6 ms·
Posting this throwaway because I don’t want my residency canceled. That should give you a hint that I might know way more than the armchair experts. Any articl
by myanmarthrow 6y ago
Posting this throwaway because I don’t want my residency canceled. That should give you a hint that I might know way more than the armchair experts.
Any article that talks about Myanmar and doesn’t include the word “China” all over it, is probably propaganda of some sort. I won’t go more into this and I will allow people to do their homework and make up their own minds about the good and the bad of all of it, but Myanmar is perhaps the first country the modern-West has totally lost from the grasp of its sphere of influence.
Sanctions won’t work. They will just punish businesses that were stupid enough to work with Americans and Europeans. At the end of the day, Myanmar is going to come out of this period looking more like China than like the British colony it was before — guess what that’s meant to prepare us for, in terms of the way the world looks by the end of this century?
The military couldn’t have done any of this without China’s permission. This is a giant fuck-you to the West, and it’ll work, because the West has zero leverage. Also, every Western ambassador and diplomat ran away like a scared child at the beginning of coronavirus, so they’re not even in the country to state their case. Guess who IS around?
PS: If you work for Facebook please tell your deranged CEO to leave the mini State Department he’s set up in Menlo Park to sit down and stay out of this one. They’ve done nothing but cause Myanmar to endure more violence and instability than was ever necessary, and made a GREAT case for the country to embrace China’s Great Firewall.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThis claim about coup results is disputed.
- enriquto 6y ago> Myanmar is perhaps the first country the modern-West has totally lost from the grasp of its sphere of influence. Not sure if this is a good or a bad thing. It can be factual, at least. But in case China is supporting the military overthrow of foreign governments over the world, then "the West" has zero moral ground to criticize, as we've been doing exactly that since, well, forever.
- newbie578 6y agoWhy do we still try to equate China and the US? They are not the same, I don’t know if it is some kind of a self-hate issue, but the West has it better. Period. As long as I can go to jail for saying Winnie The Pooh, China sucks and we should not encourage such regimes.
- gtufano 6y agoIt is currently probably way better (USA vs. China). Especially when seen from Europe (or USA)... looking at it from the point of view of a South-American citizen probably don't give the same result... and it's not self-hate, just history
- cheph 6y agoIf China was so much better why do people from South America risk life and limb to get to the fascist, racist white supremacist hellhole that is USA (where cops hunt people of color like dogs on the street and throw the ones they don't murder in cold blood in jail to use as slave labour) instead of just going to China?
- meiraleal 6y agoMaybe because China is ~15,000km away while the US is ~5,000
- leesalminen 6y agoIn Chile, there has been a growing anti-China sentiment over the past several years as they began dominating the retail sector, pushing out many locals’ jobs.
- enriquto 6y agoAs opposed to the USA for, you know, actually staging a military coup in there?
- cheph 6y ago> Sanctions won’t work. They will just punish businesses that were stupid enough to work with Americans and Europeans. > This is a giant fuck-you to the West, and it’ll work, because the West has zero leverage. They won't work to fix Myanmar, but at some point the West has to ask itself if trade with China is worth it, for the future of both the West and all other countries that are not already in the grasp of China. My opinion is that anyone who have political representation in the west (i.e. congressional representative, member of parliment, etc) should be calling and writing to them and demanding that they sanction China to the fullest extent. I think there are plenty of reasons to sanction China, and maybe your political representatives won't actually push for sanctioning China as such a move would be rather impractical now, but they need to understand that the people they represent are not okay with what is happening so that, at the very least, they start pushing back and stop making new deals with China like the EU-China deal that Germany rammed through on it's neo-empire[1]. If the West does not take action on China soon it will be too late, if it is not already too late, and it is pathetic that Germany, a country that should know what "never again" means more than any other country, can't find a backbone and stand up against a genocidal tyrannical state like China. Germany should be ashamed of itself. [1]: https://www.politico.eu/article/germanys-drive-for-eu-china-deal-draws-criticism-from-other-eu-countries/ https://www.politico.eu/article/germanys-drive-for-eu-china-...
- djohnston 6y agoTBF it isn't Germany that lacks a backbone but rather the entirety of the EU. Even if Germany wanted to make a statement I don't think they would risk dragging eastern EU members into a spat since they are already busy buddying up to China.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoSomeone has to get off the porch first. My bet is on one of the eastern EU members saying "screw it, we're already poor" and then the big players using that as their excuse.
- jacquesm 6y agoI would say that it's already too late. Way too late. And if the US won't stop it's infighting soon enough pretty soon there will be only one super power left.
- anothermmthrow 6y agoPosting this throwaway because I don’t want my residency canceled. That should give you a hint that I might know way more than the armchair experts. And I claim that parent is just spreading "Western" propaganda here, whatever that means. Do you believe me? In any case, I just demonstrated that posting under a throwaway is hardly "a hint that I might know way more than the armchair experts."
- echelon 6y agoSo now China's game plan is to topple democracies? What's next, and how far will this go?
- baybal2 6y agoChinese have't toppled a democracy.. yet, but they were rather successful at absorbing banana republics previously belonging to major powers. China now has a dozen satellites made of countries formerly being playgrounds of foreign political games.
- iso1631 6y agoChina's spent the last 15 years taking over Africa. Hell it's made a good job at bringing frickin Australia into its circles too. The West (and US in particular) has meanwhile done squat since making another mess in the middle east fighting for last century's resources.
- secfirstmd 6y agoTo be fair the West spent 150 years taking over Africa, enslaving its people, treating them as animals and pillaging it's riches.
- joshuahedlund 6y agoTo be fair the West also stopped that and now invests billions in foreign aid, economic development, medical assistance, NGO's, and a whole lot more (to varying degrees of success)
- sudosysgen 6y agoI assure you the West has not stopped attempting to make African countries do what is wanted by force or subterfuge. France is perhaps the largest offender in this respect.
- umeshunni 6y ago
- onethought 6y agoIsn’t this related to the head general not being able to extend his term... how is china involved?
- baybal2 6y agoIt's the biggest sugar daddy of Myanmar's military, after US wasn't able to cope with rising appetites of Burmese generals.
- onethought 6y agoHow does the Chinese giving money to Burmese generals related to the generals trying to hold onto power?
- baybal2 6y agoMoney, the inevitability of them losing power, means the inevitability of them losing money.
- baybal2 6y ago> Sanctions won’t work. They will just punish businesses that were stupid enough to work with Americans and Europeans. At the end of the day, Myanmar is going to come out of this period looking more like China than like the British colony it was before — guess what that’s meant to prepare us for, in terms of the way the world looks by the end of this century? Sanctions won’t work, but tanks would. The entirety of Myanmar's army stock of modern armoured vehicles is less than 1000, with only 200 modern tanks in unknown state of readiness. 3-4 marine heavy brigades can easily stomp all tank battalions in Myanmar's disposal. Just saying it to state that if US wants to do anything about that, it can do that effortlessly much like its Grenada, and Panama interventions. Laos, and Vietnam will also be eager to trim ambitions of their bellicose neighbour. The question is how Washington, and countries in the region are afraid the prospect of direct encounter with Chinese military which is rumoured to have a secret military treaty with Yangon.
- oefrha 6y agoThe question I always ask when people suggest warfare, especially an invasion: will you personally fight in it?
- klibertp 6y ago> will you personally fight in it? Personally, like in piloting a drone? It's a good question to ask, to be sure, but its value continues to diminish as more and more tech is deployed in warfare.
- mofosyne 6y agoMaybe a better question would be are you willing to allow crimes against humanity to occur if you can avoid personally fighting against it? Plus there is a whole spectrum of physical intervention if we choose to. E.g. drones, supporting insurgencies, etc... that doesn't even require boots on ground. This principle would be under R2P responsibility to protect.
- oefrha 6y agoWe must have pretty different views of history if you think the actual goals of this kind of "intervention" ever included fighting "crimes against humanity", and they were not or did not lead to crimes against humanity themselves. Also, killing <s>human beings</s> enemy combatants dispassionately with drones... Not something I'm energetic enough to debate today.
- bosswipe 6y ago> Myanmar is perhaps the first country the modern-West has totally lost from the grasp of its sphere of influence. This makes no sense except maybe as Chinese propaganda. Burma hasn't been under any western influence since the military took over in 1962.
- hitekker 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011%E2%80%932015_Myanmar_political_reforms https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011%E2%80%932015_Myanmar_po... is one of several articles demonstrating how the West was rebuilding its influence in Burma up until recently.
- bosswipe 6y agoGot it. So locking up political opponents and suppressing democracy is the glorious Chinese influence we all get to look forward to.
- einszwei 6y agoI found this article very enlightening about Sino-Myanmar relations https://cm.scholasticahq.com/article/5874-sino-myanmar-relations-analysis-and-prospects https://cm.scholasticahq.com/article/5874-sino-myanmar-relat... I don't think we have any credible source for if china is in any way involved in current military coup. (Would be great if someone can correct me here) But what we do know from past is * China has previously financially supported military regime in Myanmar. * China has vested interests in many infrastructure projects like dams, ports, oil and mining. There have been many human rights violations in these copper mines which are operated by chinese state owned companies [1]. [1]: https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2017/02/myanmar-suspend-copper-mine-linked-to-ongoing-human-rights-abuses/ https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2017/02/myanmar-suspe...
- yorwba 6y ago> I won’t go more into this and I will allow people to do their homework and make up their own minds about the good and the bad of all of it I assume that homework includes learning Burmese and living in Myanmar for a few years to get a feel for local conditions? Probably more effort than most here would like to expend. It's nice of you to share your conclusions, but it'd be even nicer if you could flesh it out a bit and share some of the observations that led you to these conclusions.
- anglercut 6y ago> Any article that talks about Myanmar and doesn’t include the word “China” all over it, is probably propaganda of some sort. And every article that does include this word is still most likely propaganda. > I won’t go more into this and I will allow people to do their homework and make up their own minds One of the least useful things one can say on a controversial topic. China alarmism is in vogue these days; people are supposed to have made up their minds and to nod along sagely. But your assumption that an incredibly unstable and violence-ridden country with powerful military cannot undergo a military coup without Chinese meddling sounds like Western projection. Current (well, previous I guess) regime has been convenient to China, being, for example, a signatory to letter in support of Uyghur treatment in Xinjiang [1]. Why would China need to foment a coup is beyond me. They'll surely try to capitalise on it, strengthening their positions, but are in no way certain to succeed ahead of India and even US. Both Chinese drive and aptitude for "hegemony" are widely, incredibly overestimated by the West, largely through the efforts of think tanks on MIC payroll. South-East Asia is a highly complex region and not merely setting for another round of Great Game. 1: https://thediplomat.com/2019/07/which-countries-are-for-or-against-chinas-xinjiang-policies/ https://thediplomat.com/2019/07/which-countries-are-for-or-a...
- tootie 6y agoI'm curious what the popular sentiment is about the military vs the civilian government of the last few years. Suu Kyi was seen as a Mandela figure in the Western media for a long time, but has since taken a ton of heat over her handling of the Rohingya genocide. I pretty much only know what I've read in the news.
- mzs 6y agoThis is all explained by the failed amendment curtailing the military and the elections after that, no need for conspiracy theories: https://www.jurist.org/news/2020/03/myanmar-parliament-rejects-constitutional-amendment-to-reduce-military-political-power/ https://www.jurist.org/news/2020/03/myanmar-parliament-rejec...