17 ms·
Fecal transplant turns cancer immunotherapy non-responders into responders
- f430 6y agoWhat exactly is a fecal transplant?? This isnt the first time I heard of this technique and it seems to have wide reaching effectiveness.
- TylerE 6y agoIt's what it sounds like. They take feces from one person, and then place it into the gut of the recipient, either via enema or a tube down the nose and through the stomach.
- f430 6y agowhoa thats what I suspected but hoped it was just a small transfer via probe...omg but I guess its quite effective in multiple medical papers I've read
- TylerE 6y agoAs transplants go, it's not even in the same state, never mind ballpark, as any other. No slicing you open, no lifetime of immunosuppressing anti-rejection drugs...
- giarc 6y agoThey actually halted a random control trial at one point since the treatment arm was so successful it was unethical to continue and not provide treatment to all.
- gus_massa 6y agoI can't read the paper now. How many persons were in the control group and how many in the intervention group?
- giarc 6y agoI don't think the paper is paywalled. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1205037 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1205037
- gus_massa 6y ago>>> They actually halted a random control trial [...] Thanks, but I misunderstood and though that you were commenting about the current treatment against cancer.
- tyingq 6y agoI wonder why there isn't an easy way to do it with a time-release coating/capsule. Edit: Apparently there is...they are called "FMT Capsules".
- war1025 6y agoI'm really not sure whether I'd rather have a poop enema or willingly swallow poop even if contained in a capsule. I would guess it's "possible" but also there is probably a lot of logistics involved in "take my poop and put it into your guts". Back fifteen or so years ago I saw a video somewhere talking about some people doing this to help with an immune condition. What I remember was basically, "We put my poop in a blender with some water to thin it out, and then they stick a tube up their butt and pour that in" Sounded like it wasn't just a one time deal, more something that needed to happen on a regular basis.
- giarc 6y agoI replied to the same comment, but to your point about willingly swallow poop pills, I've been there when many patients are tasked with taking this. I'd say patients have no issue with the pills since it typically means they've had debilitating diarrhea for 6 months or longer if they are at the FMT stage. When I was involved, the treatment was around 20-30 pills in one go. The hardest part for most was the amount of water they drank trying to swallow that many pills at once. One guy we treated had IBS and had been taking pills all his life. He downed the 30 pills in like 5 minutes and was done. He came back the next day and said he had never felt better in 20 years. For some, it's like a miracle drug.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> I'm really not sure whether I'd rather have a poop enema or willingly swallow poop even if contained in a capsule. Whats really disgusting is that your insides are already full of poop cause thats where its made.
- war1025 6y ago> already full of poop cause thats where its made. Your intestines are full of poop. Your stomach isn't full of poop. Your throat and mouth aren't full of poop. Vomiting is very unpleasant. Vomit isn't poop. The thought of poop in your mouth is very unpleasant. I really don't understand how a comment stating, "I really think it would be a toss-up for me which method I would prefer" is down-voted through the floor.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- umvi 6y agoIt's exactly what it sounds like... when you put someone else's poop up your butt
- Engineering-MD 6y agoIt is generally an oral supplement rather than a reveal suppository.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoIt's exactly what it sounds like... when you eat someone else's poop under the supervision of a team of physicians
- samstave 6y agoGo on....
- _Microft 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_feces#Fecal_transplants https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_feces#Fecal_transplants
- stickydink 6y agoExactly what it sounds like. Fecal matter from a healthy person, transplanted into the GI system of an unhealthy person. Benefits come from all the "good bacteria" living in there that are missing. YouTube has some deliciously informative videos if you'd like to watch a real surgery!
- samstave 6y ago" deliciously informative videos" I don't think that's the correct phrasing for this particular subject...
- PointyFluff 6y agoUh...there's no surgery involved.
- stickydink 6y agoI'm not incredibly familiar, but I watched some of those tasty videos I referenced. It certainly looked like there was somebody in there unconscious, with a Dr gowned up. Tubes and cameras and robot arms inserting various things. Depends where you draw the line at surgery VS procedure, does something have to be cut? Who knows! Either way, I recommend not DIY'ing this one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 1337shadow 6y agoSee full procedure details in 20 seconds here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKX2afmgcEM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mKX2afmgcEM
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoI don't want to watch that video.
- nathancahill 6y agoI knew exactly which video this was before clicking.
- programmarchy 6y ago> Davar and colleagues collected fecal samples from patients who responded extraordinarily well to anti-PD-1 immunotherapy and tested for infectious pathogens before giving the samples, through colonoscopy, to advanced melanoma patients who had never previously responded to immunotherapy. The patients were then given the anti-PD-1 drug pembrolizumab. And it worked. It's pretty crazy that your gut biome can change the way your body responds to skin cancer treatment. Could this work for basically anything immune-related? Maybe people who got COVID but were asymptomatic could donate some poop.
- samstave 6y agoThe question I have is how to evaluate the 'proper?' gut biome / fecal "recipe" to get the desired outcome?/Expression? So what characteristics would a good vs bad donor gut biome/fecal biome be?
- Bjartr 6y ago> The question I have is how to evaluate the 'proper?' gut biome / fecal "recipe" to get the desired outcome?/Expression? You and the rest of the medical community. This is largely still an open question.
- tharkun__ 6y agoThis is something that I've been thinking for quite some time now (i.e. pre-COVID and just generally health related). I was on lots of anti-biotics as a kid and I turned from skinny to fat at some point. We know already from experiments/treatments being made that fecal transplants can make a fat person skinny for example (no I didn't do that :)) Personally I transformed my life from being very lethargic and not being able to tolerate anything but small amounts of certain foods and also alcoholic beverages without getting major migraines by getting the right probiotics. To give you an idea, eating leftover lasagna two days in a row was a sure fire way to get a migraine, as was drinking a bottle of alcohol-free beer and anything with alcohol was even worse. Even just small amounts. We're talking migraines where you feel like you're gonna puke and my eyesight was affected as well. I felt really sick for about 2 weeks after starting the right probiotics. And it wasn't just any probiotics that would do. I tried out different ones, until I found a specific one that mainly differs in one bacterium from all the others I tried. Bacillus subtilis in case you're wondering. During that time my then current microbiome would've been fighting with the newly introduced strains. After that, I was no longer lethargic and slowly but surely I was able to tolerate foods in normal quantities again. Leftover lasagna is just awesome now, like it should be! So yeah that's just a personal anecdote on how gut health can really eff up your life and health. So I can very well believe that people with a 'broken gut' would die more easily from COVID or get infected more easily with other things as well. But where's the money in simply fixing peoples guts? Isn't it 'better' if we make them sick, so we can then prescribe them stuff?
- TeaDrunk 6y agotl;dr: In a proof-of-concept phase 2 trial, researchers transplanted gut bacteria from patients who responded extraordinarily strongly to immunotherapy into the gut of patients who are completely nonresponsive to the therapy. N = 15, with 6 people experiencing reduction of tumors or stabilization. It's definitely not a silver bullet... I feel like we still don't understand enough about the mechanisms surrounding the gut flora. This is flailing in the dark. Fingers crossed these results encourage more research into the biological chemistry behind this.
- wrinkl3 6y ago> N = 15 I'm not a scientist but isn't that a tiny sample?
- jhbadger 6y agoAs an author on the paper, that's reality. We'd all like cohorts with hundreds or thousands of people, but that's just not how things work in reality.
- xvilka 6y agoIt will take decades if not more just to classify all bacteria, protists, viruses, etc who live in human gut. Even more to understand personal differences, mechanisms of influencing human immunity and behavior.
- rubatuga 6y agoStuff like this motivated me to do a minor in Immunology during university. And we still have no idea what is going on.
- silexia 6y agoI had a business idea a few years ago to do fecal transplants from famous people as a new LA business. There seems to be a lot of regulatory hurdles for doing it though. I would love to see someone do this both in disease treatment, as well as just to test out impact on things like mental or athletic performance.
- klmadfejno 6y agoWhat exactly was the rational behind that?
- gambiting 6y agoI mean, if people are willing to pay money for Gwyneth Paltrow's vagina eggs or Twitch streamer's bath water, I can only imagine the small fortune people would pay for a bacteria transplant from a famous person, even if it had no effect whatsoever(you can always craft a cleverly worded ad that suggests there are benefits but never actually states so as a fact).
- klmadfejno 6y agoIt would have an effect though. That's a direct alteration to your gut microbiome. I guess, sure, fetishists are a thing. But I'm not sure it's a viable target market haha.
- gambiting 6y agoYou could probably sterilise it so there's absolutely no live anything remaining and people would still buy it. But yes, it's probably a tough market :-P
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ExcavateGrandMa 6y agoOkay dudes, now you know what you have to do if you feeling short with money :D SELL YOUR FRESH CRAPs :D
- mechnesium 6y agoEdit: Not medical advice. Cancer is largely a failure of the immune system, and it is well known that nearly 70% of the immune system lives in the digestive tract. Sometimes the microbiome in that digestive tract gets messed up, paving the way to bowel issues, autoimmune disorders, general illness, and cancer. Studies have even shown that poor gut health is linked to many mental health issues such as depression and autism. Populating the digestive tract with healthy microbes from another person is a good way to jumpstart it again. I’ve actually done probiotic and fecal transplant enemas at home and put my UC into remission without the need for steroidal or anti-inflammatory medications. It can be easily done using standard enema equipment, healthy donor stool, saline and oral loperamide to increase efficacy. Expect to be able to fill the rectum, ascending, transverse, and descending colon. There are big risks to this, especially if you are immunocompromised. Most people will want advice or support from a doctor.
- leptoniscool 6y agoWow that's amazing! One reason that I suspect these therapies aren't more widely used is the lack of funding. Big pharmaceutical companies have millions to spend on R&D and also fund studies.
- mechnesium 6y agoYeah. Admittedly, I was frustrated with having to rely on $1000+ a month prescriptions to treat my symptoms rather than the underlying cause. My venture into researching the human microbiome and homemade enemas was sprinkled with “danger” and “don’t try this at home.” Being riddled with daily bouts of diarrhea caused by my UC, I wasn’t go to just sit idly by. Enema kits are sold in grocery stores and are perfectly safe if not used regularly. There was simply no reason for me to believe that breaking open some probiotic capsules or putting a little poop in that enema is going to kill me. More than likely, toxic megacolon or colon cancer is going to kill me if I didn’t take the risk. I consider myself a body hacker, having experimented with nootropics for many years before. Hacking of any kind involves some level of risk, and it’s risks that I’m willing to take to become better.
- surfsvammel 6y ago
- qzw 6y agoThe procedure seems to have all kinds of benefits, but I think the name could've really used some of the good ol' marketingspeak. I bet a lot more people would be open to getting something like a "digestive microbiome transfer" than the more accurate but gross "fecal transplant".
- ghgdynb1 6y agoYou may have a gift
- leptoniscool 6y agoYou're right a lot of things has benefited from rebranding. For example instead of 'cow feet juice', it's now Jello.
- TheMagicHorsey 6y agoOMG! This is the worst TIL of my entire life. I eat a shameful amount of Jello as an adult, and I did not know this!
- throwaway316943 6y agoIt’s good for you
- surfsvammel 6y agoHacker news is one of the places where I often value the comments more than the linked articles themselves. But wow. This thread is full of pseudo-science type reasoning. Let’s be careful. We have science and the scientific methods to investigate things like this. It’s worked very well for us for a long time, let’s try to have som faith in it.
- ngngngng 6y agoIsn't all science "pseudo-science type reasoning" before someone goes out and proves/disproves it? I don't see a problem with some curious conversation.
- tkzed49 6y agothere's nothing wrong with sharing anecdotes, but it's not science until someone actually does the "proving/disproving" in a convincing way.
- surfsvammel 6y agoWell, it might be wrong to share anecdotes, IMO. We should always be careful when communicating online as we don’t know who we might be communicating with. Someone might take those anecdotes as proof that something works, and might go out and do something that might not be safe.
- surfsvammel 6y agoNo. There is difference. Science works by making observations, making hypothesis and then testing those. The result is some kind of knowledge which is useful for making predictions. Reasoning in this world is based on that. We only make predictions when something is tested, established or pure fact. What I mean by pseudo-science type reasoning is; not based on any fact, nor any position which has been tested (scientifically), nor any established knowledge. Instead it is often based on anecdotes or the reason is motivated or heavily biased. Frankly, I don’t care too much about bad reasoning. But when there is risk that it might be understood as recommendations, and it might be unsafe for someone reading it, then I think it’s dangerous.
- jonplackett 6y agoHoly shit! That’s amazing.
- PointyFluff 6y agoSo awesome. So gross.
- Vaslo 6y agoI just can’t even fathom having an original idea like this and then even more so having it work. Who thinks of this shit?
- fastball 6y ago> Who thinks of this shit? Heh.
- poopcrusader 6y agoThere’s been information about the power of FMT floating around out there for a while now. I’m convinced that pharmaceutical corporations have nothing to benefit from more effective treatments, which could largely be why we see smaller players doing these types of honorable and groundbreaking studies. One study I’d love to see is the effect of treated tap water on our microbiome. If tap water is designed to kill micro-organisms, what could it be doing inside us?
- feanaro 6y agoGiven that there's a large body of work detailing the importance of the gut microbiome, which has effects on everything from cognition to the immune system, it wasn't as huge a stretch as it might seem. Perhaps only when you're not aware of the incremental progress so it may seem as a huge leap.
- jb1991 6y agoThe article states that an AI algorithm directed the researchers to gut bacteria.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bluSCALE4 6y agoHow about calling it the anti-douche. Who wouldn't want an anti-douche.
- billiam 6y agoWill I now be obligated to yell at someone who cuts me off on the freeway "Eat sh%t and DON'T die?"
- danans 6y agoNow that's not too shitty an outcome!
- npsimons 6y agoI'm curious if you could get the same effects by changing your diet, and what that diet is. I suspect this is at the bottom of all gut microbiome "problems", and furthermore that any fecal transplant will only have temporary effects if one continues to have a bad diet.
- kbelder 6y agoI think antibiotics can cause a lot of problems. You get strep throat, take antibiotics, and it kills off something in your gut you've had all your life. How do you get it back? Eat yogurt? That's nonsense. There are supplements that supposedly help rebuild your intestinal flora, but I'm pretty skeptical that they work. So a bad diet can definitely kick your microbiome out of whack, but I don't think that's the only cause.
- npsimons 6y ago> So a bad diet can definitely kick your microbiome out of whack, but I don't think that's the only cause. True, but I think it's just one of those truths people know but don't want to hear: a baseline of good health is behaviors/habits that boost it, and that includes things like getting enough good sleep, adequate exercise and a diet that is not just enough food (not too little and not too much), but the right kind of food. If we're going to go down the path of judging some gut flora as "better" than others, it behooves us to discover how to get those gut flora, and it only makes sense a large part of that is what we ingest. And yeah, I'm opposed to overuse of antibiotics too. In the same vein, fecal transplants seem like a quick fix that might be justifiable (ie cancer cases), but shouldn't be seen as a "get out of jail free card" for bad habits.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jlizzle30 6y agoAs an anecdote, I'm close to someone who had issues w/ their microbiome causing havoc for a year after taking antibiotics. They tried all kinds of diet and probiotic treatments to no avail. In desperation, a doctor prescribed an experimental approach where they'd take antibiotics again to kill the 'bad bacteria', then go on a heavy probiotic regimen. This worked thank god.
- MikeLumos 6y agoCould you share the specific antibiotics and probiotics they've used?
- crawdog 6y agoThere has been a recent paper published around treatment of melanoma cancer with positive results as well. Interesting to see how the research in this area progresses. Hopefully making more of these devastating cancers more treatable. https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6529/602 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/371/6529/602
- ChuckMcM 6y agoWhen a possible link between gut biomes and disease progression was first proposed, the response by the established science was pretty harsh. That people studying these links persisted and have created many reproducible experiments that demonstrate the connection is a testament both to perseverance and to science. When people try to argue that science is "people making things up." as a reason for disbelieving science that challenges their beliefs, I use this example of fecal transplants as a real world case of how scientists challenge, confront, debate, and incorporate changes into their world views through process, review, and reproduction.
- quercusa 6y agoSame story for bacteria and stomach ulcers.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoAnd I know at least one researcher who started looking more deeply into the impact of the gut biome on health because of the demonstrated link between bacteria and ulcers. At some point, I would expect a fecal sample/biome to be part of one's periodic physical so that we could build a data set of biomes + medical history database that is a bit more comprehensive than the voluntary ones that exist today.
- mirekrusin 6y agoIs that true? Hitler was doing it, so it must have been known for a while.
- tartoran 6y agoI wonder if it could be simply inserted into the other end instead of being swallowed. Perhaps a suppository would do?
- byset 6y agoSays in the writeup that the transplant is done "through colonoscopy" so it is "inserted in the other end", right? I have heard of fecal transplants being effective administered orally via capsule. Though that might be a bitter pill to swallow, I might prefer it to the other route...
- tartoran 6y agoSorry, I skimmed through and didn’t get the colonoscopy part. I guess the bitter pill to swallow is no longer part of the practice though easier than a colonoscopy it was just grossing me out.
- hinkley 6y agoGiven all the weird shi... phrasing... stuff that has happened with performance enhancing drugs I have to wonder if there aren’t some sports doctors out there who know a bit more about this stuff than they’re letting on...
- LinuxBender 6y agoI hope that some day they break down the science in this method to find the exact cultures that are providing benefit. Many performance athletes already use probiotics rectally and are said to gain advantages from doing so. I've only seen limited scientific papers on the topic and more often anecdotal responses from athletes. Well now I have a weekend research project.
- im3w1l 6y agoIs immunotherapy orally administered? Could it be simply changing the absorption efficiency?
- bdauvergne 6y agoDoes not seem so new, https://science.sciencemag.org/content/359/6371/91 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/359/6371/91 .
- jb1991 6y agoSo the core idea in this study was actually determined by an algorithm to focus their attention: > Artificial intelligence linked these changes to the gut microbiome, likely caused by FMT.
- FMT_throwaway 6y agoMeanwhile, offering high quality FMT transplants is a huge startup opportunity. People who need FMT are very sick, desperate, and willing to pay thousands of dollars to get it done. Recently, I have spent $2000 to order poop from the internet. Finding a high quality doctor is extremely difficult for a normal person. You have to find someone who is young, athletic, very healthy, never taken antibiotics, and then do some medical tests on them (pretty much everything that's wrong with a person can be transferred through FMT). Finding such person, bringing up the subject with them, and getting them agree to help is very hard. A company who could find and screen high quality FMT donors could make thousands of dollars just selling poop. Hundreds, if you're willing to drop prices to help people. All you have to do is find a healthy person who matches the criteria, and spend $2000-$3000 doing a number of blood/stool tests (and retest them every few months). Also figure out how to freeze/package/ship the transplants in a way that does the least harm to the microbes. If you are a healthy person who fits the description (or know someone who is), and are willing to help - please send me an email - fmthelp@protonmail.com
- ska 6y ago> Finding a high quality doctor is extremely difficult I'm pretty sure you meant "donor" there, no?
- monoideism 6y agoI think it would be helpful here to describe how very sick people looking for a fecal transplant usually are. And also how - even though it's only been clinically approved for Clostridium difficile infections - there are also controlled data that indicate it's effective for other intestinal illnesses.
- NolF 6y ago> never taken an antibiotic I understand recent antibiotic use such as past 12-24 months, but never?
- patmcc 6y agoThis is still an under researched field (with a lot of alternative medicine types surrounding it), but there have been some studies that even relatively minor antibiotic usage in childhood may have long-term impacts. And there are more (and better) studies that gut flora isn't back to normal 6 months after a course of antibiotics. It's something of an open question currently. It seems like there may be a few stable microbiomes that can develop in humans; some are better than others for health.
- jariel 6y agoIt seems like an outrageously simple and fundamental thing, to the point wherein one might wonder how many other positive things could be achieved - and - why on earth some people have such a deficit. Could it be diet, exercise, other things? If this response turns out to be valid, in that fecal transplants materially affect these kinds of therapies ... it would seem to me that we need to spend a few $Billion researching this immediately, the potential outcomes for relatively non-invasiveness ... seems like massive ROI opportunity.
- fuzzfactor 6y agoWho needs fecal transplants when you've got splashback from shared toilets?
- hntrader 6y agoIt's also being studied as a treatment for autism: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/04/190409093725.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/04/190409093725.h...
- lliamander 6y agoI actually know someone who is going through immunotherapy (for leukemia) and so suddenly this kind of news is quite a bit more relevant than just a interesting factoid. Thankfully this person seems to be responding to therapy, but it makes me wonder whether they will end up benefiting from microbiome therapy in the future.
- sircastor 6y agoMy sister got to move to immunotherapy after years of cancer treatment. It has been very effective. Anecdotally, I have learned that immortality tends to be effective, and less hard on patients than other types of cancer treatment, but is held off because insurance providers don’t want to pay for it.
- 8bitsrule 6y ago"Out of 15 advanced melanoma patients who received the combined FMT and anti-PD-1 treatment, six showed either tumor reduction or disease stabilization..." It's a clue, at least. So much we don't know.
- ricc 6y agoThey know about The Spice Melange! the spiiiccee
- throwaway420-69 6y agoI heard about this on south park