12 ms·
The Downside to Life in a Supertall Tower: Leaks, Creaks, Breaks
- ggm 6y agoSchadenfreude but.. also not. Nobody wants to have a home beset by a ticking clock you can't stop, rich or poor its the minor irritation which nags. For the poor it's the constant hunt for newspaper to wrap themselves in over a steam vent. For the rich, it's losing your free breakfast in a Michelin starred restaurant you have to spend $15,000 pa in by contract, but which is closed by covid. Oh well. Anyway..
- melq 6y agoI get where you're coming from, but sheesh you could hardly have made a more tone deaf analogy. Aside from the fact that their private restaurant is almost certainly not closed, some billionaires being inconvenienced by what amounts to minor condo fees on their second (or third, or fourth) home is wildly different than a person with no home struggling to keep themselves warm at night. And 'wildly different' is an understatement.
- ggm 6y agoWhoosh
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/DZy0r https://archive.is/DZy0r
- ramraj07 6y agoI get conflicted feelings about this. On the one hand it's highly unlikely anyone in that tower would get a shred of empathy from the common man (and highly unlikely this is even one of their 5 other homes), but on the other it's just a damn shame that some of the most prominent landmarks in the greatest city in the world are crappy places to live at. I'm not of the opinion they're eyesores - the nyc Skyline was stagnant for decades until these needles came in. One way or another progress in that regard is good?
- Razengan 6y ago> the nyc Skyline was stagnant for decades until these needles came in. Maybe it's time to embrace the future and replace these with arcologies.
- nradov 6y agoAlso see the Millennium Tower in San Francisco which is sinking and leaning. They built it on unstable ground without a sufficiently deep foundation.
- taneq 6y agoCould have taken some hints from the Italians...
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoFor the ones that didn't immediately catch the reference, it's the leaning tower of Pisa [0]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaning_Tower_of_Pisa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaning_Tower_of_Pisa
- tedunangst 6y agoAnd taxpayers get to pay for fixing it. Nice.
- vmception 6y agointeresting. from the article > making clear that even multimillion-dollar price tags do not guarantee problem-free living this reiterates that you can make a living simply catering to wealthy people's problems instead of dismissing them pick and choose your battles
- RodgerTheGreat 6y agoYou can make a living in organized crime. You can make a living polluting the environment. You can make a living defending corruption, helping the rich grow richer and the poor grow poorer. The problems of the wealthy are as the problems of a tick sucking the lifeblood from a host. Rest assured that extending them empathy and compassion will be a strictly one-sided arrangement when push comes to shove.
- Animats 6y agoIt's a pain having a building that flexes. Everything needs expansion joints, and ordinary building materials aren't designed for that. The steelwork can handle it, but wallboard can't.
- xyst 6y agofor once, a subsection of rich people get a taste of what most regular people go through on a daily basis just goes to show that this project might have spent more money on marketing and advertising rather than on their engineering and architect departments.
- nefitty 6y agoI get the schadenfreude. I used to dismiss the suffering of people who were “beyond” the survival levels of Maslow’s hierarchy. This changed for me when I read that Peter Singer himself focuses on influencing survival-level needs for those in poverty because they are more immediate and are more quantifiable. He said something like, “Well-off people suffer, of course, but those types of suffering are more difficult to measure and entail interventions beyond vaccines or food distribution. I don’t focus on those types of suffering because there so much of the basic kind and also because it’s too hard of a problem.” When I segmented suffering by the individuals’ place on Maslow’s hierarchy, it helped me develop more compassion for the rich than is in vogue. “Oh, that guy driving that Lamborghini isn’t hungry, but he might be the loneliest person I’ve ever met.”
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoHaving to take the freight elevator to your unfinished $20M apartment isn't suffering. These are spoiled brats grown up.
- tasuki 6y ago> Having to take the freight elevator to your unfinished $20M apartment isn't suffering. It might be? Suffering is entirely subjective... > These are spoiled brats grown up. Yes indeed.
- zimpenfish 6y agoWorks better if you say "...isn't suffering on a level the rest of us need to worry about", I think.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI know a lot of people hate the rich and are happy to see such misery befall them. But for many I think a residence here may have been something like a lifelong dream, and to have their money tied up in a condo that is repeatedly flooded sounds awful. Not to mention the stress and anxiety that comes with such situations. Homeowners with more modest homes will also know the pain and frustration if they have dealt with bad contractors or made a regrettable home purchase.
- cm2187 6y agoNoise is what turns me off from high rise residential buildings. When you watch the construction, many don’t event have concrete walls between apartments on the same floor, and I am ready to guess the concrete floors are as thin as required to keep the weight of the structure down. Add to that all-glass external walls, and I only heard stories from friends who live there that you hear everything your neighbours do, particularly walking on wooden floor.
- sershe 6y agoI think it's more typical for apartments.. I've only rented a concrete condo once (in Vancouver), and I distinctly remember getting out of the elevator and feeling like I just walked into a heavy metal concert, then getting into my unit next door to the source and hearing... nothing. It was pretty amazing. But the apartments at the same price point had no noise isolation.
- vineyardmike 6y agoI don't know where your friends lived, but I've lived in quite a few high rises (most recently 3 in seattle, built 2015, '17, '19) and the thing that draws me back to them is how I can NEVER hear my neighbors. The '19 has an awful lot of street noise, but the 17 was so silent it was incredible (and has the biggest windows).
- katbyte 6y agoDepends on the apartment and when it was built - you can do good or bad noise insulation. Live in a condo and never hear anyone on my floor, and once a month maybe? Sorta hear someone above me. Windows closed I head nothing from outside
- elyobo 6y agoAgreed, live on the 37th floor of a 45 floor building - it's not exactly high by these standards, but still decently high. Never hear side neighbours, every now and then I hear something quiet from upstairs. I used to rent here, the owner was selling, so we bought it instead of moving.
- 6y ago
- sam_bristow 6y agoIgnoring the content of the article for a second - how exactly was the author pronouncing that title in their head? Leeks creeks breeks? Lakes crakes brakes?
- mmanfrin 6y agoLeeks, Creaks, Breaks -- they're not all meant to rhyme. The last element is pronounced differently. I don't know what the term for it would be, but it's reminding me of 'Planes, Trains, and Automobiles'. Rhyme, Rhyme, Schema Deviation.
- napier 6y agoMy heart weeps and I’m reminded of the novel ‘Highrise’by J. G. Ballard.
- colordrops 6y agoI don't understand how anyone would want to live in a high rise. Rational or not, if feels dangerous to live high up in a narrow bottlenecked artificial construct.
- aerovistae 6y agoI feel the same way. A fire in a building like that would be inescapable.
- BoorishBears 6y agoWe had a fire about 10 floors above me in a 60 story building. Never even got an alarm for it. Modern building practices mean that it's not that easy for a fire to spread, and evacuating the entire building is a last resort. Every apartment has fire rated doors with a spring forcing them closed (so even if you leave in a panic the door will close behind you) The interior doors also seem pretty heavy to me, they don't have a fire rating placard but I wouldn't be surprised if they were picked with fire resistance in mind. I'm lowest worry is fire, highest is easily elevators. One day at my last building I hears a very loud crashing sound, look in the hallway and FDNY was cutting a hole in a wall to access a stuck elevator on a separate elevator bank... On one hand, the fact the failed elevator stopped is good, on the other whoever was inside probably had a truly awful time. M
- BrentOzar 6y agoQuick rundown of the advantages (I usually live in high-rises): High rises usually have spectacular shared amenities: grand pools, exercise rooms, party rooms, theaters, etc. One of mine had outdoor grilling areas that you didn't even have to clean up: the apartment had cleaning staff who would scour the grills every day. High rises usually have 24/7 door staff to sign for & lock up packages, get taxis, handle dry cleaning, store grocery deliveries in a fridge, and let you into your unit if you get locked out. The sheer number of units makes this cost-effective for them because the costs are shared across all tenants. High rises usually have maintenance staff during business hours and on call after hours to fix issues. Sometimes you can also hire them for handyman duties, too - I've had them install TVs, hang green screens, or paint a wall. High rises are often the only cost-effective way to live in the core of a really vibrant city like Chicago: we couldn't have afforded a town home, let alone a single family home.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yotamoron 6y agoSo, the super-rich have some issues with their 27th home? Oh, no! I truly couldn't care less.
- refurb 6y agoThat’s for letting HN know! Really fascinating stuff.
- EvilEy3 6y ago> The Downside to Life in a Supertall Tower: life in a supertall tower Ftfy.
- kelnos 6y agoThis is kinda a weird comment; I would find living in a supertall tower like that pretty cool, if not for the issues mentioned in the article... most, if not all, of which could have been designed around during construction if it'd been done right.
- choeger 6y ago> Initial findings showed that 73 percent of mechanical, electrical and plumbing components observed failed to conform with the developers’ drawings How is that even legal? Let alone technically possible? How does construction of these monsters work? "Yo, Bert, I need some 5x5 high-elastic steel framing for the 72th floor!" "Sorry man, we ran out of that when we 'redesigned' the elevator shaft, how about you take this plywood we should have used for the 68th floor?"
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoIt's going to get even better when the concrete starts spalling off in 40 years of swaying in the wind.
- pmontra 6y agoDo they use concrete in those towers or is it all steel?
- OJFord 6y agoGenerally concrete slabs form the rough shape of it, on top of a framework of steel. At least from what I see in the UK. I know NY & London do have, at very least historically but I assume now too, quite different heights and construction methods, due to differences in the geology.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoAll of the new thin supertall residential towers in NYC are reinforced concrete. It is incredibly stupid to allow such construction methods.
- vineyardmike 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- carrozo 6y agoThis feels like a powerful metaphor for the times we live in; over-promised and under-delivered; the value of image over reality; little emperors everywhere with no clothes. Would make a great film. :)
- tourist_ 6y agoI was thinking of buying one of these if my GME stonks had been short squeezed :)
- mech422 6y agoFoiled Again! :-)
- tamaharbor 6y agoUnion built for sure.
- VestingThrowawy 6y agoWhen did HN turned into Leninist Central?
- ksec 6y agoI submitted this for just to make another point for my own Reference. Turns out there are enough interest for it to get onto Front page :) For nearly 7 years, I have been asking the same question, Why Tall and Skinny? How far do the building Sway during High Wind? How do sound insulation work etc? And also the same question to Central Park Tower, Steinway Tower. SkyScrapper isn't new. But Tall and Skinny top to bottom SkyScrapper is very new ( to me at least ), and to make the matter worst this is Residential. It is one thing to work in such environment during the day, it is completely different having to stay and rest at night in one. The building would sway enough during High Wind and Cyclone you would get sea sick. And that is with the commercial building which tends to have a much larger / thicker base and lots of weight while adding massive damper. Sound / Noise insulation is also problematic because doing any of it would add weight. Central Park Tower, if I remember correctly, mentioned something about AWS and Cloud Computing meant they could do simulation that couldn't be done before! Technology has improved with better Material Science! And Steinway Tower is famous for its "tuned" mass damper. But again none to these are new. So whenever I have my own dose of skepticism, I was always met with people calling me idiots; "You think the Billionaires dont do their Due Diligence?" Having said that this article is only about 432 Park Avenue. Central Park Tower and Steinway Tower are still not completed. So may be they are really better with some "magic" technology improvement. I am just skeptical, and will have to wait and see.
- herendin 6y agoCompare property price to land price. Then consider that apartments need windows, so building footprint is limited
- tomatotomato37 6y agoI wonder if the old guard of mega skyscrapers like the Empire State or Chrysler suffered from these problems too, or it's just inherent to the new skinny towers popping up.
- baybal2 6y agoThey aren't that tall. 300m buildings are everywhere in China. Quite ordinary residentials are creeping on 200m. But 300m+ building all require very special engineering. Glazing designs for <300m building will not suit a 300m+ building. HVAC, water, and savage systems for supertall skyscrapers are still more or less a case, by case designs. I lived in a few quite tall 200+ buildings. Leaks seem to be unavoidable with curtain walls, and the only remedy is to have glazing engineers fixing them every year. Water supply is also finicky, and that's an inherent property of having so much apartments relying on a single pipe run. Booming noise in ventilation is possible to avoid with extra equipment, or simply solid vent shafts at extra cost, but I experienced it even in buildings with $1m+ apartments. So, I doubt construction companies will bother ever fixing this en masse. Sound insulation! Yes, there is no trick for it than thicker walls, and bigger gaps in between them, and it costs a lot, really a lot. You don't get it in highrises no matter the cost, unless it's being sold on this specifically.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Abimelex 6y agoat this point after a few years it would be probably very convenient to have a good insurance and a "random airplane" flying into the tower.
- yc-kraln 6y agoMy first house was a condo in a building which had been built about ~2 years before I moved in; I joined the board as the developer was transitioning out and handing over responsibility to the tenants. This sounds exactly like what happened with us, just on a grander scale. Things like the post-tensioned concrete construction where the steel post-tensioner cables were left exposed to the elements, severe life-safety issues, electronics and machines which died far too early from being under-spec'd and improperly installed. The developer, of course, had incorporated a new company just for the building, and it was super easy for them to let it go bankrupt. In the end we managed to recoup some costs, but had to raise everyone's fees to cover the reduced lifetime of some of the major structural elements of the building.
- nemo44x 6y agoIt’s interesting because I’ve heard from numerous people that work in construction that they would never buy into most of the new construction they worked on. Especially expensive condos in popular urban locations. Bare minimum construction that saves on both material and labor costs. Buy old and renovate has been something I’ve been told by various people.
- Breza 6y agoI absolutely love my ninety year old house. It's remarkably solid and there's no sound of settling or anything like that. Although apparently it was in vogue to put broken glass along fence lines during the eighties for security, which makes gardening adventurous...
- jberryman 6y agoI had a summer job in college with a real estate partnership that consisted entirely of filing unopened bills and liens into four different bins based on the project, each a different company that presumably was about to go bankrupt. The only time I saw the two owners was when I started and when the take me out to lunch when they abruptly (but not unexpectedly) let me go. At that meal one of the two was really excited about a new project: some turn-key restaurant idea, and how he'd only hire "hot waitresses".
- arminiusreturns 6y agoThe real juice here for those who want some good "conspiracy theory" level "connections everywhere" reading: CIM group. If you want to know about LA/NY real estate, political subterfuge (including PACs and pension funds), etc from the "how things really work" angle, just give them a search and read a few articles. Even more fun: try to guess what the name stands for.
- ksec 6y agoTurns out it wasn't easy to google what the name stands for. >The meaning of the three letters in CIM Group’s name is one of real estate’s best-kept secrets. But it might as well stand for Condos In Manhattan https://therealdeal.com/2016/12/13/manhattans-new-skyline-cim-group/ https://therealdeal.com/2016/12/13/manhattans-new-skyline-ci...
- asah 6y agoFor this reason, I don't buy new and instead buy in places that have been "burned in" and where I can talk with current and previous inhabitant(s) and read complaints online. If you have "that" kind of money, you can always remodel. Flipping it around, that due diligence can also result in amazing deals on places that non-engineers are too afraid to touch.
- Breza 6y agoAgreed all around, especially about due diligence. My wife found a house that had been on the market for months in a market where most houses were going under contract before we could get a tour. Description said it was "cozy and historic." Lots of warning signs. She booked a showing anyway. We dug did our due diligence and we've lived here happily for three years.
- dathinab 6y agoWhy do we even build (high) sky scrapers? IMHO they make no sense and only seem to exist because either broken local economies or people getting unhealthy obsessed with showing power. I.e. both things which should be fixed without sky scrapers. I mean sure "small" sky scrapers can make sense but there is a point where the additional cost and safety problems just by far outweigh any real benefits I believe. I mean (ignoring ground price) it's as far as I know much cheaper to build two 100m sky scrapers then building a single 200m sky scraper. So I would always prefer a view high but not supper high buildings over one or two super high buildings. I mean the moment it's no longer rentable to put (non super high end) apartments into most floors of a building it IMHO should generally not be build.
- Schiendelman 6y agoI’m seeing you fall into a common fallacy when discussing buildings. “Two buildings are cheaper than one” - sure, if you ignore the land, and all the processes of zoning, permitting, and construction management. If you want to understand all this better, start learning about those!
- dathinab 6y agoOuch, First I explicitly excluded the ground price so it should be obvious that I'm well aware of it. Second if zoning and permitting make it more economical to build buildings which on itself are fundamentally problematic than maybe zoning and permitting needs to be changed. Besides that the cost of construction management for one large building compared to multiple smaller buildings(1) should be larger because of additional requirements for material verification etc. due to having stricter requirements to materials and material quality which you simply don't have on smaller buildings. And sure as we can see from quite a bunch of (often by now older) sky scrapers the additional requirements where sometimes just ignored now leading to problems left and right. EDIT: Just to be clear if you make it multiple projects instead of one it can very well be more expensive. But building multiple smaller (but not small) houses as one project using mostly the same blueprints for all of them, using the same contractors, same workers etc. is altogether a different matter. EDIT2: The main drawback besides things like ground cost is the cost of creating a multiple fundaments. In turn simpler fundaments can normally be build but the cost can largely vary depending on the ground you are building on (like stability of the ground, ground water level etc.).
- zimpenfish 6y ago"Ms. Abramovich and her husband, Mikhail, retired business owners who worked in the oil and gas business" sounds like one of those phrases that legal has spent a couple of days working over.
- teslaberry 6y agomankind is still foolishly building towers that are taller and taller. USEABELE volume , not height , is what will determine which civilizations win the competitive struggle for existence over the next few thousand years. We haven't even begun to build our first true megastructures yet. and we are still probably 30-60 years away from sufficient technological convergence to make them functionally competitive with modern mega-cities like new york or hong kong. thing about that though, in 30-40 years we may have the technology to begin seriously designing a form of city that will make ALL other past cities, not merely obsolete, but quickly anachronistic. in 300-400 years from now , it is quite likely none of the major cities of our current world exist as 'dominant cities'. , at least in any recognizeable form. if at all.NONE of them. why? technological convergence of simulated reality with ever increasing methods of both engineering marvels, combined with software accounting systems that measure monitor and predict human suffering/pleasure as a function of living in a mega city for sustainable periods of time.