61 ms·
IBM has cut its blockchain team down to almost nothing – sources
- skywhopper 6y agoTurns out, blockchain is not actually a solution to all that many problems. All the things that make it work for Bitcoin are big downsides in most other contexts.
- Pet_Ant 6y agoThe core concept is being trustless. Any situation where only trusted parties are going to be present... litterally defeats the purpose. There is a lot of mechanism that is only justified in being trustless. I could image block chain could be useful if you had digital cash off-grid, like a food truck that visited a logging camp. Collect the transactions, and then validate them when you get back to town/within signal range.
- m3kw9 6y agoSure where are the actual apps that are used widely?
- gruturo 6y agoOr, any concept where the centralized trusted ledger is bulletproof, but you can't be sure that the data entered is any good. You may as well not bother with the whole thing.
- MrMan 6y agoI want more trust not less
- iso8859-1 6y agoBut what do you want to trust in? Your fellow citizen? Luck in hashing? If you wanna trust your fellow citizen: You could go down on the street and deposit your cash with strangers walking by. If you wanna trust luck in hashing: You should be mining Bitcoin. If you are lucky, every single attempt at mining a block will be successful. You'd become rich pretty fast.
- bena 6y agoSo what happens when a transaction doesn't validate?
- tomku 6y agoValidate them when you get to town... and find that you just donated lunch to a bunch of clever loggers who knew you could not check the validity of their payments until hours after they ate the food you gave them. You seem to have a very strange definition of "trustless."
- Pet_Ant 6y agoIt’s like a clearinghouses with stock shorts. You eat the few times it happens. Cost of doing business, like charge backs on credit cards.
- anon98356 6y agoOr you could use a standard card machine that has an included transaction buffer. I remember having these in my retail gig 15 years ago for the odd time the network went down (happened pretty much every christmas season)
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoIs there an example of a blockchain implementation that is tried and true outside of cryptocurrency? I remember seeing when large tech firms were jumping on the bandwagon and proposing things that blockchain could do. Everyone was like "so, that problem has already been solved for years with X, blockchain provides no advantages".
- teepo 6y agofrom the article: "Big Blue’s major blockchain networks are FoodTrust, a farm-to-supermarket tracking system backed by Walmart; and TradeLens, a shipping container logistics blockchain backed by Maersk. IBM has also added the Trust Your Supplier network and previously had a go at payments via World Wire."
- perardi 6y agoIs there any analysis out there about how well these systems work, and why a blockchain works better than a traditional inventory management system? All I can find on these implementations are by blockchain startups who have a pretty obvious interest in making blockchain solution look good. But…how is this better than a good old database? They say “trust”, and I guess that’s true in the sense you can verify the changes to the ledger. But isn’t the lack of trust in the original producers? How is it more trustworthy if they catalog this with a blockchain versus a database?
- x86_64Ubuntu 6y agoBut since IBM is canning the blockchain group, it's safe to say that those implementations are far from tried-and-true.
- arsome 6y agoThere's some really cool stuff going on in the distributed storage space thanks to this - blockchains have provided a way to pay for, prove you've stored data and provide collateral should you fail to store it, establishing the whole contract without the need for a centralized party, allowing anyone to sell excess storage. Sia is probably the most mature implementation at the moment, but there's a number of competitors in the space. But as you can see even this is pretty cryptocurrency adjacent. For anything that doesn't rely on distributed trust you're much better off making a database, perhaps with a hash chain glued to it if you need to prevent reversion.
- dralley 6y agoProbably for the best. > IBM is now 100% focused on hybrid cloud, so everything that doesn’t support that is deprioritized.
- superbcarrot 6y agoI wonder what happens when hybrid cloud doesn't work out. Also, what about AI and quantum - are they also getting dropped in favor of hybrid cloud?
- 908B64B197 6y agoI don't think there's any AI at IBM. As for Quantum, I can see it being very lucrative as they'll end up licensing their patents.
- rrdharan 6y ago> I don't think there's any AI at IBM. A dozen misinformed CTOs who signed large Watson checks just felt a great disturbance...
- pasttense01 6y agoWatson. "How IBM Watson Overpromised and Underdelivered on AI Health Care" https://spectrum.ieee.org/biomedical/diagnostics/how-ibm-watson-overpromised-and-underdelivered-on-ai-health-care https://spectrum.ieee.org/biomedical/diagnostics/how-ibm-wat...
- peterkelly 6y agoFebruary 2024: "IBM has cut its hybrid cloud team down to almost nothing – sources"
- bonzini 6y agoQuantum computers are going to be so expensive that they are unlikely to be on premises. So it does fit hybrid cloud.
- zaat 6y ago
- ToJans 6y agoIn my experience - I have done a lot of pre-sales for an IT service company - the use case for blockchain can usually be solved with classical, cheaper and simpler solutions by having a central trusted authority for storage (like a third-party service provider), and appending using digital signatures. For me personally, blockchain is a solution looking for a problem in most cases...
- RicoElectrico 6y agoIndeed - a blockchain only makes sense in decentralized trustless proof-of-X systems. Everything else could be a Git repository or variation thereof (commit chain vs blockchain).
- Qub3d 6y agoSpecifically, a Merkle tree[0], which is the hash tree root of both Git and most blockchains. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merkle_tree
- zapdrive 6y agoIn other news, water is wet. Obviously!!!! Blockchain has earned a bad name because of sales people trying to sell it for something it can't do. Blockchain is a very very very inefficient database that removes the need for a central trust authority. That's it's only selling point. You don't need it if you are storing your customer data in a central database.
- chadash 6y agoThis. How many real use cases are there where you really need to distribute trust? For currency, there's some sense in it. But when i hear things like using blockchain for contracts or for keeping track of supply chain... it always seems like what people really want is just a well organized and reasonably trustworthy third party who can handle this stuff. Does anyone have any specific examples where blockchain would be a better solution?
- diegocg 6y agoEvery once in a while people rediscovers asymmetric cryptography, and try to apply it to EVERYTHING while ignoring the difficulties of PKI. Meanwhile in the real world we still don't have E2E encrypted email by default fire everybody.
- bob33212 6y agoI have plenty of criticism of the blockchain hype, but IBM does this for all buzzwords regardless of how useful the underlying technology is. It is all marketing to get executives at large companies to cut large checks. Once those checks are cashed they drop everyone and move on to the next buzzword. The current buzzword is hybrid cloud. Which is awesome for IBM because most large companies already have some on-prem and cloud resources. So IBM inserts a bunch of people into existing processes and resources and claims credit for creating a hybrid cloud for their customers.
- zzzeek 6y agoRed Hat employee here. Contrary to your "inserts a bunch of people" characterization, IBM wanted to get into hybrid cloud so they acquired Red Hat in one of the largest tech acquisitions in history, and we create hybrid clouds for our customers. As we are part of IBM now, IBM is in fact providing hybrid cloud to its customers from start to finish in a substantive way. So there's really no comparison to be made to technologies for which IBM has not made substantive investment.
- jaywalk 6y agoI don't think the OP was claiming that IBM doesn't create hybrid clouds, because they clearly do. But "hybrid cloud" is definitely a buzzword right now.
- zzzeek 6y agoSure it's a "buzzword" but OP was claiming "Once those checks are cashed they drop everyone and move on to the next buzzword", as though IBM does not have substantive capabilities and investment in the hybrid cloud area. This is the opposite of reality. The phrase "inserts a bunch of people into existing processes and resources and claims credit " suggests IBM is not actually providing the service as well, also not the reality.
- monsieurbanana 6y agoI somehow missed/forgot IBM bought Red Hat. Reading OP's comment, I certainly didn't had the impression we were talking about a 34 billion dollars acquisition.
- m3kw9 6y agoIs there a wide spread use yet as much as transferring currency?
- intotheabyss 6y agoDecentralized finance
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Taek 6y agoIBM having a blockchain team makes about as much sense as Nintendo having a self driving car team.
- zzzeek 6y ago> Nintendo having a self driving car team. im sorry that makes TOTAL sense, where can I buy one?
- mrcartmenez 6y agoMario Cart is self driving on the easiest settings. So there’s that
- bena 6y agoIt does it in a different way though. The AI in Mario Kart knows the track, including obstacles, it doesn't have to really navigate based on input.
- agumonkey 6y agoSuper /VES
- GizmoSwan 6y agoBlock chain is just a frozen link list database. It has its uses and every big software company has it and can offer it. It can support all sort of permanent registry stuff and protect against tampering.
- seibelj 6y agoEnterprise blockchain only makes sense if you have multiple industry partners that don't trust each other, compete, but agree standardization on protocols make sense. But even if you get to that point, probably you don't need blockchain, although the buzzword may help decision-makers approve the standardization project. That said I am enormously bullish on the crypto / blockchain space. Decentralized finance just makes so much sense. But I am an individualist and a strong believer in decentralization, so that biases me. We are still in very, very early days, but what has been accomplished has been incredible, and you see it reflected in the prices of major assets like BTC and ETH but if you care to look deeper beneath the prices and actually see the tech, what's going on in the Ethereum space is incredible.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoThe average Bitcoin transaction fee right now is $15, up almost 3000% from a year ago. I can’t really imagine any database that cost you $15 a transaction and took 10 minutes to commit/confirm. Bitcoin is, was, and will probably forever be about low transaction wealth storage.
- allie1 6y agoMore a - still somewhat anonymous crime method of payment, cheap/easy way to move money across borders, an easy way to fund things that should not be funded. Ref: https://www.coindesk.com/north-korea-stole-2-billion-in-crypto-and-fiat-to-fund-weapons-programs https://www.coindesk.com/north-korea-stole-2-billion-in-cryp... Ref: https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-is-aiding-the-ransomware-industry https://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-is-aiding-the-ransomware-in... Would love to see what good it has done so far.
- allie1 6y agoSo downvotes and no comments? Nice
- epinephrinios 6y ago$2B only? That's peanuts. Look at your beloved fiat currency: https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/industry/financial%20services https://violationtracker.goodjobsfirst.org/industry/financia... And of course, this is not a full account of all the dirty fiat transactions. At least with Bitcoin, those transactions would be public forever.
- allie1 6y agoHow about a time relative comparison? Fiat has been around for how long? In what quantity? How much of that has been crime % wise? Same question about crypto.
- Tenoke 6y agoYou wouldn't need the massive amount of compute going into bitcoin for this hypothetical database. Something a few orders of magnitude cheaper on a separate blockchain or on top of a blockchain can be viable for that use case even if bitcoin specifically isn't.
- geodel 6y agoThere goes my hope for verifying provenance of heirloom tomatoes for dinner salad. [1] 1. https://innotechtoday.com/blockchain-agriculture/ https://innotechtoday.com/blockchain-agriculture/
- jayonsoftware1 6y agoI was one of the first customers when http://softlayer.com/ http://softlayer.com/ started, loved the company, low prices and best technology. IBM buys it and drag it down. Now I am with Digital Ocean.
- jake_morrison 6y agoI keep a small collection of applications where I think blockchain applications actually make sense. So far, most involve things where transparency in a distributed network is very important: 1. Running a lottery over the Internet. There are a lot of people who would be happy to buy a share in a typical national lottery as long as they could be sure they were not getting cheated. I don't care if e.g. 10% of the money goes to fund schools, as long as it's fair and transparent. 2. Internet gambling. If I bet on something, I want the odds to accurately reflect the bets of all the players, and I want to be able to get my money out if I win. 3. A currency for use in online advertising. A lot of the money that advertisers pay mysteriously disappears into the hands of middlemen before it gets to the sites that host the ads. There is also a lot of fraud. Having a transparent and accountable system would make it more effective for people who are not parasites. Anything else?
- pjmorris 6y agoCompliance and regulatory audits (e.g. ISO certification, SOC 2, the list goes on) seem like a candidate to me. There is typically a standard set by one organization, that has to be complied with by (multiple departments within) another organization, and verified by an auditor external to the first two organization (as well as to auditors within each of the organizations.) A database managed by any of the three players wouldn't be trusted by the others, so it seems like a candidate for multi-party distributed trust.
- perardi 6y agoI asked this downthread, but to rephrase: are there any semi-objective case studies on blockchains being useful for physical items, such as the food supply tracking that IBM is doing? (I mean, I see plenty of blockchain startups promoting this use case, but they inevitably end up with a pitch to get on a blockchain.) I do not understand how, in the case of food supply, that a blockchain is somehow better than a good ol’ database. You can verify the ledger, but I don’t see how that’s the primary issue. It seems like the issue would be getting everyone up and down the supply chain to get on board with tracking everything, and not the integrity of the ledger. If a meat packing plant is going to adulterate the pork, the problem is going to be getting any verification at all, and not them hiring some hackers to mess with a database.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThe issue with tracking physical things on the blockchain is that humans can lie to computers about the state of the physical world. Solving that with cryptography is attacking the wrong failing link; it’s actually a social issue and not a technical one.
- castlecrasher2 6y agoThis right here. Whenever I see proponents of blockchain listing ways it could be used, every single one I read has second and third-order consequences they clearly haven't thought much about.
- bena 6y agoExactly, Blockchain is only useful when you can't trust the store of information. Blockchain does not prevent people from just lying. Or people being lazy.
- yenwel 6y agowell you could validate data integrity based on - feedback from consumers of the commodity - some kind of built in monitoring with growth model benchmarking the different suppliers and instead of proof work do a decentralized/federated machine learning competition as a hard to falsify computation which uses private data for training and verification
- tyingq 6y agoThe trough of disillusionment. Finally.
- anjc 6y agoEvery top level comment seems to be making a joke that blockchain has no use, or that IBM have no real use for it. Look at how quickly funds in defi projects (i.e. non-speculative, useful projects) are growing, and please explain how you will create trustless, accessible financial products (e.g. lending and exchange) using databases. Then please tell me why it's inappropriate that IBM, who consult for competitors to these decentralised finance products, shouldn't have a big interest in blockchain.
- anon98356 6y agoSerious question. What is the business case for trustless financial products? If there's money involved 90% of people are going to need to trust something in the process, whether that's the counter party or the middleman.
- anjc 6y agoDo you always need to trust something in the process, for every product? You have a secure trustless mechanism for consensus, and can assess counterparty risk for a given product by auditing the smart contract (e.g. for Compound, borrowers have to deposit collateral). A simple business case might be interest earned by lending. Could you use traditional banking for this? Can any lay person lend? Is traditional banking accessible to anybody in the entire world with just an Ethereum wallet? This is just the beginning of defi and deposits have gone from ~0 to $30B in a year. Not much, in the grand scheme, but there's clearly demand for the products. No doubt this market will be regulated in due course, but I think this bell can't be un-rung.
- anon98356 6y agoAll of those business cases already exist in a reasonably accessible form. >A simple business case might be interest earned by lending. Could you use traditional banking for this? That is the basic business model of most retail banks. You lend the bank your money and they lend it out in bulk. In modern situations your "interest" is the relative security and ease of use you get from the bank storing your money instead of under your mattress. For a more explicit example: A term deposit is you lending your money to the bank and earning interest. Banking in the developing world is definitely a problem, personally I'm not sure using a pretty volatile currency like ethereum is as compelling as using the likes of M-Pesa.
- ChicagoBoy11 6y agoThe insane disconnect between the actual engineering (which often exists, can actually be useful, and DOES have real-world applications) and their marketing department is so absolutely cringe-worthy. I can't imagine that there was a single technically minded person who saw some of those blockchain TV ads and didn't want to look away.
- iramiller 6y agoHaving built a Hyperledger Fabric blockchain platform inside a fintech startup over the last three years I am completely unsurprised by this announcement. From the start the HLF platform appeared to be extremely optimized for demos and quick start tutorials but fell flat for any production use. The operational complexity of the Hyperledger Fabric spirals uncontrollably with the tight ‘enterprise style’ control layered on top (the extensive use of certificate authorities—an external chain of trust at conflict with the blockchain) resulted in extensive administration overhead. Early on we would joke occasionally that the platform seemed to be designed around an idea that customers should be overwhelmed and just choose to have IBM host the network instead. I absolutely do not regret our decision to move off of the platform in the slightest.
- coding123 6y agoI'm in the same boat. I was put on a hyperledger project last year. The configuration was like 4 maybe 5 certs or private keys. We were using the AWS blockchain stuff and it uses a version that's like a year or two behind. The code, samples, everything felt super enterprise level crazy. I would be super surprised if I hear a company puts Hyperledger into production beyond some silly PR stunt. TG I'm off that project...
- mkl95 6y agoI wrote a couple of hobby projects with Solidity (Ethereum) years ago. At the time, I found the language to be ugly and amateurish at best. I'd expect any corporate project that uses such tools to eventually reach technical bankruptcy.
- intotheabyss 6y agoSo you used a language years ago when it was in its infancy. Have you used it recently?
- MR4D 6y agoI’ve said this before and I’ll say it again: blockchain’s killer app is creating trust where there otherwise wouldn’t be. This is similar to how RSA enabled trusted security/communication on an untrusted network. Applying blockchain to situations where trust already exists is a waste (maybe a great learning experience, but provides no other value).
- motohagiography 6y agoIBM can hire and outsource most technical blockchain development anyway, so the I'd argue the company only needs a product manager, a couple of sales engineers, and an engineering manager to run the outsourced teams.
- johnward 6y agoI'm not sure that IBM leadership really understands what direction they want to go. They seem to pivot all-in on a tech sector and then abandon it a few years later. Rinse and repeat. It was AI/Watson, then a cloud platform, now its "hybrid cloud" because they can't compete with the established cloud providers. What will be the all-in bet next week? I also have to mention their strategy of trying to cut their way to prosperity.
- ssmiler 6y agoA lot of ex-IBM famous crypto researchers (Craig Gentry, Shai Halevi ...) are with Algorand foundation now, which I found suprising considering their scientific career. IBM should be an important stakeholder in Algorand foundation...
- dandanua 6y agoIBM needs at least one man in this team. He will explain to the others why they don't need blockchain.
- kthejoker2 6y agoNot here to talk about IBM Blockchain in particular, but to just offer a "meta" take on the difference between blockchain and other technological innovations. In our world, we have problems and solutions. Most technologies are created to provide new solutions to existing problems. The problem? It's dark. The solution? Fire, and then the light bulb, and now LEDs and so on. As we've gone digital, we've found that many of the problems of the physical world found their way into the digital world, and needed a "digital equivalent" solution, so those solutions were "ported over". The problem? Pictures needed to be touched up for publication. The physical solution? Retouching kits, gelatin, paintbrushes, patience. The digital solution? Photo editing tools with (at a minimum) the same capabilities and results. If you go back and read Satoshi's original paper, he does something relatively novel - it may even be a first - in that he: * proposes a solution * to a digital problem * where no such solution exists in the physical world, and * no one is even sure it's a problem in the physical world And by doing so, he set off a firestorm, because now the wrangling isn't "is his solution better than other solutions for this problem" but "is this really a problem at all?" It is (for once!) a genuine example of begging the question. It says "remove these premises and this is the only mechanism that makes sense." Two of the key premises being removed are "trust in others" and "adjudication of transactional disputes" - here's from the original whitepaper: > Completely non-reversible transactions are not really possible, since financial institutions cannot avoid mediating disputes. The cost of mediation increases transaction costs, limiting the minimum practical transaction size and cutting off the possibility for small casual transactions, and there is a broader cost in the loss of ability to make non-reversible payments for nonreversible services. With the possibility of reversal, the need for trust spreads. Merchants must be wary of their customers, hassling them for more information than they would otherwise need. A certain percentage of fraud is accepted as unavoidable. These costs and payment uncertainties can be avoided in person by using physical currency, but no mechanism exists to make payments over a communications channel without a trusted party. If you see trust and mediation only as costs and with no benefits, the worldview of blockchain is appealing. But clearly some of the benefits of the existing system are transparency (or at least, the ability to have your day in court) and stability - being able to prevent bank runs is a good thing. And of course, for the wider applications of blockchain, again, you have to consider the premises under which you're operating to define a "problem" such that blockchain is a solution. We joke that blockchain is a "solution in search of a problem", but that's not the case - it just declares a broad swath of social norms to be "the problem" it's solving, and makes no attempt at a countercase ("Why you shouldn't use Blockchain") I think we are all largely better served by spending our efforts creating solutions to problems everyone agrees we have and need solving.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoHaven't they just invested heavily in Stella Lumens? Why have in house blockchain when you got a whole team working on it?
- king_magic 6y agoYep. Blockchain is a joke for all of the ridiculous use cases outside of digital currency.
- JCM9 6y agoNot a surprise. Blockchain is an interesting concept but a terrible solution for most problems that people pitch it for. IBM feeds off executives that hear buzzwords but don’t understand the fundamentals to make sound decisions. They tried it with “AI” and Watson, “blockchain” and this stuff... What’s next?
- warkdarrior 6y agoI bet they're going to look into this "cloud" thing.
- spoonjim 6y agoThe real question is why their blockchain team wasn’t already the same size as their perpetual motion machine team.
- swagtricker 6y agoWow! That almost sounds as bad as when they ramped down their Aspect Oriented Programming (AOP) team when they figured out the logging example was the best thing you could do with it:) Seems like blockchain is a technology that's been overhyped, just like AOP. If you're not familiar with AOP, welcome to the post-dot.com Internet & enjoy what's left of your youth.
- worik 6y agoA lot of the comments here are about trust. About how there is a technical solution to mistrust. I am a bit confused: Trust really matters. It is one of the most important distinguishing features between societies. Societies with higher levels of trust tend to do better than others. SO they taught me when I studied development economics. Trust is between people, it is a complex fabric. How can some technological solution replace that? Put on your black hat (temporarily) and analyse every use case of technology to replace trust and think How could I subvert this? Will not take you long. We all need to be kind to one another, be trustworthy ourselves, and verify where possible, and be confident in each other. There is no technological replacement for that
- baby 6y agoThe answer is transparency: in a cryptographic decentralized system you still have human interactions, but they are in the open (in most systems) and can be verified. This is better than relying on gossiping alone.
- Jasper_ 6y agoNo, they're not? You can still have backroom deals with a blockchain, you just don't put the backroom deals on the blockchain.
- baby 6y agoIt depends what you're doing, and what you're allowing in your system. You're talking about an omnibus account[1] or a trade that hasn't been settled (but will be settled at some point). Depending on your system, there are ways to be less transparent. You also lose the transparency that you could benefit from the system yourself, and there's some limitation to it (the amount of the omnibus account is still visible, and money still moves between omnibus accounts). On the other hand, wherever you are on the spectrum, it is still a more transparent system compared to a blackbox centralized system, or a multitude of blackbox systems trying to settle between one another all the time. [1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=omnibus+account&oq=omnibus+account&aqs=chrome..69i57j69i59j0i271j69i60l4.1575j0j7&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=omnibus+account&oq=omnibus+a...
- mark4 6y agoFrom IBM's whitepaper on blockchains in 2017: https://www.ibm.com/downloads/cas/REGBVG7J https://www.ibm.com/downloads/cas/REGBVG7J "7 in 10 consumer industry executives expect to have a blockchain production network by 2020"
- haltingproblem 6y agoIBM's hyped initiatives are almost a sell signal. Blockchain, Watson,.... whatever IBM gets into and sinks huge resources into invariably fails. How can a company with so many smart people and technical managers lead to so much failure. Failure not of the "portfolio of small bets most of which go nowhere" but rather a few major hyped initiatives that almost all fail.
- hehehaha 6y agoDo quantum next. I actually think quantum could save IBM if they some how manage to pull it off.
- haltingproblem 6y agoI totally forgot about quantum. Highly suspicious that Quantum will go anywhere - reminds me of 5th generation computing around the mid-90s which then sank without a trace taking billions of dollars with it. Scott's rant below on it is epic. Even if quantum does go somewhere, IBM is the last company of earth I would bet on to monetize it ;) https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2019/01/15/quantum-computing-as-a-field-is-obvious-bullshit/ https://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2019/01/15/quantum-comput...
- koolk3ychain 6y agoIf there was ever an answer to the question of "is there commercial or enterprise value in blockchain technology" this is the indicator of all indicators. Hyperledger / Corda were always shit, but this really takes the cake. Even as someone who loves ethereum and has been active in the community since the early days - I still maintain that the technology, other than distributed DNS and the advent of IPFS (not in itself a blockchain technology) are the only productive real products of current blockchain "tech". If you meet someone at a party (god forbid we have those anymore) and they espouse the "value" of blockchain, please immediately move on and ignore them.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoApparently IBM finally got the memo that for 95% of applications a blockchain is merely an ad hoc, informally-specified, bug-ridden, slow implementation of half of a database.