6 ms·
another example of "why don't you just"- the tendancy of technical people to tell other people technical people how to do their job better, without the necessar
by dekhn 6y ago
another example of "why don't you just"- the tendancy of technical people to tell other people technical people how to do their job better, without the necessary context to understand why it is a way (chesterton's fence).
- 300bps 6y agoAgree absolutely. It also reminds me of, “For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple and wrong.” I don’t know how people have the ego to think they’re going to study a problem for an hour or two and discover solutions that have eluded competent people that have spent their careers studying the problem.
- jiofih 6y agoIt’s much more complicated than that. Sometimes the people who start from scratch actually lead to real innovation while the scholars are stuck in their old world view. There is room for both types of exploration.
- koonsolo 6y agoI get your point. But that innovation comes from experts too, not someone who watched 10 YouTube videos on the subject. I would say most novices soon find out why things are done the way they are done. True innovation is really exceptional.
- toast0 6y agoI've run into all sorts of things in my career where competent people completely ignored parts of the problem. Someone, qualified or not, spending two hours studying the problems would apparently have been the first two hours spent; and to good use. Many times, I've stumbled across reports from other fields about solving problems in ways well known for their field, but unknown in mine that would apply well for some problems in my field. A (kindly worded) suggestion and reference from someone who thought to be helpful would be useful. Of course, some fences are Chesterton's fences, and some are just randomly placed fences in weird spots.
- kstenerud 6y agoChesterson's Fence is the act of DECIDING without knowing. There's nothing wrong with SUGGESTING without knowing. In fact, that's a very desirable thing. Different disciplines bumping into each other and making such suggestions is how great ideas and great solutions are hatched.
- Closi 6y agoI think there is another one to add to the list, which is assuming something is wrong without knowing enough about the problem to know why something is the way it is right now. E.g. Instead of telling a cat food company how much they would save with a different size, you could ask a company why they don't optimise for the lowest surface area, or if they have considered it. The first assumes you are right and they are wrong from the get go, while they are the domain experts. Really interesting dialogue though!
- kstenerud 6y agoAssuming wouldn't be a problem either. Since the person assuming is not in a position to decide policy, no harm can come of it, and possibly a benefit could result if he happens to be right.
- rgoulter 6y ago"Ask vs Guess" is one difference between people. Roughly, "it should always be okay to ask, since they can always just say no" vs "saying no is a bit awkward, so only ask for things if the answer is going to be yes". In terms of the above: Sure, the person doesn't have to apply the suggestions. But the only reason you'd make a suggestion is if you think something's wrong or could be improved. And suggesting something is wrong if it isn't is awkward. etc.
- Closi 6y agoI just think it's just good practice to remain humble, and consider that the people who own a giant tinned cat food packaging line just might know more about tinning cat food than you do, with your degree in maths, and frame the question as 'why do you not optimise to the minimum packing material?' rather than 'you should optimise to the minimum packing material'. I personally find that approaching problems with an attitude of "Why do you do it like that instead of like this?", or even "have you considered this?", usually provides more insight and a more collaborative discussion than "You should do it like this".
- lallysingh 6y agoI ask that all the time, but start with "Pardon my ignorance" or "I know you must have good reason, but..."
- t0mas88 6y agoThat's also a useful managment tool. I often ask "Uninhibited by any actual knowledge, I would think X is the easier solution, what's the real story?" A competent team will either explain why things are the way they are or give you an improved version of X that may be faster than what they had you if you're willing to accept the associated limitations. Often that dialogue on limitations is valuable because the client facing people may know some things about what limitations can be accepted without client impact and are thus good choices.
- mark-r 6y agoI did that just yesterday with a comment here on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26044548 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26044548
- LanceH 6y agoYour post is an example of attributing to technical people the bad habits of all people. Much like, "engineers are bad at business" -- people in general are bad at business. Every person out there has a brilliant idea that just needs to be implemented (by someone else), fitting nicely into the "why don't they just". Engineers are conspicuously good at something and then it's fun to make fun of them, but I don't think their behavior in this regard is any different than anyone else, except that they may more frequently give thought to solving something.
- rm445 6y agoIt's interesting to see this exchange, though, because it's high-trust: I would bet the professor's initial letter was courteously written, and asked if there were other factors besides purely surface area to volume. The responder wrote a clear technical letter without any marketing flim-flam. We are in a golden age of communication in some sense, with blogs and technical online communities. But I could hardly imagine getting a letter from a corporation of this quality.
- h_anna_h 6y ago> the tendancy of technical people to tell other people technical people how to do their job better "why don't you just" is a question, and if they had not asked said question they (as well as the readers of their book) would not know the (right) answer to it.
- tshaddox 6y agoIt’s clearly phrased with the implication that the person has never thought of doing it the way the speaker is suggesting.
- Closi 6y agoWhy don't the IDIOTS at Heinz just make goddamn spherical ketchup?! Everyone knows that a perfectly spherical ball would reduce the amount of packing material per ml of ketchup yet they are just closing their ears and not listening to the maths. And don't get me started on the cereal box people... THEY SHOULD BE CUBES. And I'm looking at you water bottles - if you were all cubes too don't you realise how you could nest to avoid air during shipping? They could have cut outs in the bases for lids... Idiots everywhere! I'm going back to my car. It runs on petrol because the idiots in engineering haven't worked out it could just run on hydrogen yet. (All the above have reasons for being the way they are, and I think it's usually a good idea to understand why something is the way it is before you try to change it)
- h_anna_h 6y agoI can't see this post as anything but a strawman. Yeah, let's presume that they insulted them and even slapped them before they made that question, why not.
- Closi 6y agoIt's implied. What if someone that had no idea about programming came over and told you that you could program faster if you used a for loop, without ever reading your code? They probably think I suck at programming, or think a bit too much of themselves. This is a mathematician telling canned packaging experts that they could save money by considering the size of the can.
- grumple 6y agoSometimes it’s important to answer those questions: it spreads knowledge and generates trust in the expertise of the person being asked. Sometimes the suggestion might actually be a good one, too.
- renewiltord 6y agoIt's strange. Almost everyone I know in real life, when told "Why don't you just do X instead of Y" treats it enthusiastically as a chance to share some nuance about their field. Two instances recently come to mind, my asking my father (an orthopaedic trauma surgeon) why we don't just make hips (in total hip replacement) out of dead people's bone instead of out of whatever material they do now, and my father's asking me something about why blue LEDs are supposedly so hard (why don't you just wrap them in blue film). On the Internet, everyone is always like "you guys always think you can do our job better!". In real life, everyone is always like "hmm, that's interesting. Let me explain why". But perhaps it's just everyone I know. I saw this the other day too in another HN comment⁰ where people assume that "Why don't you just" and questions like that are demeaning. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25826835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25826835
- zebnyc 6y agoI presume this has to do with how you frame the question and the recipient perceives your intent.
- renewiltord 6y agoI'm sure I agree, but surely there is something to how so many commentators here clearly immediately assume that the Prof's question must have been framed so that the best interpretation is condescending.
- tompccs 6y agoAbsolutely - in fact in 2021 you might even be accused of mansplaining, when actually the purpose of asking these questions is to genuinely learn more about why the world works the way it does! (And of course there are the occasional examples of genuine insights gained from having a fresh perspective - I remember reading about Alan Sugar discovering that he could make satellite dishes for a tenth of the cost by contracting the manufacture out to a bin lid factory)
- kelnos 6y ago