14 ms·
AMD vs. Intel vs. Nvidia: How Users Are Switching
- userbinator 6y agoIf you own an Intel CPU, you are far, far more likely to have a Nvidia GPU as well. I remember seeing that correlation many years ago, also on the Windows side, and likewise most people with an AMD CPU also had an ATI GPU. The acquisition of ATI by AMD seemed quite natural after that. (I personally have the Intel+Nvidia combination, although it's very old, and I don't use Linux as my main OS.)
- autokad 6y agomine is intel / nvdia from 2014 as well
- anotherhue 6y agoAMD's GPU drivers are already in the mainline kernel. We shouldn't loose sight of what a victory this is. Imagine any other core component of modern systems requiring such extensive, closed source binary blobs? The APU combos are particularly compelling for desktop Linux.
- podiki 6y agoThat's huge and a big reason why my next GPU will be from AMD. If I can ever get one that is, between scarcity, demand, bots, scalpers, ...it is terrible out there. You can be on a stock watcher Discord and click instantly to still see that it is sold out (and at a huge markup too).
- totalZero 6y agoFor what it's worth, Lisa Su said that although AMD had underestimated demand, the tightness should ease up by the second half of this year.
- podiki 6y agoI'm sure it'll eventually ease up (there's always a crunch with new GPUs and consoles, plus all the factors of 2020/21), but I don't take AMD's word for much as their early PR on launch availability was hardly good. This was after what we saw happen for Nvidia's launch too. Anyway, there's blame to go around, and these days I'm more inclined to look at how poorly retailers handle it. There are few (or none) backorders or queuing, and sometimes easily gamed systems. Either way they get their money, but it's not a good look. (It is not the end of the world, but annoying and doubly so when so many of us are stuck inside. Certainly much worse problems to have, I know.)
- ev1 6y agoA fairly significant amount of the "easily gamed systems" are actually taking reasonable precautions. Several of the people doing the gaming are escalating it to very stupid heights: dozens of LLCs registered, applied for ASNs, used to hijack large amounts of IP space and hijack Comcast/Verizon/etc IP space to place fraudulent orders. There is a huge amount of CFAA or worse stuff that needs prosecuting - it isn't just bots placing orders, it's mass amounts of hacked machines and hacked phones being used as proxies and cookies stolen for a valid fingerprint/less CAPTCHAs, wire fraud and forgery of documentation being accepted (instead of RPKI/proper filtering) Anyone that has a slightly popular (at all, really) will get shady requests asking to "install a SDK" or "buy your extension" which installs malware on your end-users devices. This is the slightly legal/grey area part. The other part is where AFRINIC recently revoked a /14 for fraud that was nearly entirely used for proxies and abuse by a 1 person US company, based on WHOIS remarks, obtained fraudulently.
- podiki 6y agoSure, there will always be people out to make a (not so quick?) buck. Having sufficient supply, and thus not being able to scalp for profit, would help. But something as simple as backorders and a queue would help too, as that would tamper demand and need to go to resellers. I think it is utterly absurd that in looking for a new AMD card in the US, there's nowhere I can order and just wait. (One exception I found was Provantage, back from the ol' mail catalog days. I have an order with them but the product has since been removed from the website. I'm not holding my breath, but maybe one day.)
- nanidin 6y ago> If I can ever get one that is, between scarcity, demand, bots, scalpers My advice, assuming you're on HN with a technical background, is to create your own bot for monitoring product availability on your store of choice. It's a pretty small investment of time, and it frees you up from the time spent watching a Discord or refreshing store pages manually. Set it up to poll at a reasonable frequency, set up some form of push notification, and find that it's not that hard to get ahead of the horde who are all relying on someone else to do the dirty work for them. Signed, Someone who got a launch day 3090 from the Nvidia store
- reilly3000 6y agoWhat would you consider a reasonable frequency?
- nanidin 6y agoOnce per minute when you're close to an expected release of product, once per 3-5 minutes when you don't have a great reason to believe that inventory will be added. My goal is just to mimic me sitting at my laptop refreshing a page trying to buy something as soon as it becomes available, so that I can use my time for something better.
- jowsie 6y agoI'm not dismissing your idea, but the fact you managed to purchase a 3090 on launch day seems more like survivorship bias than anything else.
- nanidin 6y agoYou have a good point, because I did fail to get a 3080, but I didn't start automating until after the initial 3080 launch. On the other hand, I did get a 1080ti several months after launch during the crypto-boom of 2017 using the same approach. I have also stumbled upon lots of "we added more tickets to X event" type situations before they are announced on social media and disappear in an instant (think sold out music festivals and concerts).
- 6y ago
- foobarian 6y agoSomething I don't get, both in case of Nvidia and PS5 products, is why they don't open the sales with higher prices. They are basically leaving at least 2x the money on the table to scalpers.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoInteresting question. I believe nVidia once had a policy of deliberately crippling the double-precision performance of their regular consumer graphics cards, in an effort to push their high-end computation-friendly 'workstation' cards, but that's not quite the same thing. Not a rock-solid source, but: https://www.techpowerup.com/forums/threads/why-include-fp64.199352/ https://www.techpowerup.com/forums/threads/why-include-fp64....
- 2sk21 6y agoRight, why not just conduct auctions?
- Volundr 6y agoPersonally I've always wished they'd just do backordering, especially with the PS5. Pre-orders sold out? That's fine just let me get in a queue instead of having to check back constantly and try to race for one. I think that alone would kill the scalper market.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoI don't think it would, people would still be willing to pay more to cut the line.
- Volundr 6y agoProbably some, but I'm not sure it'd be enough to maintain a market. All my friends I game with seem to think they'd prefer just being able to back-order to the current system, and clearly basing market predictions based on myself and my friend group couldn't be wrong :-).
- ekianjo 6y agoYes - but for proper hardware support you often need to compile the latest Mesa-git. That's not super user friendly yet, but I expect it will get better down the road.
- shrimp_emoji 6y agoIs this true on rolling releases like Manjaro or Arch? If you get the latest Mesa packages regularly, new GPU support seems pretty robust. (Windows 10, where you can expect the latest hardware to work, is closer to a rolling Linux distro in that way. Meanwhile, point-release distros like Ubuntu seem more fit for purpose as server, not end-user, distros.)
- ekianjo 6y agoYes even on Arch, it's recommended to use the AUR to get Mesa-git, especially when a new GPU card comes out.
- samhh 6y ago6800 is already working fine on release mesa for me. Mightn't have been the case if stock wasn't buggered and I'd have gotten my hands on it a couple of months ago at launch, mind.
- donio 6y agoI think that only tends to be the case with the newest hardware? Even 3 years ago when I finally made the switched from nvidia to an rx580 things just worked out of the box with stable Mesa and kernel versions.
- ekianjo 6y agoYes mostly for new hardware
- Kaze404 6y agoI've had the RX 5700 XT since launch and only had to use mesa-git on the first couple of months, which is reasonable imo.
- Farfignoggen 6y agoFor game's yes but for Blender 3D's GPU accelerated Cycles rendering(Not CPU Cycles rendering) that relies on OpenCL that's not shipping in the Kernel. So on some of the later HWE Kernels 5.8 for me that's not so good just yet for getting OpenCL working on AMD's Ryzen/Vega integrated graphics(Ryzen 5 3550H) and Radeon RX560X discrete mobile Graphics as well on the same laptop. So Blender 3D currently on my laptop can not detect any OpenCL/Cycles compatible rendering enabled Graphics/GPU and will default to Cycles rendering on the CPU cores instead(Way Slower and ties the CPU cores/threads up 100% until the CPU rendering is finished). So the MESA OpenGL and Vulkan drivers are in good shape but really any OpenCL compute acceleration on AMD's Ryzen APUs and on Kernel 5.8/Later and that's a wait and see. And Blender 3D, Gimp, Dark Table and other open source Graphics applications that need OpenCL will have to wait for that for me. So Compelling for gaming maybe yes but compelling for GPGPU compute workloads that rely on OpenCL not so much compelling on the newer Razen APU based hardware and AMD's Instructions and not as polished as some of the Intel/Linux related instructions. But really most laptop OEMs are still not tuning their laptops firmware for Linux except system76/other linux laptop OEMs! But that ASUS TUF FX505DY laptop was on special sale pre pandemic for $499 so not a bad deal but with loads of special issues to surmount just to get a Linux Mint 20.0 Live USB to even boot to install Mint 20 in a dual boot configuration alongside Windows 10 10/1909 Home. But Blobs and out of tree Wifi drivers and that laptop's getting a Samsung M.2/NVMe to replace the WD Black M.2/NVMe that shipped with the laptop and the Realtek WiFi card sits right under the M.2/NVMe SSD slot so that's getting a more Linux Kernel out of the Box friendly WiFi card with better features as well.
- executesorder66 6y ago> most laptop OEMs are still not tuning their laptops firmware for Linux Just curious, what would they actually change in the firmware to "tune a laptop for Linux"?
- jcelerier 6y agoJust checking that ACPI works correctly would already be great. It took my current laptop almost a year of having to disable ACPI completely before fixes&workarounds were implemented in-kernel.
- asddubs 6y agojust recently switched to an AMD card for this reason. well, that, and because I wanted to emulate mac os for safari testing
- depressedpanda 6y agoHow did it go? You might already be aware of this, but a less annoying way to test Safari compatibility is by using Epiphany (aka 'Web') as a substitute, since it's also based on Webkit. I've solved several Safari bugs that way.
- asddubs 6y agoIt went okay, the install was a little messy, I had to restart the VM a couple of times when it hung, but I got it t work in the end, and the actual system itself is pretty stable. I used this project: https://github.com/foxlet/macOS-Simple-KVM https://github.com/foxlet/macOS-Simple-KVM Thanks for the tip in regards to Epiphany, I am aware, but it doesn't help with testing stuff like ITP unfortunately.
- pjmlp 6y agoI would jump of joy, if I wasn't sour with open source drivers dropping support for the AMD E-350 APU shipped on the 1215B netbook. Closed source blob, OpenGL 4.1 with video hardware acceleration. Open source drivers, OpenGL 3.3 with a kind of working video hardware acceleration. Windows drivers, still OpenGL 4.1 and DirectX 11. So much for the benefit of open source drivers.
- boudin 6y agoAre you sure? According to arch docs, it should be openGL 4.3 or 4.5 when using mesa: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_AMD_graphics_processing_units#Features_Overview https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_AMD_graphics_processin... (if I'm not mistaken the GPU architecture is TeraScale 2)
- atq2119 6y agoThis kind of thing usually tends to be some sort of configuration error. Rare these days, but not entirely unheard of, and more likely if you build drivers from source.
- pjmlp 6y agoI don't build drivers from source. If it is a configuration error, Canonical has been making the error since it decided to replace fxgl drivers.
- whywhywhywhy 6y ago>Imagine any other core component of modern systems requiring such extensive, closed source binary blobs? Isn't there actually a worrying amount that do? Wifi for instance.
- podiki 6y agoIntel/Nvidia here, starting with Windows and then exclusively Linux. Both CPU and GPU are from early 2015 (ready to upgrade my GPU first, but impossible to get anything these days, as I noted in my other comment). Those parts have been great, but ready for AMD (open source drivers, better VR support, competitive on performance/price).
- ngcc_hk 6y agoShould have Apple now.
- taurath 6y agoI swapped to AMD for proc but on PC I still want NVIDIA, simply because their drivers are often extremely messed up. Nvidia has a lot of hacks but driver stability is still a huge thing
- technofiend 6y agoSame. The only downside to Nvidia is they go out of their way to prevent sharing mainstream / consumer cards via virtualization. So it's not easy to drop a 2080 into an ESXi host and then share it to various VMs. Even applying the fixes on Virtual Ghetto doesn't work.
- navaati 6y agoWhat ? I'm permanently sharing a 2080Ti into a Windows VM. It's kvm, not esxi, but still, no reason for it to be a blocker. Yes I had to apply a workaround but this part was easy.
- technofiend 6y agoReally? Dude please share your workaround.
- navaati 6y agoYes (I was on my phone, that’s why I kept my secrets, sorry :) ). Basically that’s how you do it in a libvirt environment: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PCI_passthrough_via_OVMF#Video_card_driver_virtualisation_detection https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/PCI_passthrough_via_OVM.... In qemu terms this translates, I _think_, to having "hv-vendor-id=Nvidia43Fixx,kvm=off" in your "-cpu" line. So don’t know how to do that with esxi but all in all you need to change your cpu hardware vendor id to some random string (that may or may not need to be 12 chars long) and not explicitely expose the fact that you’re a VM.
- robmsmt 6y agoFor those of us doing any ML that requires CUDA/CuDNN. It feels that AMD (specifically for GPU) still isn't a viable option at this moment in time. I sincerely hope that this changes.
- ekianjo 6y agoAMD apparently has a patent to include specific ML-related chips on their GPU cards. Maybe they intend to strengthen their position there.
- COGlory 6y agoUnfortunately, there's far too much inertia to ever change back, unless they can absolutely crush CUDA-based performance somehow. Hopefully OneAPI just makes this whole conversation irrelevant.
- nl 6y agoNVidia has "ML-related chips on their GPU cards" shipping now no some cards (the tensor cores): https://developer.nvidia.com/tensor-cores https://developer.nvidia.com/tensor-cores
- kavalg 6y agoWhile I agree with the current status quo, I don't think that it is too hard to break the vendor lock-in here. Most ML people code against pytorch or tensorflow/keras APIs, so as long as AMD is a viable backend for these frameworks, people won't really care. But whether and when this will happen is another story.
- InTheArena 6y agoI still find this surprising given how crappy my experience has been with recent AMD cards. I have a 12 Core ryzen which I love. And every time I try to go AMD for the video it’s been a disaster. I have an old RX 480 which seems to work pretty well on everything except Wayland, and then in Nvidia that I VFIO into windows.
- Rapzid 6y agoI've been rocking Intel CPU and AMD GPU for close to 15 years. Built a i7 6700k with an RX 480 back in mid 2016. Just upgraded over the holidays and flipped. AMD CPU for obvious reasons(4950x while I wait for the opportunity for a 5950x) and an RTX 3070 OTW(haven't been able to get a 3080). I have been mostly satisfied with AMD drivers, but I have not owned some of the problem cards(like the Radeon VII). I do like the latest Catalyst and Ryzen Master software.. But the new crop of NVidia cards crush the AMD cards on ray tracing performance, and DLSS 2.0 is voodoo I want for 4k gaming and VR. Would really, really have liked to go with an AMD 6800 XT to support the underdog but.. Those two features are clutch when shelling out nearly a grand for a video card. I have a good feeling about AMD in general and for their next GPU architecture iteration. They are supposedly working on an answer to DLSS(details are thin and NVidia are ML giants though) and this was their first generation with hardware ray tracing support so lessons learned should bear fruit.
- CraftThatBlock 6y agoThe 4950X doesn't exist, do you mean 3950X? I'm definitely very excited for RDNA 3. I think AMD's GPU momentum is just starting, similar to the 1000s series.
- Rapzid 6y agoHa, yes, I do mean the 3950x.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoThe rasterization performance of AMD is often better than NVDA's, only raytracing and DLSS are lacking, but nvidia has significant advantage in the two domains. The next few years will bring an interesting GPU market.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoSwitching all enterprise server workloads to AMD. Workstations will also be AMD with many already deployed. I agree that NVIDIA QUADRO GPUs have an edge in stability. The AMD FirePros are very nice cards and AMD actively works on improving the drivers. The RX 580 is also a really nice card. NVIDIA dominates in the vGPU and compute side of things in the data center.
- StillBored 6y agoDespite the insane difficulty of actually buying amd parts for the last couple months its sort of crazy that they are still gaining market share like that. I for one would upgrade my 5+ year old desktop, but I simply can't buy the parts (and I refuse to pay 2x MSRP to scalpers).
- gambiting 6y agoAt least here in the UK both the 5600X and 5800X are readily available at MSRP. It's only the 5900 and 5950 that are experiencing a shortage.
- ineedasername 6y agoI don't understand how we're multiple years into a GPU shortage from both vendors. $400 retail price cards sell for $800, presumably from scalpers. I read breathless reviews of how the latest card performs so well even though it's just $x MSRP and the reality makes that seem ridiculous. It shouldn't take 3 or 4 years to ramp up production that much. Yes, demand has increased, but again they've had years to react to that trend. I'd like to be able to buy a mediocre card for less than $500.
- vlovich123 6y agoI’m with you. This is a really strange situation. Unless these chips are really hard to manufacture for some reason or there’s some kind of component shortage, mobile manufacturers pump out billions of devices annually (meaning so does the supply chain pumping out the CPU/GPU SoCs). Maybe a node issue, but lasting multiple node sizes? If it’s crypto and persisted so long, then wouldn’t they have ramped up their pipelines? Is it that sales aren’t as good as they need them to be and artificial scarcity let’s them drive MSRP higher so that their revenues are a bit boosted? Maybe the flagships are way too complicated and expensive to manufacture with sales too few so that it basically amounts to nothing more than an expensive PR campaign? Maybe the real focus is primarily on cloud/mobile offerings? I really don’t know the details of the GPU business model so perhaps someone more knowledgeable can provide some insight. I’m really curious.
- somerandomboi 6y agoWhat does the new kernel mostly rely on? I'm not sure what part of the cycle we're in for development although I am interested to see who wins this generation.
- mkaic 6y agoI run Ubuntu with an AMD Ryzen CPU and Nvidia RTX GPU. I'm all for open/nonproprietary drivers, but RTX giving me +20% perf/$ in Blender rendering over Radeon is a dealbreaker.
- post_break 6y agoOnly went Nvidia because my friend snagged a 3060ti founders on launch while waiting in line to try to snag an AMD cpu. My next build will be AMD.
- sempron64 6y agoI feel like Intel is being dismissed much too quickly. I purchased 2 laptops in the last few months at about the same price, one having the latest-gen-available Ryzen and one having the latest-gen Intel. Here is a benchmark comparison of the chips: https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-1135G7-vs-AMD-Ryzen-5-4500U/m1286124vsm1052299 https://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i5-1135G7-v... The Zen 3 and M1 chips are unfairly being compared even in recent articles to 10th gen Intel chips when 11th gen is widely available. Considering there is an actual node change at the 11th gen it’s clear from the benchmarks that Intel has not actually fallen behind AMD —- they are neck-and-neck. Considering the lack of disparity in benchmarks, though I am a long-time AMD fan (see my tongue in cheek username), I still think Intel is the better choice at this time for laptops. The reason is that the ACPI and general driver situation for Zen 2 and 3 is very bad. Power management and hibernation are totally unstable on Linux and Windows. I like my Zen 2 laptop for the better multithread capacity (slightly faster compile times!) but the Intel laptop is likely to last much better given that it will not destroy its own battery. The AMD machine discharges in a day even when hibernating, and in a matter of hours when sleeping. Intel still has a chance to catch up. It all hinges on how fast they can move to 7nm. And given the “chip shortage” (i.e. limited capacity and likely yield/production issues at TSMC), Intel is well positioned to continue to dominate the market for quite a while by dint of having its own supply chain.
- Shorel 6y agoAbsolutely true in regards to Linux support, hibernation support and battery life in Ryzen laptops. For a desktop Ryzen sounds great. But for a laptop it has given me only frustration.
- kkaranth 6y ago> The AMD machine discharges in a day even when hibernating That isn't a CPU-related issue right? The CPU would be completely powered down when hibernating
- gambiting 6y agoThat's a firmware issue. I see the same problem in my i5-10300H equipped Legion 5.
- hexadec 6y agoI went with dual AMD for a lot of the reasons discussed (ability to drop into my Proxmox server later) but for a more salient one to me: ray tracing. Personally I did not think it would change that much gameplay-wise when I picked up my RX5700XT since there were so few games in the pipeline. I decided it was not worth the premium. I can still do most any game at 1440p and 100 fps or more without the headache. Why should I pay the premium for GPU features I will never use?
- girvo 6y agoI’m running a 3060 Ti with a 3600X, and I agree: raytracing isn’t remotely worth it. DLSS though has been amazing. I hope AMD manages to get close soon with a similar feature, it’s brilliant for 4K gaming, and all my displays are 4K in my house these days.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dncornholio 6y agoAs a consumer, I will still pick Intel + Nvidia. This stuff (mostly) just works.. Even without drivers AMD can just work, but most people who have problems with new hardware are the AMD users. It comes mostly down to software support, drivers and BIOS configuration. Another example is that every 'fps performance guide' always included a big section just for AMD users. It's just too finicky.. Always has been. This still makes me shy away from AMD and just spend the extra few bucks. AMD's sweet spot are the people on lowish budgets
- melvyn2 6y agoI would like to remind you of th le existence of nvidia gameworks. The fact that games are optimized for nvidia isn’t something AMD can exactly work around.
- dncornholio 6y agoI know! most problems aren't exactly AMD's fault, but they are still problems that the consumer faces you know?
- jsiepkes 6y agoHaving AMD GPU drivers in the mainline kernel makes me seriously consider selling my 2070 Super and getting and AMD. I'm tired of playing driver roulette with every kernel update. Crossing my fingers and hoping my setup won't break.
- EugeneOZ 6y ago> Only AMD makes it possible to play Cyberpunk 2077 properly so far What?? Actually, it's quite contrary. RTX has significant impact on the image in this game.
- mamon 6y agoNot that big: impact: https://www.pcgamer.com/cyberpunk-2077-amd-rx-6800-xt-vs-nvidia-rtx-3080/ https://www.pcgamer.com/cyberpunk-2077-amd-rx-6800-xt-vs-nvi... So, in lower resolutions/level of details AMD wins. In 4k Ultra NVidia leads by 4/5 fps. But you for 4k you probably want 6900XT/RTX3090...
- EugeneOZ 6y agoI’ve been playing this game with and without RTX (2k, 27 inches, HDR) and the difference is “night and day”, especially if it's raining or it's a night in the game and you are in the city (where most of the neon lights are located). The only thing which is not better with RTX is direct, non-ambient shadows (surprisingly), but the overall image is much better with RTX on (I really wish I could say there is no difference because it would let me save 20-30 FPS, but image quality is more important than FPS). Maybe a comparison of still images is not the best tool for “measuring” RTX impact.
- mikewhy 6y ago> in lower resolutions/level of details AMD wins Are people really buying new mid/top-tier graphics cards to play at low resolutions and levels of detail though?
- Jerry2 6y ago>I might add that while Nvidia is often reviled for its GPU drivers being proprietary, they are still excellent drivers nonetheless. Couldn't disagree more. For the last 4 to 5 months or so, Nvidia's drivers have been horrendous. I've experienced numerous crashes with my GTX 2080 Super card. About once every two days I experience a kernel panic and the only solution is to reboot. There are multiple threads on this issue on Nvidia's official Linux forum and Nvidia's driver developers have stated they don't know what the cause is and cannot reproduce it. [1] My HDMI also doesn't work well after the computer wakes-up from sleep. Sometimes the monitor does work, sometimes it doesn't. It's also a known issue. I'll be looking at AMD and their graphics cards a lot more closely when I build my next computer later this year. I just can't deal with Nvidia's driver issues. It's extremely annoying and it has wasted a ton of my time. I've been using Nvidia's HW with GNU/Linux for about a decade and have never had any major issues and have always been happy with the performance and reliability. However, this is not the case anymore. I'm pretty sure all this mess started when Kernel devs started blocking Nvidia's "GPL condom" effort [2]. [1] https://forums.developer.nvidia.com/c/gpu-unix-graphics/linux/148 https://forums.developer.nvidia.com/c/gpu-unix-graphics/linu... [2] https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Linux-Kernel-Blocking-NV-NetGPU\\\ https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Linux-Ke...*
- avereveard 6y agoEven on Windows, the driver batch of 2017 tanked my card performances to the point even old games I used to play on max were stuttering. I hold on the 36x series as long as games let me, but came late 2018 new release started complaining and then stopped starting due the old driver So I jumped on AMD, missed the rtx train, but my card is still running strong in 2021 and I'm not in a hurry to switch; I'll wait until the release of a midrange ready tracing card from them.
- bayindirh 6y agoWhen nVidia got what it wanted from Linux by dominating compute space using CUDA, they've just left visual part of their drivers to rot. Moreover, they stay silent in the forums now. They don't listen to customer feedback or at least give any signs of hope or assurance. Their company image became too dominant and arrogant (I think it runs more than skin-deep). Some of the nVidia's huge market share is coming from the momentum they have. Linux users do not refresh their hardware too frequently generally. I'm running a GTX680 on my primary Linux box, but it won't be nVidia next time. I'll be returning back to red team and I'd be a happy camper.
- shmerl 6y agoCheck also GOL stats which are relevant for Linux gaming: * https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&view=trends#GPUVendor-top https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&vi... * https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&view=monthly#GPUModel-top https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&vi... AMD usage is rising on Linux and for obvious reasons.
- manav 6y agoWouldn't be surprised to see Apple in the mix soon.
- EricE 6y agoDunno why you are getting downvote. I've been more than pleasantly surprised with the amount of games with minimal fuss that I have been able to get to not only run, but run VERY well on my new M1 MBA. For example, I think there is going to be far more expansion of Mac in gaming than there is going to be with Linux and as for hardware all it will take is for a desktop with a PCI slot and some driver support. It would not surprise me if Apple and AMD weren't working on Apple Silicon drivers already, especially if the rumored mythical "xMac" mini tower is indeed in play (I hope so!). I can get enough games running on my MBA right now that at this point I would have to think really long and hard about upgrading my Windows gaming box.
- propelol 6y agoSupply is so low that people just grab whatver they can get their hands on these days
- alkonaut 6y agoI upgrade my gaming machine every 3-5 years and it's typically a full rebuild. What I noticed in the last ones is that switching CPU manufacturer is easy, since you switch cpu+motherboard and never expect to be able to upgrade (3 years later you want a new motherboard anyway even if you could theoretically upgrade). But what creates inertia is my big expensive G-Sync screen which ties me to Nvidia. My monitor is the only expensive piece of hardware that survives between machines. And that's the genius of Nvidia's proprietary sync solution: So long as the cards are anywhere close, I'd of course choose the one that doesn't force me to switch screens. So far it has luckily not been an issue since AMD haven't upset Nvidia nearly in the way they upset intel. So Now I'm running a Ryzen and an RTX in the latest build.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoNVDA also enabled freesync on their graphics cards, so realistically you can swap between the two without any issues. I really don't think NVDA will become complacent in the way INTC became. Nevertheless, the last generation of GPUs seemed to close the gap if we ignore DLSS and raytracing. In the former NVDA has a non trivial advantage, and that is their cards have been the backbone of DL research. It'd be interesting to see how the NVDA+Arm partnership continues.
- tomnipotent 6y ago> interesting to see how the NVDA+Arm partnership continues They also just completed the acquisition of Mellanox, a company working on 300G NICs (I have a few of their ConnectX-2's in my home lab). It would be very interesting to have all the networking, CPU, and GPU in one place to see what kind of things would come of it (as proprietary as they may be...).
- MayeulC 6y agoNo mention of my favourite source for that kind of data: https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&view=trends#GPUVendor-top https://www.gamingonlinux.com/index.php?module=statistics&vi... > On Linux, most AMD enthusiasts have probably started by adopting CPUs for quite a while since they fared better for parallel workloads – and now AMD is even catching up on single-thread performance with their latest processors. I did the opposite, and started with AMD gpus, as those provided best bang for the buck in ~2008. Driver situation on Linux was quite dire, but it improved tremendously around 2013 (when Steam appeared on Linux). Even though I was still advising AMD in the bulldozer era, Intel was winning performance-wise. On the GPU side, though, GPU drivers have been quite hassle-free since 2015, provided your GPU wasn't the latest and greatest. They got better at supporting their latest GPUs recently. Intel and Nvidia always had despicable market segmentation and anti-consumer practices, which is the main reason I always went ATI/AMD. Intel: No ECC on consumer CPUs, reduced number of PCI lanes, restricted frequency multiplier. Nvidia: Signed GPU firmware, non-redistribuable. Driver limiting the use of GPUs in datacenters. Proprietary tech everywhere: G-sync, 3D vision, Physx. Artificially restricts the speed of nvidia libraries on non-nvidia hardware (Intel did that too, to a lesser extent). Cripples FP16 and FP64 on "consumer" hardware. I recently got myself a HTC vive. It works fine, while not perfectly, on my R9 Fury under Linux. Go team red!
- neverminder 6y agoI bought the Radeon RX 5700 XT about a month after it came out and it wasn't supported by the latest linux kernel at the time, so I returned it and got the 2070 Super which worked out of the box just fine. People say AMD cards are better if you're on linux, but I disagree, because it doesn't look like AMD is coordinating their product releases with linux kernel releases at all.
- monadic3 6y agoNever buying nvidia again if I can help it. Not into ML.
- marcusjt 6y agoThe subject/title should be updated to make it clear that this is in the context of Linux
- wcfields 6y agoFrom my perspective as a streamer using OBS and Vmix: Nvidia was the obvious choice for NVENC.
- lorax_108 6y agomy next laptop will be a amd cpu/gpu machine... hopefully 2nd q this year!
- fit2rule 6y agoGot your eye on one in particular?