fauxtomation" follows a fairly established startup methodology of doing things manually before automating. It allows sufficient time for engineers to observe the full scope before attempting to automate. In addition, it is provided as a sort of API to the end user while true automation efficiencies can be implemented incrementally with the in-house team. The end goal of these services is almost certainly full automation. To a greater extent, I suspect this is the intended future of entire gig economies ("fauxtomation" at scale) created by the likes of Uber and DoorDash who are pushing for further advancements in technology to replace the comparatively high cost of human labor. 2. Where was the "partial automation" alternative to "full automation" in this article? It seems that most of the described technologies fall short because the scope is too big. They do not allowing enough flexibility for fixing (and learning from) errors or accommodating unplanned use-cases. If a product (like self-service checkout) typically requires training for an employee to use properly, it is not ready for the average consumer. I have heard the following quote used frequently: > What can be automated, should be automated. What is not given enough airtime is the inverse: > What cannot be automated, should not be automated. The immediate future is more cyborg than robot. A modern website is an assortment of modular APIs glued together. Some have referred to smartphones as a human appendage, and I think this is the proper analogy to view technology as a whole over the next decade: upgrades rather than replacements to our biological limitations. Instead of replacing an entire industry with an industry-sized vending machine, large amounts of untrained workers will slowly be replaced by a smaller amount of trained practitioners who know how to use better tools. What this will mean for society as a whole, though, is anyone's guess.
- dfilppi 6y agoThe invention of the wheel was a huge job killer
- ameister14 6y agoThis is not a very tightly written article. I don't think it makes that much sense, it jumbles multiple scenarios and arguments together and doesn't fully flesh out the argument anyway. I don't disagree - full automation isn't happening anytime soon. We'll stick with partial automation, where 5 people do the work that 100 people did previously. That said, the author used a few pretty terrible examples to illustrate his point. The Flippy example from 2018 was an interesting choice, considering after reworking the robot it is currently in use in dozens of restaurants throughout the US and is being trialed by White Castle. Yeah, version 1.2whatever from 2018 wasn't ready yet - that happens. If the cost benefit still makes sense, the robot will be improved and version 4.5 might be the one to succeed. It's not over. The author writes about doctors doing administrative work - that's just a misuse of the software and a failure of management - there are actually more administrative staff in hospitals than ever before, though they don't seem to do anything additional. This is not because of a failure of automation, but because of a failure to align incentives. The manager is incentivized to increase administrative staff as it enlarges their personal power within the system, and is also not incentivized to make the work of doctors easier in any way. I think a better conversation would be about why production remained steady while workforces decreased in the midwest. Why Jack Welch's methods became popular despite long-term failures and how we can reset business and investment ethics to allow for a greater wealth distribution based on worker input. What the goals of automation are and how we can move away from employer based healthcare and understand the realities inherent in a system where "Automation...recomposes the workforce, isolating and rearranging tasks, altering job descriptions, and hollowing out middle-tier occupations."
- ilaksh 6y agoThe article fails to anticipate significant improvements in AI and robotics. That is shortsighted, given the progress we have already seen. Many researchers are aware of the shortcomings in AI and beginning to work on them. And that wave of research is growing. It is strange that people discount the possibility of this research paying off. I think they just aren't aware of it. As AI and robotics improve, it will disrupt the workforce more and more. How that plays out is something that we should consciously direct with foreknowledge.